Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

Posted By Message

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

For those not venturing off Parenting, there is a post on NFR about the middle school girl that was arrested for doodling on a school desk.post

I've always imagined myself as a more laid back mom but I am surprised to see that I'm more strict regarding my own kids based on some of the parenting I've seen with friends & family. We've all eaten our "I will never" words.

So let's fast forward to the future.

How do you *think* you would handle or for those of you who have BTDT, how have you handled the following scenarios:

Your child being called the principal's office for breaking school rules.

Your child being bullied.

Your child is a bully.

Your child steals from a store.

Your child gets caught smoking pot.

Your child gets caught underage drinking.

Your child (under 21) gets arrested for drunk driving.


Posted 2/18/10 12:18 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

I tend to *think* I'll be firm but reasonable in all the situations posted??? I actually wasn't guilty of any of the offenses listed as a kid, I think my parents were just VERY VERY clear on what the expectations were for us and I intend to be the same with DS. I think my DH will be the "cooler" parent (i.e. not freaking out regarding booze/pot, where I will be much more strict about those kind of things...).

The one situation I can honestly say I will NOT do well in from those listed is... having my child BE bullied (I would seriously want to RIP the bully's head off, or more realistically, his parents' heads!) *OR* having a child who *IS* a bully - I will NOT abide either one!!!!

Posted 2/18/10 12:26 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

obviously I am not "there" yet so I basing this off what I think I would do: I do see myself being on the stricter side in terms of behavior.

Posted by nrthshgrl


Your child being called the principal's office for breaking school rules. punished. length of time depending on severity. and when I say punished, I mean missing parties, school functions, after school activities...EVERYTHING.

Your child being bullied. karate classes/boxing lessons..and I would have to restrain myself from beating the kid myself. maybe I'll take his/her mom for a spin Chat Icon Chat Icon

Your child is a bully.: karate. their teaching I feel would help with that. also, serious punishments. I dislike bullies in a big way and would hate to see this trait in my son.

Your child steals from a store. punished. allowance/shopping privileges nixed for a befitting amount of time.

Your child gets caught smoking pot. a serious drug talk. a talk with my heroin addicted uncle. a few movies about drugs. and the age old...punished.

Your child gets caught underage drinking. similar to above

Your child (under 21) gets arrested for drunk driving.: oof. my father always said that if he ever had to pick us up from jail, he'd ask for some alone time in the cell with the nightstick. that has always stuck with me. hopefully some serious shock therpay...like a trip to the hospital, to a rehab facility...someplace so the magnitude of what he could have done to himself or another person would shine through. of course, bye bye car. bye bye keys. privileges completely revoked.


Posted 2/18/10 12:27 PM
 

My4GirlsMyLife
My 4 girlies

Member since 2/08

9702 total posts

Name:
Valerie

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

Q~~Your child being called the principal's office for breaking school rules.


A~~Jade was punished for 3 days , no tv, phone, games, she had to read or study



Q~~~Your child being bullied.


A~~~I dealt with the school, and made sure Jade knew how beautiful she is on the inside and out


Q~~~Your child is a bully.


A~~~I would have a serious talk ,and would try to find videos to show her



For these last four things ,I am not sure what I would do ,but I am going to continue teaching her right from wrong and hope she doesn't do these things, but if she does ,I guess I need to prepare myself .


Your child steals from a store.

Your child gets caught smoking pot.

Your child gets caught underage drinking.

Your child (under 21) gets arrested for drunk driving.

Message edited 2010-02-18 12:32:45.110000.

Posted 2/18/10 12:31 PM
 

Bri
I Love You to Pieces!

Member since 5/05

9919 total posts

Name:
Brianne

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

I will be reasonably strict. This issue is extremely contraversial for me, since I am a middle school teacher and feel that many (not all, but too many IMO) kids get away with murder and receive very few consequences for unacceptable behavior.

I will teach my child what is acceptable and unacceptable and there will be consequences that I will have to follow through with, no matter how hard that will probably be at times.

Consequences clearly have to be a loss of a privelege that would be worth the child correcting their behavior for. I think consequences are effective when started young and when they are followed through with.

Point by point, this is how I perceive myself:

"Your child being called the principal's office for breaking school rules."

Discussion and consequences.


"Your child being bullied"

Contact the school.
Empower my child in appropriate ways.


"Your child is a bully."

Discussion and consequences.


"Your child steals from a store."

Discussion and consequences.



"Your child gets caught smoking pot."

Discussion and consequences.


"Your child gets caught underage drinking."

Discussion and consequences.


Your child (under 21) gets arrested for drunk driving.

This one is a tough one, but again definitely discussion and some form of consequence.

Message edited 2010-02-18 12:40:18.027000.

Posted 2/18/10 12:31 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

Hmm, hard to say but my guess:

Your child being called the principal's office for breaking school rules.
United front with the school, grounded or restricted based on the severity.

Your child being bullied.
scratch the eyes out of thd kid doing it, or maybe just his parents.

Your child is a bully
Must apologize to the victime, gets grounded. If it keeps going, I take days off from work and shadow him/her at school. I assume they'll be on the receiving end of some jokes after that but it should prove my no tolerance for that ish.

Your child steals from a store.
Go back to the store with the items, apologize and ask the manager what they think is an appropriate punishment-work it off?

Your child gets caught smoking pot.
Grounded/restricted, very lengthy conversation.

Your child gets caught underage drinking.
Grounded/restricted very lengthy conversation.
Your child (under 21) gets arrested for drunk driving.

I'll remove doors from their bedrooms if I find a stash at home. Privacy is a privlrdge and if you are hiding illegal substances you've proven to me you don't deserve your privacy.

I hope to come up with more ideas. I am also a fan of extra chores to keep you out of trouble. Obviously you have too much time on your hands since you keep getting into trouble so we'll take care of that for you.

Posted 2/18/10 12:32 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

My child being called the principal's office for breaking school rules:

I'd be pizzed. I supposed it would depend on the rule, but there would be an appropriate consequence.

My child being bullied:

I was bullied HORRENDOUSLY (verbally not physically), but I do remember how my mother handled it. She was non-confrontational with the child OR the parent and taught me how to be strong. She would say what comes around goes around and it did.

My child is a bully:

ZERO tolerance. MAJOR consequences.

My child steals from a store:

ZERO tolerance. My child returns stolen item and apologizes PLUS MAJOR consequences at home - no privileges.

My child gets caught smoking pot:

Telling her EXTREMELY conservative father who never touched the stuff. I remember having to tell my father I smoked a cigarette because my sister caught me and it was devastating.

My child gets caught underage drinking:

If not by the police, then she gets jail time at home.

My child (under 21) gets arrested for drunk driving:

Let the law handle it. That will be bad enough. She will probably not drive for a long time past what the law dictates because I sure as hell would not insure her on MY policy.

Now yes, many of us have done illegal things in our lifetimes - some still do. You take chances. If you get caught, you need to be prepared to deal with the consequences. I did not get caught. I did not get arrested. They are going to do it anyway. You do adult things, you get an adult consequence. illegal activity will not be permitted in my home - no underage alcohol or drugs. I won't risk my home for potentially bad decisions my children may make.

Message edited 2010-02-18 12:33:44.073000.

Posted 2/18/10 12:32 PM
 

MamaB17
Back for baby #3

Member since 5/09

4065 total posts

Name:
N

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?


Your child being called the principal's office for breaking school rules.
They will be punished at home in regard to the offense committed at school, and their age.

Your child being bullied.
I want my children to walk away when they can, but by no means want them to be a pushover. I want them to stick up for themselves when appropriate.

Your child is a bully.
They will be punished. I will try to get it in their heads that it isn't nice to be a bully, and how would they like it if they were being bullied. I would make them apologize to the other child for sure.

Your child steals from a store.
Public humiliation. I would drag them back to the store and make them apologize/pay for/return the item. I would also make them volunteer if the owner wanted. This also depends on the age.

Your child gets caught smoking pot.
Considering their father is a police officer I would let him deal with this one. Have a friend of his scare the crap out of them, make them think they were getting arrested. Severe punishment. I would also take them to see ppl in rehab who started out just smoking a little pot.

Your child gets caught underage drinking.
Same as if they got caught smoking pot.
Your child (under 21) gets arrested for drunk driving.
I would take their car away, and wouldn't let them drive even after their license was returned. They would never again drive any of our cars, they would have to wait until they could afford a car on their own. I would also make them go to programs where ppl who have lost loved ones due to drunk drivers gain support. I would want them to grasp how they could have killed someone. I also would not pick them up for a few days, let them stay in jail. I know DH would never want to pick them up.

Posted 2/18/10 12:39 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

Posted by MrsB0118


I would also make them go to programs where ppl who have lost loved ones due to drunk drivers gain support. I would want them to grasp how they could have killed someone. I also would not pick them up for a few days, let them stay in jail. I know DH would never want to pick them up.



This is a great one.

Posted 2/18/10 12:42 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

To answer my own question:


How do you *think* you would handle or for those of you who have BTDT, how have you handled the following scenarios:

Your child being called the principal's office for breaking school rules.

BTDT. Punished. No TV, computer, gaming for a week. Talk to ad nauseum, reminded why they can't do anything & the choices they made. Also big talks about self esteem - that they are a better person than that, we know they knows better, etc. Work with the school regarding anything they want to see done as well (behavior programs etc)


Your child being bullied.
BTDT. It's varied depending on the type of bullying. I once explained that a little girl didn't know how to be friends with others & needed help along the lines of "you can play with us but you cannot take our toys" Another time I told my child to say "Stop hitting me" loud enough for a teacher to hear. I explained why the kid was acting out (feeling bad about themselves, their dad abandoned them, etc.) DH told them to deck the kid. I'm not sure which was better but the latter was what stopped the bullying.

Your child is a bully.
BTDT. Spoke to the child about why they would do what they did, bolstered self esteem, talked about how great we think they are & to make better choices. There was some discrepancy over if it was bullying or being bullied.

Your child steals from a store.
BTDT. I made the child pick their top 3 favorite toys. Bring the stolen item back to the store & apologize to the manager. They had to pick which toy they were giving up for stealing. When the manager of the store wouldn't take the toy as punishment, we dropped it in the Big Brother/Big Sister's donation bin.

Your child gets caught smoking pot.
Not there yet. Grounded. For a long, long, long time. Maybe a walk through a detox center if I could arrange it. I think I'd call the parents of any kid involved to alert them to what happened in case they opt to punish their kid. Depending on their reaction my kid may or may not be allowed to socialize with the kid out of school.

Your child gets caught underage drinking.
Grounded (same as above)

Your child (under 21) gets arrested for drunk driving.
Have fun taking the bus. I'd bail them out with their own money. I'm torn on this one. I would expect a plea guilty & whatever followed, followed and it would break my heart to see my child go to jail for an extended period of time.

Posted 2/18/10 12:45 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

Posted by CrankyPants
I'll remove doors from their bedrooms if I find a stash at home. Privacy is a privlrdge and if you are hiding illegal substances you've proven to me you don't deserve your privacy.



I like this one. I know someone who did that when their kid slammed the door to their room.

Posted 2/18/10 12:51 PM
 

MamaB17
Back for baby #3

Member since 5/09

4065 total posts

Name:
N

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

Posted by Ophelia

obviously I am not "there" yet so I basing this off what I think I would do: I do see myself being on the stricter side in terms of behavior.

Posted by nrthshgrl

Your child being bullied. karate classes/boxing lessons..and I would have to restrain myself from beating the kid myself. maybe I'll take his/her mom for a spin Chat Icon Chat Icon

Your child is a bully.: karate. their teaching I feel would help with that. also, serious punishments. I dislike bullies in a big way and would hate to see this trait in my son.





I totally agree w/ the karate thing. I took karate growing up, and also taught young children. It can do so much for bullies/and those being bullied.

Posted 2/18/10 12:51 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

My mother was VERY strict and I had the fear of death in me at all times... I don't want to do that to my DD, but I already feel that I'm not going to take crap. I'm already the tough one in my house and I don't see it changing anytime soon.

That said, here's my answers as best I can foresee them as a toddler mommy:

Your child being called the principal's office for breaking school rules. Serious discussion followed by punishment - no tv, phone, toys, friends for a week or so.

Your child being bullied - I was bullied so I definitely would have to restrain myself from beating the ever loving crap out of a kid or two, but I'd call the school and I would talk to my child and try to give her a boost of confidence. Maybe a self-defense class or karate like Ophelia mentioned.

Your child is a bully - I will NOT tolerate this. I can't even fathom how I'd deal with it but it irritates me almost as much as if my child was being bullied.

Your child steals from a store - I want to say that I would go with my child and make them return the stolen items, followed by an extended punishment. I really feel that I would want to do that (return to the scene of the crime) but I'm afraid the store wouldn't accept my act of good faith and make it worse. But the punishment would be no joke.

Your child gets caught smoking pot - ugh. I don't want to think about this. I know I'll have to, but I sooo don't want to think about it today. She's 2!!

Your child gets caught underage drinking - she can go to an (or 3) AA meeting with my father, followed by extended punishment, no privileges, no going out until I'm over it.

Your child (under 21) gets arrested for drunk driving. OMG... more things I don't ever want to think about. If she had a car she'd lose it first and foremost. I don't know. I really don't know. This was never an issue in my life - I didn't have a car until I was 25 years old!!

Posted 2/18/10 12:57 PM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

Your child being called the principal's office for breaking school rules.
Been here. It was uncomfortable and before I reacted I got the full story from the principal's perspective and then the story from Robbie's perspective. It was clearly Robbie in the wrong with this situation. I was very upset. Robbie had all privileges revoked for a few days and we had a long discussion about his behavior. A few days later he was in trouble AGAIN. This time I was mortified because it was like.. nothing I said penetrated (different infraction- but still breaking rules). He had privileges revoked for a week and another LOOONG talk. I also worked with the principal so that he was made to have some in school consequences as well (no recess for a day)

Your child being bullied.
Been here too. Noah (just a few weeks ago actually) got pushed on the ground and had his stomach jumped on by a boy. I was FURIOUS. Immediate mother bear instinct. If the school had been open I would have flown down there and lost my mind. Fortunately it was after hours so I got to calm down and get the full story from Noah. He was provoking the kid first and although that didn't make it RIGHT - it did make it more understandable. The boy had already been punished at the time of the incident so I left it at that. If it was an ongoing thing, I'd be at the school and on the phone with the bullies parents trying to figure out what we can do to get this to stop.

Your child is a bully.
Yeah.. Noah again. He actually kicked an older kid that Robbie was having problems with in the groin. Noah's short. He didn't MEAN to hit him there. But he did mean to hit him. I called the mother, we got the boys together and Noah apologized, asked if they could be friends and gave him a drawing he made of the two of them playing. He was truly remorseful. He also got privileges revoked for a weekend. I have ZERO tolerance for true bullying and I think there'd be a huge issue in our house if either of my boys were bullies.

Your child steals from a store.
I'd take him right back to the store, ask for the manager and have him return the goods and apologize.

Your child gets caught smoking pot.
Depends on the age. Young teen? I'd find out the source and rip their f*cking head off. Older teen? I'd be disappointed and let them know my disappointment and remind them that it is an illegal substance. In either case I think I'd have to put them on lock down. College age or older? I'd probably turn a blind eye unless I thought it was a habit or disrupting their lives.. in which case it's off to family drug counseling.

Your child gets caught underage drinking.
This one is hard. I drank a lot when I was young. I'd probably just give a lecture and put them on lockdown. I would be more concerned about how they were getting from point A to point B while intoxicated. A lot of my lecture would focus on drunk driving.

Your child (under 21) gets arrested for drunk driving.
I would lose my ever loving mind. Seriously. LOSE. MY. MIND. And then I would force them to watch videos of families DEVASTATED by drunk driving. I can't even begin to imagine how furious I would be.. I'm literally shaking thinking about it.

Posted 2/18/10 12:57 PM
 

chikita315
Love

Member since 8/06

7945 total posts

Name:
M-lo

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

Your child (under 21) gets arrested for drunk driving

I saw an afterschool special years and years ago about drunk driving. The teen drunk driver ended up killing a young girl. Part of his punishment was he had to pay the family $1 every day for the next 25 years. He had to write them a check every day. To constantly remind him of what he did so he wouldn't do it again.

Obviously, that is the worst possible outcome of driving drunk, but I like the idea of the punishment.
A constant reminder of what your consequences could be.

Posted 2/18/10 1:07 PM
 

chikita315
Love

Member since 8/06

7945 total posts

Name:
M-lo

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by CrankyPants
I'll remove doors from their bedrooms if I find a stash at home. Privacy is a privlrdge and if you are hiding illegal substances you've proven to me you don't deserve your privacy.



I like this one. I know someone who did that when their kid slammed the door to their room.



My father did this to me (for door slamming) and it worked.

If I stomped up the stairs, he made me walk up and down them 20 times.

Posted 2/18/10 1:11 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

Posted by nrthshgrl

For those not venturing off Parenting, there is a post on NFR about the middle school girl that was arrested for doodling on a school desk.post

I've always imagined myself as a more laid back mom but I am surprised to see that I'm more strict regarding my own kids based on some of the parenting I've seen with friends & family. We've all eaten our "I will never" words.

So let's fast forward to the future.

How do you *think* you would handle or for those of you who have BTDT, how have you handled the following scenarios:



I have a 13 year old step son and we are just starting to get into the difficult years. I am finding that we have to be strict and stern. SS is starting to become resentful of having two households, especially since the rules are very different. We try to get his mom on the same page but she "feels sorry for him" and continues to do his homework (resulting in many failing grades on tests) and to give him responsibilities he has not earned.


Your child being called the principal's office for breaking school rules.

Your child being bullied.
This one was really tough for me, I was made fun of as a kid for being overweight. I dealt with it by ignoring the kids and then crying to myself later. A few years ago my Mom made SS a fuzzy bright orange scarf with his name on it. He LOVED it and wore it to school with pride and then came home in tears because the kids were calling him a hippy. Neither he or the kids had any idea what a hippie was, but SS knew he was being made fun of. I tried to tell him that those kids don't matter and he should be proud to be an individual.

Your child is a bully.
This one I would sit SS/DS down and let him know how it feels to be bullied. If it continued anyway we'd start with grounding, losing privileges and of course apologising to the other child.

Your child steals from a store.
We just dealt with this recently. SS stole candy from a store, he was grounded for a week, he was not allowed any TV/Computer time (including missing the SuperBowl) he was supposed to go car shopping with his Dad and Aunt but that got cancelled and he also had to write an apology to the store manager. Next time it happens we will take him to talk to a police officer about stealing.

Your child gets caught smoking pot.

Your child gets caught underage drinking.

The drinking and the pot are the same to me, I hope we can instil enough responsibility in SS/DS to know how to be safe. I will not them them drink in our home with friends, however I may let them have a beer/glass of wine with family. I really don't know yet how I would handle this, I think it depends on the maturity level of the child at the time.


Your child (under 21) gets arrested for drunk driving.
Absolutely no tolerance for this he would lose his car/license until he was out of our house. Period.




Posted 2/18/10 1:16 PM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

I am such a STRICT parent and both DH and I thought I'd be the laid back one. So to the questions below...
Your child being bullied.
I would contact the school, then the parents, & get my kid into boxing or karate as suggested above.

Your child is a bully.
Oh there is a NO TOLERANCE policy with me for this. My kid would be marched up to the school or where ever it took place hand in hand with me and would be made to apologize. Then (if old enough) would write a report on why we don't bully

Your child steals from a store.
I would do as others posted and make him return item to store and apologize. Punishment...toys taken away, grounded no tv.

Your child gets caught smoking pot.
He would be randomly drug tested in my house until he moved out. He would lose all privilages, and do what my dad did to us. He would have to read two books about drug use and write full reports on both books.

Your child gets caught underage drinking.
Same as above except the random drug testing

Your child (under 21) gets arrested for drunk driving.
As much as I may get flamed my kid would stay in jail until released. Then I would arrange for them to speak with two people, one that has lost someone they love to drunk drivers, and someone that took someone else's life. He would learn to love public transportation, and depend on mom and dad for rides until he could poney up the dough to buy a car for himself, insurance, and maintenance. As far as I am concerned this is a deal breaker for me.


Posted 2/18/10 1:28 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

It hard to say for any of those situations because my DD is not yet 3. BUT I was raised with very strict parents.

I have worked in the South Bronx for 13 years and I have to say, until I began that job I didn't really appreciate my upbringing. Even after college, I was a bit bitter about how strict and overprotective my parents were. But it didn't take long for me to see that I was SO lucky. I have come across so many parents that either don't know how to discipline, are too lazy, or have the attitude that authority is bad even when the goal is to help the child. I've seen kids go to jail and had students who were killed, and while it's no guarantee, if better examples and enforcement had been happening at home, things might have turned out different.

Posted 2/18/10 1:31 PM
 

MamaB17
Back for baby #3

Member since 5/09

4065 total posts

Name:
N

Re: Spinoff from NFR: How strict will you be?

I totally agree w/ the random drug testing, and also would get a breathlizer (sp?) for underage drinking. DH's parents did this to him every single night he came home that he had been driving.
I also agree with the taking off of doors, my parents did it to me. It is awful to be a teenager w/ no privacy. Lol. It hits them hard. I will also do room searches when they are not home. No privacy under our roof.

Posted 2/18/10 1:32 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Anyone know if hospitals are being strict w/ visitors? aw29 5/17/09 1 Pregnancy
how strict are you with your toddler about using utensils? LoveBeingMrsT 5/11/09 17 Parenting
if you did not have a strict napping schedule when your baby was young? Kerie-is-so-very 12/26/08 3 Parenting
Are you strict when it comes to Organic Milk? LIMOMx2 7/18/07 15 Parenting
Why are PETS in the "NFR" section?? MsG 5/24/05 1 Pets
NFR Birthday list. Tany 5/13/05 117 Families Helping Families ™