Need your opinion-update below

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

GossipQueen

Member since 9/07

25113 total posts

Name:

Need your opinion-update below

I wanted to have this painting re-created for Baby K's nursery and put it over her crib. I didn't purchase the original art because I wanted to change the branches from brown to black. I put in a alchemy request on Etsy.com and had someone paint it for me. I don't know but something seems off to me. Am I just seeing things or did she do a good job?

First Picture- Original

Second- Etsy.com


Image Attachment(s):

Message edited 2010-08-21 13:17:50.157000.

Posted 8/20/10 2:31 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Need your opinion

crashing, sorry...


its the flowers. the borders of the flowers are significantly thicker than in the original.

Posted 8/20/10 2:35 PM
 

babyonboard2010
our little monkey butt

Member since 6/10

1086 total posts

Name:
Kristi

Re: Need your opinion

the colors are deeper and the lines aren't as soft as the original...

Posted 8/20/10 2:37 PM
 

Lara&Aidansmommy
For mom i miss u ETC ILOVEU

Member since 3/07

13921 total posts

Name:
ETC I LOVE YOU

Re: Need your opinion

Definately looks different second pic looks more "cartoonish" to me

Posted 8/20/10 2:37 PM
 

LadyBug1209
Mommy to FOUR little men!

Member since 8/08

9655 total posts

Name:

Re: Need your opinion

It was a good attempt, but the 2nd version definitely does not have the same look. The colors are off and it seems more 'chunky' if that makes any sense.

Posted 8/20/10 2:41 PM
 

TwoPeas
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

1165 total posts

Name:

Re: Need your opinion

I agree with the other girls...The 2nd picture isn't as delicate as the first. It's not bad and you certainly could still use it. The other thing that's off is the first one has those rhinestones on it while the 2nd one doesn't.

Posted 8/20/10 2:44 PM
 

Bridex100
Two Under Two Mommy

Member since 3/08

10420 total posts

Name:
Momx100

Re: Need your opinion

Definitely does not look like a replica if that was what it was supposed to be.

I think the second one is cute and perfect for a nursery though.

Posted 8/20/10 2:44 PM
 

springsandra
Baby girl has a baby brother!

Member since 11/09

7155 total posts

Name:
Sandra

Re: Need your opinion

I actually like the second one better for a nursery. It has more of a childish, whimsical look to me.

I can see what you're saying about them looking different, though. Not in a bad way, but it's just two different artists' renderings.

Posted 8/20/10 2:57 PM
 

Mrs-D-Girl
Love my fur baby

Member since 8/07

5183 total posts

Name:

Re: Need your opinion

IMO, totally different then the first one.

Posted 8/20/10 3:00 PM
 

Barbiegrl
So in love with my little man!

Member since 8/09

2618 total posts

Name:
Barbara

Re: Need your opinion

The black looks much more heavy and the flowers are different.

Posted 8/20/10 3:05 PM
 

nraboni
Uggh...

Member since 10/09

6905 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Need your opinion

Posted by springsandra

I actually like the second one better for a nursery. It has more of a childish, whimsical look to me.

I can see what you're saying about them looking different, though. Not in a bad way, but it's just two different artists' renderings.



ITA!!

Posted 8/20/10 3:08 PM
 

poasBFP
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/09

599 total posts

Name:
EDD April 25th 2011

Re: Need your opinion

It certainly is not an exact replica. She has buds where the original has flowers and vice versa. The lines aren't as precise - a little more childish/whimiscal. The black makes the whole design a little bolder.

But overall I think she did a great job and would still use it. I love it!

Posted 8/20/10 3:08 PM
 

J9-13
We're gonna be big sisters!

Member since 6/06

14887 total posts

Name:
J9

Re: Need your opinion

The lines don't look as clean and they are a little thicker in the replica. Looks more like a cartoon than a painting. I still really like it and think it would look great in a nursery!

Posted 8/20/10 3:28 PM
 

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: Need your opinion

The etsy one looks like she did abad trace job and colored over it. Jmho. Can you find another vendor to redo it? I do love the first even with the brown.

Posted 8/20/10 3:33 PM
 

KGools
Happy

Member since 9/06

9532 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: Need your opinion

Posted by laura33

Definately looks different second pic looks more "cartoonish" to me



That's EXACTLY what it is! I couldn't put my finger on it.

She did a good job, but I prefer the original.

Posted 8/20/10 3:34 PM
 

BabyFactory
LIF Infant

Member since 8/09

249 total posts

Name:
Can't tell ya ;)

Re: Need your opinion

I still like the copy but it is different. I think she did a good job still.

The original is in lighter/softer tones, the brown outline is thinner, the branches on the original are outlined in dark brown/black and painted in lighter brown, there is also more space between the petals in the orig. and they are more amorphic.

I'm assuming you wanted different colors to match your room?

ETA, since it was online, the color change could be due to her printer being different.

Message edited 2010-08-20 15:45:03.713000.

Posted 8/20/10 3:42 PM
 

Pray4Baby2010
<3 Cutest Giants Fan

Member since 10/09

5796 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: Need your opinion

Posted by laura33

Definately looks different second pic looks more "cartoonish" to me


Yes! this is exactly what I thought when I saw it too

Posted 8/20/10 4:38 PM
 

cityandbeachmom
Vineyard hopping time

Member since 6/10

1821 total posts

Name:
Suffer the pain of discipline,

Re: Need your opinion

Posted by laura33

Definately looks different second pic looks more "cartoonish" to me



ITA

Posted 8/20/10 4:45 PM
 

lbride
Lovin' my mini man!

Member since 3/07

2475 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Need your opinion

umm.. not a fan of it to be honest...
If you want a good person to reproduce it, my sister's mother-in-law is an amazing artist and muralist and has been doing it for almost 40 years. let me know.

Posted 8/20/10 5:22 PM
 

miamimerger
Loving my bundle of pure JOY!

Member since 4/10

2429 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: Need your opinion

Posted by cityandbeachmom

Posted by laura33

Definately looks different second pic looks more "cartoonish" to me



ITA



ITA, and the contrast against the black and that particular shade of pink makes it more "loud" instead of soft. JMO, I wouldn't pay for that since it's not a fair representation of the picture you showed.

Posted 8/20/10 5:34 PM
 

pandaworm
LIF Adult

Member since 8/08

1125 total posts

Name:
bethany

Re: Need your opinion

crashing...

i think what you're seeing is that the panels are all shorter than the original which in turn is making the whole thing more spread out and chunky feeling. that combined with the color changes and thicker strokes is making much heavier (cartoonish).

it's still nice, just different from the original. if you don't like it, tell her and get someone else to do it.

Posted 8/20/10 8:00 PM
 

KNic19
Baby's First Christmas

Member since 7/09

3541 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: Need your opinion

I agree with the others with it seeming more cartoonish due to the bolder colors and the heavier brush strokes. If it isn't what you were looking for I would let the artist know. It is still a great piece, but if you were looking for a replica in different coloring, that is not what you are getting with this piece.

Posted 8/20/10 9:35 PM
 

GossipQueen

Member since 9/07

25113 total posts

Name:

Re: Need your opinion

I asked the artist to revise a bit and she delivered. I love it more than the original. Thank you for helping me ladies! Chat Icon

Image Attachment(s):
Posted 8/21/10 1:11 PM
 

8ternity
<3

Member since 11/08

10586 total posts

Name:
Formally NYPD-Wife

Re: Need your opinion-update below

Much better!!! glad it worked out!! Chat Icon

Posted 8/21/10 1:18 PM
 

babyonboard2010
our little monkey butt

Member since 6/10

1086 total posts

Name:
Kristi

Re: Need your opinion-update below

the new one is WAY better!!! totally glad you got what you wanted!!

Posted 8/21/10 2:02 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
What is your opinion on Anna Nicole Smith and her pursuit of her DH's fortune? SweetestOfPeas 5/1/06 18 Families Helping Families ™
repost form NWR, shower location place? Opinion on Alias Smith and Jones in Oceanside. 04bride 4/26/06 5 Pregnancy
Can I ask you for your opinion??? PLEASE??? bellarina 4/5/06 34 Parenting
Hey Mommies...Need to know your opinion- Is the Diaper Genie necessary? AndreaLMT 9/21/05 23 Parenting
Do I go for a 3rd opinion? (sorry it's long) Donna 8/7/05 14 Infertility
What's everyone's opinion about having a seperate checking account that hubby doesn't know about for a safety net? JerseyMamaOf3 7/21/05 38 Families Helping Families ™