Re-doing taxes?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re-doing taxes?

I'm so upset. We just got our federal return today and its WAY less than our CPA told us we would be getting. Like, $2K less!! I called him, he looked at the paperwork and says its correct. I told him that wasn't what we were told three weeks ago when we filed with you, and he has no record of what he said our return would be. I believe I wrote it down on my folder at home, but I don't remember that figure now, what use is it anyway.

My question is - what could have happened? Should we have another CPA look at our taxes and possibly re-do them? This is our first year in a house, how is it possible we are getting back a total of $450!!! Can someone help me?

I'm waiting for him to call me back after looking at our return again. Chat Icon

ETA: he says he just remembers that we were disappointed with our return. We were, even when it was $2k more! Everyone tells you that you get so much $ back your first year in a house. SO NOT TRUE!!

Message edited 2013-04-11 13:52:59.460000.

Posted 4/11/13 1:52 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re-doing taxes?

When did you close? You do much better after your first FULL year in the house. If you closed in November, there likely won't be much of a difference in your taxes unless you paid a bunch of points and taxes up front (actual taxes paid out not escrows).

Posted 4/11/13 2:15 PM
 

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

We closed on May 31 of '12, so it's 1/2 year. I just don't understand how he could have told us one number and then we get something else altogether!

Posted 4/11/13 2:20 PM
 

AngnShaun
Sisters

Member since 1/10

21015 total posts

Name:
Ang

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Posted by LovesMike

We closed on May 31 of '12, so it's 1/2 year. I just don't understand how he could have told us one number and then we get something else altogether!



that happened to me last year... i was furious! It was the first year we used someone... i always did them myself on turbo tax... never had a problem.

Posted 4/11/13 2:24 PM
 

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

I was disappointed when it was a $2700 return, now I'm just totally deflated.

It feels like we pay so much in taxes, bring hardly anything home, are always living check to check. And this just adds insult to injury. Chat Icon

Posted 4/11/13 2:37 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re-doing taxes?

I have no advice but I am seriously questioning this whole, you'll get back more when you are in your house for a full year, thing. I put in my info into turbo tax and it said we're getting back maybe $1000 more than last year and 2012 was our first full year in the house. I decided to just take my stuff to an accountant so we'll see in a couple of days if TT was right or not.

There may be other factors as to why you're not getting back as much as you thought.

Posted 4/11/13 2:45 PM
 

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Posted by LovesMike

I was disappointed when it was a $2700 return, now I'm just totally deflated.

It feels like we pay so much in taxes, bring hardly anything home, are always living check to check. And this just adds insult to injury. Chat Icon



Just found out we are getting back HALF what we are used to getting. Not a happy camper

Posted 4/11/13 2:47 PM
 

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Yes, we know that we both made more $ this year and DH changed his status to Married-1 (v. Single 0 for most of 2011), but when we were sitting at his desk he told us one number. Tax return comes it's another. And of course he has no recollection. He does tons of taxes, but I just don't understand how there could be such a discrepancy.

DH spoke with him and he's claiming it's right.

Does anyone know if there is any type of penalty for doing a second look? Could we end up owing? that would be our luck.

Posted 4/11/13 2:56 PM
 

evrythng4areason
And then there were 4

Member since 1/10

5224 total posts

Name:
Kayla

Re-doing taxes?

We got married and bought our house last year-we closed in may and our refund was around 4700 if I remember right

Posted 4/11/13 3:11 PM
 

evrythng4areason
And then there were 4

Member since 1/10

5224 total posts

Name:
Kayla

Re-doing taxes?

We don't claim any dependents though

Posted 4/11/13 3:12 PM
 

Peaches77
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

993 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Re-doing taxes?

There are a lot of different factors that go into play.

You said you made more money this year than last - that could've pushed you into another bracket.

Then, you said DH changed from Single 0 to Married 1. Well that will make a big difference in comparing to the prior year.

PLUS, if you both work, the withholding is calculated based on your individual salaries alone, not combined. So even if the withholding is right on one of your salaries based on the tax brackets, if you add both of your salaries together, then the withholding might not be sufficient if you get bumped into the next tax bracket.

As for the purchase of the house. Did you give him your HUD statement? There might have been items on there that could have been picked up (credits for real estate taxes, points paid, etc.)

It can't hurt to have someone else look at it if you are unhappy with the outcome. There is no excuse for him not knowing why the amount changed.

I'm a CPA and we document everything so we can tell a client if and why something changed from what was originally thought.

Posted 4/11/13 3:20 PM
 

BklynBabe12
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/12

561 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

That doesn't sound right at all. I would have another CPA look at it. I see Daniel Samela in Deer Park, he is absolutely amazing!

If you want more info, FM me.

Posted 4/11/13 3:29 PM
 

MrsYankeeGirl72
LIF Toddler

Member since 7/10

452 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Re-doing taxes?

If you feel that you are owed more, then my suggestion is after April 15th, you have another Tax person review your paperwork.

Last year DH and I went to a tax person, who was recommended by one of my co-workers. DH is a cop so he tons of deductibles, and when we visited this specific tax guy, DH asked him if he was going to ask him about all his expenses. DH works two jobs so things like gas, uniforms, etc count. The CPA just ignored DH and did NOTHING with all that info. So we ended up getting $60 from Federal and paying like $1400 to NYS. DH and I were beyond Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon!!!

This year we went to another accountant in Queens, our income and tax situation this year was about around the same as last year, well lo and behold we got back, for both Fed and NYS, thousands of dollars. We brought him our tax return from last year and he said OMG this CPA put no deductions down for you, not even charitable donations!! So he told us to leave him last year's return and that after the 15th of April, he will do an amendment. We expect to receive thousands more.

Posted 4/11/13 4:00 PM
 

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Posted by MrsYankeeGirl72

If you feel that you are owed more, then my suggestion is after April 15th, you have another Tax person review your paperwork.

Last year DH and I went to a tax person, who was recommended by one of my co-workers. DH is a cop so he tons of deductibles, and when we visited this specific tax guy, DH asked him if he was going to ask him about all his expenses. DH works two jobs so things like gas, uniforms, etc count. The CPA just ignored DH and did NOTHING with all that info. So we ended up getting $60 from Federal and paying like $1400 to NYS. DH and I were beyond Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon!!!

This year we went to another accountant in Queens, our income and tax situation this year was about around the same as last year, well lo and behold we got back, for both Fed and NYS, thousands of dollars. We brought him our tax return from last year and he said OMG this CPA put no deductions down for you, not even charitable donations!! So he told us to leave him last year's return and that after the 15th of April, he will do an amendment. We expect to receive thousands more.




I'm so glad to hear you are going to get more money back!! A friend also made this suggestion - after the 15th another CPA can take a second look. Any idea how much this might cost? We already paid the first guy $200. Our return was only $450.

Posted 4/11/13 4:03 PM
 

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Posted by Peaches77

There are a lot of different factors that go into play.

You said you made more money this year than last - that could've pushed you into another bracket.

Then, you said DH changed from Single 0 to Married 1. Well that will make a big difference in comparing to the prior year.

PLUS, if you both work, the withholding is calculated based on your individual salaries alone, not combined. So even if the withholding is right on one of your salaries based on the tax brackets, if you add both of your salaries together, then the withholding might not be sufficient if you get bumped into the next tax bracket.

As for the purchase of the house. Did you give him your HUD statement? There might have been items on there that could have been picked up (credits for real estate taxes, points paid, etc.)

It can't hurt to have someone else look at it if you are unhappy with the outcome. There is no excuse for him not knowing why the amount changed.

I'm a CPA and we document everything so we can tell a client if and why something changed from what was originally thought.



Thank you for this reply. Yes, he did have our HUD. He is acting like he doesn't recall that he told us to expect an entirely different return. Still not what we hoped for, but better than this.

Posted 4/11/13 4:13 PM
 

MrsYankeeGirl72
LIF Toddler

Member since 7/10

452 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Re-doing taxes?

We paid 180 for our taxes this year, and I would think it would be at least the same amount or less for the amendment. In any case, at this point we don't care what the amount is, just as long as he gets us back some significant amount of $$.

Based on this year's return, we are thinking conservatively what we might get back from the amendment like around 3K.

Posted 4/11/13 4:17 PM
 

MrsYankeeGirl72
LIF Toddler

Member since 7/10

452 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Re-doing taxes?

I remember one year I went to get my taxes done. And I didn't realize that a financial transaction I did, not enough taxes were taken out. Well I almost Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon at my old CPA's office, when she told me I owed almost 4K. Grant it i was single at the time and very naive.

In order to avoid that type of situation, I decided to take additional federal and state tax from my paycheck. Ever since I have not had to pay, except for last year, but that was due to the awesome CPA guy we used. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 4/11/13 4:21 PM
 

BabyBoy
is Skylar Elizabeth

Member since 5/05

4189 total posts

Name:
Tom

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Posted by LovesMike

Yes, we know that we both made more $ this year and DH changed his status to Married-1 (v. Single 0 for most of 2011), but when we were sitting at his desk he told us one number. Tax return comes it's another. And of course he has no recollection. He does tons of taxes, but I just don't understand how there could be such a discrepancy.

DH spoke with him and he's claiming it's right.

Does anyone know if there is any type of penalty for doing a second look? Could we end up owing? that would be our luck.



1. If he claimed 1 dependent means he was taking LESS taxes out each pay check meaning less in your return. He should claim 0 if you want more back in your return. Some will argue that you change your number so you get more back each paycheck instead of large sum at tax times - different strokes for different folks.

2. Every year I have had an account (15 years), I have left with some sought of summary of what was filed, etc.. Inside said summary would be what was filed on my behalf. Do you have a record/summary of what he filed?

3. To file an amendment cost money just like a return. Someone could look at it but if its someone else, he may not do it as your not their client unless they see something wrong and then you will become their client and then you get charged.

4. Regarding the house thing, when I owned my co-op, i didn't see any big impact for the 3 years I've had it. There are other variables to your taxes such as income, credits, tuition, children, etc.. Granted your upset, they has to be a reason why it came to the amount you have.

Posted 4/11/13 4:47 PM
 

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Thanks, BabyBoy.

To answer your questions -
1) Yes, we are aware the change has had implications. We would like to get more money in our checks, but I still wouldn't think that each of us claiming 1 would mean such a small return.

2. CPA didn't give us any summary. Nada.

3. I would not mind paying to have the amendment done and ditching the current CPA since he is the worst. But only if the amended return would be worth the extra trouble and $.

4. I understand. In the 6 months we owned the house we paid c. $6K in taxes, paid easily a few grand in mortgage interest, I think we had 1 point on the mortgage, we have about $500/mo of student loans, and we don't make that much money!! I think our combined income is in the low $100Ks. OH, DH is a teacher too, so he gets all sorts of deductions. We are both union employees and our dues are deductible.

We know he did an itemized return. It seems like something is wrong, to me, at least. But I'm no CPA. Chat Icon

Posted 4/11/13 4:59 PM
 

JerseyMamaOf3
Boo!

Member since 6/05

15144 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Sounds to me like he gave you an estimate when he sat by maybe roughly looking at your numbers, which he shouldn't have done. Things change once you input everything into the program. He may have thought things were also similar from last year and went by how you filed last year and last years salary.

Posted 4/11/13 5:00 PM
 

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Posted by JerseyMamaOf3

Sounds to me like he gave you an estimate when he sat by maybe roughly looking at your numbers, which he shouldn't have done. Things change once you input everything into the program. He may have thought things were also similar from last year and went by how you filed last year and last years salary.




We were sitting there as he entered everything into the program. This was when it was all said and done. Ugh, he's the worst.

Posted 4/11/13 5:02 PM
 

IveGotAFeeling
Always look on the bright side

Member since 1/12

2286 total posts

Name:
of life!

Re: Re-doing taxes?

FWIW- we owed about $6k in taxes the year we bought the house. This year is our first full year in and we broke even. It all depends on your bracket and how much your employer takes out throughout the year. There's no guarantee of a big return.

Message edited 2013-04-11 17:07:22.717000.

Posted 4/11/13 5:07 PM
 

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Posted by IveGotAFeeling

FWIW- we owed about $6k in taxes the year we bought the house. This year is our first full year in and we broke even. It all depends on your bracket and how much your employer takes out throughout the year. There's no guarantee of a big return.



I know. Last year we owed, so it could be worse. I keep trying to tell myself that. It's just so frustrating. Why do people perpetuate the myth that closing on a house = gigantic return?? I wish!

Posted 4/11/13 5:09 PM
 

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re: Re-doing taxes?

Also, how do I know what "bracket" we're in?

ETA:
To answer my own question,

Tax Bracket Married Filing Jointly Single
10% Bracket $0 – $17,400 $0 – $8,700
15% Bracket $17,400 – $70,700 $8,700 – $35,350
25% Bracket $70,700 – $142,700 $35,350 – $85,650
28% Bracket $142,700 – $217,450 $85,650 – $178,650
33% Bracket $217,450 – $388,350 $178,650 – $388,350
35% Bracket Over $388,350 Over $388,350

So, we are in about the 20% bracket. But what does this mean?

Message edited 2013-04-11 17:11:42.993000.

Posted 4/11/13 5:10 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Re-doing taxes?

It means income under the $35350 for married filing jointly, will be taxes at 15% and the income above that amount will fall into the next higher tax bracket.

As for us, we owed as well and when we had originally spoken with our accountant he thought we were going to get a refund. It turns out that we ended up going into the next higher bracket and lost some deductions because of it. It happens. I don't think that buying a home gets people the refunds they think it does.

Posted 4/11/13 5:21 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Okay, so maybe I am on the late bus, but DH is doing our taxes and if he is reading it correctly, we have to claim BigB 4/13/09 1 Families Helping Families ™
ok why is everybody getting so much money back from doing their taxes??? MamaNDaddyof3 3/1/08 27 Families Helping Families ™
Quick question about doing taxes....are we supposed to bring anything with us if we sold/bought a home last year? Mommy2Boys 1/25/07 3 Home
Turbotax vs an accountant doing your taxes Oldusernewname 2/19/13 9 Families Helping Families ™
question about doing taxes bea559 2/1/11 11 Newlyweds
PSA for those doing your own taxes: make sure you enter your stiimulus check correctly Cpt2007 2/7/09 15 Families Helping Families ™