Peds pushing formula on EBFers

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

Posted by DanaRenee


I still don't understand...if he's gaining on my breast milk alone does anyone know why he would push formula on me? I still think I want to EBF, what would you do?



if he's gaining then I would still EBF. My baby was born big, 9.7 lbs...but he dropped to 8.10 lbs in the hospital. I had to rent a pump and the hospital staff then felt fine with me EBFChat Icon

Posted 9/20/07 4:55 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

I am not yet a parent (due in December) so I have not tried to BF yet. But this post caught my attention. I went to a BF class the other day and the consultant was so amazing!

One thing she explained is that we make 2 types of milk (I had no idea of this) the first thing a baby gets (I think I have the right name) if called foremilk which is thinner and more "sugary" after that is done, they will receive hindmilk which is fattier. Her suggestion was to feed from one side if the baby falls asleep or seems done, change them, burp them and then "top them off" from the opposite side. Then next time you start off with the side you ended on, this will mean that in the next feeding they are getting the more substantial hind milk.

She also said they are working on a new height/growth chart for BF babies because BF babies are generally leaner than FF babies.

If it were me, I would give it more time, the poor kid is only 12 days old! and the dr didnt give a real valid reason. Go with your heart.

Posted 9/20/07 5:29 PM
 

Karebaby
Precious

Member since 10/06

5304 total posts

Name:
Karyn

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

I wouldn't supplement at all. If he is gaining on EBF there is no reason why you should supplement even one feeding with formula.

Posted 9/20/07 5:54 PM
 

Dragonfly75
I love Hypnobabies

Member since 3/06

2333 total posts

Name:

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by Dragonfly75

Posted by elyssa222

I hate to say this but many peds receive kickbacks from formula comapnies and that is one of the main reasons they try to push formula on moms who are breast feeding. Money talks.

How sad is that!!



The formula companies also give lots of "free" educational material to the doctors. I shudder each time I open the stats book my ped gave to keep track of height/weight -- it's full of formula advertising.



Why would formula advertising make you shudder? I formula feed but breastfeeding ads are everywhere and that certainly doesn't make me "shudder".

The fact is that many moms leave the hospital breastfeeding but the percentage that actually continue drops dramatically after 2 weeks..more moms formula feed than breast feed and there needs to be samples, ads, options etc...

If it were so bad for a baby, moms would not offer it...at least not smart educated and caring moms such as myself...



My concern is that it shows that my doctor is accepting free "gifts" from formula companies (sort of like the drug reps who parade around doctors' offices with freebies). I don't like formula advertising in doctors offices. If a mom wants more info on formula and wants to talk about it with her doctor that's her business, but I don't think it should be advertised at a doctors office.

ETA: It also concerns me that this is a growh/weight book pushing formula -- considering the OP's issue.

Message edited 2007-09-20 18:22:22.913000.

Posted 9/20/07 6:02 PM
 

Dragonfly75
I love Hypnobabies

Member since 3/06

2333 total posts

Name:

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

Posted by Janice

Posted by maybebaby



Why would formula advertising make you shudder? I formula feed but breastfeeding ads are everywhere and that certainly doesn't make me "shudder".

The fact is that many moms leave the hospital breastfeeding but the percentage that actually continue drops dramatically after 2 weeks..more moms formula feed than breast feed and there needs to be samples, ads, options etc...

If it were so bad for a baby, moms would not offer it...at least not smart educated and caring moms such as myself...



I always think of it as putting up beer ads at AA meetings...they send you home with the formula samples...in the middle of the night the samples are screaming out your name. That's why I don't like to see formula ads at the dr's office. I work very hard to BF. I would think the drs office is the one place that would understand that and not throw formula at me.



ITA -- this pretty much sums up my feelings on it. I'm asking myself, "when every major medical association currently endorses breastfeeding, why is my doctor advertising formula?" The answer is because formula companies have multi-million dollar ad budgets and they're in hospitals and doctors offices with all kinds of "free" give-aways that push their product. As a formula feeding mom you should be upset by this also, since all this advertising drives up the price of the formula you are buying.

Posted 9/20/07 6:19 PM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

Posted by Dragonfly75

Posted by maybebaby

Posted by Dragonfly75

Posted by elyssa222

I hate to say this but many peds receive kickbacks from formula comapnies and that is one of the main reasons they try to push formula on moms who are breast feeding. Money talks.

How sad is that!!



The formula companies also give lots of "free" educational material to the doctors. I shudder each time I open the stats book my ped gave to keep track of height/weight -- it's full of formula advertising.



Why would formula advertising make you shudder? I formula feed but breastfeeding ads are everywhere and that certainly doesn't make me "shudder".

The fact is that many moms leave the hospital breastfeeding but the percentage that actually continue drops dramatically after 2 weeks..more moms formula feed than breast feed and there needs to be samples, ads, options etc...

If it were so bad for a baby, moms would not offer it...at least not smart educated and caring moms such as myself...



My concern is that it shows that my doctor is accepting free "gifts" from formula companies (sort of like the drug reps who parade around doctors' offices with freebies). I don't like formula advertising in doctors offices. If a mom wants more info on formula and wants to talk about it with her doctor that's her business, but I don't think it should be advertised at a doctors office.




I'm sorry, but I completely disagree with this.

Not every mom wants to breastfeed..some of us have zero desire and love the concept of formula...why shouldn't we be allowed to view an ad that promotes one formula over another??

If a woman has made the choice to breastfeed thats great for her. I don't that anyone should find the literature and ads on formula distracting or insulting or whatever you want to call it.
If she's going to do it, an ad will not deter her!

And why NOT a doctors office? We, as moms, go to the pediatrician with our babies many of whom are formula fed. There can be ads up and pamphlets everywhere you turn promoting breastfeeding and no one blinks, but formula ads are frowned upon?

And the other comparison someone made to an alcoholic being lured with beer ads irks me. Very very different concepts if you ask me. Comparing an alcoholics draw to alcohol to an infants need for nourishment is just slightly different, no?

Sorry, i just get very heated with this kind of talk. If it weren't for formula, there would be a lot of hungry babies...not every mom can breastfeed and we must remember that!!

Posted 9/20/07 6:23 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

Posted by maybebaby

And the other comparison someone made to an alcoholic being lured with beer ads irks me. Very very different concepts if you ask me. Comparing an alcoholics draw to alcohol to an infants need for nourishment is just slightly different, no?



you read to much into it. Why does formula even need to be advertised? Mothers are obviously going to use it. Aren't they pretty much all the same anyway?

Why are they sending BFing moms home with samples? Is it to hope that one long night when they can't do it anymore, they cave and crack open the container?

I know you are a proud formual feeder. No one judges you, you are a good mom with a great baby.

At a drs office, I would expect it to be neutral ground, and if they were to lean to a side, it should be the side of the bf'ers...its the best, the drs say so-they should stand behind it.


Posted 9/20/07 6:42 PM
 

sometimesmommy
Always in my heart.....

Member since 11/06

6686 total posts

Name:

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

There is no problem with getting free samples or literature but it is a problem if doctors try to push formula over BF to moms who clearly can BF and vice versa.

One viewpoint I have to share is that "yes" the literature and ads can be distracting-not insulting(at least for me). I thought formula was a good substitute based on the literature I've read so when my milk wasnt in fully for my preemie DD in the hospital I was all for it. Based upon info I received from the neonatologist-I opted to pump even if it was inconvenient. Formula IS GREAT but as a preemie mom we have to deal with the possibility our babies can develop NEC-an infection where the intestine dies-seen in young preemie babies because their breakdown of lactose is incomplte and promotes bacteria. There seems to be a higher rate of NEC cases in formula fed babies since the formula is harder to break down than BM and that wasnt in any of the literature I read pushing formula. I never heard of NEC until I was a preemie mom.

Message edited 2007-09-20 19:09:41.400000.

Posted 9/20/07 7:03 PM
 

Dragonfly75
I love Hypnobabies

Member since 3/06

2333 total posts

Name:

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

Posted by maybebaby

And why NOT a doctors office? We, as moms, go to the pediatrician with our babies many of whom are formula fed. There can be ads up and pamphlets everywhere you turn promoting breastfeeding and no one blinks, but formula ads are frowned upon?




I'm glad formula works so well for you. The fact is that every major medical association recommends breastfeeding, so a breastfeeding poster would be in-line with current medical recommendations (although I've never seen a breastfeeding poster or any other breastfeeding literature at my ped's office). I feel like doctor's offices should be ad-free zones. Doctors shouldn't be accepting "free" stuff from formula companies, period. It blurs the line between medicine and consumerism and compromises their professionalism.

Posted 9/20/07 7:08 PM
 

vegalady
Love my family

Member since 6/06

4546 total posts

Name:
SNV

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

You dont have to supplement at all if you dont want to. I supplemented b/c i was worried that DS was not getting enough but i only supllemented for like 1 week and 1/2 until my supply stash that the hospital gave me ran out. BM contains all the nutrients and the vitamins that a child needs to thrive. Its the best thing you can give to your baby. Its your call not the doctors you are his mother and the only one who knows what the baby truly needs. MY ped never pushed formula on me in fact he is an advocate for BM only.

Posted 9/20/07 7:13 PM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

My DS was born 9 lbs 7 oz and he was EBF for 1 year. He was always in the 95% or above and has always thrived on just BM alone. He never had a drop of formula, ever!



Same here! Except my son was very small, 6lbs 5oz when born, which proves the point even better! He was always in the 90% and was EBF till being weaned off to whole milk at the age of 13 months.

I think this is absolutely ridiculous that some pediatrician do that! I am sure as PP noted they get some kicks from formula companies!

It is the worst advise to give to a BF mom, to make her think that her BM alone is not enough! I especially love it when a mother complains that she feel she might not be producing enough milk and instead of telling her to put the baby on the breast more often or give advice on some good flow increasing remedies a doctor says "oh, why don;t you supplement with formula"! How can they be saying that when by giving the baby formula a mother inadvertently lowering her supply!!! Idiots!!! Chat Icon

You milk is all he needs to thrive, good for you for standing up do that doctor!!!

Posted 9/20/07 8:02 PM
 

thiadora
Happy Little Girl

Member since 5/05

3830 total posts

Name:
Thia (Cynthia)

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

Posted by WhatNow

My DS was born 9 lbs 7 oz and he was EBF for 1 year. He was always in the 95% or above and has always thrived on just BM alone. He never had a drop of formula, ever!



Same here! Except my son was very small, 6lbs 5oz when born, which proves the point even better! He was always in the 90% and was EBF till being weaned off to whole milk at the age of 13 months.

I think this is absolutely ridiculous that some pediatrician do that! I am sure as PP noted they get some kicks from formula companies!

It is the worst advise to give to a BF mom, to make her think that her BM alone is not enough! I especially love it when a mother complains that she feel she might not be producing enough milk and instead of telling her to put the baby on the breast more often or give advice on some good flow increasing remedies a doctor says "oh, why don;t you supplement with formula"! How can they be saying that when by giving the baby formula a mother inadvertently lowering her supply!!! Idiots!!! Chat Icon

You milk is all he needs to thrive, good for you for standing up do that doctor!!!



ITA

My DS was 7 lbs 1 oz at birth. At his well visit at 16wks, he was 18 lb 4 oz- off the charts. And this is all from BM. (No solids yet.)

Posted 9/20/07 9:09 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

Posted by Janice

Posted by maybebaby



Why would formula advertising make you shudder? I formula feed but breastfeeding ads are everywhere and that certainly doesn't make me "shudder".

The fact is that many moms leave the hospital breastfeeding but the percentage that actually continue drops dramatically after 2 weeks..more moms formula feed than breast feed and there needs to be samples, ads, options etc...

If it were so bad for a baby, moms would not offer it...at least not smart educated and caring moms such as myself...



I always think of it as putting up beer ads at AA meetings...they send you home with the formula samples...in the middle of the night the samples are screaming out your name. That's why I don't like to see formula ads at the dr's office. I work very hard to BF. I would think the drs office is the one place that would understand that and not throw formula at me.



Honestly, this is the age old debate. Formula fed mothers feel that breast feeding is thrown in their faces and vice versa.

And no offense, but my milk never came in, not one drop. I HAD to use formula and my choice of formula was ONLY recommended to me by ped b/c DS was gassy. I never had a doctor, nurse, anyone who pushed any brand of formula.

Maybe I am clueless, but I have never seen ads for formula in my ped's office. When they gave me samples of gentlease they took it out from a hidden little compartment.

But what really succks is that everyone drills "breast is best" into your head, so that if your milk doesn't come in, you are not doing the right thing by your child, but what other option was there for me and mommies like me?

Posted 9/20/07 10:06 PM
 

MrsBlueSash
Love my sailor

Member since 6/05

5793 total posts

Name:
Christian

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

I refused to supplement with formula and just BF. I increased DD feeding frequency and made sure I was getting plenty of healthy food. DD is now in the 85% of weight at 2.5 mos. If you only want your DS to have BM than just give BM.

Message edited 2007-09-20 22:10:10.690000.

Posted 9/20/07 10:09 PM
 

Dragonfly75
I love Hypnobabies

Member since 3/06

2333 total posts

Name:

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

Posted by KateDevine


But what really succks is that everyone drills "breast is best" into your head, so that if your milk doesn't come in, you are not doing the right thing by your child, but what other option was there for me and mommies like me?



I can't comment on your situation since I don't know you, but if you really wanted to breastfeed, tried hard, worked with an LC, etc. and it still didn't work I can understand that it would be very hard for you.

Very few women are actually physically incapable of breastfeeding (although you might be one of them) -- most problems come from bad breastfeeding advice --early supplementation with formula is a major culprit -- the breast is not stimulated, milk is not produced, mom can't produce enough to feed her baby, etc. This is why it's upsetting to see a ped suggesting supplementing to a mother who is successfully breastfeeding -- it could sabotage her efforts.

For the record, I don't think there is anything wrong with choosing formula -- everyone has to do what is right for them, but if a mother wants to breastfeed I feel like she should have the proper advice and support to help her succeed and I hate it when doctors give out bad breastfeeding advice -- unfortunately it happens a lot.

Posted 9/21/07 7:33 AM
 

clydrak
LIF Infant

Member since 2/06

141 total posts

Name:

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

Bottom line to the OP is that if she really wants to BF and is struggling or concerned about her baby's weight gain, she needs to think about her choice of ped and possibly switch to another, preferably one that has a Lactation Consultant on staff and will be a supportive resource for the entire first year of her baby's life.

To all the new moms or soon to be moms reading this thread: the ped will recommend what they think is the best option for your child, if you disagree with their medical advice or their support or lack thereof of BFing, please get a second opinion from another medical professional. Other moms mean very well and can offer FANTASTIC support by sharing THEIR experiences, but everyone is different, you need to weigh your own situation and I think a newborn's weight gain is something that should be monitored by a professional. Sure there are a lot of moms on here who EBF and their babies eventually started gaining normally, but you never know why your baby isn't gaining weight, if you don't feel supported in your choice to breastfeed, look into a consult with another physician and a lactation consultant, but don't ignore the problem, there could be another reason why your baby isn't gaining weight.

Message edited 2007-09-21 11:35:42.820000.

Posted 9/21/07 11:18 AM
 

michele31
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3372 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

just get a new ped. it is really that simple.
if your ped is not support of your BFing then find one who is.
Don't even sweat it. Doctors are human..not God. They can be wrong or misguided in their advise. You need one that you are in synch with.

And for those that wanted to BF but had issues did your ped rec'd a LC to you? Did they support your efforts to correct your BFing issues? Many do not. That is a major problem IMO. Ped offices need LCs on staff! BFing is not easy. I paid over $1K to my LC to help me and you now what...even though I had to pump full-time and I used formula for the first 4 weeks not one penny of it was wasted IMO. But insurance companies will not cover LC charges very often yet they will cover "special" formula for non-hospitalized babies..what is that? The insurance company literally said to me "If Bfing is not working you can use formula. " That was B/S to me!

Message edited 2007-09-21 12:17:04.520000.

Posted 9/21/07 12:13 PM
 

an9elic
♥ HJ ♥

Member since 6/07

3331 total posts

Name:
kristen

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

Posted by Dragonfly75

Posted by Janice

Posted by maybebaby



Why would formula advertising make you shudder? I formula feed but breastfeeding ads are everywhere and that certainly doesn't make me "shudder".

The fact is that many moms leave the hospital breastfeeding but the percentage that actually continue drops dramatically after 2 weeks..more moms formula feed than breast feed and there needs to be samples, ads, options etc...

If it were so bad for a baby, moms would not offer it...at least not smart educated and caring moms such as myself...



I always think of it as putting up beer ads at AA meetings...they send you home with the formula samples...in the middle of the night the samples are screaming out your name. That's why I don't like to see formula ads at the dr's office. I work very hard to BF. I would think the drs office is the one place that would understand that and not throw formula at me.



ITA -- this pretty much sums up my feelings on it. I'm asking myself, "when every major medical association currently endorses breastfeeding, why is my doctor advertising formula?" The answer is because formula companies have multi-million dollar ad budgets and they're in hospitals and doctors offices with all kinds of "free" give-aways that push their product. As a formula feeding mom you should be upset by this also, since all this advertising drives up the price of the formula you are buying.



i happen to work in a pediatricians office and i just wanted to point out that the "freebies" doctors' offices get from formula companies are nothing more than those growth books someone mentioned, maybe some pens, little pads of paper and occasionally some formula to have on hand for parents who WANT to use it. in my personal experience where i work the doctors never push the formula on parents, nor do they hand out those growth books to shove ads in parents' faces.. they use them cuz theyre there.. theyre free.. and they come in handy. i havent been to a huge amount of pediatric offices, but i can say the office i work in does not advertise for the formula companies in exchange for "freebies" or money. okay just had to get that off my chest... Chat Icon

Posted 9/21/07 2:06 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

I BF. EBF at the beginning and now both BF and pump.

I have NO issue with formula companies sending me litterature. I did not know how the BF would work for me so we signed up with all of them.

Their literature is actually very instructive. It's not just about formula. It discusses child development, milestones, etc...I even got some that read i the beginning that they encourage BF but that in case you EVER need formula...here are some coupons. I have given the coupons away for someone who might need them.

I don't care about any ads. I am not offended. I know how I feel about feeding my child.

I DO have an issue with someone who keep "pressuring" you in doing something you don't want to do.

Message edited 2007-09-21 14:39:04.513000.

Posted 9/21/07 2:38 PM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: Peds pushing formula on EBFers

Change your ped. I did when it was suggested to me. i was much happierChat Icon

Posted 9/21/07 2:40 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2]