please explain how this is racist?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

please explain how this is racist?

GARDEN CITY, N.Y. — A weekly newspaper photo depicting President Barack Obama and his wife as characters from the TV sitcom "Sanford and Son" was intended as political satire and not a racist commentary, the publisher said Wednesday.

Phillip Sciarello, publisher and part owner of the Smithtown Messenger on New York's Long Island, defended the decision to publish the photo, but added the newspaper would run a retraction in its next edition for anyone who might have been offended.

The photo spread features "before and after" shots of the last six presidents and their wives, starting with Jimmy and Rosalynn Carter and ending with the Obamas. The "after" photo of the Obamas is a shot from the 1970s show, with Redd Foxx as Fred Sanford and LaWanda Page as Sanford's sister-in-law, Aunt Esther. She is seen standing ready to box Sanford; the characters often verbally jousted as part of the show's story line.

The "after" photos of the other presidents feature their images as slightly older than when they took office.

The controversy prompted the Brookhaven town board to remove one of the Messenger's sister publications, the Brookhaven Review, as an official newspaper, meaning it will no longer publish town government legal notices.

"The reference to racial stereotypes is where the line was crossed," Brookhaven Supervisor Mark Lesko told Newsday in Wednesday's editions. Lesko, a Democrat, did not immediately return a call for comment.

A Suffolk County legislator, DuWayne Gregory of Amityville, said he will propose a resolution to drop the Messenger as an official county paper at next week's meeting of the Legislature.

Hazel N. Dukes, president of the state NAACP conference, said in a statement Wednesday that the county should immediately pull advertising from any publication that ran the photo.

"It is simply shocking and outrageous that such a blatantly racist ad would run in any paper, much less an official paper of Suffolk County," Dukes said. "New Yorkers of all races and ethnicity are disgusted by it and reject it."

Tracey Edwards, the NAACP's Long Island regional director, described the portrayal of the Obamas as "despicable and disrespectful. If this was intended as satire, it misses the mark."

___________________

I mean, if they're showing a depiction of the Obama's as an elderly black couple.. why on earth would showing The Sanfords be wrong?
Should they have shown an elderly white couple?

sometimes we go too far in trying to be PC imo

Posted 5/7/10 2:11 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Posted by Otherme

I mean, if they're showing a depiction of the Obama's as an elderly black couple.. why on earth would showing The Sanfords be wrong?
Should they have shown an elderly white couple?

sometimes we go too far in trying to be PC imo




It's wrong (not saying racist, just the wrong thing to do and certainly disrespectful IMO) because none of the other presidents were shown as caricatures of their culture... the Sanfords are a stereotype of an African American family.

Were George and Laura Bush depicted as that family from the Beverly Hillbillies? If you do it to one, you have to do it to all..

Posted 5/7/10 2:22 PM
 

J9-13
We're gonna be big sisters!

Member since 6/06

14887 total posts

Name:
J9

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Posted by eroxgirl

Posted by Otherme

I mean, if they're showing a depiction of the Obama's as an elderly black couple.. why on earth would showing The Sanfords be wrong?
Should they have shown an elderly white couple?

sometimes we go too far in trying to be PC imo




It's wrong (not saying racist, just the wrong thing to do and certainly disrespectful IMO) because none of the other presidents were shown as caricatures of their culture... the Sanfords are a stereotype of an African American family.

Were George and Laura Bush depicted as that family from the Beverly Hillbillies? If you do it to one, you have to do it to all..




I agree!
If that was the theme of the spread, fine. But they didn't do that with any of the other presidents because they all have aged since their terms. I just think the whole thing seemed pointless.

Message edited 2010-05-07 14:26:53.497000.

Posted 5/7/10 2:26 PM
 

momma2b
Princess is here!

Member since 8/08

1386 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: please explain how this is racist?

it's political satire!
c'mon now people!!!

people would be rolling on the floor hysterical laughing if it were bush or cheney or palin being depicted like that!

IMO people are hypcritical and overly sensitive when it comes to this administration!

Posted 5/7/10 2:27 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Posted by eroxgirl

Posted by Otherme

I mean, if they're showing a depiction of the Obama's as an elderly black couple.. why on earth would showing The Sanfords be wrong?
Should they have shown an elderly white couple?

sometimes we go too far in trying to be PC imo




It's wrong (not saying racist, just the wrong thing to do and certainly disrespectful IMO) because none of the other presidents were shown as caricatures of their culture... the Sanfords are a stereotype of an African American family.

Were George and Laura Bush depicted as that family from the Beverly Hillbillies? If you do it to one, you have to do it to all..



oooh, ok duh, i actually realize what they're getting at now (that's why i asked! Chat Icon)
i still don't see it as racist.. but i can see how it wasn't right to depict them as characters if none of the other presidents were shown that way.
See..i'm too quick to judge myself!
Chat Icon
thanks for the explanation

Posted 5/7/10 2:28 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Posted by eroxgirl

It's wrong (not saying racist, just the wrong thing to do and certainly disrespectful IMO) because none of the other presidents were shown as caricatures of their culture... the Sanfords are a stereotype of an African American family.

Were George and Laura Bush depicted as that family from the Beverly Hillbillies? If you do it to one, you have to do it to all..



I agree.

If they aged it, I'd still think it was humorous.

I get that it's satire but still inappropriate in my book.

Posted 5/7/10 2:29 PM
 

McSullivan
.

Member since 5/05

1573 total posts

Name:

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Message edited 2011-02-23 11:27:45.903000.

Posted 5/7/10 2:30 PM
 

evnme
My little lamb

Member since 8/05

12633 total posts

Name:
aka momma2b

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Posted by McSullivan

PLEASE!! They did FAR worse to Bush during his entire administration!
I don't understand why is was A-OK to completely lampoon one President and not the next.



ITA.
I was going to say some similar.

Posted 5/7/10 2:33 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Posted by McSullivan

PLEASE!! They did FAR worse to Bush during his entire administration!
I don't understand why is was A-OK to completely lampoon one President and not the next.



I don't see anything wrong with lampooning this president or any president AT ALL. Like any president, he's given his fair share of material to work with!

But when you line them all up and you only do it to ONE, that's where the inappropriateness comes in.

Posted 5/7/10 2:36 PM
 

McSullivan
.

Member since 5/05

1573 total posts

Name:

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Message edited 2011-02-23 11:28:21.447000.

Posted 5/7/10 2:38 PM
 

LoriH
There's no place like home

Member since 8/07

4110 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: please explain how this is racist?

I think the issue is it was done to just one president and not the others. If each of them had equally stereotypical representations, it would not be perceived as racist. Sanford and Son is known for the stereotypes portrayed on the show. Like someone else said it would be similar to showing George W Bush's family as the Beverly Hillbillies. Still not sure it is wrong, it was intended as political satire and there is this little thing called the first amendment.

Posted 5/7/10 3:10 PM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Posted by McSullivan

Posted by eroxgirl

Posted by McSullivan

PLEASE!! They did FAR worse to Bush during his entire administration!
I don't understand why is was A-OK to completely lampoon one President and not the next.



I don't see anything wrong with lampooning this president or any president AT ALL. Like any president, he's given his fair share of material to work with!

But when you line them all up and you only do it to ONE, that's where the inappropriateness comes in.



That's what I'm saying, they used to do that to Bush ALL the time!! ALL the time.



But not like this. I didn't see the publication but if I am understanding this article correctly - all of these pictures were posted next to each other. Carter, Reagan, Clinton, etc - they were depicted as older white men. Not Archie Bunker or Jed Clampett. Obama wasn't depicted as a an older black man but as a TV character.

Posted 5/7/10 3:25 PM
 

McSullivan
.

Member since 5/05

1573 total posts

Name:

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Message edited 2011-02-23 11:27:28.750000.

Posted 5/7/10 4:16 PM
 

debsabourin13
LIF Toddler

Member since 4/10

465 total posts

Name:
Debra

Re: please explain how this is racist?

This is the pic in question...see the paper, it seems wrong to me...I understand that its before and after the white house and the effect on married couples but with the other presidents they have before and after photos, with Obama obviously they don't. I am not really sure what the point of the satire was, but perhaps it just shouldn't have been run.

Image Attachment(s):

Message edited 2010-05-07 16:21:50.767000.

Posted 5/7/10 4:19 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Posted by debsabourin13

This is the pic in question...see the paper, it seems wrong to me...I understand that its before and after the white house and the effect on married couples but with the other presidents they have before and after photos, with Obama obviously they don't. I am not really sure what the point of the satire was, but perhaps it just shouldn't have been run.




Well, they don't have 'after' photos of the Obama's yet..

Posted 5/7/10 4:37 PM
 

debsabourin13
LIF Toddler

Member since 4/10

465 total posts

Name:
Debra

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Obviously.It just seems weird to me that this was the "after" couple that they chose. If I was to just look at the pics I would think this is wrong, of course not being able to read what context it was in, if there was an article that accompanied it, and am just not sure what the point is. If any of those couples should have been in fighting stance after the presidency was over I would think it would be, IMO, the Clintons, but their pic is actually mostly pleasant. Just don't know not being able to see the context.

Message edited 2010-05-07 16:56:59.420000.

Posted 5/7/10 4:54 PM
 

LINewbie
Tigger the the Rescue!

Member since 8/08

5647 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Posted by momma2b

it's political satire!
c'mon now people!!!

people would be rolling on the floor hysterical laughing if it were bush or cheney or palin being depicted like that!

IMO people are hypcritical and overly sensitive when it comes to this administration!


Agreed.
I think it'd be funny too if the Bushes were the family from the Hillbillies.. So what? It was a funny show and not offensive at all.

Posted 5/7/10 5:15 PM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

Re: please explain how this is racist?

I don't think its racist but I find it in very poor taste, disrespectful, and inappropriate...

Posted 5/7/10 8:28 PM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: please explain how this is racist?

thanks for posting the pic. i guess its to show the effects of being president and how it ages you..

they could have just drew caricitures of the Obamas as old people since it will be a while before we see the effects on them.

I dont think its racist, just maybe not in good taste.

Posted 5/7/10 10:18 PM
 

HelenZ
So worth the wait :)

Member since 10/07

2862 total posts

Name:
Helen

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Posted by staceyums81

I don't think its racist but I find it in very poor taste, disrespectful, and inappropriate...



I agree...in poor taste....it helps to see the actual pictures though, thanks for posting! every sitting president gets abused in political cartoons, because they're generally the center of attention in current events. it's nothing new, and they're usually meant to stir up controversy (as this one has succeeded in doing!). I'm curious though whether this was in the paper more as a cartoon or article? If this was an article, then it's definitely poor taste IMO

Posted 5/8/10 12:09 AM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Posted by debsabourin13

and am just not sure what the point is. If any of those couples should have been in fighting stance after the presidency was over I would think it would be, IMO, the Clintons, but their pic is actually mostly pleasant. Just don't know not being able to see the context.



that was my first thought as well.


The Obama's are a very well educated and highly respected couple (looking outside the presidency), it seems like the only comparison that they have to Fred Sandford is that they are black? I think if they had made the Bush - Clampett connection, it wouldn't have been as bad (Texas and oil)...but I think if they made a Bush - Bunker connection, that would have been as highly offensive (As much as I don't/didnt like Bush, I would never compare him to Archie Bunker, just because he's white)


Are the obamas fighting? I hadn't heard anything, is that what sparked this satire?

Posted 5/8/10 9:33 AM
 

MrsH2009
Thank you St. Gerard!

Member since 8/09

6631 total posts

Name:
M

Re: please explain how this is racist?

I don't think it is trying to show anything about how the white house ages you, or about the couples' relationships. The comic thought he had a funny idea, comparing the Obamas to Sanford and Son, so he made up this whole spread around it. It is very disrespectful. To make fun of Bush or Quayle or someone b/c of something they said (and there was a lot of material), is very different from just commenting about their skin color. There is no link to Obama and Sanford and Son, except skin color.

Posted 5/8/10 11:28 AM
 

Songwriter76
LIF Adult

Member since 4/08

902 total posts

Name:
David

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Posted by MrsH2009

I don't think it is trying to show anything about how the white house ages you, or about the couples' relationships. The comic thought he had a funny idea, comparing the Obamas to Sanford and Son, so he made up this whole spread around it. It is very disrespectful. To make fun of Bush or Quayle or someone b/c of something they said (and there was a lot of material), is very different from just commenting about their skin color. There is no link to Obama and Sanford and Son, except skin color.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Exactly! It is TOTALLY racist because there is no "funny" connection between The President and the First Lady and Sanford and Son.

There IS more of a connection between Bush and Jed Clampett. Which is not hard to figure out. Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-05-08 14:56:44.180000.

Posted 5/8/10 2:55 PM
 

mrsboss
my little love

Member since 12/09

5054 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Would it have been 'acceptable or appropriate' if they used a photos of the Huxtables from the Cosby show? I am sure that would have been ok. Because they are black professionals, not black junk collectors.
it's not racist at all. This is taking PC too far. They just dont have 'after' photos of the Obamas yet.

Posted 5/8/10 3:26 PM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: please explain how this is racist?

Posted by mrsboss

Would it have been 'acceptable or appropriate' if they used a photos of the Huxtables from the Cosby show? I am sure that would have been ok. Because they are black professionals, not black junk collectors.
it's not racist at all. This is taking PC too far. They just dont have 'after' photos of the Obamas yet.



yes...it would be. The Obama's are professionals - so linking them to another professional couple is acceptable and appropriate. Linking them to Fred Sanford is soley based on skin color.

Posted 5/9/10 7:51 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Someone explain the utility Budget plans please. krashnburn 11/1/05 3 Home
Can someone Explain MamaNDaddyof3 9/4/05 2 Families Helping Families ™
Pre Approval: Can Someone Explain ... Elbee 8/23/05 11 Home
Can someone explain Marcie 8/4/05 23 Pets
Can someone explain Weight Watchers to me!! octobergirl 5/16/05 5 Diet & Fitness
Can someone explain to me OPK's? Cheryl 5/12/05 7 TTC