No flu shot, no school
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
|
No flu shot, no school This is absolutely ridiculous ! |
|
Posted 1/8/13 4:24 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: No flu shot, no school This is ridiculous. But, personally, I think it is ridiculous allergy or not. Every child I know that has had the flu this yr - guess what, they had the flu shot. Go figure. Before you force me to inject that crap into my child and risk the consequences of a serious reaction (and I know many children that have had one) you better be sure that it is a vaccine that is definitely going to work. In thgis situation - They should sue. There is no way this is even remotely fair. Message edited 2013-01-08 16:53:47.297000. |
|
Posted 1/8/13 4:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school Posted by itsbabytime This is ridiculous. But, personally, I think it is ridiculous allergy or not. Every child I know that has had the flu this yr - guess what, they had the flu shot. Go figure. Before you force me to inject that crap into my child and risk the consequences of a serious reaction (and I know many children that have had one) you better be sure that it is a vaccine that is definitely going to work. In thgis situation - They should sue. There is no way this is even remotely fair. Just curious - what was the type of serious reaction that the many children you know suffered from? |
|
Posted 1/8/13 4:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school Ridiculous! As a side not this years flu shot does nothing for this years flu as its based on last years strain of flu. |
|
Posted 1/8/13 5:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school Posted by Irishbride Ridiculous! As a side not this years flu shot does nothing for this years flu as its based on last years strain of flu. Can you tell me where you learned that it does nothing for this years flu? I'm really interested in learning more about it. Thanks. |
|
Posted 1/8/13 5:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school Posted by Bearcat Posted by Irishbride Ridiculous! As a side not this years flu shot does nothing for this years flu as its based on last years strain of flu. Can you tell me where you learned that it does nothing for this years flu? I'm really interested in learning more about it. Thanks. A year or two ago I got my first-ever flu shot. Came down with a really bad flu. Never got the shot again and haven't had the flu. Go figure! |
|
Posted 1/8/13 5:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school Posted by itsbabytime This is ridiculous. But, personally, I think it is ridiculous allergy or not. Every child I know that has had the flu this yr - guess what, they had the flu shot. Go figure. Before you force me to inject that crap into my child and risk the consequences of a serious reaction (and I know many children that have had one) you better be sure that it is a vaccine that is definitely going to work. In thgis situation - They should sue. There is no way this is even remotely fair.
|
|
Posted 1/8/13 5:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school Posted by Bearcat Posted by Irishbride Ridiculous! As a side not this years flu shot does nothing for this years flu as its based on last years strain of flu. Can you tell me where you learned that it does nothing for this years flu? I'm really interested in learning more about it. Thanks. Bear, just because nobody else is answering you ha, I learned about the potential ineffectiveness of flu shots from my brother. He is a scientist and did a fellowship working on the development of flu vaccinations and he explained that they take the most common flu strand from the previous year to use in the vaccine, but flu viruses mutate each year so it is possible (and sometimes likely depending on how quickly it mutated) that you are being vaccinated against a less common or even potentially dormant flu strand than the current one. So for people who tend to react badly to vaccines in general (either severe arm soreness or actual illness symptoms) it can be advisable to actually NOT get the shot and just be prudent during flu season. |
|
Posted 1/8/13 7:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school Posted by MandJZ Posted by Bearcat Posted by Irishbride Ridiculous! As a side not this years flu shot does nothing for this years flu as its based on last years strain of flu. Can you tell me where you learned that it does nothing for this years flu? I'm really interested in learning more about it. Thanks. Bear, just because nobody else is answering you ha, I learned about the potential ineffectiveness of flu shots from my brother. He is a scientist and did a fellowship working on the development of flu vaccinations and he explained that they take the most common flu strand from the previous year to use in the vaccine, but flu viruses mutate each year so it is possible (and sometimes likely depending on how quickly it mutated) that you are being vaccinated against a less common or even potentially dormant flu strand than the current one. So for people who tend to react badly to vaccines in general (either severe arm soreness or actual illness symptoms) it can be advisable to actually NOT get the shot and just be prudent during flu season. Ah, ok thanks - so it's not necessarily that it "does nothing" - it's a little more complicated than that. I got a little freaked out for a moment!
|
|
Posted 1/8/13 8:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school This is nuts. |
|
Posted 1/8/13 8:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school Posted by Bearcat Posted by Irishbride Ridiculous! As a side not this years flu shot does nothing for this years flu as its based on last years strain of flu. Can you tell me where you learned that it does nothing for this years flu? I'm really interested in learning more about it. Thanks. I don't have a scientific study to post but I can tell you that my pediatrician said it was totally inaccurate. He is watching his patients who have been vaccinated come back one by one with the flu... |
|
Posted 1/9/13 5:40 AM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school I agree with the parents, I would not give my child the shot. |
|
Posted 1/9/13 6:29 AM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school Posted by OneOfEach Posted by Bearcat Posted by Irishbride Ridiculous! As a side not this years flu shot does nothing for this years flu as its based on last years strain of flu. Can you tell me where you learned that it does nothing for this years flu? I'm really interested in learning more about it. Thanks. I don't have a scientific study to post but I can tell you that my pediatrician said it was totally inaccurate. He is watching his patients who have been vaccinated come back one by one with the flu... Thanks. This is so strange to me because I've heard the opposite - in that it was a great match this year. I guess there will always be explanations for both sides! |
|
Posted 1/9/13 7:02 AM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school I don't have any proof to back it up. But I've heard it from the Dr's in the ER I work at & almost every patient that has come in had tested positive for the flu. |
|
Posted 1/9/13 8:12 AM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school From the CDC how the flu shot is made |
|
Posted 1/9/13 8:21 AM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school I heard this on the news the other day & think it's completely ridiculous! Lawsuit waiting to happen.. Message edited 2013-01-09 09:02:48.713000. |
|
Posted 1/9/13 9:02 AM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school Posted by Lillykat Posted by LI2VA Posted by LSP2005 I did not read the article, but we are in NJ and DD has a mild egg allergy. Our ped wrote a scrip for her preschool so she does not need to have the vaccination. See then this is what frustrates me... why is this not an option for this little boy??? See the ped probably should have. Which is why I wonder if there is more to the story (or they need a new ped). I know you can get it with an egg allergy so I wonder if maybe this child got it before, or if there is something else to this. I know if mine said no and I really didn't want to give it I would think maybe it was time to find one who supported me if it was legitimate allergy and a concern. I agree with this. The law is the law, but it sounds like with a doctor's note, the child would be exempt. For whatever reason, his pediatrician does not want to write the note, so either there's another side to this story, or the parents should seek out a different pediatrician! |
|
Posted 1/9/13 9:10 AM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school I really don't know what to think about the flu shot after reading this post. I recently got the shot, my family has gotten the shot and no one has had the flu. In my extended family, the only one's that got the flu are people that didn't get the shot. Our pediatrician said that no one that got the shot at their office has come back with the flu. But it does seem like the opposite is true at other places. This topic made me so confused. |
|
Posted 1/9/13 9:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school Posted by Bearcat Posted by OneOfEach Posted by Bearcat Posted by Irishbride Ridiculous! As a side not this years flu shot does nothing for this years flu as its based on last years strain of flu. Can you tell me where you learned that it does nothing for this years flu? I'm really interested in learning more about it. Thanks. I don't have a scientific study to post but I can tell you that my pediatrician said it was totally inaccurate. He is watching his patients who have been vaccinated come back one by one with the flu... Thanks. This is so strange to me because I've heard the opposite - in that it was a great match this year. I guess there will always be explanations for both sides! This...I heard the exact opposite too-that it is a great match this year. And my drs have said the only patients coming back sick with the flu, are the ones who didn't get vaccinated. So idk |
|
Posted 1/9/13 9:25 AM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school Posted by SlurpeeDad I really don't know what to think about the flu shot after reading this post. I recently got the shot, my family has gotten the shot and no one has had the flu. In my extended family, the only one's that got the flu are people that didn't get the shot. Our pediatrician said that no one that got the shot at their office has come back with the flu. But it does seem like the opposite is true at other places. This topic made me so confused. See I heard that this years has been effective BUT remember you can still get the flu even with the shot. My ped said the same as yours I know a lot of people who have or had the flu but they have not gotten the shot. Here is the thing it is a kind of numbers game. Say there are 5 strains going around. The shot might cover say 3 or 4 so you could get the shot and still get strain 5. Well one of the above posters said everyone coming in to the ER has the flu but didn't say they had gotten the shot. |
|
Posted 1/9/13 9:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school Also...you have some doctors and patients with inaccurate info. My MIL (who is clueless btw) gets her shot in like Jan or Feb. She tells us this is when HER doctor tells her to get it |
|
Posted 1/9/13 10:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school Posted by Lillykat Also...you have some doctors and patients with inaccurate info. My MIL (who is clueless btw) gets her shot in like Jan or Feb. She tells us this is when HER doctor tells her to get it She said her doctor tells her it is good for a year so to get it in Jan/feb So if you ask her she will say she had her shot That is like the lady I was next to when I got the shot. She said the Flu isn't contagious. How do you get it then? |
|
Posted 1/9/13 10:05 AM
|
|
|
No flu shot, no school I haven't gotten it in the 3 years. I was sick of feeling ill and sore afterwards. In addition, I have not gotten the flu in more than a decade. I believe in keeping ones immunity up through diet, exercise, lots of sleep, no heavy drinking, frequent hand washing etc.. Obviously, it is isn't full proof, but it has been working for me for a while :: knock on wood :: |
|
Posted 1/9/13 11:30 AM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school Message edited 2013-01-09 11:59:24.880000. |
|
Posted 1/9/13 11:54 AM
|
|
|
Re: No flu shot, no school Posted by lilqtny This is nuts. I do NOT believe in vaccines at all let alone one that is totally unnecessary. Out of curiosity, why don't you believe in vaccinations? No flame at all. I'm always curious when people say why they are unnecessary. I ahve some friends who are very anti-vax as well. I would like to see soeone elses opinion as to why. |
|
Posted 1/9/13 11:58 AM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Student shot on first day of school in Baltimore | CouponKT | 8/27/12 | 7 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| 16 yr old shot 5x in his back on way home from night school | EckoRed81504 | 3/11/10 | 23 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Middle School Student Shot by SWAT Team | leighla | 1/13/06 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Ughhh - Potential Swine Flu at DH's School | lbelle821 | 6/1/09 | 9 | Parenting |
| Confirmed swine flu at the school I work! | nicole97 | 6/1/09 | 4 | Pregnancy |
| Ahhhh...Swine flu hit my school!! | Jonsgirl04 | 5/20/09 | 14 | Newlyweds |













She said her doctor tells her it is good for a year so to get it in Jan/feb
So if you ask her she will say she had her shot