Question for Jewish people

Posted By Message

stinger
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

4971 total posts

Name:

Question for Jewish people

Is using the word "Jew" considered offensive or not? I mean just as a short form of "Jewish"

Either for you personally or in general?

Posted 5/4/14 10:08 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

luvbuffet
LIF Adult

Member since 7/10

6470 total posts

Name:

Re: Question for Jewish people

I'm not Jewish but it is offensive. "She's a Jew" "you're a Jew" just stick to Jewish.

Posted 5/4/14 10:14 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Question for Jewish people

Posted by luvbuffet

I'm not Jewish but it is offensive. "She's a Jew" "you're a Jew" just stick to Jewish.


I am Jewish. I don't saw I am a Jew. I think it is usually meant in a derogatory way to say She/he is a Jew, but it would depend upon the context. I agree, stick to He/She is Jewish.

Message edited 2014-05-04 22:20:16.823000.

Posted 5/4/14 10:18 PM
 

stinger
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

4971 total posts

Name:

Re: Question for Jewish people

Posted by LSP2005

Posted by luvbuffet

I'm not Jewish but it is offensive. "She's a Jew" "you're a Jew" just stick to Jewish.


I am Jewish. I don't saw I am a Jew. I think it is usually meant in a derogatory way to say She/he is a Jew. I agree, stick to He/She is Jewish.



I always thought it was deragatory. The reason I ask is because today at our house my 8yo daughter used it while discussing food and Jewish holidays with her friend whose parents are Israeli and Jewish. My daughter came home asking for apples and honey last week and she asked again when her friend was here. I love that she is embracing someone who has different traditions at home and wants to learn so I know she didn't mean it as deragatory however I was taken aback when I heard her say it. Maybe her friend uses the word?

Posted 5/4/14 10:23 PM
 

sameinitials
insert creative comment here

Member since 2/12

1998 total posts

Name:

Re: Question for Jewish people

Posted by LSP2005

Posted by luvbuffet

I'm not Jewish but it is offensive. "She's a Jew" "you're a Jew" just stick to Jewish.


I am Jewish. I don't saw I am a Jew. I think it is usually meant in a derogatory way to say She/he is a Jew, but it would depend upon the context. I agree, stick to He/She is Jewish.



I think it totally depends on context. I say "I am a conservative Jew" not "a conservative jewish person." That's not offensive. If someone is like "ugh, so-and-so is *such* a Jew," that's offensive. If it's in an offensive context then it's offensive, if it isn't in an offensive context then it isn't offensive, just like anything else.

Posted 5/4/14 10:24 PM
 

bunnyluck
LIF Adult

Member since 1/14

3196 total posts

Name:

Re: Question for Jewish people

Posted by sameinitials

Posted by LSP2005

Posted by luvbuffet

I'm not Jewish but it is offensive. "She's a Jew" "you're a Jew" just stick to Jewish.


I am Jewish. I don't saw I am a Jew. I think it is usually meant in a derogatory way to say She/he is a Jew, but it would depend upon the context. I agree, stick to He/She is Jewish.



I think it totally depends on context. I say "I am a conservative Jew" not "a conservative jewish person." That's not offensive. If someone is like "ugh, so-and-so is *such* a Jew," that's offensive. If it's in an offensive context then it's offensive, if it isn't in an offensive context then it isn't offensive, just like anything else.



This. It's perfectly acceptable depending on the context. E.g., "I studied the history of Jews in Latin America" is fine to say.

Message edited 2014-05-04 22:32:30.433000.

Posted 5/4/14 10:30 PM
 

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

Re: Question for Jewish people

I have always wondered the same thing, and err on the side of caution.

Posted 5/4/14 10:44 PM
 

dimples
LIF Infant

Member since 5/12

274 total posts

Name:

Re: Question for Jewish people

Posted by bunnyluck

Posted by sameinitials

Posted by LSP2005

Posted by luvbuffet

I'm not Jewish but it is offensive. "She's a Jew" "you're a Jew" just stick to Jewish.


I am Jewish. I don't saw I am a Jew. I think it is usually meant in a derogatory way to say She/he is a Jew, but it would depend upon the context. I agree, stick to He/She is Jewish.



I think it totally depends on context. I say "I am a conservative Jew" not "a conservative jewish person." That's not offensive. If someone is like "ugh, so-and-so is *such* a Jew," that's offensive. If it's in an offensive context then it's offensive, if it isn't in an offensive context then it isn't offensive, just like anything else.



This. It's perfectly acceptable depending on the context. E.g., "I studied the history of Jews in Latin America" is fine to say.



ITA. It's all about context.

Posted 5/5/14 7:09 AM
 

Jax430
Hi!

Member since 5/05

18919 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Question for Jewish people

Totally fine based on context and intent.

Acceptable: I am a Conservative Jew. She is an Orthodox Jew, etc.

Unacceptable: He's a cheap Jew. (Then again, "He's a cheap Jewish person," doesn't sound any better).

There is nothing intrinsically offensive about the word "Jew."

Posted 5/5/14 8:38 AM
 

GoodThoughts
Dreams do come true

Member since 2/12

2259 total posts

Name:

Re: Question for Jewish people

I am offended by the word, period. Obviously, if someone says. "He's a cheap Jew" or "She's such a Jew," that's offensive. The intent is clear.

Growing up where I did, I dealt with anti-Semitism beginning in elementary school. I remember being invited to play at a classmate's house. Her brother came home, looked at me, stomped off into the kitchen (we were in the adjacent living room), and said, "G-d damned Jew friends in the house!" It was my first experience, and I remember it like it happened yesterday. I remember another girl whom I had invited to my birthday party. When she declined, a few days after getting the invitation, in typical kids don't know what not to repeat fashion, she said, "My mom said I can't go because you're a Jew." Now, these examples would have been equally offensive if the complete word, Jewish, had been used, but in my personal experience, when ever I've heard someone say "__________ is a Jew," it's always had a negative tone; there has always been a derogatory remark that followed shortly.

If someone were to say, "Goodthoughts is Jewish," I don't flinch. If someone were to say, "Goodthoughts is a Jew," it sends a bad vibe, at least for me.

Posted 5/5/14 9:47 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Question for Jewish people

Posted by Jax430

Totally fine based on context and intent.

Acceptable: I am a Conservative Jew. She is an Orthodox Jew, etc.

Unacceptable: He's a cheap Jew. (Then again, "He's a cheap Jewish person," doesn't sound any better).

There is nothing intrinsically offensive about the word "Jew."




I agree.

Posted 5/5/14 12:48 PM
 

Ian&EmmesMommy23
My family is complete!

Member since 11/08

12970 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Question for Jewish people

Posted by GoodThoughts

I am offended by the word, period. Obviously, if someone says. "He's a cheap Jew" or "She's such a Jew," that's offensive. The intent is clear.

Growing up where I did, I dealt with anti-Semitism beginning in elementary school. I remember being invited to play at a classmate's house. Her brother came home, looked at me, stomped off into the kitchen (we were in the adjacent living room), and said, "G-d damned Jew friends in the house!" It was my first experience, and I remember it like it happened yesterday. I remember another girl whom I had invited to my birthday party. When she declined, a few days after getting the invitation, in typical kids don't know what not to repeat fashion, she said, "My mom said I can't go because you're a Jew." Now, these examples would have been equally offensive if the complete word, Jewish, had been used, but in my personal experience, when ever I've heard someone say "__________ is a Jew," it's always had a negative tone; there has always been a derogatory remark that followed shortly.

If someone were to say, "Goodthoughts is Jewish," I don't flinch. If someone were to say, "Goodthoughts is a Jew," it sends a bad vibe, at least for me.



i have to agree. if i hear "that person is a Jew" i take offense. it could also be that a lot of us were raised to not know if someone hates us because we're Jewish. so we're usually on the lookout for it. to be safe, the proper term is Jewish person.

Posted 5/5/14 2:02 PM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: Question for Jewish people

There is nothing inherent wrong about saying "Jew." I am a Jew and proud of it! I tell my DD that we are Jews and that is why we do certain things (like keep kosher). I use Jew and Jewish interchangeably, as do many Jews. If your DD picked it up at her Jewish friend's house, then they probably use the word like I do.

Message edited 2014-05-05 20:05:00.620000.

Posted 5/5/14 8:02 PM
 

TheDivineMrsM
2 girls 4 me!

Member since 8/08

7878 total posts

Name:
Mama mama mama....

Re: Question for Jewish people


I think it totally depends on context. I say "I am a conservative Jew" not "a conservative jewish person." That's not offensive. If someone is like "ugh, so-and-so is *such* a Jew," that's offensive. If it's in an offensive context then it's offensive, if it isn't in an offensive context then it isn't offensive, just like anything else.



Exactly. I write for a Jewish magazine and have referred to myself as an American Jew. No biggie.

Posted 5/5/14 9:11 PM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Question for Jewish people

I don't think it's inherently bad but people say it in a derogatory way often enough that I would phrase it differently. Jane is Jewish instead of Jane is a Jew.

Posted 5/5/14 11:39 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Question for Jewish people

Posted by lynnd126

I don't think it's inherently bad but people say it in a derogatory way often enough that I would phrase it differently. Jane is Jewish instead of Jane is a Jew.



Yeah same here, since I am not Jewish I would fear sounding negative. Now if I were saying "Jane is an Orthodox Jew" that would be fine to me.

Posted 5/6/14 6:35 AM
 

Jax430
Hi!

Member since 5/05

18919 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Question for Jewish people

Posted by Shelly

There is nothing inherent wrong about saying "Jew." I am a Jew and proud of it! I tell my DD that we are Jews and that is why we do certain things (like keep kosher). I use Jew and Jewish interchangeably, as do many Jews. If your DD picked it up at her Jewish friend's house, then they probably use the word like I do.



I agree with this 100%

It's only negative if someone uses it negatively.

Posted 5/6/14 9:27 AM
 

SecretlyTTC14
LIF Adult

Member since 12/13

1770 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Question for Jewish people

Posted by DiamondGirl

Posted by lynnd126

I don't think it's inherently bad but people say it in a derogatory way often enough that I would phrase it differently. Jane is Jewish instead of Jane is a Jew.



Yeah same here, since I am not Jewish I would fear sounding negative. Now if I were saying "Jane is an Orthodox Jew" that would be fine to me.



ITA

I really think it depends on what is being said and how it's said that makes it derogatory or not.

Posted 5/6/14 11:58 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Question for Jewish people about keeping Kosher... ChilisWife 11/28/07 1 Families Helping Families ™
Jewish People...I have a question yankinmanc 11/21/07 75 Families Helping Families ™
Godparent Question spin off-Do Jewish people do Godparents? munchkinfacemama 8/12/09 7 Pregnancy
Bris question, for Jewish people or anyone who knows........ Kerie-is-so-very 6/1/07 15 Pregnancy
Union talks(question for people that know H.R.) bklyngirl 10/25/05 8 Families Helping Families ™
Apartment/Co-op People without a terrace question MissJones 8/19/05 13 Families Helping Families ™