Re: Paci or Thumb? Opinions please
Posted 7/2/2008 8:39:14 PM by Porrruss


Posted by HillaryW2Be


Posted by cjik

It looks like I'm in the minority, but I don't think there is anything wrong with thumb sucking at their age. It's seen as such a negative, and I'm not sure why except as someone said, you can take the paci away when they are older. If they like the paci, fine, but I wouldn't force DC to use it if he/she likes thumb/fingers better.

I researched this a little, and there are no known detrimental effects to thumb sucking. Their bite won't get thrown off or their mouth shape destroyed, all myths.

So, offer the paci but if it's not appreciated, I would leave DC alone and let him soothe with a thumb.



ITA.. and I dont mind one bit that DD sucks her thumb. I actually prefer that over the pacifier because I see a lot of 2 and 3 year olds still with a paci and I think that does more harm than a thumb, IMHO.

DD only does it at night.. or when she's sleepy Chat Icon



I'm a speech pathologist in an elementary school (pre-K to 5th grade) and I can tell you 100% that thumb-sucking CAN leading to speech disorders as well as dental issues if the child doesn't wean from the thumb at an early age.

I'd say most of the kids I work with who have "s" distortions or tongue thrust issues were/are thumb-suckers.

ETA: pacis should be GONE by age 2-3 or we see the same issues as well. It's just easier to break a paci habit than a thumb habit.
Print Post      Close Window