Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

Posted By Message

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

So Chanukah has been cancelled in my house this year after two nights of Noah throwing a tantrum after opening his presents and not getting what he wants.

He only wanted Chuggington trains every night and he got a Thomas Take along boat one night, and a Thomas train another night. When he opened them he went crazy saying why did I get these, I don't want them, I don't like Thomas toys (keep in mind that his whole bedroom is one big huge Thomas track that he plays with every.single.day. Every.Single.Day) So now I have cancelled gifts for the rest of the holiday because I feel like its rewarding bad behaviour. I did get him quite a few Chuggington Toys, and also, I got him a lot of accessories for his Thomas Trackmaster Trains, and his Take Along Thomas stuff.

And we also have Christmas coming up, and his Birthday...and guess what I have bought him. Thomas stuff...

We have taken away his Chuggington toys for the moment and we are trying to teach him a lesson, but I feel like we have created this monster, because he is usually such a lovely, even tempered boy. He hasn't thrown a tantrum in probably two years....its such odd behaviour, I don't quite know what to do.

Should I:
a. Take all the Thomas stuff back to the shop and buy other stuff
b. take all the Thomas stuff back to the shop and buy all Chuggington stuff
c. Cancel all the holidays this year
d. Continue to give him gifts like nothing has happened...

We gave him the whole lecture about how if he didn't like the gift he should say Thank you, and we could have returned them to the store and we are upset because of the tantrum etc...I am really sad that now, I don't want to give him any gifts.

I just don't know what to do! HELP!! Any advice is really welcome!

Message edited 2010-12-05 05:03:47.250000.

Posted 12/5/10 5:01 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Calla
My girls

Member since 7/05

4303 total posts

Name:

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

This is not uncommon behavior for a five year old. We've had tantrums too this year, and I spoke to a friend who is dealing with the same. Hopefully that makes you worry less about your child's sense of values.

I think that it isn't so much that they are spoiled, but simply that they feel powerless and misunderstood. They lack the perspective needed to be grateful.

I think that this is a teaching moment. I don't think taking everything away for a long time is necessary.

Posted 12/5/10 5:48 AM
 

Diana712
RIP my beloved Brother Richard

Member since 5/07

6710 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

This is a really hard one.. I think you have the right idea..My only question is ....... Is there another child in the house? How is he reacting to no Chanukah..

How many days are left ? Sorry I think 6 right ?

Message edited 2010-12-05 07:00:02.773000.

Posted 12/5/10 6:58 AM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

That is hard.
Really, I have a feeling I would ignore him.
Go on with your celebrating and put a box out. Whatever he isn't happy with, have him put it in the box. Deliver the box to a hospital.
I would not get him new gifts. I would stick with what I have already...if he isn't happy wtih it, then I would tell him put it in the box and have nothing.

good luck!!

Posted 12/5/10 7:06 AM
 

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

I would tell him it's cancelled. And if he doesn't act like a good boy, Santa will get a call and cancelled Xmas too. I know he is only 5, but I don't think it's too young, to know what he did is wrong. So, enforcing no more gifts for Chanukah may just be the way to get your point across. And, if he is good give him the stuff for his bday and Xmas.

Posted 12/5/10 7:06 AM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

I would take the Thomas gifts back and not replace them with new toys because of his behavior.

I would however continue to celebrate your holiday because I think that's important... The religious meaning behind it, not so much the gift part.

Whatever toys he complains about or throws a fit about return to the store, and don't replace them. Now he gets, 2, 3, 4, less gifts, because it's ok not to like a gift, but it's not ok to be ungrateful. I would explain that had he been polite and said thank you his toys would have been replaced.

Posted 12/5/10 7:08 AM
 

Ang-Rich
Beyond Compare

Member since 5/05

17988 total posts

Name:

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

I would WANT to go and return everything and get him the toys he wanted but that would accomplish nothing. Rather...it would just add fuel to the fire that's cooking a monster and so I think that when the time comes and I am in this situation I will try to do the following:

- Tell him exactly what you told him

We gave him the whole lecture about how if he didn't like the gift he should say Thank you, and we could have returned them to the store and we are upset because of the tantrum



- Tell him that tonight we are opening presents...if his behavior is anything but appreciative we will not open any more presents and what he has opened will be returned. (Even if you just hide them for now).

- Remind him that if he doesn't like a gift that he needs to say thank you because you put a lot into getting him the gift - the shopping the wrapping and you are excited to give it to him. Be honest with your feelings...tell him that it makes you sad and hurts your heart that he throws a tantrum and that you understand that he might not like a gift but there is a right way and a wrong way to resolve those feelings. Have him really take a look at the toy and decide if it should be returned. If it gets returned that does not mean he gets another toy..it just means that he doesn't have to have that one. Chat Icon (Although I am a huge SUCKER and would probably get another).


Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/5/10 7:16 AM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

Great advice everyone! Thanks! Keep it coming, I am going to have my husband read this thread also!

Posted 12/5/10 7:21 AM
 

labonnevie
sometimes 1+1= 4 <3

Member since 8/09

3869 total posts

Name:
the lucky one

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

Posted by KerriSteve

I would however continue to celebrate your holiday because I think that's important... The religious meaning behind it, not so much the gift part.




i would do the same. and because i think you have another child, it's kind of putting a damper on their holiday as well, which isn't fair to that child. so i would probably do what janice said

Posted by Janice

Really, I have a feeling I would ignore him.
Go on with your celebrating and put a box out. Whatever he isn't happy with, have him put it in the box. Deliver the box to a hospital.
I would not get him new gifts. I would stick with what I have already...if he isn't happy wtih it, then I would tell him put it in the box and have nothing.

Posted 12/5/10 8:03 AM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

I wouldn't change one thing with your plans..no returning of anything, no swapping presents so he is happy.

His behavior can be very normal for this age, but obviously you want him to appreciate everything he gets. I know I'll cross a similar bridge w/my son cause he tells it like it is, lol. I know I would tell him over and over that he is very lucky to be getting these wonderful gifts. I LOVE janices idea of donating anything unwanted...

Stick to your guns. It's the only way the behavior will change. It'll happen! Good luck!

Posted 12/5/10 8:10 AM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

Posted by labonnevie

Posted by KerriSteve

I would however continue to celebrate your holiday because I think that's important... The religious meaning behind it, not so much the gift part.




i would do the same. and because i think you have another child, it's kind of putting a damper on their holiday as well, which isn't fair to that child. so i would probably do what janice said

Posted by Janice

Really, I have a feeling I would ignore him.
Go on with your celebrating and put a box out. Whatever he isn't happy with, have him put it in the box. Deliver the box to a hospital.
I would not get him new gifts. I would stick with what I have already...if he isn't happy wtih it, then I would tell him put it in the box and have nothing.




Everything they said!

Posted 12/5/10 9:08 AM
 

carlowlou
loving my babies!

Member since 4/08

4594 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

Posted by Janice

That is hard.
Really, I have a feeling I would ignore him.
Go on with your celebrating and put a box out. Whatever he isn't happy with, have him put it in the box. Deliver the box to a hospital.
I would not get him new gifts. I would stick with what I have already...if he isn't happy wtih it, then I would tell him put it in the box and have nothing.

good luck!!



My DD is nowhere near this stage but I did witness this with a young relative of mine and always wondered what the best thing to do is. Well I LOVE the above idea and will be keeping this in mind if the situation ever occurs with DD.

Posted 12/5/10 9:33 AM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

Posted by Ang-Rich

I would WANT to go and return everything and get him the toys he wanted but that would accomplish nothing. Rather...it would just add fuel to the fire that's cooking a monster and so I think that when the time comes and I am in this situation I will try to do the following:

- Tell him exactly what you told him
We gave him the whole lecture about how if he didn't like the gift he should say Thank you, and we could have returned them to the store and we are upset because of the tantrum



- Tell him that tonight we are opening presents...if his behavior is anything but appreciative we will not open any more presents and what he has opened will be returned. (Even if you just hide them for now).

- Remind him that if he doesn't like a gift that he needs to say thank you because you put a lot into getting him the gift - the shopping the wrapping and you are excited to give it to him. Be honest with your feelings...tell him that it makes you sad and hurts your heart that he throws a tantrum and that you understand that he might not like a gift but there is a right way and a wrong way to resolve those feelings. Have him really take a look at the toy and decide if it should be returned. If it gets returned that does not mean he gets another toy..it just means that he doesn't have to have that one. Chat Icon (Although I am a huge SUCKER and would probably get another).


Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



I like this advice, but I'm a huge sucker too. I'm not a BTDT but I have a feeling id do something on this level.

Posted 12/5/10 10:42 AM
 

Momma2Be
Mommy of an angel

Member since 10/09

5911 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

Posted by Janice

That is hard.
Really, I have a feeling I would ignore him.
Go on with your celebrating and put a box out. Whatever he isn't happy with, have him put it in the box. Deliver the box to a hospital.
I would not get him new gifts. I would stick with what I have already...if he isn't happy wtih it, then I would tell him put it in the box and have nothing.

good luck!!



I love this idea!

Posted 12/5/10 11:05 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

Posted by Janice

That is hard.
Really, I have a feeling I would ignore him.
Go on with your celebrating and put a box out. Whatever he isn't happy with, have him put it in the box. Deliver the box to a hospital.
I would not get him new gifts. I would stick with what I have already...if he isn't happy wtih it, then I would tell him put it in the box and have nothing.

good luck!!



This is a fabulous idea. I would make him come with me to give the gifts to a charitable organization - he will be able to see how the volunteers express gratitude for even the smallest of gifts.

I feel like canceling the holiday is catering to his bad behavior in a way, ya know? If he has a fit over a gift, you can treat it how you would treat any other tantrum - time out or removal from the situation or whatever you normally would do. He'll catch on quick.

Message edited 2010-12-05 11:50:55.693000.

Posted 12/5/10 11:49 AM
 

SofiaBella
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/07

785 total posts

Name:
Vanessa

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

Posted by Janice

That is hard.
Really, I have a feeling I would ignore him.
Go on with your celebrating and put a box out. Whatever he isn't happy with, have him put it in the box. Deliver the box to a hospital.
I would not get him new gifts. I would stick with what I have already...if he isn't happy wtih it, then I would tell him put it in the box and have nothing.

good luck!!



ITA!! Great Idea!! Teaches him that other kids would appreciate them.

Posted 12/5/10 12:10 PM
 

twicethefun
Loving life

Member since 7/06

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

I also celebrate both holidays. I do not think that they are just about gift giving so I personally would not "cancel the holiday because that puts too much emphasis on getting gifts. I do not tolerate ungratefulness, and would and did send my son to his room and give away the toy (with no replacement) that he was not grateful for last year. He learned his lesson quickly.

However, I would not continue to give him toys that I know he does not want either. I like to make my son happy. I would return at least some of the toys and get new ones that I know he would like. I would not want my dh to get me things he knows I would not like, I would say thank you if he did but I would be less than thrilled. So I do try to thrill my children for the holidays. However they do NOT get everything they want. Just some of it and they know it.

Posted 12/5/10 10:44 PM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

We have dealt with some of that this year too. DS is upset when he doesn't get a "toy" every night. He has gotten two games, which once we sat down to play he was pleased with and the same thing tonight with an art set. I just reinforcing that he will not always get "toys" and he needs to be appreciative no matter what. I'm also trying to prepare him that he may be getting clothes from some family and to just say thank you and move on. It's tough though.Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

ETA_ I do loe Janice's suggestion about that box. In fact, I have been trying to explain to DS that many children do not have all that he has. I told him that we were going to empty our his piggy bank and take that money and go to the toy store and buy something. Then he has to donate it to Toys For Tots.

Message edited 2010-12-05 22:51:50.257000.

Posted 12/5/10 10:50 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Parenting Crisis...need help with this one.

Posted by Ang-Rich

I would WANT to go and return everything and get him the toys he wanted but that would accomplish nothing. Rather...it would just add fuel to the fire that's cooking a monster and so I think that when the time comes and I am in this situation I will try to do the following:

- Tell him exactly what you told him
We gave him the whole lecture about how if he didn't like the gift he should say Thank you, and we could have returned them to the store and we are upset because of the tantrum



- Tell him that tonight we are opening presents...if his behavior is anything but appreciative we will not open any more presents and what he has opened will be returned. (Even if you just hide them for now).

- Remind him that if he doesn't like a gift that he needs to say thank you because you put a lot into getting him the gift - the shopping the wrapping and you are excited to give it to him. Be honest with your feelings...tell him that it makes you sad and hurts your heart that he throws a tantrum and that you understand that he might not like a gift but there is a right way and a wrong way to resolve those feelings. Have him really take a look at the toy and decide if it should be returned. If it gets returned that does not mean he gets another toy..it just means that he doesn't have to have that one. Chat Icon (Although I am a huge SUCKER and would probably get another).


Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



I agree with this.

The big thing is NOT to cancel Hanukkah for everyone else. I would give him the gift & ask if he thinks he can behave properly when he opens it.

If he doesn't straighten up & you've cancelled the gifts for the night, I'd leave his unopened gift where he can see it the next day. Then you can tell him that when he shows he is happy to get what he gets, then he can open it. Mainly because it would torture him not to open a gift - and after not getting a gift, he's going to want to know what's in the box.

I'm all about the torture option.Chat Icon

Hang in there....Chat Icon and Happy Hanukkah!

Posted 12/5/10 11:25 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Parenting Style MrsBumbleb 8/18/05 7 Parenting
parenting magazines futuremrs 8/18/05 3 Parenting
Toy Bags....(xpost parenting) monkeybride 8/17/05 1 Pregnancy
Diapers? (reposted on Parenting) Melbernai 8/3/05 8 Pregnancy
Repost from Parenting board...maternity/disabiloty 05mommy09 7/25/05 2 Pregnancy
Repost from Parenting: Mom Can't Live With Her and Can't Live Without Her nylisa 7/15/05 1 Families Helping Families ™