Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

Posted By Message

luvnlife
LIF Adult

Member since 7/07

981 total posts

Name:

Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

DS sucks on his fingers all day long. I don't know if it is the beginning of teething (he's 3 1/2 months) or not. It definitely soothes him to suck his thumb though.

Right now we swaddle him to for naps and bedtime and he needs to suck to fall asleep so we give him the pacifier. He sucks until he falls into a deep sleep and usually stays asleep once it falls out, but when he wakes up at night he settles down once the pac is back in his mouth. He's starting to break out of the swaddle though so I think soon we won't need it and I'm not sure what to do once his hands are free.

Should I encourage him to use his thumb to soothe himself to sleep? Then I don't have to worry about him needing the pacifier in the middle of the night. But, I don't want him to be addicted to sucking his thumb when he's older.

Any advice from the BTDT moms?

Posted 7/2/08 3:12 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

You can take a pacifier away, the thumb is permanently attached! At 2 my DD is still a thumb sucker and it has gotten worse over time. It drives me nuts especially being in the dental field and seeing the bites caused by thumb sucking Chat Icon

Posted 7/2/08 3:15 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

NO THUMB!!! Get him to use the pacifier to soothe!

I had both a pacifier sucker and a thumb sucker and I will tell you that with DS (the paci sucker), he stopped using it at 7 months. With DD, she will be 23 months old and she sucks her thumb when she goes to bed. It's annoying and a hard habit to break because her thumb is attached to her body. Whereas you can throw out a paci and just cut it out cold turkey.

With DD we have tried everything, thumb sucker polish, hot sauce (cruel, I know, but we are desparate), aloe, etc. The only thing that is somewhat working now is constantly getting on her to NOT suck the thumb unless it's to go to bed. It's been working for us so far, but I am a freak and keep checking her teeth to make sure they aren't getting crooked or anything.

IHTH!Chat Icon

Posted 7/2/08 3:16 PM
 

longford73
Welcome to the world Baby Boy!

Member since 8/06

3127 total posts

Name:

Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

Posted by BlessedMommy

You can take a pacifier away, the thumb is permanently attached! At 2 my DD is still a thumb sucker and it has gotten worse over time. It drives me nuts especially being in the dental field and seeing the bites caused by thumb sucking Chat Icon



ITA

Posted 7/2/08 3:16 PM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

Ryan never took a paci until 2 wks ago. He started teething at 12wks and sucks his thumb. He's still not a full-time paci taker but he will take it now to soothe himself and my ped said that the American Ped Association, or someone like that, recommends the paci to reduce SIDS risk so she encourages us to use one. We have also had to take away the miracle blanket b/c he started to break out and b/c I felt he need to have access to his hands in case he wanted to suck his thumb.
Anyway, I think my point is I would let him have whichever one works for him. I watch DS on the monitor at night - when he wakes up, he is sticking his fingers in his mouth to soothe himself and he goes back to sleep - it's a good thing!

ETS: I don't "encourage" either really. I don't plan on pulling his fingers out of his mouth if that's what he uses. If he were to have a tantrum and need something, I would offer the paci.

Also, I had one ped in my practice tell me to go with thumb b/c DC can regulate that and you don't have to keep going in to offer it, and one said use the paci. So, you can't win!

Message edited 2008-07-02 15:20:40.207000.

Posted 7/2/08 3:17 PM
 

RM23
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

997 total posts

Name:
Rachel

Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

I am definately not a BTDT mom, but DS is 4 months old now and went through the same thing. He still is actually. He never took to the pacifier at all, but would need me to hold it in his mouth occasionally to help him fall asleep. Defiantely needed to suck something to go to bed. Then he randomly started to go in his crib drowsy and suck his thumb. He did that for a few weeks, and he sucked his thumb to sleep. It was a lot easier than the paci, and I wasnt worried about it being an issue later on. But then he stopped!! Now he sucks his fingers and pulls at his bottom lip which i think is a definate sign of teerthing. My point is i dont think its worth worrying about which is better, because they are going to change and decide what they want anyway.

Posted 7/2/08 3:18 PM
 

Theresa05
Sofialiciciousssssssssssss

Member since 10/06

4891 total posts

Name:

Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

how do you get them to stop early on? Sofia Only sucks when she goes to sleep.. bc she spits the Paci out.. or she pulls it.. Chat Icon

Posted 7/2/08 3:18 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

Posted by Theresa05

how do you get them to stop early on? Sofia Only sucks when she goes to sleep.. bc she spits the Paci out.. or she pulls it.. Chat Icon



is she sucking the thumb or the paci?

Posted 7/2/08 3:24 PM
 

Theresa05
Sofialiciciousssssssssssss

Member since 10/06

4891 total posts

Name:

Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

only her thumb.. I scream NO thumb and she sucks it when she is sleeping and its only in the crib.. not at nighttimes..

Mom says she might be soothing her gums....

She hates paciChat Icon

Posted 7/2/08 3:27 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

Posted by Theresa05

only her thumb.. I scream NO thumb and she sucks it when she is sleeping and its only in the crib.. not at nighttimes..

Mom says she might be soothing her gums....

She hates paciChat Icon



Chat Icon

I know that feeling. That's how mine is. She refuses the paci but loves that thumb at bed/naptime. If I could go back, I would have been more consistent with putting those mitts/socks on her hands so she wouldn't suck.

Posted 7/2/08 3:32 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

It looks like I'm in the minority, but I don't think there is anything wrong with thumb sucking at their age. It's seen as such a negative, and I'm not sure why except as someone said, you can take the paci away when they are older. If they like the paci, fine, but I wouldn't force DC to use it if he/she likes thumb/fingers better.

I researched this a little, and there are no known detrimental effects to thumb sucking. Their bite won't get thrown off or their mouth shape destroyed, all myths.

So, offer the paci but if it's not appreciated, I would leave DC alone and let him soothe with a thumb.

Posted 7/2/08 6:38 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

In all due respect, most of the time the childs bite will be affected and many times it interferes with their speech pattern. Below is just an example of dental issues that arise....

Why Worry About It?

Thumb or finger sucking habits can and do cause tooth misalignment or jaw deformation.The degree of disruption depends on several factors: like how hard the child sucks, how often, and to what age. The problems produced by these habits are:
* Protrusive upper front teeth. This can be a simple tooth position problem, where the upper incisor teeth were simply tipped outward. Occasionally the formation of the upper jaw can be effected, and the upper jaw and teeth will warp out and away from the rest of the face.
* Tipped back lower incisors. Commonly found with thumb sucking: the pressure of the thumb forces the lower incisors backward toward the tongue. This exaggerates the protrusion of the upper incisors - making the face even more distorted.
* Distortion of nasal growth. In a long term or severe situation, the nose will appear to be tipped up. When viewing the child from the front, you can see right up the nose since it is tipped up at a severe angle by the constant pressure of the thumb on the under side of the nose. These distortions of the upper jaw and nasal complex are very difficult to reverse without long term orthodontic intervention.
* Open bite. The upper and lower front teeth do not overlap when the back teeth are together. The shape of the opening between the upper and lower front teeth may match the shape of the child's finger or thumb. This obviously interferes with the child's ability to bite into food, and will cause problems with digestion.
* Cross bite. The formation of the upper jaw is too narrow for the lower jaw. This distortion seems to be due to the flexing of the cheek muscles during sucking. Severe bite problems occur from these prolonged forces and must be treated before completion of growth.

Message edited 2008-07-02 20:27:11.397000.

Posted 7/2/08 7:43 PM
 

HillW9608
Hello Summer!

Member since 5/08

5916 total posts

Name:
Hill

Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

Posted by cjik

It looks like I'm in the minority, but I don't think there is anything wrong with thumb sucking at their age. It's seen as such a negative, and I'm not sure why except as someone said, you can take the paci away when they are older. If they like the paci, fine, but I wouldn't force DC to use it if he/she likes thumb/fingers better.

I researched this a little, and there are no known detrimental effects to thumb sucking. Their bite won't get thrown off or their mouth shape destroyed, all myths.

So, offer the paci but if it's not appreciated, I would leave DC alone and let him soothe with a thumb.



ITA.. and I dont mind one bit that DD sucks her thumb. I actually prefer that over the pacifier because I see a lot of 2 and 3 year olds still with a paci and I think that does more harm than a thumb, IMHO.

DD only does it at night.. or when she's sleepy Chat Icon

Posted 7/2/08 7:46 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

Posted by HillaryW2Be

Posted by cjik

It looks like I'm in the minority, but I don't think there is anything wrong with thumb sucking at their age. It's seen as such a negative, and I'm not sure why except as someone said, you can take the paci away when they are older. If they like the paci, fine, but I wouldn't force DC to use it if he/she likes thumb/fingers better.

I researched this a little, and there are no known detrimental effects to thumb sucking. Their bite won't get thrown off or their mouth shape destroyed, all myths.

So, offer the paci but if it's not appreciated, I would leave DC alone and let him soothe with a thumb.



ITA.. and I dont mind one bit that DD sucks her thumb. I actually prefer that over the pacifier because I see a lot of 2 and 3 year olds still with a paci and I think that does more harm than a thumb, IMHO.

DD only does it at night.. or when she's sleepy Chat Icon



I'm a speech pathologist in an elementary school (pre-K to 5th grade) and I can tell you 100% that thumb-sucking CAN leading to speech disorders as well as dental issues if the child doesn't wean from the thumb at an early age.

I'd say most of the kids I work with who have "s" distortions or tongue thrust issues were/are thumb-suckers.

ETA: pacis should be GONE by age 2-3 or we see the same issues as well. It's just easier to break a paci habit than a thumb habit.

Message edited 2008-07-02 20:40:33.957000.

Posted 7/2/08 8:39 PM
 

clmj2
cant believe hes gone

Member since 3/07

4407 total posts

Name:
Candice

Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

ive actaully wondered the same thing...which would be the lesser of two evils...I sucked my thumb until I was 5...I really dont want to have to go through that with DD and I feel that since she will take a sucky it will be easier to get her off of it when shes older...I cant take her thumb away when shes older.

JMO

Posted 7/2/08 8:42 PM
 

luvnlife
LIF Adult

Member since 7/07

981 total posts

Name:

Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

Looks like we'll try to stick with the pacifier for sleep. Most of the time he's ok when it falls out so maybe it won't be so bad. Its just he's 15 weeks and still getting up at night and sometimes he just needs to be soothed so I was hoping he could start doing it himself. Wishful thinking from the sleep deprived. Chat Icon

Thanks for all the advice!

Posted 7/3/08 9:39 AM
 

NewlyMrs
Laugh-Live-Love LIFE!

Member since 10/06

14432 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please

I was wondering the same thing. My DD is sucking on her hands (infact she did it through most of the baptismChat Icon ) I am starting to wonder if a paci would be better than her fingers.

Posted 7/3/08 9:43 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Moms of thumb-suckers Marcie 7/2/08 4 Parenting