Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

alisonggg
Cutie

Member since 3/06

4749 total posts

Name:
a

Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

I'm at such a loss... DD has always teethed very early. She is just over a year and on tooth 15 and 16. The first 8 were not a problem, but the 4 eye teeth and the 1 year molars have been awful. She goes in 3 weeks spurts where she will wake up about 3 times a week, screaming. Once the teeth are through she is back to her normal (great) sleeping patterns. I've tried on and off rocking but the only thing that will get her to sleep when she is like this is tylenol. I was getting concerned that I was giving too much tylenol ( about 3 nights a week, once a night never during the day, for about 3 weeks) so I called the ped to see if it was a problem.

She told me tylenol does not make help pain and that I shouldn't be giving it. I said it definitely helped her but if she didn't think I should be giving it would she prefer motrin. She said no to that too. I said what should I be doing then and she said let her cry herself to sleep. There is NO WAY I am going to let her do that. I've tried the teething tablets and they don't work for her. Now I see my only option as either letting her sleep in my arms 3 nights a week, or putting her in bed with us which I REALLY don't want to do. I'm at a loss.

Has anyone ever had a ped tell them not to use tylenol for teething? I normally love my practice but am SO upset with them for suggesting to let a teething baby cry herself to sleep for 2 hours. I can almost understand if she told me I was using it too frequently (I mean thats what I called to check about) but it was honestly helping her and I have no idea why she would say it did nothing.

I'm so upset!

Posted 8/10/10 12:47 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

It's a pain reliever....teething is painfull...therefore it relieves the pain...not sure what your doc is talking about!!

Posted 8/10/10 12:48 PM
 

alisonggg
Cutie

Member since 3/06

4749 total posts

Name:
a

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

Posted by Linda1003

It's a pain reliever....teething is painfull...therefore it relieves the pain...not sure what your doc is talking about!!



she told me "it's a fever reducer and it does nothing for pain".... I was not under that assumption so thats why I was Chat Icon as well.... I'm so confused!

Posted 8/10/10 12:50 PM
 

megsm3
Life is Good!!

Member since 8/06

3867 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

Posted by Linda1003

It's a pain reliever....teething is painfull...therefore it relieves the pain...not sure what your doc is talking about!!



ITA! I have given the girls tylenol and motrin for teething. I would be Chat Icon at your doctor for at advice.

Posted 8/10/10 12:50 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

Yeah so if it doesn't relieve pain, what the heck does it do?
That sounds like an odd statment.

Posted 8/10/10 12:50 PM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

I prefer motrin my SIL is a pharmacist and give motrin each time her kids are teething.

Posted 8/10/10 12:51 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

It is believed that the pain associated with teething is the inflammation of the gums so acetaminophen wouldn't necessarily help with that since it does nothing for the inflammation. Ibuprofen reduces inflammation and may help more with teething.

Message edited 2010-08-10 12:56:24.023000.

Posted 8/10/10 12:55 PM
 

alisonggg
Cutie

Member since 3/06

4749 total posts

Name:
a

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

Posted by shamrock124

It is believed that the pain associated with teething in the inflammation of the gums so acetaminophen wouldn't necessarily help with that since it does nothing for the inflammation. Ibuprofen reduces inflammation and may help more with teething.



thanks for the explanation Chat Icon I guess thats what she meant, its just hard for me to follow her advice when the tylenol had been working for us so well, my only concern was the frequency. I really don't want to go against my peds advice, but I'm not comfortable letting a teething baby cry.

Posted 8/10/10 12:57 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

I found Motrin works better - I agree with the inflammation idea. Motrin and frozen washclothes for them to chew on. This is the point where you break out the silver rattles (the cold is soothing)

Also with teething comes secondary symptoms - coughs, ear infections, etc. so I think it does help but I haven't studied medicine. Just studied my children.

Posted 8/10/10 12:58 PM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

That is ridiculous. My ped DOES say that tylenol is not as effective for teething. After 6 months though he DOES recommend motrin if they seem to be in a lot of pain. I couldn't imagine not doing anything if your DC is in a lot of pain. Having said that - you want to make sure you aren't always giving it though. I think DD has gotten 2 maybe 3 times total b.c she was just in a lot of pain and nothing else seemed to comfort her.

Posted 8/10/10 1:05 PM
 

Angel321
...

Member since 4/08

15553 total posts

Name:

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

i can tell you i don't know why - but i kinda agree with your doc.

tylenol has never done ANYTHING for em's teething...motrin is the key.

we've been out of it lately because it's so hard to find (generic's) since the huge recall.....and the other night we ONLY had tylenol and we gave it to her. Well - it didn't help.....she was miserable....i felt so badly i went to 6 stores yesterday on my lunch until I found one with generic Motrin.

Message edited 2010-08-10 13:07:04.500000.

Posted 8/10/10 1:06 PM
 

alisonggg
Cutie

Member since 3/06

4749 total posts

Name:
a

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

Posted by Lillykat
Having said that - you want to make sure you aren't always giving it though. I think DD has gotten 2 maybe 3 times total b.c she was just in a lot of pain and nothing else seemed to comfort her.



For DD it (tylenol) has always worked, but this was my main concern. I completely would have understood if doc told me I was giving it to much and I had to give less, thats why I was calling! But to say not to give either pain med in any instance (which is exactly what she said!) seems so off to me.

Posted 8/10/10 1:11 PM
 

BethanyLynn
Love these munchkins

Member since 10/09

6295 total posts

Name:
Bethany

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

Ive been going thru BAD teething this past week. Tylenol most definitely helps. Cant find motrin anywhere or I'd try that.

Posted 8/10/10 1:12 PM
 

Casperthefriendlyghost
LIF Zygote

Member since 8/10

8 total posts

Name:
S

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

I always found motrin to work better Chat Icon

Posted 8/10/10 1:32 PM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

I've always given DS Motrin and it sure seems to make a difference. I think sometimes we need to take what the docs say with a grain of salt. Chat Icon

Also, does your DD have a lovey? We have this thing we give DS and it seems to comfort and distract him while we are waiting for the Motrin to kick in.

Posted 8/10/10 1:34 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

when was the last time your ped teethed? Chat Icon

it seems to work in MY house.

Posted 8/10/10 1:35 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

Posted by Ophelia

when was the last time your ped teethed? Chat Icon

it seems to work in MY house.



LOL amen to that

I used tylenol and motrin

For my child motrin worked better but tylenol was tastier for her so we used that.

Whatever works. I know I went a week or so giving her the combo for awhile and my ped was totally for it.

Posted 8/10/10 1:40 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

DH is a physician, not a ped, but I made him dig through medical journals for this. He is in agreement that Motrin is better for swelling and the kind of pain caused by teething.

He thinks Tylenol will work as well, but probably Motrin will be better aimed at the problem at hand.

We use Motrin because a smaller dose of it works better longer for us.

Recent research (past 10 years or so) has shown motrin to be as safe as tylenol for babies 2m and up.
Google Dr. Search Ibuprofen Dosage for more info.

Posted 8/10/10 1:58 PM
 

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

One of the peds at the group I go to believes that teething does NOT cause painChat Icon

I have used the hylands for my two and it seems to help - mind you both of mine were BF and they just nursed ALL night every time a tooth was coming in.

Posted 8/10/10 2:06 PM
 

trnity44
I hope you stay beautiful baby

Member since 5/05

8356 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

I definitely agree that Motrin works better than tylenol- based on personal experience!

Posted 8/10/10 2:07 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

motrin and tylenol work differently but tylenol IS a pain reliever.

motrin has the added benefit of being an anti inflammatory which is great for swollen gums.

both have worked at taming the savage beast.

Posted 8/10/10 2:09 PM
 

MaMaTeenie
Party of 5

Member since 4/08

6489 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

IMO itprobablyjust takes the edge off the pain or makes them sleepy enough tonot wake. My cousinis a pharmacist and just told me its better to rub motrinon the gums b/c it reduces swelling and helps with the throbbing.

Posted 8/10/10 2:14 PM
 

Charly
LOVE!

Member since 5/05

12578 total posts

Name:

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

my ped INSISTS teething does NOT hurt and doesn't recommend tylenol or motrin. He would tell me if they are "fussing" it was something else. So everytime they were cranky and I assumed it was teething I'd take them to the ped. And sure enough it was something else (ears, throat, etc.)

SO while I really don't believe his statement is entirely true, he seemed to be right.

But more on your topic, I never found that tylenol helped. I only gave motrin and only at night if they were having trouble sleeping. I never bothered with it during the day. I just gave them frozen washclothes, frozen teething toys, etc. Maybe I'm just lucky and they weren't really bothered by teething.

Posted 8/10/10 2:19 PM
 

anewday
<3

Member since 9/08

1493 total posts

Name:
Dawn

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

Chat Icon my ped told me to give dd tylenol for teething
when I asked if I was giving her too much....same as you 3 nights in a row but nothing during the day....maybe 1 dose during 1 daybut only one of the three days) he said it was fine as long as I didn't exceed the rec dose in 24 hours (I think its 4)

Posted 8/10/10 2:19 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Ped just told me tylenol does not help teething, is this true??

I think that ibruprofen works better, but tylenol is a pain reliver.Chat Icon

Posted 8/10/10 2:26 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I really need to be told that this (teething) gets better maybebaby 5/17/07 7 Parenting
PED told me he CANNOT split the MMR smdl 11/6/08 20 Parenting
Teething Tablets & Tylenol MrsSchwags 2/10/08 5 Parenting
spinoff of my teething post - how much tylenol? alexlynn7 1/22/08 13 Parenting
Spin off to Motrin/Tylenol and teething... chelle 11/29/07 6 Parenting
Who's using Tylenol for teething? btrflygrl 10/6/07 7 Parenting