Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 | |
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check If they were told that they could order whatever they would like, then it is not rude. I think the generosity of the host is in question if they consider such an action to be rude. Otherwise have a set menu. |
|
Posted 4/15/14 4:07 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check Posted by BaysideForever BIL always orders the most expensive thing off the menu. He's always goes for the biggest steaks, special salmon dishes etc. Especially when he knows someone else is paying--- he literally just looks for the item that costs the most money and picks that one. My bil does the same thing! It drives me nuts. My MIL actually said something to him so now he only does it on his birthday |
|
Posted 4/15/14 4:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check Posted by Pinkisles Posted by BaysideForever BIL always orders the most expensive thing off the menu. He's always goes for the biggest steaks, special salmon dishes etc. Especially when he knows someone else is paying--- he literally just looks for the item that costs the most money and picks that one. My bil does the same thing! It drives me nuts. My MIL actually said something to him so now he only does it on his birthday My cousin always does the same thing, plus adds on appetizers, deserts and lots of drinks. Nobody in the family want to include her in restaurant meals any more as she's too expensive. She orders things she never would on her own, and she can't afford to take anyone else out for anything. She's very self-centered, selfish and feels entitled to have whatever she wants. Other than that she's charming
|
|
Posted 4/15/14 4:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check Posted by sunnyflies Posted by Pinkisles Posted by BaysideForever BIL always orders the most expensive thing off the menu. He's always goes for the biggest steaks, special salmon dishes etc. Especially when he knows someone else is paying--- he literally just looks for the item that costs the most money and picks that one. My bil does the same thing! It drives me nuts. My MIL actually said something to him so now he only does it on his birthday My cousin always does the same thing, plus adds on appetizers, deserts and lots of drinks. Nobody in the family want to include her in restaurant meals any more as she's too expensive. She orders things she never would on her own, and she can't afford to take anyone else out for anything. She's very self-centered, selfish and feels entitled to have whatever she wants. Other than that she's charming I have a friend who does this. Once we went out to dinner for someone's birthday and everyone ordered basic entrees like chicken, pasta, etc, no apps, and had one drink each. Meanwhile, my DH friend ordered an app, the most expensive entree on the menu (well over 2x the price of everything else), and had 4 drinks. When it came time for dessert most people passed or split with their SO and DH friend ordered a dessert and a pricey scotch. Everyone was pissed because we all split the bill evenly as friend knew we would and picked up the birthday person's share too so it ended up $$$ and a lot of people were tight on funds and purposely ordered conservatively at the time. Apparently DH friend does this all the time for group dinners because he thinks it impresses everyone. Um, if you wanted to impress me pick up the tab for everyone! Having to subsidize your crazy meal (that you barely ate) doesnt impress me. Nobody wants to go out with him anymore for this reason.
|
|
Posted 4/15/14 4:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check Posted by sunnyflies Posted by Pinkisles Posted by BaysideForever BIL always orders the most expensive thing off the menu. He's always goes for the biggest steaks, special salmon dishes etc. Especially when he knows someone else is paying--- he literally just looks for the item that costs the most money and picks that one. My bil does the same thing! It drives me nuts. My MIL actually said something to him so now he only does it on his birthday My cousin always does the same thing, plus adds on appetizers, deserts and lots of drinks. Nobody in the family want to include her in restaurant meals any more as she's too expensive. She orders things she never would on her own, and she can't afford to take anyone else out for anything. She's very self-centered, selfish and feels entitled to have whatever she wants. Other than that she's charming My sisters fb ordered filet mignon at my moms bday dinner. I think my jaw hit the floor. I thought it was rude, but then again I'm biased because I don't like him. |
|
Posted 4/15/14 4:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check Posted by Chatham-Chick If I'm hosting a party, I would hope my guests chose what they wanted off the menu that was presented to them, regardless of price. And when I've been invited to a restaurant, I order what I want to eat there. I don't look for the most expensive item(s), but don't think I would order something just because it was cheaper for my host. I agree. I would order what appealed to me. I honestly wouldn't even think about the price. |
|
Posted 4/15/14 4:55 PM
|
|
|
Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check All depends on the event |
|
Posted 4/15/14 5:02 PM
|
|
|
Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check If no mention of cost is given from the host then I would order what I want. My parents take a big bunch of us out to dinner monthly and pay for it (we offer to pay but they decline). Most of the time we all order what we want, some steak, some chicken, some get apps, etc. There are times though that my father may say, it's a burger night which is code for keep it on the low end and we all get cheaper meals and split apps. |
|
Posted 4/15/14 5:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check Posted by KarenK122 If no mention of cost is given from the host then I would order what I want. My parents take a big bunch of us out to dinner monthly and pay for it (we offer to pay but they decline). Most of the time we all order what we want, some steak, some chicken, some get apps, etc. There are times though that my father may say, it's a burger night which is code for keep it on the low end and we all get cheaper meals and split apps. Awe that sweet and cute. If I do this, host a dinner with no limitations on menu, then I always tell everyone order whatever you want. So no one is uncormfortable or shy to order the steak/pricey meal. Obviously, this is a rare event cause I'm not Rockefeller, but I did something like this for my DS's baptism since we didn't have a huge party. Message edited 2014-04-15 17:11:32.280000. |
|
Posted 4/15/14 5:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check Posted by loveus Posted by MsSissy Posted by loveus Posted by Straightarrow Posted by loveus Yes it is rude. We had a party with a priced fix menu and an open bar. The people who drank I had no problem paying for their drinks because as people say, if you would pay for it yourself I don't see a problem. Most drank beer, wine or a simple vodka. I had a guest that was constantly ordering top-shelf liquor straight and I have never seen them pay for 1 drink yet alone an expensive one. They took advance of us being generous and treating our family and friends. I haven't hosted another party since but when I do, things will be different. No offense, but how can you get mad when you have an open bar? If you wanted to put restrictions on it, then you should have. I would have put restrictions but I didn't realize that I would have been taken advantage of. Out of 30 adults there is always one that makes you regret some of your decisions. I did say going forward things would change and unfortunately this person would still need to be invited. Isn't open bar already paid for in advance with the package? Did the bar charge you more at the end of the party for top shelf liquor? Or were you running a tab at the bar? We ran a tab. I didn't care that someone ordered Grey Goose as opposed to Absolute (I would have done the same). I don't remember the name of the liquor but they were getting double shots of some expensive liquor that was around $15 each. All other drinks were no more than $8 each. I find it rude and that is my opinion. As I said to begin with, I have learned my lesson and this won't happen again. Honestly, all bets are off when certain people start drinking. I'm glad you learned your lesson. When alcohol is involved and you're running a tab, who's to say someone doesn't say "shots for all" KWIM? |
|
Posted 4/15/14 6:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check PS: I know some people may disagree but when I was younger and a lot more broke, I ran a tab for something one night. I told the bartender in advance once people started to get over 2-3 drinks, to give me a heads up. It was nice because there were some +1s I didn't know who showed up who ended up paying for themselves and also friends chipped in and paid for a round since I was celebrating an accomplishment. |
|
Posted 4/15/14 6:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check I think yes it could be rude. It depends on the situation. I was always taught when someone took me out to look for clues as to what to order. Often a good way is to ask if they had been there and what they recommend, and maybe what they are getting. That is a good way to judge. That way if your host is ordering a $25 meal I would want to pick a similar or less priced item. But no I would not order the most expensive item unless the host was ordering it too and pressed me to (I.e, we are having x and it is delicious I highly recommend it and you should try it). But if they are not ordering salads or apps I do not and I pick what I would enjoy in the range either of what they are getting or what they suggested. I am sorry but just because someone takes me out I do not see it as a free for all. So yes I think it could be rude depending on the situation. While I agree the host should pick a place they can afford I would not necessarily expect a guest to order the most expensive full courses, several drinks etc if the host is not ordering in a similar fashion. They are treating you to a meal not a free for all. |
|
Posted 4/15/14 7:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check Posted by Hofstra26 I always try to gauge what everyone else is ordering and then I choose what I am going to have accordingly. If everyone is getting burgers I'm certainly not going to order a $42 steak. I would feel awkward ordering a very expensive dish unless everyone else was as well. This |
|
Posted 4/15/14 8:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check I don't think its rude - but I never do it - unless its business. |
|
Posted 4/15/14 9:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check Yes, It is not right. |
|
Posted 4/15/14 9:33 PM
|
|
|
saraH
Member since 5/05 16555 total posts Name: |
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check It's not, but I would order what I wanted and I'm sure it wouldn't be the most expensive item. |
Posted 4/15/14 10:36 PM
|
|
|
Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check I wouldn't. People would probably talk.... look it everyone gets $10 burgers go for a $20 steak. Not the big surf and turf |
|
Posted 4/15/14 10:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check Posted by Sunny10 If you are going to dinner party at a restaurant that someone else is hosting, say entrees are anywhere from $16 to $42, is it rude for a guest to order the most expensive entrée, $42 entrée? Going by OP alone, no, I would not order the most expensive dish on the menu. I would find something I liked in the mid-range of the menu. I wouldn't see being taken out to dinner as a free-for-all. |
|
Posted 4/15/14 10:39 PM
|
|
|
saraH
Member since 5/05 16555 total posts Name: |
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check Posted by Xelindrya All depends on the event Vendor takes me out, I'm eating whatever I want Host is putting together a party and its on their dime, then I stay middle of the pack. But honestly I've been out with vendors who pick places where the cheapest thing ON the menu is $30 for a salad. What am I going to do? So I order the 'special' whatever the place is known for. Hey might as well, none of us are actually paying for it. Its on a company dime and chances are I won't ever be back. Someone hosting a party for a friend or engagement etc. I go with what I'd order if I was paying or middle of the pack. No apps no drinks (unless I pay for them myself). But I agree that if the host had a limit they'd get a prix fix menu. Honestly I just prefer not to look like a pig :D Now at Disney when I have my deluxe dinning plan? All bets are off.. we pick the HIGHEST price thing and ask if the deluxe picks up the app and dessert if so we get it even if we don't finish it! LOL Hahah. We do the same at Disney. It's already paid for, I'm getting the ribs!!!! |
Posted 4/15/14 10:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check Posted by evrythng4areason I normally wouldn't do it-the only time I have is when it's for business and a company, not an individual is picking up the bill This |
|
Posted 4/16/14 9:15 AM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check Only if I plan to put out that night..... |
Posted 4/16/14 9:19 AM
|
|
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check I would stay within the pack. I certainly wouldn't order something I don't like just to keep costs down, but I'm not that picky so I'm sure I would be able to find something in the middle. |
|
Posted 4/16/14 9:52 AM
|
|
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check No. |
|
Posted 4/16/14 10:15 AM
|
|
|
jendar Member since 12/13 1323 total posts Name: |
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check If the dish i really wanted to eat was the most expensive. Id order it lol |
Posted 4/16/14 1:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Ordering most expensive item on menu when someone else is picking up check First, I would NOT do it. |
|
Posted 4/16/14 1:28 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| X-Post Re: Menu Item for DD's 1st Birthday | Bri | 7/5/10 | 0 | Parenting |
| Geeze, pumpkin picking is expensive! | 4ForMe | 10/14/07 | 4 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Spinoff- what is the most expensive item of clothing/accessories you have | nferrandi | 11/12/13 | 29 | Fashion & Beauty! |
| expensive item on registry.... | jennielee15 | 3/5/13 | 23 | Pregnancy |
| Not a good first week on WW!!(update can you check out my menu) | Linda1003 | 1/7/11 | 11 | Diet & Fitness |
















