Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

Posted By Message

waterspout4
My loves

Member since 5/06

19150 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

Who did you have and are you happy?

TIA!

Posted 5/9/10 3:25 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Calla
My girls

Member since 7/05

4303 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

You can also have both -- I went to a bris a few weeks ago done by a mohel who was a pediatric urologist.

Posted 5/9/10 6:36 AM
 

Summergrl73
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/07

510 total posts

Name:
Excited

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

My mohel is a urologist- Dr. Diamond he did a great job! And you can always go see him in his office if there are any issues. That made me feel better about it.

Posted 5/9/10 7:23 AM
 

Ian&EmmesMommy23
My family is complete!

Member since 11/08

12970 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

i used Cantor Sherman who is a mohel. He did a great job and also did my friend's bris. DS hardly cried and healed perfect.

Posted 5/9/10 9:10 AM
 

Shelleybean11
Mommy of 2!

Member since 12/08

11013 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

I used a family friend, who is a OBGYN and a Mohel.

Dr Marchbein

Posted 5/9/10 9:19 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

My OB did C3's. It was fine

Posted 5/9/10 10:13 AM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

We used a Mohel. It came out fine. However, you can have a Dr. who is also a Mohel. Since we are Jewish, we needed a Mohel. However, if you are going to get it done outside of a bris, I would still use a Mohel or Dr. who is also Mohel because of the sheer number of times they have performed the procedure.

Posted 5/9/10 10:22 AM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

Honestly, I would only use a mohel - Doctor or not - because I am Jewish. This is pretty much all they do. Many of them come from long family lines of mohels and have been doing it for decades. Some of them do as many as 3 and 4 a day. If that is your bread and butter, there is very little room for error. We will more than likely be using the same mohel who did my nephew's bris as well as all of DH's cousin's little kids - Rabbi Peysach Krohn - I've seen his work - no complaints. Kelly, you will see it too come September!

Posted 5/9/10 11:36 AM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

Posted by Shelleybean11

I used a family friend, who is a OBGYN and a Mohel.

Dr Marchbein



I used him too, and I can't tell you how impressed we where with his professionalism and how personable he was. My entire family was in shock when the baby did not peep even a sound the entire time.

Baby healed perfectly. The entire experience was beyond better than anything I could have hoped for.

FM if you want more info.



Message edited 2010-05-09 12:41:57.563000.

Posted 5/9/10 12:41 PM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

I used a doc who learned the "trade" from a mohel. circ was done in hospital as he is an OB, my PED raved about my DS circ.

Posted 5/9/10 12:54 PM
 

sal79
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

1464 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

Posted by Goldi0218

Honestly, I would only use a mohel - Doctor or not - because I am Jewish. This is pretty much all they do. Many of them come from long family lines of mohels and have been doing it for decades. Some of them do as many as 3 and 4 a day. If that is your bread and butter, there is very little room for error. We will more than likely be using the same mohel who did my nephew's bris as well as all of DH's cousin's little kids - Rabbi Peysach Krohn - I've seen his work - no complaints. Kelly, you will see it too come September!



just to let you know, we used him too, he is really nice, came to my house the next day and a week later to recheck ds. ds healed fine.

Posted 5/9/10 1:20 PM
 

LoveBeingMrsT
Love my Boys!

Member since 12/05

4648 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

Posted by Shelleybean11

I used a family friend, who is a OBGYN and a Mohel.

Dr Marchbein



same. we LOVE LOVE LOVE him! he's the best!Chat Icon

Posted 5/9/10 1:49 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

We used Cantor Sherman, who is a Mohel. Just so you know, the mohels who are also doctors are reform mohels. A conservative or orthodox doctor will not also serve as a mohel because they believe that is taking away another man's livelihood. I'm pretty sure that the reform movement is exactly opposite in that they want their mohels to be doctors.

Posted 5/9/10 3:44 PM
 

waterspout4
My loves

Member since 5/06

19150 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

Posted by Kerie-is-so-very

We used Cantor Sherman, who is a Mohel. Just so you know, the mohels who are also doctors are reform mohels. A conservative or orthodox doctor will not also serve as a mohel because they believe that is taking away another man's livelihood. I'm pretty sure that the reform movement is exactly opposite in that they want their mohels to be doctors.



Would I offend by doing one or the other?

Posted 5/9/10 4:28 PM
 

Shelleybean11
Mommy of 2!

Member since 12/08

11013 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

Posted by waterspout4

Posted by Kerie-is-so-very

We used Cantor Sherman, who is a Mohel. Just so you know, the mohels who are also doctors are reform mohels. A conservative or orthodox doctor will not also serve as a mohel because they believe that is taking away another man's livelihood. I'm pretty sure that the reform movement is exactly opposite in that they want their mohels to be doctors.



Would I offend by doing one or the other?



I just want to make it clear that Dr. Marchbein is not a reform mohel. He himself goes to a conservative shul, keeps kosher and received his training from the Jewish Theological Seminary of Conservative Judaism. What the PP stated may be true in some Haredi communities but it is not an absolute.

Posted 5/9/10 7:17 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

I had KJ's done by a pediatric urologist that came highly recommended

Posted 5/9/10 7:21 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

Posted by Shelleybean11

Posted by waterspout4

Posted by Kerie-is-so-very

We used Cantor Sherman, who is a Mohel. Just so you know, the mohels who are also doctors are reform mohels. A conservative or orthodox doctor will not also serve as a mohel because they believe that is taking away another man's livelihood. I'm pretty sure that the reform movement is exactly opposite in that they want their mohels to be doctors.



Would I offend by doing one or the other?



I just want to make it clear that Dr. Marchbein is not a reform mohel. He himself goes to a conservative shul, keeps kosher and received his training from the Jewish Theological Seminary of Conservative Judaism. What the PP stated may be true in some Haredi communities but it is not an absolute.



Sorry and thanks for clarifying. I assumed that there had to be some conservative mohel doctors and that there will probably be more in the future. I learned that the traditional reason that some conservative doctors won't become mohels is the reason I stated above and I simply found it interesting. I don't think that I came across Dr. Marchbein's name in my search and I really I only know the backgrounds of the ones I looked into. Some of the ones I looked into are doctors but the one we used is not.

Kelly, I'm not sure what you are asking.

Posted 5/9/10 8:14 PM
 

waterspout4
My loves

Member since 5/06

19150 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

Posted by Kerie-is-so-very

Posted by Shelleybean11

Posted by waterspout4

Posted by Kerie-is-so-very

We used Cantor Sherman, who is a Mohel. Just so you know, the mohels who are also doctors are reform mohels. A conservative or orthodox doctor will not also serve as a mohel because they believe that is taking away another man's livelihood. I'm pretty sure that the reform movement is exactly opposite in that they want their mohels to be doctors.



Would I offend by doing one or the other?



I just want to make it clear that Dr. Marchbein is not a reform mohel. He himself goes to a conservative shul, keeps kosher and received his training from the Jewish Theological Seminary of Conservative Judaism. What the PP stated may be true in some Haredi communities but it is not an absolute.



Sorry and thanks for clarifying. I assumed that there had to be some conservative mohel doctors and that there will probably be more in the future. I learned that the traditional reason that some conservative doctors won't become mohels is the reason I stated above and I simply found it interesting. I don't think that I came across Dr. Marchbein's name in my search and I really I only know the backgrounds of the ones I looked into. Some of the ones I looked into are doctors but the one we used is not.

Kelly, I'm not sure what you are asking.



Well, since I am Catholic, I don't know what mohel is considered okay to ask to do a non-Jewish circumcision.

Posted 5/9/10 8:45 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

Posted by waterspout4

Posted by Kerie-is-so-very

Posted by Shelleybean11

Posted by waterspout4

Posted by Kerie-is-so-very

We used Cantor Sherman, who is a Mohel. Just so you know, the mohels who are also doctors are reform mohels. A conservative or orthodox doctor will not also serve as a mohel because they believe that is taking away another man's livelihood. I'm pretty sure that the reform movement is exactly opposite in that they want their mohels to be doctors.



Would I offend by doing one or the other?



I just want to make it clear that Dr. Marchbein is not a reform mohel. He himself goes to a conservative shul, keeps kosher and received his training from the Jewish Theological Seminary of Conservative Judaism. What the PP stated may be true in some Haredi communities but it is not an absolute.



Sorry and thanks for clarifying. I assumed that there had to be some conservative mohel doctors and that there will probably be more in the future. I learned that the traditional reason that some conservative doctors won't become mohels is the reason I stated above and I simply found it interesting. I don't think that I came across Dr. Marchbein's name in my search and I really I only know the backgrounds of the ones I looked into. Some of the ones I looked into are doctors but the one we used is not.

Kelly, I'm not sure what you are asking.



Well, since I am Catholic, I don't know what mohel is considered okay to ask to do a non-Jewish circumcision.



Reform may be the way to go in that case, but I am not sure.

Posted 5/9/10 8:48 PM
 

waterspout4
My loves

Member since 5/06

19150 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

Sorry everyone. Not even PG, nor planning on it soon. I was just thinking with all the botched circumcisions from our pediatricians, which way to go. My DS had to be redone at the age of 2 and I felt bad.

Posted 5/9/10 8:54 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel

Cantor Phil Sherman will perform a circumcision on a non Jewish baby. He did a great job. http://www.holisticcircumcision.com/holistic.htm

If you want the Jewish version of his website it is: emohel.com HTH

Posted 5/9/10 11:53 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Anyone have a number for a Mohel on Long Island? PrincessP 10/12/07 4 Families Helping Families ™
Moms of boys....when can I give my DS a real bath after a circumcision? missrock 4/27/09 2 Parenting
Can anyone refer a urologist to correct a circumcision in Nassau? ckone 2/3/09 4 Parenting
not for the easily offended. Circumcision and bris humor Kerie-is-so-very 10/8/07 2 Pregnancy
Spinoff-Circumcision-Personal question W/ Poll giggles 3/3/06 22 Pregnancy
Something I didn't know about Circumcision nrthshgrl 3/3/06 30 Pregnancy