Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? "treat infants with respect in order to help children grow up to be independent people with a strong sense of self" |
|
Posted 1/15/11 1:41 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? I know people that do. I don't label my parenting style, but I try to give as much of my time and attention as I can to my DS...And that means giving him options, but knowing that it will take him 10 minutes to decide whether he wants a pretzel or a cracker, a shower or a bath, the green pajamas or the blue pajamas, etc. But I feel like giving him those choices empowers him, and in a world where toddlers don't have much of a voice, it gives some control. |
|
Posted 1/15/11 1:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? i dont know..seems like it would be common sense to me. |
|
Posted 1/15/11 2:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? There are always going to be people who are for and against any method or style of anything. Its just the way it is. I happen to do a lot of the things they talk about, but for me it was my way of parenting not someone else's theory. I let them play by themselves, I'm not all over them, they explore things on their own, I speak to them as adults (with in reason) I give them choices etc etc. I disagree with some points; I would not throw out my children's toys, I do let them watch tv, I think its ok to have noisy toys and I don't think I should expect them to play for very long periods by themselves at such a young age. I do think there are phases and separation anxiety is a very basic one IMO. I don't see why people would get so up in arms about it unless someone was forcing it on them, but I don't care if people agree or disagree with what I do. |
|
Posted 1/15/11 2:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? I read the article and it's funny but to me because that RIE sounds like common sense. I mean, I've been doing all of that with my DD since she was born. I just always assumed it's the natural way to parent a child, who knew it had a name!! Message edited 2011-01-15 14:57:01.320000. |
|
Posted 1/15/11 2:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? I think different styles of parenting help develop different kinds of children. NOt saying one is better than the other. Just different. For example I am a schedule mom, and that is what works for us. My best friend is a more lax mom. THey sleep in the car or wherever, eat at whatever works. I don't think either is better, but its just what works for us. |
|
Posted 1/15/11 3:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? The only thing I can say is that labeling it is what I find to be a little silly, but certainly not controversial. It just seems like, um, ok, common sense shouldn't need a name. KWIM? I just don't see parenting as being a method, y'know? So it's the label and the calling it a parenting method that get me, not what it's actually all about. |
|
Posted 1/15/11 3:14 PM
|
|
|
! Posted by Hofstra26 I read the article and it's funny but to me because that RIE sounds like common sense. I mean, I've been doing all of that with my DD since she was born. I just always assumed it's the natural way to parent a child, who knew it had a name!! We've always talked to our DD and explained what we're doing as we're doing, we're always showing her everything and teaching her about the world around her, we love to listen to her babble as a baby and now talk and tell "stories" as she's older, we've always encouraged independent play from the time she was an infant and now at age 2 she can occupy herself forever with toys and games and coloring, and we have always let her try and figure things out for herself instead of jumping in and doing everything for her.........in fact, we always stop other people from jumping in as well because I think the natural reaction to a child's frustration is to step in and "make it all better for them" by just doing it for them and to me that does more harm then good. It was always important to DH and I that we raise a child who is confident, independent, imaginative, happy, and secure and I think by doing things like encouraging independent play, and talking to them constantly, and treating them with respect, manners and love all the time accomplishes that and it's so easy to do. Again, to me that's just being a good parent.........I never even knew I was following any sort of "method". I never knew this. My mother told me I should sleep near my baby, take him to the kitchen when I'm cooking and showering and talk and entertain him till I'm blue in the face, and if he doesn't play by himself, put on some catchy kids show. Honestly it didn't come as common sense, and the advice I got was so against my nature. It wore me down. I had no clue this is how I could do things and that DS and I could be so happy. There is a lot more to it than what the article picks at, its really just this whole, pause and think about what your doing approach, let the baby's queue lead play, but also discipline is big part of it too. It teaches that you are your child's leader, you have to set rules for bedtime, diaper time, cleaning, changing, and you insist that they are cooperative. To insist that my DS help me with his diaper change, never ever occurred to me. But now I ask him to lift his legs so I can whipe him, and he does, blows me a way. My mom asked me today, why he does that with his legs. I say because he knows you need to wipe his butt. She didn't believe me, then he did it the next time, she was like "really?, you think he gets it" Of course! He used to wrestle me, fight me, try to stand up and climb me. No way, no more! Who knew respecting him and telling him what I'm going to do, could change that? I don't need toys during diaper changes anymore. I'm free! I cannot contain the excitement I have over how well this is working. I think people need to know about it! eta: pressed enter too quick... Message edited 2011-01-15 21:22:02.227000. |
|
Posted 1/15/11 9:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? For me, this also sounds like common sense. You said the RIE method is "sort of the anti-thesis of attachment parenting", but I don't see it like that. The only major difference I've seen (from a quick look at the article) is that RIE says to let your infant cry. Attachment parenting promotes letting your baby do/learn things on their own, at their own pace. In the end, they're both about raising children to be independent & secure. |
|
Posted 1/15/11 10:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? Posted by mommyIam Posted by Hofstra26 I read the article and it's funny but to me because that RIE sounds like common sense. I mean, I've been doing all of that with my DD since she was born. I just always assumed it's the natural way to parent a child, who knew it had a name!! We've always talked to our DD and explained what we're doing as we're doing, we're always showing her everything and teaching her about the world around her, we love to listen to her babble as a baby and now talk and tell "stories" as she's older, we've always encouraged independent play from the time she was an infant and now at age 2 she can occupy herself forever with toys and games and coloring, and we have always let her try and figure things out for herself instead of jumping in and doing everything for her.........in fact, we always stop other people from jumping in as well because I think the natural reaction to a child's frustration is to step in and "make it all better for them" by just doing it for them and to me that does more harm then good. It was always important to DH and I that we raise a child who is confident, independent, imaginative, happy, and secure and I think by doing things like encouraging independent play, and talking to them constantly, and treating them with respect, manners and love all the time accomplishes that and it's so easy to do. Again, to me that's just being a good parent.........I never even knew I was following any sort of "method". I never knew this. My mother told me I should sleep near my baby, take him to the kitchen when I'm cooking and showering and talk and entertain him till I'm blue in the face, and if he doesn't play by himself, put on some catchy kids show. Honestly it didn't come as common sense, and the advice I got was so against my nature. It wore me down. I had no clue this is how I could do things and that DS and I could be so happy. There is a lot more to it than what the article picks at, its really just this whole, pause and think about what your doing approach, let the baby's queue lead play, but also discipline is big part of it too. It teaches that you are your child's leader, you have to set rules for bedtime, diaper time, cleaning, changing, and you insist that they are cooperative. To insist that my DS help me with his diaper change, never ever occurred to me. But now I ask him to lift his legs so I can whipe him, and he does, blows me a way. My mom asked me today, why he does that with his legs. I say because he knows you need to wipe his butt. She didn't believe me, then he did it the next time, she was like "really?, you think he gets it" Of course! He used to wrestle me, fight me, try to stand up and climb me. No way, no more! Who knew respecting him and telling him what I'm going to do, could change that? I don't need toys during diaper changes anymore. I'm free! I cannot contain the excitement I have over how well this is working. I think people need to know about it! eta: pressed enter too quick... How you parent makes a such a difference in how your child behaves and reacts to different situations. I know so many people think I was "blessed" or just "lucky" with my DD because everything with her has always been easy........diaper changes, napping, eating, etc. but I firmly believe that I wasn't lucky, DH and I have just parented her well. I think things have always been easy for us because we've always respected our DD, we've always been consistent, and we're always engaging her in the world around us. Because of the routines we set in place with her she always knows what to expect. When a child knows what to expect it makes things easier, there is no fight. She knows what to expect when she's on the changing table, she knows what to expect when we put her in the tub, and so on and so forth. I don't believe in getting "lucky" and having a "good" kid. Good kids comes from good parents. I really believe that. As a teacher I've met many, many, many children and whenever I've met a sweet, well mannered, well behaved child sure enough there is a really wonderful, kind, respectful parent right behind them.
|
|
Posted 1/15/11 10:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? See, I never heard of this...but I don't parent like this at all. |
|
Posted 1/15/11 10:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? Posted by OrganicMama For me, this also sounds like common sense. You said the RIE method is "sort of the anti-thesis of attachment parenting", but I don't see it like that. The only major difference I've seen (from a quick look at the article) is that RIE says to let your infant cry. Attachment parenting promotes letting your baby do/learn things on their own, at their own pace. In the end, they're both about raising children to be independent & secure. I said that because after a ton of research the only people who were apposed to this method where saying its anti attachment parenting... I don't know about attachment parenting, the first I ever heard of it was you sleep with your baby and I was just so turned off by this. The times I tried it, I couldn't sleep. But anyway, I'm sure a lot of the good parenting approaches have similarities. I just wanted to get info about this one out there, something about it a whole clicked for me, so magically. I can't contain excitement, like I said.
|
|
Posted 1/15/11 10:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? OK, DS is 10 months old and diaper changes are craziness now that he just wants to roll over and crawl all over. Seriously, it's a struggle to get the new diaper on.... anyone care to tell me how to get this accomplished without all the struggle? |
|
Posted 1/15/11 10:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? i also feel this is kind of what i do already |
|
Posted 1/15/11 11:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? Posted by mommyIam Posted by OrganicMama For me, this also sounds like common sense. You said the RIE method is "sort of the anti-thesis of attachment parenting", but I don't see it like that. The only major difference I've seen (from a quick look at the article) is that RIE says to let your infant cry. Attachment parenting promotes letting your baby do/learn things on their own, at their own pace. In the end, they're both about raising children to be independent & secure. I said that because after a ton of research the only people who were apposed to this method where saying its anti attachment parenting... I don't know about attachment parenting, the first I ever heard of it was you sleep with your baby and I was just so turned off by this. The times I tried it, I couldn't sleep. But anyway, I'm sure a lot of the good parenting approaches have similarities. I just wanted to get info about this one out there, something about it a whole clicked for me, so magically. I can't contain excitement, like I said. ![]() Yes, co-sleeping is a part of attachment parenting, so is wearing your baby in a sling (they get to see the world from a different view). Basically, the baby develops trust & the closeness to the parents fosters independence. It's also about being a sensitive and "responsive" parent, attending to baby's cries and needs. Typically, attachment parents would never do CIO. I don't follow it to the letter, I do what works for me and what I feel is right. DS sleeping in my bed feels right, not letting him cry, etc. I held him most of the day for the first 2 months, and everyone told me I was spoiling him He has his moments, but he's a pretty independent 7.5 month old. We go through periods of separation anxiety, but I believe that's a normal phase that has to do with them becoming more mobile (and an instinctual safety mechanism). He knows how to play by himself and doesn't need me to entertain him all day. Granted, it's only for about 15 minutes, but I don't expect him to play for longer than that. I am curious about the diaper change thing too. How in the heck do you get him to lift his legs? |
|
Posted 1/16/11 8:40 AM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? Posted by LoveyQ OK, DS is 10 months old and diaper changes are craziness now that he just wants to roll over and crawl all over. Seriously, it's a struggle to get the new diaper on.... anyone care to tell me how to get this accomplished without all the struggle? Diaper changes where beyond crazy here. If it was poop, it was a guarantee I'd have to change all his clothes and mine after he diaper change. So my first attempts at a "RIE diaper change" went down like this: He is on the floor playing I kneel down to him, make eye contact and say "Looks like you need a diaper change" pause "I'm going to pick you up" pause pick him up "Lets go to your room, where is your changing table" - go to his room "I need you to lie down on the changing table, and help me change your diaper" pause "Lie Down, Please" pause and lie him down. pause I know the pause is probably obvious and annoying, but really pause and give them a chance to think about what you said, take this time to see their reaction, they really do respond and understand. The first few times he decided to turn over, I said "I see you want turn over, we can do it later, now is time for diaper change" or if he tried to pull up on me "I see your very good at pulling up, but now we do diaper change" Or if he decided to thrust himself off the table. I hold him down and say "you kick hard, but not now, I need your help with diaper change" ... be persistent, not angry, not too stern, just materfactly, we need to get this done, and I need you to cooperate. The first diaper change of this kind too 10 minutes. It was hard work not too loose it. The next time I incorporated, "here are your pants, lets pull them down, can you help?"... "lift your legs I need to wipe your tush" - so I ask him to participate in every aspect of it, in that way he's paying attention to whats going on and whats involved and actually makes it a lot easier. Diaper changes now are pretty easy I'm can't believe the contrast. Now I even give him a choice, before I even pick him up "It looks like you need diaper change? Do you want to go to your room for diaper change?" and wait for his response. For a 10m to have this kind of control and power in his life is huge I think. I makes him feel it was his idea and his game to play. He knows the rules are ones i made up, but 9/10 its a flawless diaper change. He'll still try to climb me, or something, I just stay calm as possible, and make sure he understands, diaper change time is off limits to creativity and play. It is what is, and he's expected to cooperate. After we really got the hang of it, I now ask him if he wants a diaper change. He's grimace and whine if he doesn't. Sometimes he's just too busy playing and cannot be bothered. So I let him be and come back a little later. It pretty amazing I can have this kind of relationship with an infant. It never would have been common sense to me to expect it. There are probably a few other things in the book I read on this, I might glossing over. "Your Self Confident Baby" really worth a read if its something you're interested in |
|
Posted 1/16/11 8:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? Don't have a problem with most recommendations in this article, and most are things we do (or did do), but I think every parent has to do what works for them and their own child. I do think it's important to give your child choices, but too many choices can backfire too. |
|
Posted 1/16/11 4:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? While I have the time, I am too lazy to read the book LOL so thank you for explaining the method and how you apply it to your DS! |
|
Posted 1/16/11 4:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? Posted by cjik This is almost exactly what I used to do with DS, maybe without the pauses or same wording but similar. It worked when he was younger, but no way does it work now. So we've had to modify how we deal with this, and I think parenting is like that. You constantly have to morph as they get older. I was just going to post something similar to this. As a teacher, I've learned that one teaching style does not work for all and what may work one day may not work the same way the next. I think parenting is very similar. Consistency is key no matter how you choose to parent, but I think you have to be prepared that as your child gets older he or she will change and you may have to change with that. I also don't think that necessarily when you see a "good" child it is always the result of good parenting. There are plenty of kids I see at school that have absent parents, obnoxious parents and/or selfish parents, and their children are sweet as can be. Just like when you see a tough kid, it doesn't mean that it is always the result of a lack of parenting. Some kids are just stubborn and wild. Of course, how the parents choose to channel that energy is up to them. Sorry to go off on a tangent but its an interesting topic!
|
|
Posted 1/16/11 5:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? Posted by Teachergal Sorry to go off on a tangent but its an interesting topic! I totally agree. I'm fascinated! I never thought so much about it. And absolutely agree, that all babies, children, moms are different, what works for one, doesn't always work for all. Posted by Tilde also I realized that when I change her diaper, half the time I am not even looking at her! I know! I did it too! You'd think it would be common sense! But I realized I was treating him like a doll and thrashing him around as such. And then wondering why in the world is he putting up such a fight? I don't know about what the future holds for us, if I'll need to re adapt this parenting style later, but I'm confident that we've developed a mutual respect - at least for now, which is a lot more than what we were going throw a few months ago. |
|
Posted 1/16/11 6:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? Thanks for explaining the diaper thing. I didn't see it until now, but just today I tried talking him through the diaper change, explaining what I would be doing etc. I've tried it before, but once he starts trying to roll over and crawl away, I used to just tell him no, stay here, etc. Today I tried asking him not to turn around, to stay still for me to change his diaper, asked him to lift his legs and help me... I don't think he had any idea what I was talking about, but he really seemed to be listening to me so that's great. Going to try some of the recommendations as well. |
|
Posted 1/16/11 7:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? Posted by Teachergal I also don't think that necessarily when you see a "good" child it is always the result of good parenting. There are plenty of kids I see at school that have absent parents, obnoxious parents and/or selfish parents, and their children are sweet as can be. Just like when you see a tough kid, it doesn't mean that it is always the result of a lack of parenting. Some kids are just stubborn and wild. Of course, how the parents choose to channel that energy is up to them. Sorry to go off on a tangent but its an interesting topic! ![]() I agree with this. Different things work for different kids. Exactly why when you have more than 1 child and you raise them both the same but each child has different idiosyncrasies and different areas of defiance, different strengths etc. |
|
Posted 1/16/11 8:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? Posted by LoveyQ Thanks for explaining the diaper thing. I didn't see it until now, but just today I tried talking him through the diaper change, explaining what I would be doing etc. I've tried it before, but once he starts trying to roll over and crawl away, I used to just tell him no, stay here, etc. Today I tried asking him not to turn around, to stay still for me to change his diaper, asked him to lift his legs and help me... I don't think he had any idea what I was talking about, but he really seemed to be listening to me so that's great. Going to try some of the recommendations as well. he is really listening! and I bet he has more idea of what is going on than you think.
|
|
Posted 1/16/11 8:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: Really? Is this a controversial parenting approach? Posted by OrganicMama He knows how to play by himself and doesn't need me to entertain him all day. Granted, it's only for about 15 minutes, but I don't expect him to play for longer than that. I used to not expect more than 15 minutes either.. but now I expect DS to play by himself for an hour and half at a time, and he does happily. It doesn't mean I leave him a lone. I'm in the room and I observe his play. I observe all his little achievements and when he looks at me to acknowledge I say "I see that, you just rolled the ball" and he smiles and is so happy with himself. I never tell him what to play with or how to play, unless he needs direction I give him a choice of 2 toys. When I need to leave him I look him straight in the eye, and I tell him I'm going to go and come back. He may whine, but there are no screams, and if there are, I acknowledge "I can hear you, but I'm in the bathroom" if his screams are too loud to hear me, so be it. I come back when I can. 1 week of this and he rarely screams when I or DH leave the room, as long as we get to his level, look in his eyes and tell him what is going on. |
|
Posted 1/16/11 9:49 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Parenting Style | MrsBumbleb | 8/18/05 | 7 | Parenting |
| parenting magazines | futuremrs | 8/18/05 | 3 | Parenting |
| Toy Bags....(xpost parenting) | monkeybride | 8/17/05 | 1 | Pregnancy |
| Diapers? (reposted on Parenting) | Melbernai | 8/3/05 | 8 | Pregnancy |
| Repost from Parenting board...maternity/disabiloty | 05mommy09 | 7/25/05 | 2 | Pregnancy |
| Repost from Parenting: Mom Can't Live With Her and Can't Live Without Her | nylisa | 7/15/05 | 1 | Families Helping Families ™ |











He has his moments, but he's a pretty independent 7.5 month old. We go through periods of separation anxiety, but I believe that's a normal phase that has to do with them becoming more mobile (and an instinctual safety mechanism). He knows how to play by himself and doesn't need me to entertain him all day. Granted, it's only for about 15 minutes, but I don't expect him to play for longer than that. 