Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel
Posted 5/9/2010 8:45:31 PM by waterspout4
Posted by Kerie-is-so-very
Posted by Shelleybean11
Posted by waterspout4
Posted by Kerie-is-so-very
We used Cantor Sherman, who is a Mohel. Just so you know, the mohels who are also doctors are reform mohels. A conservative or orthodox doctor will not also serve as a mohel because they believe that is taking away another man's livelihood. I'm pretty sure that the reform movement is exactly opposite in that they want their mohels to be doctors.
Would I offend by doing one or the other?
I just want to make it clear that Dr. Marchbein is not a reform mohel. He himself goes to a conservative shul, keeps kosher and received his training from the Jewish Theological Seminary of Conservative Judaism. What the PP stated may be true in some Haredi communities but it is not an absolute.
Sorry and thanks for clarifying. I assumed that there had to be some conservative mohel doctors and that there will probably be more in the future. I learned that the traditional reason that some conservative doctors won't become mohels is the reason I stated above and I simply found it interesting. I don't think that I came across Dr. Marchbein's name in my search and I really I only know the backgrounds of the ones I looked into. Some of the ones I looked into are doctors but the one we used is not.
Kelly, I'm not sure what you are asking.
Well, since I am Catholic, I don't know what mohel is considered okay to ask to do a non-Jewish circumcision.
|