Random q - physical fitness re: cops...
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] | |
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Posted by smdl Why should we have fitness requirements for cops? What about other jobs then? We're not comparing a police officer to other jobs, stop reaching. I feel like you're just trying to be contrary and/or playing devil's advocate. In any case, in order to be a practicing CPA in NYS - you are REQUIRED to meet continuing education requirements. Same with doctors and I'm sure lawyers as well. If you're REQUIRED to be able to perform certain physical tasks in order to BECOME a police officer, why isn't that requirement continually met? edit for grammar - improper your/you're Message edited 2010-12-09 17:11:10.070000. |
|
Posted 12/9/10 5:10 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Posted by smdl Why should we have fitness requirements for cops? What about other jobs then? Ehh---I think certain jobs require certain abilities. In the academy you have to pull a dummy that is almost 200lbs (I could be wrong on the weight, but I know it's not light) of dead weight a certain distance. If you can't, you're out. Not to mention scaling walls in a certain amount of time. Sitting at a desk as a CPA doesn't require the physicality that a police officer might need. It's not like in the movies where everyday you are chasing a perp down the street or anything -- but DH needs his physical strength/ability pretty often at his job. Whether he has to jump over a fence after a suspect or help an attempted 250lb suicide victim off the ground, there is a physical aspect to what he does. (Btw - he has done both of these just in the past couple of weeks.) I wouldn't want our police officers out there to be all out of shape, I do think they are a sort of para-military organization and they should have certain standards that should be maintained....because it goes with the territory of their job. But that's JMO....and I am the wife of a pretty fit cop. Message edited 2010-12-09 17:17:36.830000. |
|
Posted 12/9/10 5:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Posted by Jenn627 Posted by smdl Why should we have fitness requirements for cops? What about other jobs then? We're not comparing a police officer to other jobs, stop reaching. I feel like you're just trying to be contrary and/or playing devil's advocate. In any case, in order to be a practicing CPA in NYS - you are REQUIRED to meet continuing education requirements. Same with doctors and I'm sure lawyers as well. If you're REQUIRED to be able to perform certain physical tasks in order to BECOME a police officer, why isn't that requirement continually met? edit for grammar - improper your/you're YOU are the one reaching here because of whatever standard you have. YOU are trying to make a requirement that is not a requirement just because YOU think should be required. Bottom line, you are just as trying to be contrary. They don't have those requirements like the CPA, Lawyers or doctors you are comparing to....... PERIOD!!!!! If you feel that strongly about it go lobby with the NY State to make it a requirement. Until then... it's still not a requirement! |
|
Posted 12/9/10 5:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Posted by smdl If you feel that strongly about it go lobby with the NY State to make it a requirement. Wait - what? Really? I wasn't battling you - tone is misconstrued in type. I felt and feel like you were reaching by saying - 'why don't other jobs have a physical requirement?' We weren't talking about other jobs - like say - desk jobs, we were talking about police. Did you just really tell me to go lobby NYS? (I don't have to since obviously they require Troopers to continually pass some type of physical test)... I would lobby NCPD and SCPD if I REALLY felt that strongly about it - I certainly wouldn't be posting my grievances on here. |
|
Posted 12/9/10 5:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Actually I know one candidate who knew quite a few higher ups but still could not get into the academy because he could not pass the psych exam, of all things (subjective) I think a lot of people are misinformed, you must pass a written exam, a psych exam and a physical exam to even get considered for the academy. When my dh go in you needed a college degree, but they have given up on that because of the rotten salary they were offering for a while. They certainly could not afford a gym membership on that! Message edited 2010-12-09 17:52:04.130000. |
|
Posted 12/9/10 5:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... When I did the agility test for the academy, there were at least 2 dozen others there that were taking the agility test for the probably the 6th time each. |
|
Posted 12/9/10 7:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... In a perfect world, cops should get physical exams periodically to make sure their in shape. People should have to retake their road test to make sure they still know the rules of the road. Teachers should be subject to random reviews and observations even if they have 15 years on the job. Blah blah blah. Message edited 2010-12-09 20:10:00.570000. |
|
Posted 12/9/10 8:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Posted by Jenn627 If you're REQUIRED to be able to perform certain physical tasks in order to BECOME a police officer, why isn't that requirement continually met? The most important thing a cop should know how to do is how to use their gun and that they have to requalify for constantly. |
|
Posted 12/9/10 8:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Posted by smdl Why should we have fitness requirements for cops? What about other jobs then? I just don't get it. I mean we all had to have PE in school and HAD TO graduate in college with some sort of sports elective. That does not mean we will even need to be evaluated for fitness our entire career life. Maybe we should, maybe then obesity wouldn't be an epidemic, but that's a different issue entirely. I've seen cops struggle to get our of their cars at Dunkin Donuts...makes me feel real safe There already IS a fitness requirement in place, why should it not be maintained? It's ridiculous that you have to be at such a high level or fitness to be hired, but never be held accountable for that again. Message edited 2010-12-09 22:50:59.267000. |
|
Posted 12/9/10 10:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Posted by LiveForMoments Posted by smdl Why should we have fitness requirements for cops? What about other jobs then? I just don't get it. I mean we all had to have PE in school and HAD TO graduate in college with some sort of sports elective. That does not mean we will even need to be evaluated for fitness our entire career life. Maybe we should, maybe then obesity wouldn't be an epidemic, but that's a different issue entirely. I've seen cops struggle to get our of their cars at Dunkin Donuts...makes me feel real safe There already IS a fitness requirement in place, why should it not be maintained? It's ridiculous that you have to be at such a high level or fitness to be hired, but never be held accountable for that again. Really? I have never seen a cop that morbidly obese. And I am pretty sure they would be taken off the streets if they were. And that D&D reference is a nice touch, but the reason most cops stop at D&D's is to get coffee just like the rest of the adult world. Except some cops have not slept in days...YOu should be more worried about that, because the tired cop who falls asleep at the wheel is much more dangerous than the fat cop! If we were to make physical fitness a requirement, we should probably make it a ten year retirement with a nice pension ETA cops are continually being trained in many areas of their jobs. I think it is sad that you think the biggest part of their job is chasing criminals. They do a lot more than that and if they have the training they can usually catch the bad guys with out running five blocks....that's mostly on the tv. When was the last time you saw a cop running down the block after a perp? Message edited 2010-12-10 07:46:05.257000. |
|
Posted 12/10/10 7:43 AM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Posted by twicethefun Posted by LiveForMoments Posted by smdl Why should we have fitness requirements for cops? What about other jobs then? I just don't get it. I mean we all had to have PE in school and HAD TO graduate in college with some sort of sports elective. That does not mean we will even need to be evaluated for fitness our entire career life. Maybe we should, maybe then obesity wouldn't be an epidemic, but that's a different issue entirely. I've seen cops struggle to get our of their cars at Dunkin Donuts...makes me feel real safe There already IS a fitness requirement in place, why should it not be maintained? It's ridiculous that you have to be at such a high level or fitness to be hired, but never be held accountable for that again. Really? I have never seen a cop that morbidly obese. And I am pretty sure they would be taken off the streets if they were. And that D&D reference is a nice touch, but the reason most cops stop at D&D's is to get coffee just like the rest of the adult world. Except some cops have not slept in days...YOu should be more worried about that, because the tired cop who falls asleep at the wheel is much more dangerous than the fat cop! If we were to make physical fitness a requirement, we should probably make it a ten year retirement with a nice pension ETA cops are continually being trained in many areas of their jobs. I think it is sad that you think the biggest part of their job is chasing criminals. They do a lot more than that and if they have the training they can usually catch the bad guys with out running five blocks....that's mostly on the tv. When was the last time you saw a cop running down the block after a perp? Wow, easy there tiger. You're absolutely right, a tired cop is worse than a chubby cop. And I am well aware that most cops are getting coffee at DD - heck I've paid for a cops cup of coffee in the past, but this is an online public forum, it's not that serious in my opinion, so I made a joke. But no one is trying to make a fitness requirement, it is something that is already in place to be hired, but that officers are not held accountable for a day after they graduate from the academy. And I never stated that I thought chasing criminals was the biggest part of their job, so no reason to be sad for me - or personally attacking. I've defintely seen cops chase perps down the street - mostly in the movies though
|
|
Posted 12/10/10 9:02 AM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Posted by LiveForMoments Posted by twicethefun Posted by LiveForMoments Posted by smdl Why should we have fitness requirements for cops? What about other jobs then? I just don't get it. I mean we all had to have PE in school and HAD TO graduate in college with some sort of sports elective. That does not mean we will even need to be evaluated for fitness our entire career life. Maybe we should, maybe then obesity wouldn't be an epidemic, but that's a different issue entirely. I've seen cops struggle to get our of their cars at Dunkin Donuts...makes me feel real safe There already IS a fitness requirement in place, why should it not be maintained? It's ridiculous that you have to be at such a high level or fitness to be hired, but never be held accountable for that again. Really? I have never seen a cop that morbidly obese. And I am pretty sure they would be taken off the streets if they were. And that D&D reference is a nice touch, but the reason most cops stop at D&D's is to get coffee just like the rest of the adult world. Except some cops have not slept in days...YOu should be more worried about that, because the tired cop who falls asleep at the wheel is much more dangerous than the fat cop! If we were to make physical fitness a requirement, we should probably make it a ten year retirement with a nice pension ETA cops are continually being trained in many areas of their jobs. I think it is sad that you think the biggest part of their job is chasing criminals. They do a lot more than that and if they have the training they can usually catch the bad guys with out running five blocks....that's mostly on the tv. When was the last time you saw a cop running down the block after a perp? Wow, easy there tiger. You're absolutely right, a tired cop is worse than a chubby cop. And I am well aware that most cops are getting coffee at DD - heck I've paid for a cops cup of coffee in the past, but this is an online public forum, it's not that serious in my opinion, so I made a joke. But no one is trying to make a fitness requirement, it is something that is already in place to be hired, but that officers are not held accountable for a day after they graduate from the academy. And I never stated that I thought chasing criminals was the biggest part of their job, so no reason to be sad for me - or personally attacking. I've defintely seen cops chase perps down the street - mostly in the movies though Umm, did you actually call me tiger? |
|
Posted 12/10/10 6:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Posted by mrsboss What's more important to me, is the intelligence, quick on their feet decision making, and common sense a cop needs to protect his/her partner and the public. I have to agree with this- and this gets me thinking back to the other day when I met the new local beat cop who came into the center I work at just to stay warm for a bit. He was overweight but overall just speaking wth him (he was NYPD btw) he was intelligent and seemed to have good common sense. |
|
Posted 12/10/10 6:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... If you are representing the uniform and what it stands for you should not be a fat, sloppy mess. Wearing the uniform is a privilege and honor. I have seen MANY obese men AND women cops and I think it is a disgrace to the job and uniform. That is my opinion. FDNY is required to pass a yearly physical, why shouldn't cops? I believe their level of fitness directly correlates on how well they can perform their job in many circumstances. Message edited 2010-12-10 21:00:41.017000. |
|
Posted 12/10/10 8:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Posted by twicethefun Posted by LiveForMoments Posted by twicethefun Posted by LiveForMoments Posted by smdl Why should we have fitness requirements for cops? What about other jobs then? I just don't get it. I mean we all had to have PE in school and HAD TO graduate in college with some sort of sports elective. That does not mean we will even need to be evaluated for fitness our entire career life. Maybe we should, maybe then obesity wouldn't be an epidemic, but that's a different issue entirely. I've seen cops struggle to get our of their cars at Dunkin Donuts...makes me feel real safe There already IS a fitness requirement in place, why should it not be maintained? It's ridiculous that you have to be at such a high level or fitness to be hired, but never be held accountable for that again. Really? I have never seen a cop that morbidly obese. And I am pretty sure they would be taken off the streets if they were. And that D&D reference is a nice touch, but the reason most cops stop at D&D's is to get coffee just like the rest of the adult world. Except some cops have not slept in days...YOu should be more worried about that, because the tired cop who falls asleep at the wheel is much more dangerous than the fat cop! If we were to make physical fitness a requirement, we should probably make it a ten year retirement with a nice pension ETA cops are continually being trained in many areas of their jobs. I think it is sad that you think the biggest part of their job is chasing criminals. They do a lot more than that and if they have the training they can usually catch the bad guys with out running five blocks....that's mostly on the tv. When was the last time you saw a cop running down the block after a perp? Wow, easy there tiger. You're absolutely right, a tired cop is worse than a chubby cop. And I am well aware that most cops are getting coffee at DD - heck I've paid for a cops cup of coffee in the past, but this is an online public forum, it's not that serious in my opinion, so I made a joke. But no one is trying to make a fitness requirement, it is something that is already in place to be hired, but that officers are not held accountable for a day after they graduate from the academy. And I never stated that I thought chasing criminals was the biggest part of their job, so no reason to be sad for me - or personally attacking. I've defintely seen cops chase perps down the street - mostly in the movies though Umm, did you actually call me tiger? It was meant in jest, and used due to the attacking nature of your response, I apologize if you were offended...Happy Holidays. |
|
Posted 12/10/10 9:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Its a great debate, but it is sort of mute - at least outside of NY. It should be noted that many police departments do require a yearly physical by a doctor that ensures police officers are fit. So while I can't speak for NY in particular, its not uncommon. Message edited 2010-12-10 22:05:45.110000. |
|
Posted 12/10/10 10:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Posted by leese Its a great debate, but it is sort of mute outside of NY. It should be noted that many police departments do require a yearly physical by a doctor that ensures police officers are fit. So while I can't speak for NY in particular, its not uncommon. And, on a side note, just because a police officer (or ANY PERSON) may appear "big" it doesn't mean they can't run, can't shoot, can't take down someone. It doesn't mean that they disrespect the uniform or themselves. Just as it doesn't mean that someone on the bigger side doesn't respect themselves. Such a huge generalization and plain wrong. And, it also doesn't mean that they won't jump in the line of fire to save your life. As I stated in my post, this is MY opinion, that my family, which is entirely made up of military, nypd and fdny all share. That cop was a not only a JOKE but a liabilty to everyone. Not because of his size, of his physical fitness. Message edited 2010-12-10 22:08:53.267000. |
|
Posted 12/10/10 10:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Posted by maybemommy10 Posted by leese Its a great debate, but it is sort of mute outside of NY. It should be noted that many police departments do require a yearly physical by a doctor that ensures police officers are fit. So while I can't speak for NY in particular, its not uncommon. And, on a side note, just because a police officer (or ANY PERSON) may appear "big" it doesn't mean they can't run, can't shoot, can't take down someone. It doesn't mean that they disrespect the uniform or themselves. Just as it doesn't mean that someone on the bigger side doesn't respect themselves. Such a huge generalization and plain wrong. And, it also doesn't mean that they won't jump in the line of fire to save your life. As I stated in my post, this is MY opinion, that my family, which is entirely made up of military, nypd and fdny all share. That cop was a not only a JOKE but a liabilty to everyone. Not because of his size, of his physical fitness. I didn't quote you. It is your opinion. I disagree with it. I offered knowledge, it's not uncommon for a yearly physical. It's not JUST weight that can cause someone to be physically unfit. Oh, and I'm completely blue through and through. |
|
Posted 12/10/10 10:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Posted by leese Posted by maybemommy10 Posted by leese Its a great debate, but it is sort of mute outside of NY. It should be noted that many police departments do require a yearly physical by a doctor that ensures police officers are fit. So while I can't speak for NY in particular, its not uncommon. And, on a side note, just because a police officer (or ANY PERSON) may appear "big" it doesn't mean they can't run, can't shoot, can't take down someone. It doesn't mean that they disrespect the uniform or themselves. Just as it doesn't mean that someone on the bigger side doesn't respect themselves. Such a huge generalization and plain wrong. And, it also doesn't mean that they won't jump in the line of fire to save your life. As I stated in my post, this is MY opinion, that my family, which is entirely made up of military, nypd and fdny all share. That cop was a not only a JOKE but a liabilty to everyone. Not because of his size, of his physical fitness. I didn't quote you. It is your opinion. I disagree with it. I offered knowledge, it's not uncommon for a yearly physical. It's not JUST weight that can cause someone to be physically unfit. Oh, and I'm completely blue through and through. Sorry i thought you were referring to my comment when you wrote "sloppy", which is why i responded to you. I also respectfully agree to disagree
|
|
Posted 12/10/10 10:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Do I believe they should be tested yearly - absolutely! I think there are many professions that should be re-evaluated much more but aren't it's sad. Unfortunatly like others said it's a financial thing. Especially with the NYPD, they have enough trouble getting recruits with the meager salary they offer as it is. Message edited 2010-12-11 10:05:24.917000. |
|
Posted 12/10/10 11:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Not going to say what I do but I am short and very thin and can kick a**. I have seen overweight cops run faster than cops that are in shape. No agency can discriminate if you are short (work with plenty of men that are). Back in the day there was a fat caliber test but I think that is gone (I almost failed that which is weird since I am 110 pounds). |
|
Posted 12/11/10 6:51 AM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Posted by smdl Posted by Jenn627 Posted by smdl Why should we have fitness requirements for cops? What about other jobs then? We're not comparing a police officer to other jobs, stop reaching. I feel like you're just trying to be contrary and/or playing devil's advocate. In any case, in order to be a practicing CPA in NYS - you are REQUIRED to meet continuing education requirements. Same with doctors and I'm sure lawyers as well. If you're REQUIRED to be able to perform certain physical tasks in order to BECOME a police officer, why isn't that requirement continually met? edit for grammar - improper your/you're YOU are the one reaching here because of whatever standard you have. YOU are trying to make a requirement that is not a requirement just because YOU think should be required. Bottom line, you are just as trying to be contrary. They don't have those requirements like the CPA, Lawyers or doctors you are comparing to....... PERIOD!!!!! If you feel that strongly about it go lobby with the NY State to make it a requirement. Until then... it's still not a requirement! Oh please. You are taking this WAY to seriously. Chill out. |
|
Posted 12/11/10 9:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: Random q - physical fitness re: cops... Posted by heathergirl Posted by smdl Posted by Jenn627 Posted by smdl Why should we have fitness requirements for cops? What about other jobs then? We're not comparing a police officer to other jobs, stop reaching. I feel like you're just trying to be contrary and/or playing devil's advocate. In any case, in order to be a practicing CPA in NYS - you are REQUIRED to meet continuing education requirements. Same with doctors and I'm sure lawyers as well. If you're REQUIRED to be able to perform certain physical tasks in order to BECOME a police officer, why isn't that requirement continually met? edit for grammar - improper your/you're YOU are the one reaching here because of whatever standard you have. YOU are trying to make a requirement that is not a requirement just because YOU think should be required. Bottom line, you are just as trying to be contrary. They don't have those requirements like the CPA, Lawyers or doctors you are comparing to....... PERIOD!!!!! If you feel that strongly about it go lobby with the NY State to make it a requirement. Until then... it's still not a requirement! Oh please. You are taking this WAY to seriously. Chill out. Some people will take this more seriously because it involves them or their family members. Just like everything else, when it directly affects you , you take it more seriously. |
|
Posted 12/11/10 10:25 AM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Random Acts of Kindness.... | MrsERod | 10/18/05 | 29 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Completely random, but i just found out my HS english teacher is now a professional wrestler | VirginiaDeb | 9/29/05 | 2 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Random Excuses... | MrsERod | 8/27/05 | 39 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Random Question | julz33 | 8/23/05 | 12 | Pregnancy |
| Random....but.... | BaroqueMama | 8/12/05 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Post something random about yourself that you've never posted before | Jax430 | 8/12/05 | 95 | Families Helping Families ™ |









