OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

Posted By Message

MyImmortal
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/10

525 total posts

Name:
Team Pink? Whoa

OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

Does anyone know of a good OB affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown? My regular dr. is not an OB, and I need to choose a new one. If I choose within the same practice, I'll be delivering at St. Charles in Port Jeff, and considering that I live/work in the Dix Hills/Melville vicinity this makes me a little nervous about getting there in time, especially if it does end up being a holiday weekend. St. Catherine's is closer, and is the hospital that my family has always used in the past, plus it is midway between our two families for visits. The more I'm thinking about it, the more I think I feel more comfortable with this, which means switching practices. TIA.

Posted 11/29/10 9:09 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

Hands down contemporary womens care. I switched bc there is no way I am delivering at st catherines again. The OBS were fantastic!

Posted 11/29/10 9:23 PM
 

twogirlsiluv
LIF Infant

Member since 5/10

62 total posts

Name:
Cynthia

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

I delivered at St Catherine's twice - no problems either time.

I HIGHLY recommend Dr Birnbaum (can I post his name here????) with Women's Healthcare of Suffolk - HE IS AWESOME!!!! I have been with the same OB more than 8 years- the office staff - is also amazing!!!! I can't say enough about him! I recommend him to everyone! If you need any more info - let me know!!!

Posted 11/29/10 9:44 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

Posted by PrincessP

Hands down contemporary womens care. I switched bc there is no way I am delivering at st catherines again. The OBS were fantastic!



I did love the doctors there but the waits were ridiculous.

Posted 11/29/10 10:18 PM
 

Harlow-J
Mason's mommy!

Member since 12/09

3623 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

I went to Dr Jerry Wider in Smithtown up until a year ago....he delivers at St Catherine's. I loved him!
I just live so far from there I had to switch OB's..

He has 2 offices-1 in the ST Catherine medical building (next to the hospital), and the other is in Stony Brook.

Posted 11/29/10 10:18 PM
 

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

Dr Soviero, who now is at Contemp. Women's Care, is affiliated with St. Catherine's.

She has the best bedside manner. Imagine your best friend delivering your child. That's Dr Soviero. She's awesome.

She left my practice, and I'd go to her in a flash, but I like SB.

Posted 11/29/10 10:20 PM
 

azailia
He's TWO already!!!

Member since 9/09

1507 total posts

Name:
Dana

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

I understand if you feel comfortable with St. Catherine's, but isn't Good Sam or Huntington closer???

Posted 11/29/10 10:27 PM
 

KittyGags
LIF Adult

Member since 7/09

5614 total posts

Name:

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

Huntington is most certainly closest to you--why wouldn't you deliver there? I wouldn't pick a hospital for family convenience!

I went here when I lived in HUntington--my old OB has since retired but Dr Horn actually delivered ME! hahah

http://www.suffolkgynecologygroup.com/default2.aspx

Posted 11/29/10 10:51 PM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

Posted by SweetTooth

Posted by PrincessP

Hands down contemporary womens care. I switched bc there is no way I am delivering at st catherines again. The OBS were fantastic!



I did love the doctors there but the waits were ridiculous.



Really? I have only been using them since I became pregnant but have never waited more than 20 minutes at night to get in....

Anyway I am happy with them and I had a great delivery at St Catherine's 3 years ago with DS!

Posted 11/29/10 10:52 PM
 

Shorty
.

Member since 5/05

30390 total posts

Name:
really

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

Posted by SweetTooth

Posted by PrincessP

Hands down contemporary womens care. I switched bc there is no way I am delivering at st catherines again. The OBS were fantastic!



I did love the doctors there but the waits were ridiculous.



waits were beyond ridiculous, and i also found the front desk staff to be incredibly rude. There's 1 great receptionist (young, tall, slim athletic looking woman) and the rest were cranky old women. I loved the sono tech, she was so sweet, and the nurses are fantastic.

I also feel I was mislead by one of the doctors - i walked into my first OB appt requesting SB delivery and was told no problem, they have privileges. It was even noted in my chart. The subject comes up again when I'm 37 weeks along and guess what? SB is off the table. They tell me to go to St Catherines or find a new Dr. They also messed up little things that ended up inconveniencing me, like doing an internal sono before a scheduled pap so the u/s gel ruins the pap results. Chat Icon

I went to SB after my water broke and the Drs on staff that night delivered my son (perfectly, might I add!). I now use University Associates. I was in L&D twice and after my experiences, there's no way would I ever deliver @ St Catherine's by choice.

3 years ago, I swore by Contemporary Women's Care, but now, I wouldn't recommend them at all. I feel the practice grew too rapidly and I always felt rushed. I waited over 2 hours (at 8pm) to be seen at 36 WEEKS PG. This isn't a free clinic, but it seriously felt like it.

Posted 11/29/10 10:58 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

Posted by Kelly9904

Posted by SweetTooth

Posted by PrincessP

Hands down contemporary womens care. I switched bc there is no way I am delivering at st catherines again. The OBS were fantastic!



I did love the doctors there but the waits were ridiculous.



Really? I have only been using them since I became pregnant but have never waited more than 20 minutes at night to get in....

Anyway I am happy with them and I had a great delivery at St Catherine's 3 years ago with DS!



I guess you've been lucky! My first pregnancy there were many times I waited at least an hour. This pregnancy i went there until 12 weeks and had was in the office for almost 3 hours every appointment.

Posted 11/29/10 11:19 PM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

Posted by SweetTooth

I guess you've been lucky! My first pregnancy there were many times I waited at least an hour. This pregnancy i went there until 12 weeks and had was in the office for almost 3 hours every appointment.




Interesting I will have to keep this in mind. I would have been so annoyed being there for 3 hours! But so far I can't complain. The staff has been pretty good.
i
ETA: with the OB I used for my first prenancy I had to wait often at night for over an hour. My DH used to get so annoyed but I just came to expect it. Plus it was a sole practitioner so I kinda understood how easily getting that backed up could happen!

Message edited 2010-11-29 23:43:54.650000.

Posted 11/29/10 11:42 PM
 

Katareen
5,000 Posts!

Member since 4/10

7180 total posts

Name:
Katherine

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

Posted by KittyGags

Huntington is most certainly closest to you--why wouldn't you deliver there? I wouldn't pick a hospital for family convenience!



ITA! You're giving BIRTH--not getting your BP checked! You have to go where you and your DH feel comfortable with the doc and the care...tough sh*t if someone has to drive 15 mins further to visit on the 2-3 days you're in the hospital.

Posted 11/30/10 7:07 AM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

Contemporary Womens Care--specifically Dr Joyce Rubin. She delivered both of my kids and is absolutely wonderful!!

I do have to say that St Catherines maternity ward is old and very outdated. You have to share rooms and there is a communal shower down the hall Chat Icon The staff was wonderful but they need a makeover BADLY!!

Posted 11/30/10 8:22 AM
 

MrsFlatbread
Skinny jeans are in my future

Member since 6/06

10258 total posts

Name:
Baby Momma

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

Dr. Birnbaum in Smithtown

Posted 11/30/10 9:03 AM
 

twogirlsiluv
LIF Infant

Member since 5/10

62 total posts

Name:
Cynthia

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

I also had a bad experience with Contemporary Women's care - almost 8 years ago -

Try Dr Birnbaum!!!! FABULOUS!

Posted 11/30/10 10:54 AM
 

MommyCorinne
LIF Toddler

Member since 10/07

405 total posts

Name:
Corinne

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

I use Dr Halpert at personal womens care in smithtown. He has delivered BOTH my boys (c section) and many many of my friends children. He partner Dr Sommers is very nice as well but I havent delt with him as much...

Side note... a friend of mine used to use Birnbaum when he was partners with my 2 drs and said he was fabulous, although Halpert ended up delivering her :)

Posted 12/1/10 1:47 PM
 

Hope4ABaby
LIF Infant

Member since 8/10

331 total posts

Name:

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

Posted by twogirlsiluv

I delivered at St Catherine's twice - no problems either time.

I HIGHLY recommend Dr Birnbaum (can I post his name here????) with Women's Healthcare of Suffolk - HE IS AWESOME!!!! I have been with the same OB more than 8 years- the office staff - is also amazing!!!! I can't say enough about him! I recommend him to everyone! If you need any more info - let me know!!!



I highly highly agree!!!! :) I have been with him since I was a junior in HS.

Posted 12/1/10 2:09 PM
 

MyImmortal
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/10

525 total posts

Name:
Team Pink? Whoa

Re: OBs affiliated with St. Catherine's in Smithtown

Thanks for all the suggestions, I'll definitely do some research in to them.

As an aside, I feel most comfortable with St. Catherine's, it's the hospital that I grew up being exposed to, and it's in my home town. We've had very bad experiences in our families at Good Sam, and Huntington is an unknown entity, so I feel most comfortable sticking with St. Catherine's.

Posted 12/1/10 5:43 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Ped in Smithtown Area-St. Catherine's Daisy07 3/2/10 7 Parenting
St. Catherine's in Smithtown ASe 1/19/09 16 Pregnancy
Dr. Sosulski or any other OBs in the Smithtown area azoodie 1/4/07 4 Pregnancy