Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

12 year old gets arrested

Posted 2/18/10 10:23 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Wow

Handcuffs in front of her classmates???

Sounds like the principal was sick of kids doodling on desks and wanted to make an example out of somewhere and humiliate her in front of other students as a warning.

I think detention or demanding that she be responsible for cleaning the desk, and making her clean all the desks in the classroom could have been a better punishment.

This was EXTREME.

Posted 2/18/10 10:26 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Ugh, this is such a sticky subject.

On the one hand, it's graffiti, which is illegal, and an arrestable offense (actually in the case of minors it's called custodializing them, not arresting them, but it's the same thing).

On the other hand, she now has to deal with an actual court case - which involves possibly hiring or being assigned an attorney, dealing with the DCA, and filing a plea, which could mean anything from a promise to stay out of trouble to actual probation.

Think about it, though - if she was "doodling" on the outside of the building, or on a subway train, or any other public place, would anyone have a problem with her being arrested? Why should it be different because she's in the school and she did it on a desk? (Just playing devil's advocate here.)

Posted 2/18/10 10:28 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

WOW!

I work in a middle school and never in a million yrs would my Principal call the cops over that!

The message was harmless...

Now if the doodling was "I am going to shoot all the boys in the school" or some sort or harmful threat I can see that the Principal may decide to call the police....

But that is just way overboard IMO

Posted 2/18/10 10:29 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted by headoverheels

Think about it, though - if she was "doodling" on the outside of the building, or on a subway train, or any other public place, would anyone have a problem with her being arrested? Why should it be different because she's in the school and she did it on a desk? (Just playing devil's advocate here.)



I see what you are saying.

But in the vein of playing devil's advocate...a school is a place to educate a child--so why not make this a teachable moment?

*I* would explain to the youngster the ramifications of graffiti and the fact that it illegal--and that the police COULD be called...

Schools have a responsibilty to educate students and keep them safe...

her doodling was not not threathing or harmful which is why I disagree with calling the police..

I think that they could have and should have handled this in house.

Posted 2/18/10 10:32 AM
 

MissJones
I need a nap!

Member since 5/05

22153 total posts

Name:

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted by headoverheels

Ugh, this is such a sticky subject.

On the one hand, it's graffiti, which is illegal, and an arrestable offense (actually in the case of minors it's called custodializing them, not arresting them, but it's the same thing).

On the other hand, she now has to deal with an actual court case - which involves possibly hiring or being assigned an attorney, dealing with the DCA, and filing a plea, which could mean anything from a promise to stay out of trouble to actual probation.

Think about it, though - if she was "doodling" on the outside of the building, or on a subway train, or any other public place, would anyone have a problem with her being arrested? Why should it be different because she's in the school and she did it on a desk? (Just playing devil's advocate here.)



I agree. I saw mentioned elsewhere, maybe the article, that a kid would never even think to do that to furniture at home. So, what makes it okay to do it in school? I have the mentality that believes you should treat wherever you are like you are at home. So, would you do that at home? If not, then don't do it at school!

I also wonder if this was just the straw that broke the camels back. What did she do in the past? OR was the principal just fired up with this and SHE was the one who got caught? Either way, she shouldn't have been doing it. But to be arrested? I'm not sure that was the best route to take.

Posted 2/18/10 10:34 AM
 

telmah
LIF Infant

Member since 1/10

239 total posts

Name:
Prince

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

When exactly did we, as a society, start losing our minds...someone please answer that.

Arrested for doodling on a desk?? I'm not saying I'd encourage that behavior, but arresting a child for that is in-sane.

Posted 2/18/10 10:39 AM
 

drpepper318
MIR MIR MIR!

Member since 6/07

8274 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted by headoverheels

Think about it, though - if she was "doodling" on the outside of the building, or on a subway train, or any other public place, would anyone have a problem with her being arrested? Why should it be different because she's in the school and she did it on a desk? (Just playing devil's advocate here.)



I agree. Although calling the cops & having her arrested sounds extreme, it's important that kids see real-life consequences of their actions... unfortunately I see the result of kids being raised without consequences at my job every day and it has led to them being totally out of control & doing whatever they want. I think a harsh punishment is better than little or no punishment. Technically she was breaking the law, so they were within their rights to do what they did. Hopefully she learns from this.

Posted 2/18/10 10:43 AM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted by MissJones

Posted by headoverheels

Ugh, this is such a sticky subject.

On the one hand, it's graffiti, which is illegal, and an arrestable offense (actually in the case of minors it's called custodializing them, not arresting them, but it's the same thing).

On the other hand, she now has to deal with an actual court case - which involves possibly hiring or being assigned an attorney, dealing with the DCA, and filing a plea, which could mean anything from a promise to stay out of trouble to actual probation.

Think about it, though - if she was "doodling" on the outside of the building, or on a subway train, or any other public place, would anyone have a problem with her being arrested? Why should it be different because she's in the school and she did it on a desk? (Just playing devil's advocate here.)



I agree. I saw mentioned elsewhere, maybe the article, that a kid would never even think to do that to furniture at home. So, what makes it okay to do it in school? I have the mentality that believes you should treat wherever you are like you are at home. So, would you do that at home? If not, then don't do it at school!

I also wonder if this was just the straw that broke the camels back. What did she do in the past? OR was the principal just fired up with this and SHE was the one who got caught? Either way, she shouldn't have been doing it. But to be arrested? I'm not sure that was the best route to take.



I have some issues with the arrest- not sure that it was needed- but as a teacher, I have so many issues with some of my kids writing on walls, desks, bookshelves, destroying property (I had a terrible group one year throw hundreds of dollars in books out a 4th floor window). I even once said to a kid "would you do that at home?" and he said "yeah" Chat Icon Chat Icon which may have been to shock me but then again, I wouldn't be surprised. Many kids I teach feel that everything is there for their convenience and that teachers and custodians are there to clean up after them.

Posted 2/18/10 10:47 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

I'm on the fence.

While it's an extreme to arrest a kid for doodling, no one can deny that graffiti is a problem - particularly in the city. I think some of the problems we have with teenagers is having things handled "in house". What they used to call "bullying" when I went to school is actually assault.

Personally, I think scrubbing all the desks after school would be a better punishment.

Posted 2/18/10 11:07 AM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted by telmah

When exactly did we, as a society, start losing our minds...someone please answer that.

Arrested for doodling on a desk?? I'm not saying I'd encourage that behavior, but arresting a child for that is in-sane.



I have to agree. I see the points of the above poster, but seriously being arrested for doodling? Where is the common sense. We are tying up our police for this when really there are so much more important things they could be doing.

Yes what the girl did was wrong. Yes she should be punished, but arrested - come on. Millions of people drive faster than the speed limit. Should we start arresting drivers for this too. We as a society are really getting out of control here. We aren't accomplishing what we oringinally set out to accomplish.

Posted 2/18/10 11:13 AM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

OMG....I so would have been arrested if they enforced this when I was in school.Chat Icon

Posted 2/18/10 11:15 AM
 

leighdvm
My golden boys!

Member since 3/06

4419 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted by Mssissy

OMG....I so would have been arrested if they enforced this when I was in school.Chat Icon



Me, too. There were quite of few "Michele wuz here" doodles....Chat Icon I know, I know....Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/18/10 11:19 AM
 

telmah
LIF Infant

Member since 1/10

239 total posts

Name:
Prince

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted by Mssissy

OMG....I so would have been arrested if they enforced this when I was in school.Chat Icon



Amen..seriously

Let he who has never doodled on a desk in Math class cast the first stone!

Posted 2/18/10 11:19 AM
 

MissJones
I need a nap!

Member since 5/05

22153 total posts

Name:

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted by nrthshgrl


Personally, I think scrubbing all the desks after school would be a better punishment.




I completely agree. Problem is that in NYC, teachers and administrators are afraid that punishments like that could be considered corporal punishment.

Posted 2/18/10 11:20 AM
 

telmah
LIF Infant

Member since 1/10

239 total posts

Name:
Prince

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted by MissJones

Posted by nrthshgrl


Personally, I think scrubbing all the desks after school would be a better punishment.




I completely agree. Problem is that in NYC, teachers and administrators are afraid that punishments like that could be considered corporal punishment.



And I think what this school did, by calling the police, was essentially washing their hands of the problem and putting it in the hands of the police. Now they've got a bigger mess in their hands.

Posted 2/18/10 11:24 AM
 

1stimemom
Love my boys

Member since 2/08

8766 total posts

Name:
Mrs Dee

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted by telmah

When exactly did we, as a society, start losing our minds...someone please answer that.

Arrested for doodling on a desk?? I'm not saying I'd encourage that behavior, but arresting a child for that is in-sane.



I agree. This is one of the stupidest most outrageous things I have ever heard for quite a few different reasons. With all of the real crime going on in the city (or anywhere for that matter), and kids bringing weapons to school, real bullies, cyber bullying, etc., THIS is what we are wasting courts and cops time and resources on!?!? If that were my kid, hell would have no fury compared to me...Chat Icon

Posted 2/18/10 11:25 AM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted by MissJones

Posted by nrthshgrl


Personally, I think scrubbing all the desks after school would be a better punishment.




I completely agree. Problem is that in NYC, teachers and administrators are afraid that punishments like that could be considered corporal punishment.



Scrubbing a child would be corporal punishment. Scrubbing a desk would not or I would have been fired a long time ago.

Message edited 2010-02-18 11:27:04.030000.

Posted 2/18/10 11:26 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted by telmah

Posted by MissJones

Posted by nrthshgrl


Personally, I think scrubbing all the desks after school would be a better punishment.




I completely agree. Problem is that in NYC, teachers and administrators are afraid that punishments like that could be considered corporal punishment.



And I think what this school did, by calling the police, was essentially washing their hands of the problem and putting it in the hands of the police. Now they've got a bigger mess in their hands.



That I do not agree with - I think that this girl's arrest will serve as a deterrent for more students than if she was simply given a detention or even suspended from school.

Posted 2/18/10 11:27 AM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

My fifth grade teacher had a stick. If he didn't like what you were doing he would smash the stick on the desk.

We were terrified of the stick.

It even had a name...

"Stickie"

I will never forget the stick.

Maybe all teachers should have a stick.

Posted 2/18/10 11:28 AM
 

1stimemom
Love my boys

Member since 2/08

8766 total posts

Name:
Mrs Dee

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted by telmah

Posted by Mssissy

OMG....I so would have been arrested if they enforced this when I was in school.Chat Icon



Amen..seriously

Let he who has never doodled on a desk in Math class cast the first stone!



I scribbled on a desk in my english class one time. I was in advanced placement for 3 yrs and missed the cutoff by 1/2 point for the 4th year. It was silly. I was bored out of my mind in the class because i was so far ahead of everyone else. The teacher caught me and asked me why I did it, so I told her. She told me to go to the bathroom to get some towels and clean it off. When I came back she had sprayed every desk in the classroom with cleaner. I cleaned my desk and sat down. She told me to clean all of the desks, and I told her no - I was a student, not a janitor. I got sent to the deans office for the rest of the period.Chat Icon

ETA - the dean happened to agree with me, and we chatted for the rest of the time.Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-02-18 11:34:22.510000.

Posted 2/18/10 11:31 AM
 

1stimemom
Love my boys

Member since 2/08

8766 total posts

Name:
Mrs Dee

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted by headoverheels



That I do not agree with - I think that this girl's arrest will serve as a deterrent for more students than if she was simply given a detention or even suspended from school.



LB, to play devils advocate from my side, would feel the same way if that was Luca being arrested? Would you want your child to be used as an "example"?

ETA - And that question goes to anyone else here, really.

Message edited 2010-02-18 11:50:13.050000.

Posted 2/18/10 11:36 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted by 1stimemom

Posted by telmah

Posted by Mssissy

OMG....I so would have been arrested if they enforced this when I was in school.Chat Icon



Amen..seriously

Let he who has never doodled on a desk in Math class cast the first stone!



I scribbled on a desk in my english class one time. I was in advanced placement for 3 yrs and missed the cutoff by 1/2 point for the 4th year. It was silly. I was bored out of my mind in the class because i was so far ahead of everyone else. The teacher caught me and asked me why I did it, so I told her. She told me to go to the bathroom to get some towels and clean it off. When I came back she had sprayed every desk in the classroom with cleaner. I cleaned my desk and sat down. She told me to clean all of the desks, and I told her no - I was a student, not a janitor. I got sent to the deans office for the rest of the period.Chat Icon

ETA - the dean happened to agree with me, and we chatted for the rest of the time.Chat Icon



Then the dean failed you in my opinion. If you intentionally drop something on the floor & are told to pick it up, do you refuse because you're not the janitor?

Personally if my kid did it & I found out about it, I'd have no issue with bringing them in on a Saturday or after school & watch them clean desks on their own time. My kids are not supposed to make a janitor's job harder.

I doodled on the desks like everyone else in school. It doesn't make it right.

Posted 2/18/10 11:39 AM
 

1stimemom
Love my boys

Member since 2/08

8766 total posts

Name:
Mrs Dee

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by 1stimemom

Posted by telmah

Posted by Mssissy

OMG....I so would have been arrested if they enforced this when I was in school.Chat Icon



Amen..seriously

Let he who has never doodled on a desk in Math class cast the first stone!



I scribbled on a desk in my english class one time. I was in advanced placement for 3 yrs and missed the cutoff by 1/2 point for the 4th year. It was silly. I was bored out of my mind in the class because i was so far ahead of everyone else. The teacher caught me and asked me why I did it, so I told her. She told me to go to the bathroom to get some towels and clean it off. When I came back she had sprayed every desk in the classroom with cleaner. I cleaned my desk and sat down. She told me to clean all of the desks, and I told her no - I was a student, not a janitor. I got sent to the deans office for the rest of the period.Chat Icon

ETA - the dean happened to agree with me, and we chatted for the rest of the time.Chat Icon



Then the dean failed you in my opinion. If you intentionally drop something on the floor & are told to pick it up, do you refuse because you're not the janitor?

Personally if my kid did it & I found out about it, I'd have no issue with bringing them in on a Saturday or after school & watch them clean desks on their own time. My kids are not supposed to make a janitor's job harder.

I doodled on the desks like everyone else in school. It doesn't make it right.



I did clean my desk. I didn't draw on anyone else's desk. I took responsibility for MY action.

Posted 2/18/10 11:46 AM
 

BabyBoy
is Skylar Elizabeth

Member since 5/05

4189 total posts

Name:
Tom

Re: Really? Arresting kids for doodling on desks?

The school has zero policy. punishment could of been handled differently but as an above poster stated, you do this any other place and you would be arrested.

good for the school

sometimes an example must be made of people...we see this all the time

Posted 2/18/10 11:48 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3