Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post Posted by MommyofG YOu should ALL send it back whether or not it caused a reaction to your child. most of this clothing will be either sold- craigslist/garage sale, passed down or donated so knowingly that a piece of clothing could cause such a reaction to ANYONE is reason enough to get it off the streets! I would be mortified if I gave out something knowing it could cause a rash- this is all we know so far- could be more they are not sharing. they told me it will take weeks for the chemical to rid itself in the body and all depends on the child too, and their immune system. oh and to give it at least 2 weeks before wearing any other carter clothing, if we did to put it inside out. Get it off the street to me means throwing it out to me, especially since my DS didn't have a reaction. Why should I make a profit by sending it back? |
|
Posted 6/8/09 7:17 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post Posted by KateDevine Posted by MommyofG YOu should ALL send it back whether or not it caused a reaction to your child. most of this clothing will be either sold- craigslist/garage sale, passed down or donated so knowingly that a piece of clothing could cause such a reaction to ANYONE is reason enough to get it off the streets! I would be mortified if I gave out something knowing it could cause a rash- this is all we know so far- could be more they are not sharing. they told me it will take weeks for the chemical to rid itself in the body and all depends on the child too, and their immune system. oh and to give it at least 2 weeks before wearing any other carter clothing, if we did to put it inside out. Get it off the street to me means throwing it out to me, especially since my DS didn't have a reaction. Why should I make a profit by sending it back? You are assuming that everyone with these articles of clothing received them as a hand me down. I am sure that's not the case. If it was a gift, when you take a gift back to the store because you don't like it, it doesn't fit, etc., you get a credit to get something else. If you throw the gift away, you have nothing. How many people throw gifts away? Not too many. |
|
Posted 6/8/09 7:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post Posted by EmmaNick You are assuming that everyone with these articles of clothing received them as a hand me down. I am sure that's not the case. If it was a gift, when you take a gift back to the store because you don't like it, it doesn't fit, etc., you get a credit to get something else. If you throw the gift away, you have nothing. How many people throw gifts away? Not too many. Actually, I said most of mine were gifts (some were hand me downs) and since they've been worn by two kids (DS and nephew) and packed up in my house, I don't see how or why I should get money back for them. There is a difference (IMO) to throwing a gift and throwing away a 2 year old, used piece of clothing that didn't cause us any harm.... |
|
Posted 6/8/09 7:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post I dont think I have any of these clothes so for me it's not an issue. BUT if this were a recall on a crib or a toy or your car you would most likley be calling the company for a replacement or refund. I don't think this is much different. Just because you don't have a rash from it doesn't mean you can't get one down the road. So I don't think it's dishonest, but I can see why some people would opt out. |
|
Posted 6/8/09 7:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post I would recommend everyone doing what they are comfortable with. I am not sure what I am going to do yet as all of miki's clothes are packed away |
|
Posted 6/8/09 7:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post Posted by KateDevine Posted by MommyofG YOu should ALL send it back whether or not it caused a reaction to your child. most of this clothing will be either sold- craigslist/garage sale, passed down or donated so knowingly that a piece of clothing could cause such a reaction to ANYONE is reason enough to get it off the streets! I would be mortified if I gave out something knowing it could cause a rash- this is all we know so far- could be more they are not sharing. they told me it will take weeks for the chemical to rid itself in the body and all depends on the child too, and their immune system. oh and to give it at least 2 weeks before wearing any other carter clothing, if we did to put it inside out. Get it off the street to me means throwing it out to me, especially since my DS didn't have a reaction. Why should I make a profit by sending it back? get it off the street to me means send it back so it does not harm someone. Just b/c your dc doesnt have a reaction doesnt mean someone elses wouldnt. its the fall 2007 line so at this point whether you purchased it, its a hand me down which if it was so what, or a gift, from a thrift shop etc. why wouldnt you send it back? you are exchanging for new clothes that dont have the potential of harming ones skin. do what is comfortable for you. you said they are packed up- will you throw them out? Message edited 2009-06-08 20:10:18.200000. |
|
Posted 6/8/09 8:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post Posted by MommyofG Posted by KateDevine Posted by MommyofG YOu should ALL send it back whether or not it caused a reaction to your child. most of this clothing will be either sold- craigslist/garage sale, passed down or donated so knowingly that a piece of clothing could cause such a reaction to ANYONE is reason enough to get it off the streets! I would be mortified if I gave out something knowing it could cause a rash- this is all we know so far- could be more they are not sharing. they told me it will take weeks for the chemical to rid itself in the body and all depends on the child too, and their immune system. oh and to give it at least 2 weeks before wearing any other carter clothing, if we did to put it inside out. Get it off the street to me means throwing it out to me, especially since my DS didn't have a reaction. Why should I make a profit by sending it back? get it off the street to me means send it back so it does not harm someone. Just b/c your dc doesnt have a reaction doesnt mean someone elses wouldnt. its the fall 2007 line so at this point whether you purchased it, its a hand me down which if it was so what, or a gift, from a thrift shop etc. why wouldnt you send it back? you are exchanging for new clothes that dont have the potential of harming ones skin. do what is comfortable for you. you said they are packed up- will you throw them out? Probably. My DS is two and I'm not having any more DC and my nephew outgrew them as well. I don't see why I should make a profit, it isn't exchanging for new clothes since they aren't being worn any more, they are used and haven't been worn in quite some time ETA: Maybe its b/c I work in litigation and I feel like to be compensated you need to have a damage, its almost "no harm, no foul" in our house, KWIM? Message edited 2009-06-08 20:15:45.930000. |
|
Posted 6/8/09 8:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post hey kate, why don't you send in the clothes and give me the $$ |
|
Posted 6/8/09 8:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post i don't have any of these clothes, but for me personally, i would feel guilty sending in for a refund if DS never had a reaction. |
|
Posted 6/8/09 8:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post Posted by headoverheels hey kate, why don't you send in the clothes and give me the $$ i kid, i kid My SIL is probably going to have a stroke that she gave them back to us now
|
|
Posted 6/8/09 8:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post Chances are if many of the ladies on here STILL have the clothing, they plan on having more children, who in turn will wear that clothing that could cause an issue. That in itself is enough reason to send the clothing back regardless if it was a gift, hand me down, whatever. If you plan on having no other kids then I could see why you don't care and would just def. throw them in the trash and not pass them onto anyone else. |
|
Posted 6/8/09 8:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post No, my DS never had a reaction, so I personally feel like it would be wrong for me to cash in on their generosity when I never had a problem with their merchandise. |
|
Posted 6/8/09 8:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post Posted by dlate07 Posted by NinasMommy Nah, Nina never got a rash and they are all packed up. I really don't have enough anyway, to go digging through all her clothes. ditto same here |
|
Posted 6/8/09 9:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post I'm not going to send them back. DS wore them and was fine. I also did not return the bottles that had BPA in them. I got my money's worth and feel guilty trying to get something back. To my knowledge they didn't recall the clothes. I threw away the bottles and will probably throw away the clothes. |
|
Posted 6/8/09 9:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post Posted by EmmaNick Chances are if many of the ladies on here STILL have the clothing, they plan on having more children, who in turn will wear that clothing that could cause an issue. That in itself is enough reason to send the clothing back regardless if it was a gift, hand me down, whatever. If you plan on having no other kids then I could see why you don't care and would just def. throw them in the trash and not pass them onto anyone else. ITA!!! Since my DD was born the end of 2006, most of her onsies, PJs and shirts have this label. I packed them away in case we decide to have another child. Why should I have to throw them out and lose all of the money I spent on Carter's cloths? DD did have a small reaction, but I can't prove it was the cloths. |
|
Posted 6/8/09 9:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post I am going to send some, not all, of what I have back b/c although DS did not have a reaction (although I notice he will scratch the back of his neck sometimes...again not sure if it is associated with the tag) there is no guarantee that my next DS won't have a reaction to it. |
|
Posted 6/8/09 9:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post I haven't decided yet. I have all of his clothes packed away in hopes of one day having another child. Which I know will be a boy too...lol. Rylan didn't have any issues with the tags but that's not to say the next one won't. We'll see. |
|
Posted 6/8/09 10:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post Posted by jellybean1420 I am going to send some, not all, of what I have back b/c although DS did not have a reaction (although I notice he will scratch the back of his neck sometimes...again not sure if it is associated with the tag) there is no guarantee that my next DS won't have a reaction to it. I would just rather be safe than sorry and considering either myself or my mother bought all of the Carter's clothes I would prefer to get my money back so I can buy new things with the new labels. I happen to love Carter's clothes for infants so I know most of the money will go right back into their pocket. Same here. I think I gave away most of my stuff but have to go through Jack's bins anyway for baby #2 - so I would rather send back the clothes than risk the next one getting a reaction. I'll take whatever money I get (if any) and go right out and buy more Carters though for the new baby! I'm sure the way I'd shop, they'd be making out in the deal!
|
|
Posted 6/8/09 11:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post No. absolutely not. |
|
Posted 6/8/09 11:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post I'm probably just going to tell the person that I pass along the clothing to. I'm pretty good about remembering. |
|
Posted 6/9/09 2:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post Nope. Because I am a lazy sack and can't be bothered....... |
|
Posted 6/9/09 8:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post No. DS had no reaction and my going through all the packed away stuff to find those is not worth the money to me. |
|
Posted 6/9/09 8:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post Posted by KateDevine Posted by MommyofG Posted by KateDevine Posted by MommyofG YOu should ALL send it back whether or not it caused a reaction to your child. most of this clothing will be either sold- craigslist/garage sale, passed down or donated so knowingly that a piece of clothing could cause such a reaction to ANYONE is reason enough to get it off the streets! I would be mortified if I gave out something knowing it could cause a rash- this is all we know so far- could be more they are not sharing. they told me it will take weeks for the chemical to rid itself in the body and all depends on the child too, and their immune system. oh and to give it at least 2 weeks before wearing any other carter clothing, if we did to put it inside out. Get it off the street to me means throwing it out to me, especially since my DS didn't have a reaction. Why should I make a profit by sending it back? get it off the street to me means send it back so it does not harm someone. Just b/c your dc doesnt have a reaction doesnt mean someone elses wouldnt. its the fall 2007 line so at this point whether you purchased it, its a hand me down which if it was so what, or a gift, from a thrift shop etc. why wouldnt you send it back? you are exchanging for new clothes that dont have the potential of harming ones skin. do what is comfortable for you. you said they are packed up- will you throw them out? Probably. My DS is two and I'm not having any more DC and my nephew outgrew them as well. I don't see why I should make a profit, it isn't exchanging for new clothes since they aren't being worn any more, they are used and haven't been worn in quite some time ETA: Maybe its b/c I work in litigation and I feel like to be compensated you need to have a damage, its almost "no harm, no foul" in our house, KWIM? I see what you mean being in litagation but me being in the health care system I see it as something potentially down the line can happen as well, many things lay dorment and then 1 day symptoms come out. it isnt dishonest if you put the money right back into carters clothing. look at it this way especially in litagation- they indirectly put your child at risk- intentional or not- the risk is still there, yes you used the clothing and to your knowledge in good health since no symptoms have arised- all of but yet- that you are aware of- again if you put it back into the company as they have great clothes look at it as compensation for putting your dc at risk. both my girls developed red nodules on their back that doctors and dermatologist had no clue what is was, it would come and go. my girls would itch and I know were uncomfortable. if you throw them out great, but many may not. i know this is a computer and its hard to hear reason so I hope you dont take anything personally.
|
|
Posted 6/9/09 9:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post Posted by MommyofG I see what you mean being in litagation but me being in the health care system I see it as something potentially down the line can happen as well, many things lay dorment and then 1 day symptoms come out. it isnt dishonest if you put the money right back into carters clothing. look at it this way especially in litagation- they indirectly put your child at risk- intentional or not- the risk is still there, yes you used the clothing and to your knowledge in good health since no symptoms have arised- all of but yet- that you are aware of- again if you put it back into the company as they have great clothes look at it as compensation for putting your dc at risk. both my girls developed red nodules on their back that doctors and dermatologist had no clue what is was, it would come and go. my girls would itch and I know were uncomfortable. if you throw them out great, but many may not. i know this is a computer and its hard to hear reason so I hope you dont take anything personally. No offense taken at ALL Obviously, since your girls had a problem, you are MORE than entitled to return the clothes and get the cash. For us, we just would chose to get rid of the clothes (i.e. not pass them on or donate them)
|
|
Posted 6/9/09 9:59 AM
|
|
|
Re: Spinoff on the Carter's Tagless recall post Posted by Little-J-Mommy I wasn't going to, but then I thought about...what if I had another baby that does have a reaction? Or if I pass the clothes on to someone else who's DC gets a rash. Why even take that chance? So I sent them back with no guilt because I will have to buy all new stuff if I do have another dc. That was my thought process too. I can't use the clothes again for DC #2 if there is one. I can't donate them. I can't give them to someone else. |
|
Posted 6/9/09 10:13 AM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BTDT moms--WWYD? Buying some baby things...(x-post) | brownie | 6/8/09 | 0 | Parenting |
| Carter's tagless label caused rashes - Cross Post From Parenting | Angel321 | 5/29/09 | 5 | Pregnancy |
| X post from parenting- Phil and Ted recall | Lillykat | 12/17/08 | 0 | Pregnancy |
| Important Post - RECALL | Gertyrae | 10/12/07 | 7 | Parenting |
| itkocak | 9/21/07 | 2 | Pregnancy | |
| X-Post Crib Recall | DancinBarefoot | 9/5/07 | 0 | Pregnancy |













