Prek question, need some perspective

Posted By Message

MrsT809
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

12167 total posts

Name:

Prek question, need some perspective

Dd's prek teacher has gone through quite a few different ideas trying to get the kids to behave. Most of the kids are good but I think she struggles with a few and somehow the whole class keeps getting dragged into it. Friday dd came out and was clearly upset. Turns out the two best listeners in the class got to pick a prize and she was upset that she wasn't picked. I asked the teachers and they verified it was only the two "best" listeners and she'd be sure to be picked another time. Is this not a little cruel for 4yos? Dd is a good girl, I've never heard one complaint, and yet she's left crying wondering what more she could have done. Obviously I don't think she should automatically have been picked but I think that whole idea is flawed. Am I bring too sensitive here? This is not the first time I'm left thinking her teacher doesn't have a great understanding of how 4yos think.

Posted 1/23/17 8:41 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

StaceyWill
It's a girl!!!

Member since 6/10

21539 total posts

Name:
Stacey

Prek question, need some perspective

I agree with you. I think that absolutely sucks. At my DD's school, only the kids who DON'T listen AT ALL, don't get a sticker. I think picking the "best" listener is pointless and the kids will not learn that way. I am not a teacher, but that is my feeling on it.

Posted 1/23/17 8:56 AM
 

ali120206
2 Boys

Member since 7/06

17796 total posts

Name:

Prek question, need some perspective

When they do rewards at my son's school for pre-k, everyone who is a good listener gets something (if it's a sticker or a lollipop).

They do give out paper awards for kids who go above and beyond though it seems (my friend's son got one but mine did not).

Posted 1/23/17 9:00 AM
 

ml110
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

5435 total posts

Name:

Prek question, need some perspective

i agree... it seems unfair to only identify 1 or 2 good listeners in the class...
there should be a reward for when they WHOLE class is listening, which kind of encourages the not great listeners to listen better. LIKE... my DS is in kindergarten. His teacher gives the whole class points for things like "working hard" "being good listeners" "good behavior"... then once the WHOLE class gets a certain number of points they get some kind of reward. SOOO that kind of encourages the kids who aren't so great, to be better behaved so that the whole class can get their reward....
not sure how you would bring this up to the teacher though....

ETA: she also will occasionally give out "extra" points to certain kids if they're extra good, or do something above and beyond (helping out a friend, etc). but that doesn't mean those kids get an extra reward. it just means they get to go home and say " i got an extra point today because i helped Tommy clean up the crayons he dropped..."

Message edited 2017-01-23 09:04:02.333000.

Posted 1/23/17 9:00 AM
 

Disneygirl17
LIF Toddler

Member since 11/16

496 total posts

Name:

Re: Prek question, need some perspective

Posted by ml110

i agree... it seems unfair to only identify 1 or 2 good listeners in the class...
there should be a reward for when they WHOLE class is listening, which kind of encourages the not great listeners to listen better. LIKE... my DS is in kindergarten. His teacher gives the whole class points for things like "working hard" "being good listeners" "good behavior"... then once the WHOLE class gets a certain number of points they get some kind of reward. SOOO that kind of encourages the kids who aren't so great, to be better behaved so that the whole class can get their reward....
not sure how you would bring this up to the teacher though....

ETA: she also will occasionally give out "extra" points to certain kids if they're extra good, or do something above and beyond (helping out a friend, etc). but that doesn't mean those kids get an extra reward. it just means they get to go home and say " i got an extra point today because i helped Tommy clean up the crayons he dropped..."



My dd is in first but same concept. She will get extra tickets for doing something extra. She doesn't always get tickets but she still tries

Posted 1/23/17 9:24 AM
 

MaZz
* Lovin my baby girl!!! *

Member since 2/09

6243 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: Prek question, need some perspective

While yes it does suck that she wasn't included, it is a learning lesson that not everyone can be chosen at once. If she keeps up her good behavior, she will get her turn too. It wasn't that she didn't do enough, there just can't be 10 winners. It teaches her to be patient. Now if this went on all year long, yes I would have a problem with it simply because of the age they are at. But I believe in teaching my daughter lessons when things don't work out.

From previous posts, it seems like you have your issues with this school she's in. Maybe that is making you more sensitive to this matter?

Posted 1/23/17 9:45 AM
 

MrsT809
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

12167 total posts

Name:

Re: Prek question, need some perspective

Posted by MaZz

While yes it does suck that she wasn't included, it is a learning lesson that not everyone can be chosen at once. If she keeps up her good behavior, she will get her turn too. It wasn't that she didn't do enough, there just can't be 10 winners. It teaches her to be patient. Now if this went on all year long, yes I would have a problem with it simply because of the age they are at. But I believe in teaching my daughter lessons when things don't work out.

From previous posts, it seems like you have your issues with this school she's in. Maybe that is making you more sensitive to this matter?



I totally get what you're saying and that was how I approached it with her. I also understand why the two kids who were picked were chosen and I think outside circumstances were taken into account if that makes sense. We talked about it a lot but that is a big lesson for a young child. I would still be annoyed but I would have felt a little better if they had said two "of the best" would be picked.

Her prek is in her elementary school but it's not run by the district. I do wish she were getting a better experience considering this is her introduction to the school she'll be in for many years to come.

Posted 1/23/17 10:17 AM
 

Nickles01
LIF Infant

Member since 3/16

165 total posts

Name:

Re: Prek question, need some perspective

Posted by MrsT809

Posted by MaZz

While yes it does suck that she wasn't included, it is a learning lesson that not everyone can be chosen at once. If she keeps up her good behavior, she will get her turn too. It wasn't that she didn't do enough, there just can't be 10 winners. It teaches her to be patient. Now if this went on all year long, yes I would have a problem with it simply because of the age they are at. But I believe in teaching my daughter lessons when things don't work out.

From previous posts, it seems like you have your issues with this school she's in. Maybe that is making you more sensitive to this matter?



I totally get what you're saying and that was how I approached it with her. I also understand why the two kids who were picked were chosen and I think outside circumstances were taken into account if that makes sense. We talked about it a lot but that is a big lesson for a young child. I would still be annoyed but I would have felt a little better if they had said two "of the best" would be picked.

Her prek is in her elementary school but it's not run by the district. I do wish she were getting a better experience considering this is her introduction to the school she'll be in for many years to come.



We tell my 4 year old all the time, not everyone is entitled to everything. You have to start somewhere with kids. Take it as a good opportunity to teach her.

Posted 1/23/17 11:27 AM
 

gina409
TWINS!

Member since 12/09

27635 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Prek question, need some perspective

Posted by MaZz

While yes it does suck that she wasn't included, it is a learning lesson that not everyone can be chosen at once. If she keeps up her good behavior, she will get her turn too. It wasn't that she didn't do enough, there just can't be 10 winners. It teaches her to be patient. Now if this went on all year long, yes I would have a problem with it simply because of the age they are at. But I believe in teaching my daughter lessons when things don't work out.

From previous posts, it seems like you have your issues with this school she's in. Maybe that is making you more sensitive to this matter?



This.

Posted 1/23/17 1:30 PM
 

lululu
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

9511 total posts

Name:

Re: Prek question, need some perspective

The fact that they are struggling with a few kids in the class, and this is how they chose to address the situation, indicates to me that they are not very good teachers.

Posted 1/23/17 1:44 PM
 

MrsT809
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

12167 total posts

Name:

Re: Prek question, need some perspective

Posted by lululu

The fact that they are struggling with a few kids in the class, and this is how they chose to address the situation, indicates to me that they are not very good teachers.



Well they've tried and abandoned a few method from what I can tell. Sometimes I think I'm overly critical as a former teacher myself but I can't imagine in any class I've taught choosing a few to name the best at anything.

As for teaching her about not always winning, etc that is nothing new. Dd has had plenty of opportunities to learn to deal with disappointment and knows she'll never get everything she wants. Chat Icon

Posted 1/23/17 3:33 PM
 

PennyCat
Just call me mommy :)

Member since 7/08

19084 total posts

Name:
Jib

Re: Prek question, need some perspective

I feel sad for your DD. It actually reminds me of when I was in seventh grade and my social studies teacher gave a "student of the week" award to two students each week. I was a good kid, pretty good student in her class, TRIED hard, and each week sat with anticipation as other kids were chosen to receive the award instead of me. I was a sensitive kid and still remember the disappointment I felt week after week when all my hard work went unrecognized-- and that was at 12 or 13 yrs old! So I can imagine your DD at 4 must feel very disappointed.

Posted 1/24/17 6:49 AM
 

lululu
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

9511 total posts

Name:

Re: Prek question, need some perspective

I also want to add for those that say this is a lesson, my daughter's teacher did something similar in kindergarten. My daughter is seriously an angel at school and she was the last to get the daily award. I think that the teacher was using it more of an incentive for the bad kids to behave so the kids that were always good got the shaft. Well, my daughter came home crying hysterically every day because she wanted the award so badly, would do everything she could to get it and never got it. It seriously ruined her first month of kindergarten. It's a crap thing for a teacher to do. It just makes good kids feel bad. And at 2 they don't need to learn that lesson AT SCHOOL. They need to learn to love school and that's about it. There are plenty of opportunities at home for parents to teach that lesson.

Posted 1/24/17 10:46 AM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Prek question, need some perspective

At four years old I think this is too young. My kids are in elementary school and they do give out awards like this. My kids have received them, but I really feel for those kids that don't get them. I really don't like it personally. I think it can make good but not outstanding or teachers favorite kids feel badly and then it can cause them to not like school.

Posted 1/24/17 10:56 AM
 

MrsT809
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

12167 total posts

Name:

Prek question, need some perspective

So to update, she actually got a prize yesterday. Of course I'm left wondering is it bc I asked about the prizes and bc dd was near tears at the time?

According to dd, they were told 8 kids got a prize in the morning class and about 5 got it in her class. So clearly, they're making up the rules as they go. As a former teacher, I don't have a problem with them struggling with behavior issues, but at this point the teacher should be asking for ideas from more seasoned teachers or her supervisor to get an effective system in place.

Posted 1/24/17 11:03 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
school question- public prek BaysideForever 1/27/14 7 Parenting
WWYD? Prek question waiting4ablessing 9/23/13 4 Parenting
PreK Moms and Homework Question AnnBrunoXO 9/20/10 18 Parents of School-Aged Children
I have a question and Forgive me post( another question on bottom) luvsbob4603 6/16/06 14 Families Helping Families ™
Another question before I become a mom- Hospital question Shelly 4/10/06 11 Parenting
This isnt a TTC question - more so a BCP question Gdesq 5/25/05 9 TTC