Should we restrict kids from flying first class?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
Should we restrict kids from flying first class?
|
|
Posted 7/3/09 11:12 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? I'm putting my thoughts on this in a separate post because the article is so long: |
|
Posted 7/3/09 11:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? i am a parent as well, and i happen to think that children should not fly first class because: |
|
Posted 7/3/09 11:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? I disagree-If the parents can afford to pay for the seat, if they can afford this luxury for their family, who are to say they shouldn't? |
|
Posted 7/3/09 11:34 AM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? I'm not a parent, but I've flown first class a few times with children in the cabin and so far it's always been fine...in fact, it's been WAY better than when I'm in coach! The babies cry the same during takeoff & landing, but I'm ok with that - it's a part of life. The toddlers I've seen had more room in their seat so the parents were better able to put them down to sleep & keep their play contained to a specific area (no running up & down the aisles). I may have been lucky, but I can't see making a restriction like that...IMO if the parent has the $$ for the ticket then they deserve to be there with their entire family (so long as they do everything they can to mind their child & keep the noise/tantrums to a minimum). |
|
Posted 7/3/09 11:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? Posted by CrankyPants To me, it's the same as expensive restaurants or movies at night-yeah, it's unlikely that kids will be there, and you hope that if they are there they/their parents act appropriately but we live in this world together so we have to deal with stuff like babies crying. the difference between taking your kids to an expensive restaurant and on a first class flight is that even if you practice good parenting skills, your child could still act up - and while you can leave a restaurant, you can't leave a plane. ETF: spelling Message edited 2009-07-03 11:55:28.180000. |
|
Posted 7/3/09 11:54 AM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? Posted by headoverheels i am a parent as well, and i happen to think that children should not fly first class because: 1. people paying for the extra amenities of first class should be able to enjoy them in (mostly) peace and quiet. 2. as the article states, most children are unable to enjoy the amenities of first class. now i have never flown first class so if anyone can give me a reason why it's better for kid to fly first class than coach (extra room to change diapers, for example ) then i am totally willing to listen. contrary to what some parents think, children do not belong everywhere, no matter how well behaved they are. We were bumped up once and I actually think it woudl be harder to take care of a child in first class than in coach because of the set up of the cabin. Probably not true of all planes, but many of the major long haul carriers have flat beds at the moment that are side by side, but facing in opposite directions. I've never attemped it, so I wouldn't know, but it seems liek it'd be hard! ETA - once this little guy arrives, I don't think we'd ever have even a hope of flying first class ever again! but that's got more to do with $$ than anything else!
Message edited 2009-07-03 12:21:09.137000. |
|
Posted 7/3/09 12:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? I don't know. |
|
Posted 7/3/09 1:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? As a person who can never afford 1st class, I think ALL children should be in 1st class--especially the loud ones! |
|
Posted 7/3/09 1:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? Posted by tourist As a person who can never afford 1st class, I think ALL children should be in 1st class--especially the loud ones! j/k
|
|
Posted 7/3/09 1:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? I think it is a shame that we as a society are becoming so increasingly intolerant of children. They are human and part of our society and we have to deal with them just as we have to deal with other segments of society that we may consider "undesirable". |
|
Posted 7/3/09 1:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? Posted by stickydust You cannot control all offensive behavior - children are just one source of many. If you are all willing to pay the same amount why should one person have more of a right to be there than another person? That's exactly what my husband said. You are paying for the extra room really--not a guarantee to not be disturbed & adults are just as capable of disturbing other passengers. I was on a flight once , in coach, it was fairly empty, we were delayed an hour, on the ground, but couldn't get off the plane. They announced that we could switch seats & spread out if we wanted b.c it was empty. The business traveler next to me muttered something like, " Oh, Thank God" and picked up her paperwork & got out of her middle seat between me & a man with a baby on his lap. She seemed disgusted to have been sitting next to them. It was a little sad. The kid took middle seat & he became my buddy-- pointing out all the clouds, when we finally got in the air. |
|
Posted 7/3/09 2:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? 1st class = no annoying individuals (children and/or adult) if you become annoying you get banned from flying first class. |
|
Posted 7/3/09 2:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? Posted by Nifheim 1st class = no annoying individuals (children and/or adult) if you become annoying you get banned from flying first class. As it was mentioned I really wish they had "childless" vacation packages for adults who want to have a child free vacation. (parents who need a break and the childless people) I maybe inclined to travel more in the summer then. try sandals
|
|
Posted 7/3/09 2:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? yes true! but that doesn't include a childless flight LoL |
|
Posted 7/3/09 2:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? I think this is a load of crap. We flew to Orlando and back with our son. He was not yet 1 year old. We flew first class both ways. |
|
Posted 7/3/09 2:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? Posted by stickydust I think it is a shame that we as a society are becoming so increasingly intolerant of children. See, I don't feel this way and I've never seen any evidence of it--and I have two small children. A hundred years ago wasn't it, "Children should be seen and not heard."? That's not how it is today. While you feel people are becoming more intolerant, I feel people are becoming much more self-centered. I'm going to do what I'm going to do, and too bad for anyone else, KWIM? We're living in a society--we should all function together for the common good. That's my opinion anyway. As for kids on a first-class flight...I personally would never do it. I realize it can be a success (as we've seen from a previous post), but I'm standing there on line at Old Navy with sweat trickling down my forehead because my two year old was acting like a lunatic. It's not worth it for ME to take that gamble in a first-class cabin. And although I do enjoy giving my children a variety of different experiences ("adult" or not), in the end, I guess Headoverheels summed up my thoughts, "Children do not belong everywhere..." However, definitely bring them to first-class, because I'm sure never going to be there! ![]() Message edited 2009-07-03 14:52:54.013000. |
|
Posted 7/3/09 2:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? Posted by Eireann Posted by stickydust I think it is a shame that we as a society are becoming so increasingly intolerant of children. See, I don't feel this way and I've never seen any evidence of it--and I have two small children. A hundred years ago wasn't it, "Children should be seen and not heard."? That's not how it is today. While you feel people are becoming more intolerant, I feel people are becoming much more self-centered. I'm going to do what I'm going to do, and too bad for anyone else, KWIM? We're living in a society--we should all function together for the common good. That's my opinion anyway. As for kids on a first-class flight...I personally would never do it. I realize it can be a success (as we've seen from a previous post), but I'm standing there on line at Old Navy with sweat trickling down my forehead because my two year old was acting like a lunatic. It's not worth it for ME to take that gamble in a first-class cabin. And although I do enjoy giving my children a variety of different experiences ("adult" or not), in the end, I guess Headoverheels summed up my thoughts, "Children do not belong everywhere..." However, definitely bring them to first-class, because I'm sure never going to be there! ![]() I agree with this wholeheartedly. There is also a difference between a plane flight--which is necessary and a means to an end (travel), and a fancy restaurant or a Broadway show where people are paying for the experience per se, and for the whole audience to miss a scene can devalue the whole experience. On a plane--you recognize that people need to get places, and that includes kids, and there's no other way to work it. I annoyed by sick people who fly with the flu, etc., and infect the whole plane...but that's another story.
|
|
Posted 7/3/09 3:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? Posted by headoverheels Posted by CrankyPants To me, it's the same as expensive restaurants or movies at night-yeah, it's unlikely that kids will be there, and you hope that if they are there they/their parents act appropriately but we live in this world together so we have to deal with stuff like babies crying. the difference between taking your kids to an expensive restaurant and on a first class flight is that even if you practice good parenting skills, your child could still act up - and while you can leave a restaurant, you can't leave a plane. ETF: spelling Wellll....they could... My opinion is that "I" do not want to be in first class with a toddler with executives and such. No thank you. They dont have to "think" this over....choice is made for us
|
|
Posted 7/3/09 4:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? Posted by stickydust I think it is a shame that we as a society are becoming so increasingly intolerant of children. They are human and part of our society and we have to deal with them just as we have to deal with other segments of society that we may consider "undesirable". The fact remains that even if you police children on flights there is no gurantee you will have a good flight because you cannot control everyone's behavior. I have seen atrocious behavior from adults on flights - far worse than anything I have seen from kids. Clipping toenails, people "getting some" underthe blankets at night on a transatlantic flight. How about banning smelly people? I once sat next to a guy who was watching porn on his laptop the entire flight!! I spent the entire thime praying he would not whip it out and start yanking I would have preferred a screraming baby a million times over.You cannot control all offensive behavior - children are just one source of many. If you are all willing to pay the same amount why should one person have more of a right to be there than another person? In general I agree with you. I cant believe how many posts have been made where children seem like vultures. I really didnt realize that so many felt like this. In this post though, I do not agree. I definitely think children should not be in first class. |
|
Posted 7/3/09 4:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? I feel like its a free country. If someone is paying, they deserve whatever they pay for! |
|
Posted 7/3/09 4:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? I think the main difference is that First Class is not Le Bernadin. The only expectation you should have as a 1st class traveller is a larger seat and some actual food instead of peanuts and MAYBE a hot towel. That is it. I know some people save up for it and and it is a luxury to them but for others it isn't and it is rather commonplace. For some Balthazar may be a special place to go and for others it is a casual Wed night. Just because it is special to you does not make it special in general. You pay for physical comfort - that is it. Frankly you are still flying in the air in a TUBE - you cannot really expect too much - all that is seperating you from the screaming children is 4 ft and a thin piece of cloth. |
|
Posted 7/3/09 5:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? Posted by stickydust I think it is a shame that we as a society are becoming so increasingly intolerant of children.. It's quite the opposite. Children are showing up in more and more places and in much different circumstances then they did even 10-20 years ago. To that end we are obviously more tolerant of children then we used to be. That being said, it doesn't mean that there shouldn't be or isn't an expectation about how said children need to behave in those situations; behave or have responsible parents remove them from the situation. Last time I checked, the only way to get off a plane mid-flight isn't a pleasant one. So, if I am flying coach (as I normally do) then I expect there to be families of all sorts and young children LEARNING proper behavior for this venue. If I was in business (don't know too many kids in the business world) or 1st class I would expect that EVERYONE there behaved in a certain way. So if it is your kids first flight, you'll have no idea how they are going to respond and they should not be seated with people that know what is expected of them and will have to deal with the consequences of not behaving. And yes, I may be childless, but I am far from anti-child or a child hater. If I am ever blessed with a child, I will be sure to practice responsible parenting and keep to the same values I have posted here today. |
|
Posted 7/3/09 6:03 PM
|
|
|
KittyKatCopper
Member since 3/09 1579 total posts Name: |
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? Posted by CrankyPants If you don't want to fly with kids, I say charter your own private jet. If I could afford to do this i would...haha |
Posted 7/3/09 7:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Should we restrict kids from flying first class? As a former flight attendant as well as the parent to a toddler my opinion is that small children do not belong in first class. |
|
Posted 7/3/09 7:31 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Article: Should kids be banned from first class? | Lisa | 7/1/09 | 33 | Childfree Families! |
| How many kids are in your class? | MissJones | 10/26/07 | 35 | Teachers |
| Flying safely with kids 22-44 lbs... | KristinasMama | 4/1/08 | 0 | Parenting |
| Flying with kids - ID question | lipglossjunky73 | 2/15/08 | 9 | Parenting |
| Sorry...Another Flying with kids question.... | btrflygrl | 1/23/08 | 3 | Parenting |
| Flying with kids when they have a cold | JennChris | 12/20/07 | 1 | Parenting |





) then i am totally willing to listen. 

but that's got more to do with $$ than anything else!


I would have preferred a screraming baby a million times over.
My son was better behaved than the "executive" who sat in the seat behind us. He broke every rule, was rude to the flight attendants and the AIR MARSHALL had to come on the flight to talk to him because he caused such a disruption.


