Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

DmarieK
My loves!!

Member since 1/06

9203 total posts

Name:

Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

Rylan had his evaluation and I received the call today that he didn't qualify. She said he is def below average but not below enough to qualify through their program and suggested trying to go through insurance.

She claims he said 3 words during his evaluation...more...papa and ball. I can see why she may have thought he was trying to but it just wasn't the case.

I was told he needed a score of 70% to qualify and he scored 74%. She also said something about -2 and he scored -1.73. I can't remember what that was for.

I know I can't have him tested again through them until 24 months because it will just be the same tests again. I also don't think I want to go through insurance right now and give him a little longer. My question is how long should I give him? I was thinking another 2 months??? I'm just scared to let it go to long incase there really is an issue.

Posted 10/13/09 8:53 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

04bride
I'm a big sister!!!

Member since 5/05

6707 total posts

Name:
Noel

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

How old is he?

Posted 10/13/09 8:54 PM
 

DmarieK
My loves!!

Member since 1/06

9203 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

He'll be 19 months on the 28th.

Posted 10/13/09 8:58 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

I would try again at 21 months - you don't have to wait until 2.

It really all depends on the evaluators that come - which really stinks. Mine said that Jack barely made it but she pushed it through.

Posted 10/13/09 9:01 PM
 

Jackie24
~We Did it~

Member since 7/06

6718 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

Posted by DmarieK


I was told he needed a score of 70% to qualify and he scored 74%. She also said something about -2 and he scored -1.73. I can't remember what that was for.



Sorry to crash, i think what she was referring to was that he has to score 2 standard deviations below the mean in one area. In order to qualify for services he must score 33% below average in one area or 25% delay in two or more areas. Hope this helps Chat Icon

Posted 10/13/09 9:07 PM
 

DmarieK
My loves!!

Member since 1/06

9203 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

Posted by Diana1215

I would try again at 21 months - you don't have to wait until 2.

It really all depends on the evaluators that come - which really stinks. Mine said that Jack barely made it but she pushed it through.




Do you think I should go through the same agency or choose another?

Posted 10/13/09 9:11 PM
 

DmarieK
My loves!!

Member since 1/06

9203 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

Posted by Jackie24

Posted by DmarieK


I was told he needed a score of 70% to qualify and he scored 74%. She also said something about -2 and he scored -1.73. I can't remember what that was for.



Sorry to crash, i think what she was referring to was that he has to score 2 standard deviations below the mean in one area. In order to qualify for services he must score 33% below average in one area or 25% delay in two or more areas. Hope this helps Chat Icon



Yes...that sounds familiar...thanks!!

Posted 10/13/09 9:12 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

Posted by DmarieK

Posted by Diana1215

I would try again at 21 months - you don't have to wait until 2.

It really all depends on the evaluators that come - which really stinks. Mine said that Jack barely made it but she pushed it through.




Do you think I should go through the same agency or choose another?



who'd you go through?

Posted 10/13/09 9:17 PM
 

DmarieK
My loves!!

Member since 1/06

9203 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

Marion K Saloman...might have misspelled that.

Posted 10/13/09 9:18 PM
 

cg511
LIF Infant

Member since 8/06

262 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

I would definately wait until 24 months because the standards they use change dramatically. Prior to 24 months, they combine the scores of the Expressive (speaking) and Receptive (being able to understand and follow directions). After 24 months, if the child is not speaking at a certain level, you would qualify.

Good luck.

Posted 10/13/09 9:20 PM
 

DmarieK
My loves!!

Member since 1/06

9203 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

Posted by cg511

I would definately wait until 24 months because the standards they use change dramatically. Prior to 24 months, they combine the scores of the Expressive (speaking) and Receptive (being able to understand and follow directions). After 24 months, if the child is not speaking at a certain level, you would qualify.

Good luck.



I'm just nervous to wait that long. It's 6 months and I feel like I should get a head start on it incase there really is an issue with him. Ugh...this stinks.

Posted 10/13/09 9:26 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

Posted by cg511

I would definately wait until 24 months because the standards they use change dramatically. Prior to 24 months, they combine the scores of the Expressive (speaking) and Receptive (being able to understand and follow directions). After 24 months, if the child is not speaking at a certain level, you would qualify.

Good luck.



I thought I remember hearing that at 21 months they have a different standard that they look for - I could be wrong though.

Dawn - I'll ask my speech therapist tomorrow what she recommends! Chat Icon

Posted 10/13/09 9:29 PM
 

sunflowerjesss
Mommy to 3!

Member since 10/05

20369 total posts

Name:
Jesss, duh.

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

I really don't have experience in the area. But I do have a friend who had her DS evaluated at 18 months. She said he wasn't speaking, acting out of frustration, short attention span, and more things. He did not qualify.

She was going to have him re-evaluated at 24 months but by 20 months he was speaking full sentences, knew all of his colors and shapes, knew his alphabet, and his behavior leveled out a bit.

Posted 10/13/09 9:34 PM
 

DmarieK
My loves!!

Member since 1/06

9203 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

Posted by Diana1215
I thought I remember hearing that at 21 months they have a different standard that they look for - I could be wrong though.

Dawn - I'll ask my speech therapist tomorrow what she recommends! Chat Icon



Thanks Diana.

Posted 10/13/09 9:49 PM
 

karacg
Babygirl is 4!

Member since 5/05

17076 total posts

Name:
Kara®

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

I had Ale evaluated at 21 months and she didn't qualify.

At 24 months she did -- the requirements are much stricter. Also she had a huge gap between comprehension and expression. Her low level of expression alone would not have qualified her. It was the discrepancy that mattered for her.

I would get him evaluated again at the next level (24 months if he's 22 months now). It can't hurt.

Until then, there are lots of exercises you can do with him.

While EI has certainly helped Ale a lot, I also think she was just taking her time. Her therapist is amazed at her recent progress -- and we missed 3 weeks!! So Rylan may just be taking his time too, so don't get too worried but in the meantime, yes do what you can.

Does that make any sense??? Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/13/09 9:50 PM
 

karacg
Babygirl is 4!

Member since 5/05

17076 total posts

Name:
Kara®

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

PS I used Marion K Solomon and liked them alot -- and Ale LOVES her therapist -- she wakes up in the morning asking for her!!

Posted 10/13/09 9:53 PM
 

DmarieK
My loves!!

Member since 1/06

9203 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

Posted by sunflowerjesss

I really don't have experience in the area. But I do have a friend who had her DS evaluated at 18 months. She said he wasn't speaking, acting out of frustration, short attention span, and more things. He did not qualify.

She was going to have him re-evaluated at 24 months but by 20 months he was speaking full sentences, knew all of his colors and shapes, knew his alphabet, and his behavior leveled out a bit.



Thanks Jess. That's what i'm hoping for...that's why I was thinking to give him a few more months. He never seems to get frustrated over not talking...we're lucky in that sense.

Posted 10/13/09 9:59 PM
 

DmarieK
My loves!!

Member since 1/06

9203 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

Posted by karacg

I had Ale evaluated at 21 months and she didn't qualify.

At 24 months she did -- the requirements are much stricter. Also she had a huge gap between comprehension and expression. Her low level of expression alone would not have qualified her. It was the discrepancy that mattered for her.

I would get him evaluated again at the next level (24 months if he's 22 months now). It can't hurt.

Until then, there are lots of exercises you can do with him.

While EI has certainly helped Ale a lot, I also think she was just taking her time. Her therapist is amazed at her recent progress -- and we missed 3 weeks!! So Rylan may just be taking his time too, so don't get too worried but in the meantime, yes do what you can.

Does that make any sense??? Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Rylan is 18 months so we would be waiting another 6 months...just seems so long to me.

I feel like Rylan comprehends so much when talking to him. When I say it's bath time he goes in the bathroom. When I ask if he wants breakfast he goes to the toaster oven...if I tell him we're going outside he runs to the door...stuff like that. But when it comes to other things like picking out objects in books he is lost. We have this book...My Little Word Book. He is beyond obsessed with it. I'm not exagerating when I say we go through it at least 2 hours a day. He points to the pictures and wants me to name them. If I ask him where's the...... he can't point it out. In my opinion he has issues with both expressive and comprehensive but still didn't qualify...i'm a little confused why.

Posted 10/13/09 10:12 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

Posted by DmarieK

Posted by karacg

I had Ale evaluated at 21 months and she didn't qualify.

At 24 months she did -- the requirements are much stricter. Also she had a huge gap between comprehension and expression. Her low level of expression alone would not have qualified her. It was the discrepancy that mattered for her.

I would get him evaluated again at the next level (24 months if he's 22 months now). It can't hurt.

Until then, there are lots of exercises you can do with him.

While EI has certainly helped Ale a lot, I also think she was just taking her time. Her therapist is amazed at her recent progress -- and we missed 3 weeks!! So Rylan may just be taking his time too, so don't get too worried but in the meantime, yes do what you can.

Does that make any sense??? Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Rylan is 18 months so we would be waiting another 6 months...just seems so long to me.

I feel like Rylan comprehends so much when talking to him. When I say it's bath time he goes in the bathroom. When I ask if he wants breakfast he goes to the toaster oven...if I tell him we're going outside he runs to the door...stuff like that. But when it comes to other things like picking out objects in books he is lost. We have this book...My Little Word Book. He is beyond obsessed with it. I'm not exagerating when I say we go through it at least 2 hours a day. He points to the pictures and wants me to name them. If I ask him where's the...... he can't point it out. In my opinion he has issues with both expressive and comprehensive but still didn't qualify...i'm a little confused why.



He sounds EXACTLY like Jack was at that age. He understood the daily things in our routine without a problem. We would read books and I would identify things all the time - he would never do it though. That was one thing that EI has worked on with him. I am pretty sure the next level is before 22 months but will find out for sure tomorrow!

Either way, I will say this - I think EI is amazing and sooooo beneficial to any child - but I do think that alot of it just comes with time. He will get there - he may just need that extra push!Chat Icon Chat Icon

ETA: Does Rylan know any sign language at all? This was the first thing that the speech therapist taught him. It helped us SOOOO much. He only knows "Give me" and "More" but it was amazing that once he started signing these words - after a while he started to say them. They are easy enough because you can get him to say them when he wants things. We used the signs with snacks, or toys. Just keep doing the signs while saying the words at the same time - he should start signing - and then eventually the words will come!

Message edited 2009-10-13 22:51:58.053000.

Posted 10/13/09 10:49 PM
 

tran92
LIF Adolescent

Member since 2/08

732 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

the requirements at 18 months are not the strongest. so if your child does some things, they will show the delay but not enough of one to qualify.

my DD was tested at 18 months (her big brother was severely speech delayed, special ed preschool for 3 years etc)

with that, she sowed a delay, but it was about 25% and she needed 33% to qualify. she had no words, not enough sounds, but her comprehension was good. and her motor skills are fine.

well, we started checking in about doing a 21 month eval, since it is a new set of test criteria. but its still not that strong of a set of requirements. and when we went over what they would be looking for, we knew she wouldn't qualify then, plus technically you need to wait 4 months to get another eval through EI. (I found this out when we called the therapist who did the eval to begin with... she also did my son's evals 6 years ago so we know her)

so you wouldn't even be able to get retested for another 4 months. at that point, you're better off waiting to the 2 year mark. you can call by the way a little before they turn 2 to get the ball rolling. we've already called, we should get the call with the appt schedule on the 19th, 10 days before her 2nd birthday.

the 2 year eval is alot harder than the 18 and 21 month evals. they expect alot more of the child, including actually expecting to hear words.

as of now, my DD will qualify at 2 because she still has no words. doesn't say mama or dada, or any of that. but meanwhile can follow complex directions easily.

if you can get speech therapy approved through your insurance, and you have to call to see what they will cover, its usually a co-pay situation. of course if your specialist co-pay is 40 bucks like mine is, it adds up fast anyway.

hth

Posted 10/13/09 10:55 PM
 

ajaysmom
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/05

810 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

A friend of mines son was tested at 20 months, and didn't qualify, she had him retested at 24-25 months and he did!! So i'd just retry when he turns 2!! Good Luck!

Posted 10/13/09 11:44 PM
 

DmarieK
My loves!!

Member since 1/06

9203 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

Posted by Diana1215
He sounds EXACTLY like Jack was at that age. He understood the daily things in our routine without a problem. We would read books and I would identify things all the time - he would never do it though. That was one thing that EI has worked on with him. I am pretty sure the next level is before 22 months but will find out for sure tomorrow!

Either way, I will say this - I think EI is amazing and sooooo beneficial to any child - but I do think that alot of it just comes with time. He will get there - he may just need that extra push!Chat Icon Chat Icon

ETA: Does Rylan know any sign language at all? This was the first thing that the speech therapist taught him. It helped us SOOOO much. He only knows "Give me" and "More" but it was amazing that once he started signing these words - after a while he started to say them. They are easy enough because you can get him to say them when he wants things. We used the signs with snacks, or toys. Just keep doing the signs while saying the words at the same time - he should start signing - and then eventually the words will come!



The evaluator said the testing won't change until 24 months so there's no point retesting because the outcome would be the same.

I've never taught him sign language...always wanted to though. I have a video...i'll have to put it on for him.

Posted 10/14/09 10:18 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

Dawn - I was just going to FM you. I asked my therapist and she said the same thing, unfortunately it's probably best to wait until 24 months - and hopefully by then he's talking up a storm! Chat Icon

Def. try the two signs I mentioned. They are SOOOOO easy and they get it right away and will help him communicate so much better!

Posted 10/14/09 10:20 PM
 

karacg
Babygirl is 4!

Member since 5/05

17076 total posts

Name:
Kara®

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

ITA with Diana -- Ale learned "more", "cookie" and "drink" and that got us through a lot of frustration.

Good luck!!

Posted 10/14/09 10:25 PM
 

DmarieK
My loves!!

Member since 1/06

9203 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about DC not qualifying for EI.

Posted by tran92

the requirements at 18 months are not the strongest. so if your child does some things, they will show the delay but not enough of one to qualify.

my DD was tested at 18 months (her big brother was severely speech delayed, special ed preschool for 3 years etc)

with that, she sowed a delay, but it was about 25% and she needed 33% to qualify. she had no words, not enough sounds, but her comprehension was good. and her motor skills are fine.

well, we started checking in about doing a 21 month eval, since it is a new set of test criteria. but its still not that strong of a set of requirements. and when we went over what they would be looking for, we knew she wouldn't qualify then, plus technically you need to wait 4 months to get another eval through EI. (I found this out when we called the therapist who did the eval to begin with... she also did my son's evals 6 years ago so we know her)

so you wouldn't even be able to get retested for another 4 months. at that point, you're better off waiting to the 2 year mark. you can call by the way a little before they turn 2 to get the ball rolling. we've already called, we should get the call with the appt schedule on the 19th, 10 days before her 2nd birthday.

the 2 year eval is alot harder than the 18 and 21 month evals. they expect alot more of the child, including actually expecting to hear words.

as of now, my DD will qualify at 2 because she still has no words. doesn't say mama or dada, or any of that. but meanwhile can follow complex directions easily.

if you can get speech therapy approved through your insurance, and you have to call to see what they will cover, its usually a co-pay situation. of course if your specialist co-pay is 40 bucks like mine is, it adds up fast anyway.

hth



I didn't know you had to wait 4 months between evals. If i'm waiting 4 I might as well wait the 6 months because then he'll be 24 months when it's time again.

I'm not worried enough to go through insurance just yet. I'm thinking i'll wait a little longer. I just hate thinking that maybe there really is an issue and I waited 6 months to help him. I'm hoping he's just a late talker and will come around soon. It doesn't seem to bother him...he never gets upset or frustrated over it which is great.

Posted 10/14/09 10:28 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
closing question and walk through question? nancygrace 1/6/07 3 Home
Not a TTC question, but a personal question Ambersmom 12/26/06 5 TTC
First question....now 2nd question... dree 10/27/06 10 Parenting
Paint Question (2nd question in org. post) MrsSchwags 10/5/06 12 Home
I have a question and Forgive me post( another question on bottom) luvsbob4603 6/16/06 14 Families Helping Families ™
Another question before I become a mom- Hospital question Shelly 4/10/06 11 Parenting