pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 | |
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies Posted by jacquig Posted by BargainMama Posted by GoldenRod Posted by jacquig Posted by annoyedTTCer Posted by jacquig I will preface this by saying that I will teach my DD and any future children I bring into this world to be respectful and love all all people regardless of race, gender, sexual orientation, religion etc. However with that said I know I'm in the minority but I do think a heads up should have been given. Kids will ask questions that some parents may not be prepared to answer and quite frankly, lets be real there is still a HUGE amount of society that does not agree with same sex marriage. Maybe not so much on this board (or at least they may not be vocal about it) but no one can negate the fact that a lot of people are still not accepting of same sex marriage. The two mommies two daddies explanation can come with many questions attached that parents may not want to explain to a 4 year old. What does marriage have to do with who is raising a child? Same sex marriage/relationships whatever you want to call it...some people don't agree with it...that was my point. As a parent you suck up your own idiotic beliefs to teach your child to be tolerant of others. There doesn't even need to be a same sex discussion about this if a child came home and mentioned it. You say all families are different. Period. They are 4 year olds, not 12 and need details. Well my beliefs are NOT idiotic...as I stated above I will teach my children to love and respect EVERYONE regardless of whomever they are with, whatever color they may be, whatever religion they might practice, etc. However to YOU it may be idiotic to not believe in same sex relationships but to someone who is very religious or has different beliefs it may not be. Maybe they don't want their kids to learn about that in Pre-K. That is their choice as a parent....like it or not. As far as details my 3 year old asks 100 questions so while some 4 year olds may let it go some may not. Some parents are not prepared or don't want to discuss it...that is their perogative. I didn't say your beliefs were idiotic. I was speaking in general. Again, they aren't learning about same sex marriage, or marriage at all! They are learning about families. |
|
Posted 9/15/11 3:20 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies Posted by BargainMama Posted by jacquig Posted by BargainMama Posted by GoldenRod Posted by jacquig Posted by annoyedTTCer Posted by jacquig I will preface this by saying that I will teach my DD and any future children I bring into this world to be respectful and love all all people regardless of race, gender, sexual orientation, religion etc. However with that said I know I'm in the minority but I do think a heads up should have been given. Kids will ask questions that some parents may not be prepared to answer and quite frankly, lets be real there is still a HUGE amount of society that does not agree with same sex marriage. Maybe not so much on this board (or at least they may not be vocal about it) but no one can negate the fact that a lot of people are still not accepting of same sex marriage. The two mommies two daddies explanation can come with many questions attached that parents may not want to explain to a 4 year old. What does marriage have to do with who is raising a child? Same sex marriage/relationships whatever you want to call it...some people don't agree with it...that was my point. As a parent you suck up your own idiotic beliefs to teach your child to be tolerant of others. There doesn't even need to be a same sex discussion about this if a child came home and mentioned it. You say all families are different. Period. They are 4 year olds, not 12 and need details. Well my beliefs are NOT idiotic...as I stated above I will teach my children to love and respect EVERYONE regardless of whomever they are with, whatever color they may be, whatever religion they might practice, etc. However to YOU it may be idiotic to not believe in same sex relationships but to someone who is very religious or has different beliefs it may not be. Maybe they don't want their kids to learn about that in Pre-K. That is their choice as a parent....like it or not. As far as details my 3 year old asks 100 questions so while some 4 year olds may let it go some may not. Some parents are not prepared or don't want to discuss it...that is their perogative. I didn't say your beliefs were idiotic. I was speaking in general. Again, they aren't learning about same sex marriage, or marriage at all! They are learning about families. exactly. No one is telling them how the mechanics of it work or what they do behind closed doors, so whats the big deal. I told DS (who is 4) that sometimes to boys love each other and sometimes two girls love each other and therefore sometimes kids have two mommies or sometimes they have two daddies. Nothing more, nothing less. He went "oh, ok" and went on his way. Its about teaching him about different types of families not about the gay lifestyle. |
|
Posted 9/15/11 3:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies exactly. No one is telling them how the mechanics of it work or what they do behind closed doors, so whats the big deal. I told DS (who is 4) that sometimes to boys love each other and sometimes two girls love each other and therefore sometimes kids have two mommies or sometimes they have two daddies. Nothing more, nothing less. He went "oh, ok" and went on his way. Its about teaching him about different types of families not about the gay lifestyle. |
|
Posted 9/15/11 3:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies I'm not sure why this is even a hot topic. Same sex partners exist, and have children. It's a fact, regardless of how anyone *feels* about it. Just like divorced families exist, and widowed families exist, etc. |
|
Posted 9/15/11 3:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies I am the furthest thing from liberal but this would not bother me in the least bit. I have no issues with my children being taught about all types of families. |
|
Posted 9/15/11 4:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies I would be thrilled to hear my 4 year old was learning about families with 2 mommies or 2 daddies! In fact, she was asking me about that the other day and we had a nice little chat. |
|
Posted 9/15/11 5:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies Seeing as my son goes to the school with the highest rate of same sex parents in the region, I am fine with them teaching this in school. Families come in many differnt ways, so its all good. |
|
Posted 9/15/11 5:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies Posted by Kate The only way this is appropriate is if there is a child in the class with a family like that. As a teacher, I would put $ on this being the reason why it was brought up in class. However, as a parent, I think it should be put out there to kids because it's not all that uncommon. |
|
Posted 9/15/11 5:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies maybe one of the students has 2 mommies or daddies and another asked? I know a lot of these "life lessons" happen on the fly in the primary grades. |
|
Posted 9/15/11 6:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies It's a fact of life - teachers teach facts. No one asks my permission to teach algebra, etc. |
|
Posted 9/15/11 7:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies I think it's great, actually! |
|
Posted 9/15/11 8:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies Posted by MsMBV I'm not sure why this is even a hot topic. Same sex partners exist, and have children. It's a fact, regardless of how anyone *feels* about it. Just like divorced families exist, and widowed families exist, etc. Exactly. |
|
Posted 9/15/11 8:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies Posted by jacquig Posted by annoyedTTCer Posted by jacquig I will preface this by saying that I will teach my DD and any future children I bring into this world to be respectful and love all all people regardless of race, gender, sexual orientation, religion etc. However with that said I know I'm in the minority but I do think a heads up should have been given. Kids will ask questions that some parents may not be prepared to answer and quite frankly, lets be real there is still a HUGE amount of society that does not agree with same sex marriage. Maybe not so much on this board (or at least they may not be vocal about it) but no one can negate the fact that a lot of people are still not accepting of same sex marriage. The two mommies two daddies explanation can come with many questions attached that parents may not want to explain to a 4 year old. What does marriage have to do with who is raising a child? Same sex marriage/relationships whatever you want to call it...some people don't agree with it...that was my point. Some people don't agree with interracial marriages or non married couples having children, etc. It is still a reality that these situations exist so whether or not you agree is irrelevant. |
|
Posted 9/15/11 8:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies i think its great, educate them young so they are tolerant and accept all kinds of people, families, etc... |
|
Posted 9/15/11 9:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies Posted by kiwi86 I teach elementary school school health and we don't cover that specifically. There are lessons about "Family" so if a teacher knows of a particular student in their class who has a special situation they might be inclined to mention that. However I have several students with 2 mommies so I often tell children that families comes in all different types. We don't get into it, just mention it, which is probably your your child's teacher did. Hope that helps I agree. Maybe there is a child in the class with this circumstanc and she said some families have 2 mommies some have 2 daddies...something like that. Funny story, right after NY passed the law DS asked me if men can marry men and women can marry women I said yes, he said is that French don't know where that came from!
|
|
Posted 9/15/11 9:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies Posted by scarletbegonia I might be in the minority but I see nothing wrong with preschoolers being "taught" about this. My son is exposed to this on a very regular basis - both with our friends and family members. It's just a way of life. Some kids have 2 mommies, some have 2 daddies, some just have one parent. A family is a family is a family. Again, this is just my opinion. I agree...I don't see anything wrong with this. It may be a controversial topic, but not to a 4 year old...only to adults. Kids can't even understand the concept of a man and woman getting married. I want my kids to respect all people even if they have made different life choices than us. Why not teach them this at a young age. I don't think schools can give parents a 'heads up' on every subject that may be deemed as controversial. What's taboo to one, is not to another. Believe me...I'm not trying convince anyone that teaching this is right or wrong. I'm just saying that I think it's acceptable. Message edited 2011-09-16 15:07:53.000000. |
|
Posted 9/15/11 9:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies If it was taught on the fly because it came up somehow... what should the teacher have done? Not answered anything and then sent a letter home to notify the parents? |
|
Posted 9/15/11 10:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies I think what it comes down to is that you want the son or daughter of a same sex couple to feel accepted! Regardless of ones politics or religion, the child in the scenario is the number 1 priority. Whether you agree with it or not, some kids do have 2 moms or dads & I would never want a kid to feel different or isolated bc of decisions made by the parents. |
|
Posted 9/15/11 10:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies I WOULD want to have a heads up about this type of discussion. It isn't something that I discuss with my children nor plan to for some time and I would certanly want to be prepared to answer any questions that might arise. |
|
Posted 9/15/11 10:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies What does marriage have to do with who is raising a child? I may be ALL ALONE with what I'm about to say but I can't hold back...I think it is sad that we live in a society where somebody can ask this question seriously! I don't care if the couple is straight or gay, but a child (IMHO) should be raised by a loving set of parents...sadly, the divorce rate is more than half and I understand situations arise where grandparents or other family may raise a child, but the ideal situation is for a child to grow up raised by 2 married, loving parents! Burn me...i dont care. My father died when I was 6 and my brother was 4. I know what it was like having 1 parent, having to constantly explain about my dad to other kids (Fathers Day crafts EVERY year in elementary school) I wouldn't wish that on any child. My family had a happy ending bc my mom remarried when I was 10 and I don't even consider my step father anything less than my father. They are still married 20 years later. So I was raised seeing what a healthy marriage looks like, and I hope to raise my daughter the same way. Like I said, gay or straight, marriage has EVERYTHING to do with raising a child IMHO! |
|
Posted 9/15/11 11:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies I have no problems with this being taught at any age. It's a lesson in family and tolerance, and that's always a good thing. |
|
Posted 9/16/11 8:08 AM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies Just wanted to say that I actually used this thread as a starting point to talk about same-sex families again to DC at dinnertime. We've brought it up before, but because of this thread, I figured I'd bring up the topic again. |
|
Posted 9/16/11 2:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies Posted by MrsECullen7319 What does marriage have to do with who is raising a child? I may be ALL ALONE with what I'm about to say but I can't hold back...I think it is sad that we live in a society where somebody can ask this question seriously! I don't care if the couple is straight or gay, but a child (IMHO) should be raised by a loving set of parents...sadly, the divorce rate is more than half and I understand situations arise where grandparents or other family may raise a child, but the ideal situation is for a child to grow up raised by 2 married, loving parents! Burn me...i dont care. My father died when I was 6 and my brother was 4. I know what it was like having 1 parent, having to constantly explain about my dad to other kids (Fathers Day crafts EVERY year in elementary school) I wouldn't wish that on any child. My family had a happy ending bc my mom remarried when I was 10 and I don't even consider my step father anything less than my father. They are still married 20 years later. So I was raised seeing what a healthy marriage looks like, and I hope to raise my daughter the same way. Like I said, gay or straight, marriage has EVERYTHING to do with raising a child IMHO! Marriage has nothing to do with raising a child. Plenty of people skip marriage yet live together as a family unit. And this number will continue to go up as more people turn away from the church and their formalities. |
|
Posted 9/16/11 3:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies Posted by MrsECullen7319 What does marriage have to do with who is raising a child? I may be ALL ALONE with what I'm about to say but I can't hold back...I think it is sad that we live in a society where somebody can ask this question seriously! I don't care if the couple is straight or gay, but a child (IMHO) should be raised by a loving set of parents...sadly, the divorce rate is more than half and I understand situations arise where grandparents or other family may raise a child, but the ideal situation is for a child to grow up raised by 2 married, loving parents! Burn me...i dont care. My father died when I was 6 and my brother was 4. I know what it was like having 1 parent, having to constantly explain about my dad to other kids (Fathers Day crafts EVERY year in elementary school) I wouldn't wish that on any child. My family had a happy ending bc my mom remarried when I was 10 and I don't even consider my step father anything less than my father. They are still married 20 years later. So I was raised seeing what a healthy marriage looks like, and I hope to raise my daughter the same way. Like I said, gay or straight, marriage has EVERYTHING to do with raising a child IMHO! I respectfully disagree. You say that you grew up seeing a healthy marriage because your mother re married, but what if she didn't? You, your mother and brother were still a family. Family doesn't = Mommy, Daddy, Baby and Doggie anymore. And to those who say they'd rather teach their kids themselves, kids are observant and see different types of familys EVERYWHERE |
|
Posted 9/16/11 4:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: pre-k "lesson" about two mommies/daddies Posted by MrsKS If it was taught on the fly because it came up somehow... what should the teacher have done? Not answered anything and then sent a letter home to notify the parents? I think sometimes answers need to be given right then and there. I agree. I've worked in early childhood for 7 years. Sometimes children ask questions and don't give you the opportunity to say, "Hold that thought while I write a note giving a head's up to your mom." And this could prevent them from asking questions in the future, which is what learning is all about. I think answering, "some children have two mommies and some have two daddies" is appropriate. |
|
Posted 9/16/11 6:34 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Two mommies/daddies "lesson" in pre-k | gpsyeyes | 9/14/11 | 4 | Parents of School-Aged Children |
| Mommies of pre-school boys | MST9106 | 10/29/09 | 6 | Parenting |
















) And that's exactly where is would have gone... I know that my oldest is very inquisitive and would want to know more details...

