Re-doing taxes?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

CSK
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/11

892 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Posted by LovesMike

Thanks, BabyBoy.

To answer your questions -
1) Yes, we are aware the change has had implications. We would like to get more money in our checks, but I still wouldn't think that each of us claiming 1 would mean such a small return.

2. CPA didn't give us any summary. Nada.

3. I would not mind paying to have the amendment done and ditching the current CPA since he is the worst. But only if the amended return would be worth the extra trouble and $.

4. I understand. In the 6 months we owned the house we paid c. $6K in taxes, paid easily a few grand in mortgage interest, I think we had 1 point on the mortgage, we have about $500/mo of student loans, and we don't make that much money!! I think our combined income is in the low $100Ks. OH, DH is a teacher too, so he gets all sorts of deductions. We are both union employees and our dues are deductible.

We know he did an itemized return. It seems like something is wrong, to me, at least. But I'm no CPA. Chat Icon



forgetting a summary, do you have a copy of your tax return? you should have a copy. if you don't, you should ask for it.

lowering your withholding when you paid last year wasn't something I would have recommended, especially if you were looking to get a refund at tax time.

Why do you think you should be filing an amended return? do you know that he did the return wrong?

you keep harping on saying this CPA is the worst.... if he's not giving you a copy of your return and answering questions that you have then I agree that is poor, have you asked him any of these?

However, he has no impact on what your tax refund/payment is. What you get back (or don't) is a series of life choices you made the the results of them. you owe the government what you owe. Any preparer who says that they have some magic to make it better for a normal everyday personal return is lying, either to you or helping you lie to the government. For most of the population of returns, there really is 1 right way to do it.

Message edited 2013-04-12 09:42:01.620000.

Posted 4/12/13 9:39 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Posted by CSK

Posted by LovesMike

Thanks, BabyBoy.

To answer your questions -
1) Yes, we are aware the change has had implications. We would like to get more money in our checks, but I still wouldn't think that each of us claiming 1 would mean such a small return.

2. CPA didn't give us any summary. Nada.

3. I would not mind paying to have the amendment done and ditching the current CPA since he is the worst. But only if the amended return would be worth the extra trouble and $.

4. I understand. In the 6 months we owned the house we paid c. $6K in taxes, paid easily a few grand in mortgage interest, I think we had 1 point on the mortgage, we have about $500/mo of student loans, and we don't make that much money!! I think our combined income is in the low $100Ks. OH, DH is a teacher too, so he gets all sorts of deductions. We are both union employees and our dues are deductible.

We know he did an itemized return. It seems like something is wrong, to me, at least. But I'm no CPA. Chat Icon



forgetting a summary, do you have a copy of your tax return? you should have a copy. if you don't, you should ask for it.

lowering your withholding when you paid last year wasn't something I would have recommended, especially if you were looking to get a refund at tax time.

Why do you think you should be filing an amended return? do you know that he did the return wrong?

you keep harping on saying this CPA is the worst.... if he's not giving you a copy of your return and answering questions that you have then I agree that is poor, have you asked him any of these?

However, he has no impact on what your tax refund/payment is. What you get back (or don't) is a series of life choices you made the the results of them. you owe the government what you owe. Any preparer who says that they have some magic to make it better for a normal everyday personal return is lying, either to you or helping you lie to the government. For most of the population of returns, there really is 1 right way to do it.




I agree. We picked up the copy of the return last night. He can't figure out why he told us we were getting a $2700 federal return, which turned out to be a $312 fed return. He has no recall, but DH and I both heard him tell us that when we sat with him.

I understand we can only get back what we may have overpaid, and it actually seems like we were spot on with our withholdings, but that's not to say he didn't give us incorrect information. He did. So we were looking forward to the return our CPA said we were owed. That's all! Nothing more or less.

Posted 4/12/13 10:10 AM
 

drpepper318
MIR MIR MIR!

Member since 6/07

8274 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Re-doing taxes?

UGH!!!!! I don't know much about taxes but I feel your pain... I was thinking since I paid estimated taxes for this year, I wouldn't have to pay anymore.... well I have to pay over $3,000 more plus estimated taxes for NEXT year... ugh sometimes I feel like why do I bother to work when I have to keep handing so much over?? We're not even high earners at all.

Anyway, sorry for my rant, but maybe pick up TurboTax & try inputting everything yourself & see what happens.... might be the least expensive solution & at least you'll have some basis for comparison.... I don't know, good luck.

Posted 4/12/13 10:15 AM
 

Jenn79
One more?

Member since 2/12

2410 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

I would say it's wrong! We moved into our house in June of last year, and bc you can claim certain things from closing, we did just as well as we did this year after a full year in the house! We have an awesome tax guy!! I sent my sister to him this year and she was insanely happy with her refund this yr! Fm if u want info.

Posted 4/12/13 10:39 AM
 

RellyWife
LIF Infant

Member since 2/10

82 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Posted by drpepper318

maybe pick up TurboTax & try inputting everything yourself & see what happens.... might be the least expensive solution & at least you'll have some basis for comparison.... I don't know, good luck.



I agree- why don't you go to the TurboTax website and input your numbers? It is super easy- it walks you through everything and you don't have to pay unless you file with them. It shows you your return/what you owe as you go along. Good luck!

Posted 4/12/13 2:57 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Switching from Single-0 to Married-1 is going to make a big difference on your refund. That's really the bottom line here. I am not sure how you can expect to take home more per paycheck and still get a huge refund. The numbers just don't work that way and it's not the CPA's fault you are getting less claiming M-1.

You should be happy breaking even, why give the government an interest free loan? I ended up owing $1000 this year, and I am perfectly happy with that. My CPA actually suggested to me that if I wanted to get a refund I should go back to claiming S-0 or S-1. No way.

I can see why he would suggest it though, people seem to base their opinions of a CPA on how much they get back a year. That is totally inaccurate, a good CPA will make sure you are paying the LEAST amount of taxes a year, not getting you the biggest refund.

Posted 4/13/13 12:46 AM
 

livdrl112
LIF Infant

Member since 1/11

348 total posts

Name:

Re-doing taxes?

Are you hitting the AMT limit? Sometimes, a big deduction like high property taxes and too many personal exemptions can mean having to pay the AMT, which is an additional tax. Check to see if you have a form 6251 in your return. The CPA might not have factored that in your initial meeting. We started hitting that limit recently and it is very frustrating to see all your deductions being taken away! I would also suggest trying out Turbo tax online. It is very user friendly and takes you through all the steps. At least you can take the calculations to another CPA to review and amend ur return if the numbers are very different. Good Luck!

Posted 4/13/13 1:06 AM
 

Shroggie
Don't Worry...Be Happy

Member since 5/06

6261 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Didn't you have to sign something in order for him to file? We always have to sign something and on that paper, it has the amount we get back/owe.

I'd just put the figures in Turbo Tax to make sure they're right.

Posted 4/13/13 9:56 AM
 

AScottWolf
I <3 our squish!

Member since 11/10

2237 total posts

Name:
Adriana

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Umm.. We also closed in May 2012 and are after owing federal we're getting back around 1200.

I am claiming M-0. I think DH is claiming the same..or S-0 with no dependents.

When we closed we paid no points. Basically, the accountant said 3 things can be claimed from the year you but the house, points, mortgage interest and something else lol (sorry, I can't remember what the 3rd was).

I always hear about people getting back insane refunds and it makes no sense to me. We write off donations, work/travel expenses, and student loan interest.

I guess I'd rather get more in my pocket each month and get a little back, then the reverse.

Stinks though.

Message edited 2013-04-13 10:24:32.727000.

Posted 4/13/13 10:15 AM
 

WannaBeAMom11
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

7391 total posts

Name:
Name

Re-doing taxes?

We bought a house this year and owed because we went into a higher tax bracket.

Posted 4/13/13 11:21 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Re-doing taxes?

I can tell you that brackets make a big difference.

I was home with my son last yr so I made no money, our bracket changed and we got DOUBLE back this year. What sucks is when I am working yes we are in a higher bracket but very far from the top of that bracket so I feel like we get the shaft when I am working, this is likely what happened to you guys, it stinks!

Posted 4/13/13 11:46 AM
 

olive98
LIF Adolescent

Member since 11/12

791 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Posted by ave1024

Switching from Single-0 to Married-1 is going to make a big difference on your refund. That's really the bottom line here. I am not sure how you can expect to take home more per paycheck and still get a huge refund. The numbers just don't work that way and it's not the CPA's fault you are getting less claiming M-1.

You should be happy breaking even, why give the government an interest free loan? I ended up owing $1000 this year, and I am perfectly happy with that. My CPA actually suggested to me that if I wanted to get a refund I should go back to claiming S-0 or S-1. No way.

I can see why he would suggest it though, people seem to base their opinions of a CPA on how much they get back a year. That is totally inaccurate, a good CPA will make sure you are paying the LEAST amount of taxes a year, not getting you the biggest refund.



ITA!

Posted 4/13/13 2:58 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Posted by DiamondGirl

I can tell you that brackets make a big difference.

I was home with my son last yr so I made no money, our bracket changed and we got DOUBLE back this year. What sucks is when I am working yes we are in a higher bracket but very far from the top of that bracket so I feel like we get the shaft when I am working, this is likely what happened to you guys, it stinks!



The bracket only affects the money you make in that bracket. Not your entire tax return.

Posted 4/13/13 7:57 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Okay, so maybe I am on the late bus, but DH is doing our taxes and if he is reading it correctly, we have to claim BigB 4/13/09 1 Families Helping Families ™
ok why is everybody getting so much money back from doing their taxes??? MamaNDaddyof3 3/1/08 27 Families Helping Families ™
Quick question about doing taxes....are we supposed to bring anything with us if we sold/bought a home last year? Mommy2Boys 1/25/07 3 Home
Turbotax vs an accountant doing your taxes Oldusernewname 2/19/13 9 Families Helping Families ™
question about doing taxes bea559 2/1/11 11 Newlyweds
PSA for those doing your own taxes: make sure you enter your stiimulus check correctly Cpt2007 2/7/09 15 Families Helping Families ™