Sensitive Topic - serious question

Posted By Message

CouponKT
Our family is complete

Member since 6/06

16494 total posts

Name:
K

Sensitive Topic - serious question

Do you think ADD can be "learned"?

I am WELL aware that this is not the case for most kids who medically have this condition and it is not controlled by themselves or their parents.

My question refers more to the kind of kids that are not well supervised by their parents, do not have much discipline and are not taught how to entertain themselves quietly. Do you think that a child of this nature can act off the wall and uncontrollable solely because their parents allowed it? Is this medically still considered ADD if the child cannot control their attention span?

Posted 2/4/12 8:06 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Teachergal
We made a snowman!

Member since 1/08

3239 total posts

Name:

Re: Sensitive Topic - serious question

No I don't think that behavior is actually ADD. Some children actually have a chemical imbalance and despite interventions from either parents or professionals (school teachers, psychologists) still need medication to alter their behavior. That is ADD. And then there are kids who don't have a lot of discipline in the home or perhaps proper supervision and the result is that their behavior appears ADD-like. The difference with these kids is that with proper intervention, you CAN see a difference in their behaviors. Usually this comes up in the school when I tell a parent that their child is hard-working and focused and then the parent reports that they don't see this at all outside of school. But school is really structured and there are clear limits/expectations so sometimes we see different behavior.

ETA: Clarified my answer a bit.

Message edited 2012-02-04 08:14:09.080000.

Posted 2/4/12 8:12 AM
 

lbride
Lovin' my mini man!

Member since 3/07

2475 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Sensitive Topic - serious question

There's a major difference between being wild and unruly and ADD or ADHD.

Posted 2/4/12 8:30 AM
 

CouponKT
Our family is complete

Member since 6/06

16494 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Sensitive Topic - serious question

Posted by lbride

There's a major difference between being wild and unruly and ADD or ADHD.



but do people/teachers/schools wind up labeling this as ADD?

Posted 2/4/12 8:34 AM
 

A3CM
Avatar Title

Member since 9/08

3762 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Sensitive Topic - serious question

Posted by CouponKT

Posted by lbride

There's a major difference between being wild and unruly and ADD or ADHD.



but do people/teachers/schools wind up labeling this as ADD?



People teachers and schools are NOT qualified to label a child anything. And if they did I would have some major issues.

They can recommend evaluations be done, but cannot label the child.

Posted 2/4/12 8:46 AM
 

happymommy100
LIF Zygote

Member since 2/12

25 total posts

Name:

Re: Sensitive Topic - serious question

Read this:

http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2010/08/17/129255572/a-second-thought-on-the-accuracy-of-adhd-diagnosis-in-kids

Posted 2/4/12 8:48 AM
 

CouponKT
Our family is complete

Member since 6/06

16494 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Sensitive Topic - serious question

Posted by happymommy100

Read this:

http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2010/08/17/129255572/a-second-thought-on-the-accuracy-of-adhd-diagnosis-in-kids




ahh, quite interesting. Thank you for posting.

Posted 2/4/12 8:52 AM
 

lbride
Lovin' my mini man!

Member since 3/07

2475 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Sensitive Topic - serious question

Posted by CouponKT

Posted by lbride

There's a major difference between being wild and unruly and ADD or ADHD.



but do people/teachers/schools wind up labeling this as ADD?



all "labeling" is done through extensive testing, most of it done by neurologists.

Posted 2/4/12 8:53 AM
 

mom2aidan
2 boys & 1 girl :)

Member since 11/06

1874 total posts

Name:

Re: Sensitive Topic - serious question

Posted by AJandCJsMommy

Posted by CouponKT

Posted by lbride

There's a major difference between being wild and unruly and ADD or ADHD.



but do people/teachers/schools wind up labeling this as ADD?



People teachers and schools are NOT qualified to label a child anything. And if they did I would have some major issues.

They can recommend evaluations be done, but cannot label the child.



But in many cases teachers complete the Connor's scale evaluation for the ped or neuro and they use it as part of their diagnosis so they do have a say.

Posted 2/4/12 9:09 AM
 

kerrycec03
Mom of 2 beautiful boys!!

Member since 6/06

13519 total posts

Name:
Kerry

Re: Sensitive Topic - serious question

hmmm never thought of it.

I have a crazy little boy (as you know) but I never thought he had ADD because when something that interests him is going on (like watching a movie, etc) he can focus for extended periods times)

He generally gets good reports in school and no one has considered "ADD".

I think there is a difference but I think many schools/doc misdiagnosis it.

Posted 2/4/12 9:47 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Sensitive Topic - serious question

I do wonder if an aspect of the diagnosis is related to a learned behavior. I think you bring up some great points.

Posted 2/4/12 4:40 PM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Sensitive Topic - serious question

I know this is not 100% what you asked but, I think it's related to the question so wanted to share. When my DS was a toddler I remember asking the Ped how much sleep he needed. We got on a discussion about how important sleep is and he told us that kids that do not get the necessary amount of sleep at night acutally manifest the attributes of ADD. I also remember reading a NY Times article a while back that noted that many of the children being diagnosed with ADD were the youngest in their class - i.e. a Nov. baby or something like that - b//c there is such a dramatic difference in the early years b/w a child born in Jan. and one in Nov. that the younger children were standing out as if they had an attention issue.

I guess my point is - yes, I do believe there can be contributing factors not necessesarily medical that contribute to a child displaying ADD tendencies.

Posted 2/4/12 5:17 PM
 

nycgirl
Angels!

Member since 3/09

7721 total posts

Name:

Re: Sensitive Topic - serious question

After having a very active child... A lot of a kids personality is innate.

My son is very active... Never napped. People with kids can't believe he has the energy he does. I would think adhd but he has a long attention span. All his behavior was there day 1. I could see adhd being similar... There from the start.

Posted 2/4/12 5:21 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Sensitive Topic - serious question

Posted by Teachergal

No I don't think that behavior is actually ADD. Some children actually have a chemical imbalance and despite interventions from either parents or professionals (school teachers, psychologists) still need medication to alter their behavior. That is ADD. And then there are kids who don't have a lot of discipline in the home or perhaps proper supervision and the result is that their behavior appears ADD-like. The difference with these kids is that with proper intervention, you CAN see a difference in their behaviors. Usually this comes up in the school when I tell a parent that their child is hard-working and focused and then the parent reports that they don't see this at all outside of school. But school is really structured and there are clear limits/expectations so sometimes we see different behavior.

ETA: Clarified my answer a bit.



ITA

Posted 2/4/12 6:38 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Sensitive Topic - serious question

In the NY Times a few days ago there was an article about a child who had Asperger's. His mom thought he had it and he was even featured a documentary about the disease. It turns out that he did not have the illness. He was a normal kid who had trouble making friends and focused a lot on obscure poetry. So yes, I think it is possible, not likely, but possible that some children are misdiagnosed with a variety of spectrum issues. If you have questions about your DC, I would get testing done, have an initial opinion, and a second opinion just to make sure your DC was correctly evaluated.

Posted 2/4/12 6:44 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Serious question..Long story..but wanted your input mitabtrfly 4/12/07 10 Families Helping Families ™
wierd but serious question Dee 10/9/06 8 Parenting
Serious question curliegirl 9/12/06 2 TTC
ok serious question about car seats for babies luvsbob4603 8/23/06 18 Families Helping Families ™
I have a sensitive question MamaNDaddyof3 6/27/06 13 Pregnancy
Sensitive question about drinking and TTC flanders 3/9/06 13 TTC