Soda Ban Passed in NYC!
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 | |
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC!
|
|
Posted 9/14/12 9:44 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Posted by EatingMyVeggies what baffles me is how ciggies are still legal...................yet soda is controlled. ITA...and cigarettes can have a negative impact on not just the person buying them but on others surrounded by smoke which may not be their own choice! i don't care, i don't really drink soda but i think it is silly and probably won't change much. If someone wants soda that badly they will buy two or go home and drink a 2 liter bottle. And why not limit diet soda? Doesn't that have calories as well? Agree with PP's if you want true change you need to change the behavior and lifestyles of people. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 9:53 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! This doesn't affect ME directly because I don't drink soda. Hopefully the objective of curbing unhealthy behaviors will be met through this and other policies because ultimately as a tax payer it WILL affect me (medical costs of preventable diseases)! |
|
Posted 9/14/12 10:04 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Posted by LittleBlueBug I am fine with the soda ban but I have one big issue with it...Diet Soda can be attributed to more obesity than regular soda and it's so bad for you. If you are truely looking out for the health of others, get the facts straight. Caffiene+Aspartame not a good combo. I wish that this was banned too. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 10:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! This ban is nothing. Annoying, yes, but really, don't we all have bigger fish to fry. Buy your soda, whatever..move on. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 10:28 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Posted by jerseypanda I will say that this ban doesn't really affect me because I don't drink soda. But, if the goal is to ban the large drinks to curb obesity and help people make healthier food choices, then WHY is it still going to be OK to buy a super large diet soda? Nothing like filling your body with artificial sweeteners as a way to keep healthy. People have a right to make whatever choices they want when it comes to food. I don't agree that we should be making it illegal for people to buy a ridiculously huge soda if they want to. The problem with this is that simply taking away people's ability to get a huge soda isn't going to stop them from eating or drinking unhealthy. They are just going to find something else to replace it. You have to change behaviors and habits for people to really change. Simply taking away 1 unhealthy option from a sea of unhealthy options is going to accomplish nothing. It's like no longer giving money to a drug addict in an attempt to get them to stop doing drugs. If they aren't willing to give it up, they are just going to find some other way to get money for drugs. You have to change the behaviors and people themselves, not the product. Actually studies have shown that trying to implement ONE change is actually more effective in public health policy than giving people many options, or a vague 'eat healthy" message. One county in Alabama, I think took an approach to do a HUGE push for people to switch from whole milk to 1% mile including installing signs in grocery stores. People's buying habits changed immediately and profoundly in a way that just does not happen when you just tell people to "eat healthy" or "make good choices". Also, diet soda is definiely not the healthiest drink, but some artifical sweeteners are not harmful. I actually take phenylalanine as a vitamin. it's only harmful if you have a specific sensitivity to it. We're not trying to make people make every healthy choise, but just to curb sugar consumption from soda since it is truly empty calories. There is no nutritional value in soda. i think this measure is aimed more at low income children who receive an astonishing portion of their daily caloric intake from soda and other sugary beverages. If a kid is getting a sode at McD's after school, regardless of whatever else he's getting there, and we can cut that soda in half from 32 oz to 16oz, then that child is going to lose ~1lb per month. I think there's a fallacy of "choice" because studies have shown time and time again that when given larger portion sizes, people will eat and drink more. If people really needed or intended to drink a QUART of soda (which is what 32oz is) at lunch, they would and could just buy 2. This was not a common practice 15 years ago before these insane portions were offered, and it won't be once they're no longer offered in NYC. I can tell you from my own experience. For example, i go to Subway quite often for lunch. If I had a choice, I'd choose the 20oz drink size they offer, but with the combo, it comes with a 32oz size. Not wanting to get less for the money, I figure, well, I'd better get the 32oz and fill it up. I often drink the whole 32oz drink even though i would have been perfectly content with the 20oz drink. I think that happens a lot. If doubling the size is just 20 cents more, people are going to do it, even if it goes against their best health interests. We can talk all we want about personal responsibility but study after study shows that people do NOT make rational decisions when it comes to what they consume (both in terms of buying and eating). If a small inconvenience, like making the person determined to drink a quart of soda buy 2 cups and pay a little more, or head down to street to 7-11 will help curb childhood obesity and diabetes, I'm willing to make that tradeoff. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 10:30 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Posted by DumpsterBaby Doesn't bother me in the least. I think people are going to read far more into it than is intended, but I think the core idea of banning large sodas to curb obesity is a good one. There are a lot of people who are clearly incapable of making responsible, healthy food choices, so perhaps they need these kinds of rules to keep them accountable. agree :) |
|
Posted 9/14/12 10:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Also it's not a ban, it's a regulation |
|
Posted 9/14/12 10:32 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Posted by halfbaked Posted by JennP I had an experience similar to Bearcat's. I went to Boston Market recently and ordered a combo meal mainly because I wanted a side order of veggies with my sandwich. The cup they gave me for a drink was more like a bucket than a cup. I would venture to say that I'm not alone in neither wanting nor needing such a large cup. However, I drank it all because it was in front of me. It was diet, but still. I had the same experience at Subway, but I just didn't fill the cup all the way up- it was about half full and had ice and I STILL had some left over. Simple solution. There was a woman in front of me who was shocked at how large the cup was, too. She asked for a smaller cup and they gave it to her no problem. That's my whole thing- it's not up to the government to make those kinds of decisions for me. I should be able to decide whether or not to drink a big gulp of soda even though it's put in front of me. And if I do drink the whole thing then it's no one's fault but my own. You're right. I've done that in the past myself, although admittedly not often. However, I would venture to say that most people do not do that, so I understand where the logic is coming from. It's a way to cut calories in a place where many won't miss them. Again, I lean towards being against the ban for logistical reasons anyway. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 10:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Posted by DaniRella I'm just curious... If there's a ban on soft drinks larger than 16 oz. what's to stop someone from ordering two 12 oz. drinks or two separate 16 oz. drinks and one person drinking both? I just don't see how there is any way to really "police" this or "control" this. So, what's the point?? A. it's because people won't go to 7-11 and walk to Subway. Most people don't set out to drink these enormous drinks. They get them because it's what's offered, best vlue in terms of unit price, etc. People can absolutely buy 2 sodas or buy a bucket of soda at 7-11. the point is not that you're not allowed to drink as much soda as you want to, but that by making this small change in how serving sizes are presented, it will change the way most people consume. Most people don't go into a store knowing how many ounces of beverage they'd like to drink. Their choices are influenced by what's available. 15 years ago these huge sizes were not available and I bet you NEVER saw anyone buying two 16 oz soda cups. It would have seemed absurd and gluttonous, but now that 32oz is a regular size, people buy it constantly. it's not about limiting what you can and can't drink, just changing behavior by changing the way those choices are presented. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 10:36 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Posted by KristenRSF He's banning "sugary drinks" but yet you can order a TRIPLE WHOPPER with cheese and order 10 of them if you want. Obesity studies in children show that in inner sity youth, obesity IS linked to sugary drink consumption. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 10:39 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Posted by JennP You're right. I've done that in the past myself, although admittedly not often. However, I would venture to say that most people do not do that, so I understand where the logic is coming from. It's a way to cut calories in a place where many won't miss them. Again, I lean towards being against the ban for logistical reasons anyway. Every individual is different but studies show that most people actually will eat and drink more when the serving size is larger. have you seen the refillablke soup bowl experiment? We like to think we eat and drink what we need to eat and drink, but the portion in front of us makes a HUGE difference in perception. it even happens in other purchases. The 2nd most expensive wine on a wine list is often the most popular. Put more expensive wines on your list, and you'll increase the amount people spend on wine. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 10:42 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Posted by JenniferEver Posted by JennP You're right. I've done that in the past myself, although admittedly not often. However, I would venture to say that most people do not do that, so I understand where the logic is coming from. It's a way to cut calories in a place where many won't miss them. Again, I lean towards being against the ban for logistical reasons anyway. Every individual is different but studies show that most people actually will eat and drink more when the serving size is larger. have you seen the refillablke soup bowl experiment? We like to think we eat and drink what we need to eat and drink, but the portion in front of us makes a HUGE difference in perception. it even happens in other purchases. The 2nd most expensive wine on a wine list is often the most popular. Put more expensive wines on your list, and you'll increase the amount people spend on wine. ITA. That's why I'm torn. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 10:45 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Posted by DaniRella I'm just curious... If there's a ban on soft drinks larger than 16 oz. what's to stop someone from ordering two 12 oz. drinks or two separate 16 oz. drinks and one person drinking both? Bloomberg actually said on the radio today that people can buy 2- 16 oz drinks if they want. So, basically he doesn't care about people trying to save money. In my opinion, he is causing problems where no problems used to lie. Large sodas in movie theaters are typically shared. The only people I see walking around drinking massive sodas are teens and construction workers. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 11:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! I don't drink soda either so this doesn't effect me but I don't agree or disagree with it. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 11:32 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! No one is talking about the big picture,,,, f this stupid ban ... AMERICA IS FAT and its not healthy OBESITY is out of control .. the question is do we continue as a society to let it be bc hey we are Americans and we deserve to do anything we want to do or should our government take action??? I dont know the answer but thats what we should be talking about. Lets stop the big brother talk and talk about the real issue. Is obesity, the health of our bodies important to all of us.. well yes of course it is ? the question and debate should be how should the government get involved? they do get involved when they need to pay the bills for the sickness that OBESITY CAuSE right ? i dont know what to think but i know there is a problem and common sense is not working Message edited 2012-09-14 11:33:08.757000. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 11:32 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Posted by JenniferEver Posted by DaniRella I'm just curious... If there's a ban on soft drinks larger than 16 oz. what's to stop someone from ordering two 12 oz. drinks or two separate 16 oz. drinks and one person drinking both? I just don't see how there is any way to really "police" this or "control" this. So, what's the point?? A. it's because people won't go to 7-11 and walk to Subway. Most people don't set out to drink these enormous drinks. They get them because it's what's offered, best vlue in terms of unit price, etc. People can absolutely buy 2 sodas or buy a bucket of soda at 7-11. the point is not that you're not allowed to drink as much soda as you want to, but that by making this small change in how serving sizes are presented, it will change the way most people consume. Most people don't go into a store knowing how many ounces of beverage they'd like to drink. Their choices are influenced by what's available. 15 years ago these huge sizes were not available and I bet you NEVER saw anyone buying two 16 oz soda cups. It would have seemed absurd and gluttonous, but now that 32oz is a regular size, people buy it constantly. it's not about limiting what you can and can't drink, just changing behavior by changing the way those choices are presented. Exactly. I get that people don't like the ban but I'm also getting that people don't understand the ban. I rarely ever drink soda.. but if I'm buying a combo meal I'll get a sprite. Usually a medium size, because that's me. But if you gave me a large, extra large, or bucket size it's very likely that I'm going to drink more than I would normally because IT'S THERE. That's human behavior. Limit what they can sell and then you limit over-consumption, which most of the time, the person didn't really want anyway. If you really want that much to drink, you'll buy 2. But most people probably don't want that much in the first place, and they won't be inclined to buy 2 because it's inconvenient. I'm not saying that I think this is where Bloomberg needed to focus his attention, but he did and it passed and it's really not evil incarnate. Message edited 2012-09-14 11:38:55.217000. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 11:37 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Posted by JenniferEver Posted by jerseypanda I will say that this ban doesn't really affect me because I don't drink soda. But, if the goal is to ban the large drinks to curb obesity and help people make healthier food choices, then WHY is it still going to be OK to buy a super large diet soda? Nothing like filling your body with artificial sweeteners as a way to keep healthy. People have a right to make whatever choices they want when it comes to food. I don't agree that we should be making it illegal for people to buy a ridiculously huge soda if they want to. The problem with this is that simply taking away people's ability to get a huge soda isn't going to stop them from eating or drinking unhealthy. They are just going to find something else to replace it. You have to change behaviors and habits for people to really change. Simply taking away 1 unhealthy option from a sea of unhealthy options is going to accomplish nothing. It's like no longer giving money to a drug addict in an attempt to get them to stop doing drugs. If they aren't willing to give it up, they are just going to find some other way to get money for drugs. You have to change the behaviors and people themselves, not the product. Actually studies have shown that trying to implement ONE change is actually more effective in public health policy than giving people many options, or a vague 'eat healthy" message. One county in Alabama, I think took an approach to do a HUGE push for people to switch from whole milk to 1% mile including installing signs in grocery stores. People's buying habits changed immediately and profoundly in a way that just does not happen when you just tell people to "eat healthy" or "make good choices". Also, diet soda is definiely not the healthiest drink, but some artifical sweeteners are not harmful. I actually take phenylalanine as a vitamin. it's only harmful if you have a specific sensitivity to it. We're not trying to make people make every healthy choise, but just to curb sugar consumption from soda since it is truly empty calories. There is no nutritional value in soda. i think this measure is aimed more at low income children who receive an astonishing portion of their daily caloric intake from soda and other sugary beverages. If a kid is getting a sode at McD's after school, regardless of whatever else he's getting there, and we can cut that soda in half from 32 oz to 16oz, then that child is going to lose ~1lb per month. I think there's a fallacy of "choice" because studies have shown time and time again that when given larger portion sizes, people will eat and drink more. If people really needed or intended to drink a QUART of soda (which is what 32oz is) at lunch, they would and could just buy 2. This was not a common practice 15 years ago before these insane portions were offered, and it won't be once they're no longer offered in NYC. I can tell you from my own experience. For example, i go to Subway quite often for lunch. If I had a choice, I'd choose the 20oz drink size they offer, but with the combo, it comes with a 32oz size. Not wanting to get less for the money, I figure, well, I'd better get the 32oz and fill it up. I often drink the whole 32oz drink even though i would have been perfectly content with the 20oz drink. I think that happens a lot. If doubling the size is just 20 cents more, people are going to do it, even if it goes against their best health interests. We can talk all we want about personal responsibility but study after study shows that people do NOT make rational decisions when it comes to what they consume (both in terms of buying and eating). If a small inconvenience, like making the person determined to drink a quart of soda buy 2 cups and pay a little more, or head down to street to 7-11 will help curb childhood obesity and diabetes, I'm willing to make that tradeoff. This is one of the reasons I really enjoy LIF! This is a different perspective that I may not have thought of myself. Thanks for sharing! You've really given me something to think about. It would be interesting to see what would happen if across the board we changed portion sizes. Also if healthier food were cheaper... like coupons for lean meats/chicken & vegetables instead of all processed foods. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 11:47 AM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Posted by EatingMyVeggies what baffles me is how ciggies are still legal...................yet soda is controlled. Agree! But, unfortunately, the tobacco growers lobby is way too powerful to ever really stop the sale of cigarettes. And...as a NYC resident and taxpayer, I am so annoyed at my tax dollars going to the implementation and enforcement of a ban on soda. If people want to drink 100oz of soda at a time despite it being unhealthy, that is their problem, not mine. Improving schools, making sure people dont get shot in movie theaters, fixing roads, subways and bridges faster than in 5 years so that there isn't mind boggling traffic and delays...those are things I can get behind. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 2:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Posted by maybeababy2010 Posted by EatingMyVeggies what baffles me is how ciggies are still legal...................yet soda is controlled. Agree! But, unfortunately, the tobacco growers lobby is way too powerful to ever really stop the sale of cigarettes. And...as a NYC resident and taxpayer, I am so annoyed at my tax dollars going to the implementation and enforcement of a ban on soda. If people want to drink 100oz of soda at a time despite it being unhealthy, that is their problem, not mine. Improving schools, making sure people dont get shot in movie theaters, fixing roads, subways and bridges faster than in 5 years so that there isn't mind boggling traffic and delays...those are things I can get behind. Yeah, but how do you feel about your tax dollars going to fund healthcare and missed work days, etc for people with obesity-related health issues? |
|
Posted 9/14/12 2:13 PM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! I just feel like obesity goes SO much further than fountain sodas and their sizes. |
Posted 9/14/12 2:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Posted by JenniferEver Posted by maybeababy2010 Posted by EatingMyVeggies what baffles me is how ciggies are still legal...................yet soda is controlled. Agree! But, unfortunately, the tobacco growers lobby is way too powerful to ever really stop the sale of cigarettes. And...as a NYC resident and taxpayer, I am so annoyed at my tax dollars going to the implementation and enforcement of a ban on soda. If people want to drink 100oz of soda at a time despite it being unhealthy, that is their problem, not mine. Improving schools, making sure people dont get shot in movie theaters, fixing roads, subways and bridges faster than in 5 years so that there isn't mind boggling traffic and delays...those are things I can get behind. Yeah, but how do you feel about your tax dollars going to fund healthcare and missed work days, etc for people with obesity-related health issues? I get that, but this isn't going to make one bit of difference. If people are determined to eat/drink themselves obese they will do so, whether they buy a 40oz. soda or 4 12 oz. sodas. There's just better ways. Put the money towards health education! |
|
Posted 9/14/12 2:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! How I feel in regards to government telling me what I can or cannot do..." Get the f out of my bedroom and get the f out of my kitchen". Governmental control doesn't start big. It starts with little things then snowballs into a state of no choice |
|
Posted 9/14/12 2:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! Posted by ElizaRags35 Posted by BaseballWidow As a fat person, I can assure you, soda has NOTHING to do with my size! I wasn't allowed ANY soda or non 100% juice as a child/teen and then as an adult never had a taste for it. Except for alcohol I only drink water or un-sweetened iced tea and am STILL fat, go figure! Same here! imagine if you were drinking that much soda too, you would probably be 400lbs. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 2:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC! I think it's a good idea...like the article said, we've become accustomed to LARGER everything and its obvious from the obesity rates here that people do not make good choices. But then want all of their health issues covered. |
|
Posted 9/14/12 3:08 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arkansas Initiative 1: Ban on Gay couples adopting children..passed. | MrsPJB2007 | 11/5/08 | 29 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| NYC Rep wants to ban Pit bulls. | MsMBV | 12/27/06 | 17 | Pets |
| Smoking ban on LIRR platforms passed | DrMeg | 8/15/11 | 15 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| TransFat Ban - PASSED | Blazesyth | 12/5/06 | 14 | Families Helping Families ™ |

















I only drink water or un-sweetened iced tea and am STILL fat, go figure!