Re: Spinoff- circumcision: dr vs mohel
Posted 5/9/2010 7:17:02 PM by Shelleybean11


Posted by waterspout4


Posted by Kerie-is-so-very

We used Cantor Sherman, who is a Mohel. Just so you know, the mohels who are also doctors are reform mohels. A conservative or orthodox doctor will not also serve as a mohel because they believe that is taking away another man's livelihood. I'm pretty sure that the reform movement is exactly opposite in that they want their mohels to be doctors.



Would I offend by doing one or the other?



I just want to make it clear that Dr. Marchbein is not a reform mohel. He himself goes to a conservative shul, keeps kosher and received his training from the Jewish Theological Seminary of Conservative Judaism. What the PP stated may be true in some Haredi communities but it is not an absolute.
Print Post      Close Window