Re: Soda Ban Passed in NYC!
Posted 9/14/2012 11:47:49 AM by maybeamommy
Posted by JenniferEver
Posted by jerseypanda
I will say that this ban doesn't really affect me because I don't drink soda.
But, if the goal is to ban the large drinks to curb obesity and help people make healthier food choices, then WHY is it still going to be OK to buy a super large diet soda? Nothing like filling your body with artificial sweeteners as a way to keep healthy.
People have a right to make whatever choices they want when it comes to food. I don't agree that we should be making it illegal for people to buy a ridiculously huge soda if they want to.
The problem with this is that simply taking away people's ability to get a huge soda isn't going to stop them from eating or drinking unhealthy. They are just going to find something else to replace it.
You have to change behaviors and habits for people to really change. Simply taking away 1 unhealthy option from a sea of unhealthy options is going to accomplish nothing. It's like no longer giving money to a drug addict in an attempt to get them to stop doing drugs. If they aren't willing to give it up, they are just going to find some other way to get money for drugs.
You have to change the behaviors and people themselves, not the product.
Actually studies have shown that trying to implement ONE change is actually more effective in public health policy than giving people many options, or a vague 'eat healthy" message. One county in Alabama, I think took an approach to do a HUGE push for people to switch from whole milk to 1% mile including installing signs in grocery stores. People's buying habits changed immediately and profoundly in a way that just does not happen when you just tell people to "eat healthy" or "make good choices".
Also, diet soda is definiely not the healthiest drink, but some artifical sweeteners are not harmful. I actually take phenylalanine as a vitamin. it's only harmful if you have a specific sensitivity to it. We're not trying to make people make every healthy choise, but just to curb sugar consumption from soda since it is truly empty calories. There is no nutritional value in soda.
i think this measure is aimed more at low income children who receive an astonishing portion of their daily caloric intake from soda and other sugary beverages. If a kid is getting a sode at McD's after school, regardless of whatever else he's getting there, and we can cut that soda in half from 32 oz to 16oz, then that child is going to lose ~1lb per month.
I think there's a fallacy of "choice" because studies have shown time and time again that when given larger portion sizes, people will eat and drink more. If people really needed or intended to drink a QUART of soda (which is what 32oz is) at lunch, they would and could just buy 2. This was not a common practice 15 years ago before these insane portions were offered, and it won't be once they're no longer offered in NYC. I can tell you from my own experience. For example, i go to Subway quite often for lunch. If I had a choice, I'd choose the 20oz drink size they offer, but with the combo, it comes with a 32oz size. Not wanting to get less for the money, I figure, well, I'd better get the 32oz and fill it up. I often drink the whole 32oz drink even though i would have been perfectly content with the 20oz drink. I think that happens a lot. If doubling the size is just 20 cents more, people are going to do it, even if it goes against their best health interests. We can talk all we want about personal responsibility but study after study shows that people do NOT make rational decisions when it comes to what they consume (both in terms of buying and eating). If a small inconvenience, like making the person determined to drink a quart of soda buy 2 cups and pay a little more, or head down to street to 7-11 will help curb childhood obesity and diabetes, I'm willing to make that tradeoff.
This is one of the reasons I really enjoy LIF! This is a different perspective that I may not have thought of myself. Thanks for sharing! You've really given me something to think about.
It would be interesting to see what would happen if across the board we changed portion sizes. Also if healthier food were cheaper... like coupons for lean meats/chicken & vegetables instead of all processed foods.
|