need a new car seat!
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
need a new car seat! DS is currently in First Years True Fit car seat. It has a removable head rest. I need to put that on now that he has reached the weight limit. The problem is now it is too tall and no one under 5ft 6in can sit in the passenger seat. Hubby is over 6 feet and it is really uncomfortable and it is unsafe for him to be up there. I need a shorter seat that can rear face up to at least 35 pounds that is comfy. I have a Dodge Grand Caravan...Please help me.. Message edited 2011-02-16 13:27:26.087000. |
|
Posted 2/16/11 12:02 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: need a new car seat! Posted by BAM 2009 DS is currently in the Safety 1st True Fit car seat. It has a removable head rest. I need to put that on now that he has reached the weight limit. The problem is now it is too tall and no one under 5ft 6in can sit in the passenger seat. Hubby is over 6 feet and it is really uncomfortable and it is unsafe for him to be up there. I need a shorter seat that can rear face up to at least 35 pounds that is comfy. I have a Dodge Grand Caravan...Please help me.. It's Learning Curve/The First Years that makes the TrueFit not Safety 1st (just want to clarify this because there is a recall on a bunch of Safety 1st/Dorel seats currently) The TrueFit goes to 35lbs RF and is one of the most comfy seats for leg room on the market. You can angle the seat more upright when you put the headrest back on. I have this, a BLVD and MyRide and they're actually all pretty comparable heightwise, but the TrueFit sits much lower since it doesn't have a "base" like the others do. The TrueFIt is 27" the MyRide is 26" The original Boulevard 65 is 27". The New Boulevard/Marathon 70 is 26" as well. For what you want (RF to 35 and comfy) you're really not going to find a seat that much shorter that would make a big difference. Don't forget that if the shell is shorter they're more apt to outgrow it by height before weight also. I suggest bringing it to a tech if you aren't able to get the seat more upright before spending another $200 on a seat that may buy you less than an inch of external height, KWIM?. The 45 degree recline is only necessary for newborns who can't hold their heads up yet. You can angle it as upright as 35 degrees, this makes a HUGE difference. Carseatsafety (Chris) is in Nassau, he can help you out 516-571-9664 Message edited 2011-02-16 09:55:54.450000. |
|
Posted 2/16/11 9:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: need a new car seat! i have the Evenflo Symphony 65 and love it. its up to 40lbs rear facing, 65lbs front facing and 100lbs booster. last seat you'll ever need. and you dont have to rethread |
|
Posted 2/16/11 9:58 AM
|
|
|
Re: need a new car seat! Posted by QTDimps23 i have the Evenflo Symphony 65 and love it. its up to 40lbs rear facing, 65lbs front facing and 100lbs booster. last seat you'll ever need. and you dont have to rethread It's a nice seat but it's actually bigger than what the OP has at 32" tall The other comparable seats I can think of: Recaro Como is 26" Britax Roundabout 55 26" Sunshine Kids Radian 28" Safety 1st Complete Air 27.5" |
|
Posted 2/16/11 10:10 AM
|
|
|
Re: need a new car seat! Posted by tarabelle99 Posted by BAM 2009 DS is currently in the Safety 1st True Fit car seat. It has a removable head rest. I need to put that on now that he has reached the weight limit. The problem is now it is too tall and no one under 5ft 6in can sit in the passenger seat. Hubby is over 6 feet and it is really uncomfortable and it is unsafe for him to be up there. I need a shorter seat that can rear face up to at least 35 pounds that is comfy. I have a Dodge Grand Caravan...Please help me.. It's Learning Curve/The First Years that makes the TrueFit not Safety 1st (just want to clarify this because there is a recall on a bunch of Safety 1st/Dorel seats currently) The TrueFit goes to 35lbs RF and is one of the most comfy seats for leg room on the market. You can angle the seat more upright when you put the headrest back on. I have this, a BLVD and MyRide and they're actually all pretty comparable heightwise, but the TrueFit sits much lower since it doesn't have a "base" like the others do. The TrueFIt is 27" the MyRide is 26" The original Boulevard 65 is 27". The New Boulevard/Marathon 70 is 26" as well. For what you want (RF to 35 and comfy) you're really not going to find a seat that much shorter that would make a big difference. Don't forget that if the shell is shorter they're more apt to outgrow it by height before weight also. I suggest bringing it to a tech if you aren't able to get the seat more upright before spending another $200 on a seat that may buy you less than an inch of external height, KWIM?. The 45 degree recline is only necessary for newborns who can't hold their heads up yet. You can angle it as upright as 35 degrees, this makes a HUGE difference. Carseatsafety (Chris) is in Nassau, he can help you out 516-571-9664 I don't know why I wrote Safety First...I know it The First Years...Do it all the time..Thanks for the correction..It has a line on the seat that has to be parallel with the ground when being used in the rear face position so I have no choice but to leave it at the angle it is. Are there any people out there that have a seat in the rear face position that have a Dodge Grand Caravan? Can you fit a tall person in the front seat. I don't have the option to put him in the seat behind the driver.... Message edited 2011-02-16 12:10:35.700000. |
|
Posted 2/16/11 12:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: need a new car seat! That's not 100% true about the line. That line is the 45 degree angle line. You'll find some type of "level" marking (or bubble etc) on every seat available for RF. If you look in the manual, you'll even see it states to make sure it's even to keep their airway open. This is only necessary for newborns. All convertibles can be placed more upright. Many seats that have been released more recently have added into their manuals about RF'ing older children. Most of the manuals for seats that have been around for a while didn't take into account the "over 1" crowd and have their RF'ing instructions written for infants. You can even see this in the manuals for the newer TrueFit Deluxe and Premier versions. And, most older RF children are generally more comfortable when the seat is less reclined. |
|
Posted 2/16/11 12:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: need a new car seat! Posted by tarabelle99 That's not 100% true about the line. That line is the 45 degree angle line. You'll find some type of "level" marking (or bubble etc) on every seat available for RF. If you look in the manual, you'll even see it states to make sure it's even to keep their airway open. This is only necessary for newborns. All convertibles can be placed more upright. Many seats that have been released more recently have added into their manuals about RF'ing older children. Most of the manuals for seats that have been around for a while didn't take into account the "over 1" crowd and have their RF'ing instructions written for infants. You can even see this in the manuals for the newer TrueFit Deluxe and Premier versions. And, most older RF children are generally more comfortable when the seat is less reclined. Please call carseatsafety (Chris) at 516-571-9664 and he will help you adjust the angle. There is no convertible seat that will be as short as the TF without headrest that is going to fit at a 45 degree angle. Ps... I can fit my TrueFit rear facing in a compact sized Kia, you should be able to fit it in your Minivan without issue. I also had it installed in my sitter's minivan (Ford's model, whatever that is) and they were able to have both front seats all the way back, but I wouldn't have been able to have it at 45 degrees with the headrest on. I have no problem installing it. It has been in the van since July...The problem now comes with the installation of the head rest. My 6ft 1in husband can't fit in the front seat nor can anyone over 5ft 5in. That means I can't have any one else in the front seat.... Which is pretty inconvienent...The seat he is in is pushed all the way back and he likes the reclined position because he sleeps in it all the time! Message edited 2011-02-16 13:27:02.520000. |
|
Posted 2/16/11 12:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: need a new car seat! Then I suggest you go to BRU/BBB and try out different seats in your car. If you insist on installing at a 45 degree angle you're severely limiting your choices. |
|
Posted 2/16/11 1:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: need a new car seat! Posted by tarabelle99 Then I suggest you go to BRU/BBB and try out different seats in your car. If you insist on installing at a 45 degree angle you're severely limiting your choices. I listed the shell heights for you, as you can see most seats are about the same height. The TrueFit and Radian sit the lowest to the seat as they don't sit up on bases. You may be able to try a MyRide and see if that works better since it has a deep natural recline but even then you're probably going to keep running into the same problem until you put the seat more upright. (Any seat that is going to get you to 35lbs, not just the TrueFit). A Scenera is another option, Target sells a 40lb RF version, but you asked for comfy. Scenera is quite bare bones with minimal padding. I get that it is inconvenient to have people eating their knees, really, I DO.. this is why I suggested you do what techs recommend: install the seat more upright for an older RF child. I don't know why you are so dead set against trying to adjust the angle and, IMO, seem a bit defensive thinking that only a new seat is going to magically solve the problem. I even gave you Chris' number so you could hear it was OK to do this from a tech who's been doing this for eons and not even have to take my word for it. IDK, maybe you just want to go shopping? . I came on here asking people who have a van like mine for THEIR opinion. I am dead set against having my son uncomfortable on long road trips which we take a lot. I didn't realize how tall the seat was when I got it and never thought that it would be such a pain. So instead of getting opinions I got you calling me defensive and thinking that I just want to go shopping...I don't care what you think and you keep pushing Chris's number on me won't change my mind. A different seat may just make the difference and I was asking about that in my original post... Message edited 2011-02-16 13:39:06.020000. |
|
Posted 2/16/11 1:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: need a new car seat! Posted by BAM 2009 I came on here asking people who have a van like mine for THEIR opinion. I am dead set against having my son uncomfortable on long road trips which we take a lot. I didn't realize how tall the seat was when I got it and never thought that it would be such a pain. So instead of getting opinions I got you calling me defensive and thinking that I just want to go shopping...I don't care what you think and you keep pushing Chris's number on me won't change my mind. A different seat may just make the difference and I was asking about that in my original post... You're very defensive (and rude), and this post just goes to prove it. First, how do you know for sure that your son will be uncomfortable if you haven't tried it? Second, I offered you plenty of options, and even went and got seat measurements for you. Even when you got defensive with me, I still tried to give you a couple options that may work for you. You're welcome for that, BTW. Third, I'm sorry you "don't care" what I think, many people here and elsewhere have been quite appreciate of my help. I know this to be true because they tell me "THANK YOU" even if it won't work for them. Fourth? I love car seat shopping. I really do. If DH didn't take my BRU credit card away I'd probably have a different seat for every day of the week. Fifth, even if someone else suggests a particular seat, there is no guarantee it will work for you if you insist on 45 degrees. Finally? I always try to offer Chris' number. He's been a tech for a long time and has a lot of experience with different vehicles. Maybe he would have had even more ideas for you. Shame you're so dead set against calling him. Sorry for trying to help you, and once again, you're welcome. Have a great day!
|
|
Posted 2/16/11 1:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: need a new car seat! Posted by tarabelle99 Posted by BAM 2009 I came on here asking people who have a van like mine for THEIR opinion. I am dead set against having my son uncomfortable on long road trips which we take a lot. I didn't realize how tall the seat was when I got it and never thought that it would be such a pain. So instead of getting opinions I got you calling me defensive and thinking that I just want to go shopping...I don't care what you think and you keep pushing Chris's number on me won't change my mind. A different seat may just make the difference and I was asking about that in my original post... You're very defensive (and rude), and this post just goes to prove it. First, how do you know for sure that your son will be uncomfortable if you haven't tried it? Second, I offered you plenty of options, and even went and got seat measurements for you. Even when you got defensive with me, I still tried to give you a couple options that may work for you. You're welcome for that, BTW. Third, I'm sorry you "don't care" what I think, many people here and elsewhere have been quite appreciate of my help. I know this to be true because they tell me "THANK YOU" even if it won't work for them. Fourth? I love car seat shopping. I really do. If DH didn't take my BRU credit card away I'd probably have a different seat for every day of the week. Fifth, even if someone else suggests a particular seat, there is no guarantee it will work for you if you insist on 45 degrees. Finally? I always try to offer Chris' number. He's been a tech for a long time and has a lot of experience with different vehicles. Maybe he would have had even more ideas for you. Shame you're so dead set against calling him. Sorry for trying to help you, and once again, you're welcome. Have a great day! Are you done? And yes I have tried it upright and he IS miserable. He is very top heavy so when he falls asleep, his head is on his chest. Try sleeping like that for a while and see how your neck feels!!! Not comfortable. And because he is so top heavy, he is safer in a more reclined position. My pedi said for me to keep him like that. ANd if I'm rude, then I have no idea what you are after this post. I wasn't looking for why I should put his seat more upright or how to install it. I asked for opinions on other car seats and mini-vans. I don't know you. You don't know me...But you think you do when you start calling me defensive and rude...GOODBYE!!!! As for everyone else's help, thank you...I will try and see if any of those seats work.. I don't have the money for a Britax or Radian. |
|
Posted 2/16/11 2:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: need a new car seat! Posted by BAM 2009 I came on here asking people who have a van like mine for THEIR opinion. I am dead set against having my son uncomfortable on long road trips which we take a lot. I didn't realize how tall the seat was when I got it and never thought that it would be such a pain. So instead of getting opinions I got you calling me defensive and thinking that I just want to go shopping...I don't care what you think and you keep pushing Chris's number on me won't change my mind. A different seat may just make the difference and I was asking about that in my original post... Kerry, I actually thought Tarabelle's posts gave you a lot of valuable info that was probably more useful than other people's posts only because she pointed out the fact that your current seat is has one of the smallest heights out there and therefore showing that you would probably have the same issue even if you bought a new seat. I'm all for not spending $ if I don't need to, so I thought it was good info for you. Everyone's opinions on here are just that, opinions, but she did offer some more insight that the average LIFer doesn't have. And FWIW, I don't know tarabelle at all, so this is not a case of a "friend having a friend's back" - if anything you and I have met and I know you're just trying to do the best for your DS. I honestly would try adjusting the incline of the seat while rearfacing. I know you said he likes to sleep in the carseat on long drives, but he may be perfectly fine being angled up a few degrees and then you would also get more legroom back in the front passenger seat. Also, you can always go to BBB and they will let you bring out a carseat to your car to try it out. I am hoping to do that soon bc DS seems to be outgrowing his infant seat (to my dismay since I hoped he'd be in it for a while longer!). ETA: Just saw your other post that you already tried the more inclined position. Ok, so do you have the option to put his carseat in the middle? Maybe that would resolve the problem? Message edited 2011-02-16 14:19:08.730000. |
|
Posted 2/16/11 2:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: need a new car seat! Posted by LoveyQ Posted by BAM 2009 I came on here asking people who have a van like mine for THEIR opinion. I am dead set against having my son uncomfortable on long road trips which we take a lot. I didn't realize how tall the seat was when I got it and never thought that it would be such a pain. So instead of getting opinions I got you calling me defensive and thinking that I just want to go shopping...I don't care what you think and you keep pushing Chris's number on me won't change my mind. A different seat may just make the difference and I was asking about that in my original post... Kerry, I actually thought Tarabelle's posts gave you a lot of valuable info that was probably more useful than other people's posts only because she pointed out the fact that your current seat is has one of the smallest heights out there and therefore showing that you would probably have the same issue even if you bought a new seat. I'm all for not spending $ if I don't need to, so I thought it was good info for you. Everyone's opinions on here are just that, opinions, but she did offer some more insight that the average LIFer doesn't have. And FWIW, I don't know tarabelle at all, so this is not a case of a "friend having a friend's back" - if anything you and I have met and I know you're just trying to do the best for your DS. I honestly would try adjusting the incline of the seat while rearfacing. I know you said he likes to sleep in the carseat on long drives, but he may be perfectly fine being angled up a few degrees and then you would also get more legroom back in the front passenger seat. Also, you can always go to BBB and they will let you bring out a carseat to your car to try it out. I am hoping to do that soon bc DS seems to be outgrowing his infant seat (to my dismay since I hoped he'd be in it for a while longer!). Thanks...It just burns my butt when someone thinks I am a certain way when I'm not.. I do listen to a lot of people's opinions on here and I learn a lot. But for someone who doesn't know me to just keep going at me puts me over the edge. I will tweak with the seat and see if there is something I can do. But I sense a new seat in the future. The only other option is to turn him forward facing. Which I really don't want to do...I only want what is best for my son and was looking for someone with a van and rear facing seat who doesn't have an issue with leg room with a front passenger...Now I have to find some time to get to BBB to try seats..Thanks again. |
|
Posted 2/16/11 2:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: need a new car seat! Posted by LoveyQ Posted by BAM 2009 I came on here asking people who have a van like mine for THEIR opinion. I am dead set against having my son uncomfortable on long road trips which we take a lot. I didn't realize how tall the seat was when I got it and never thought that it would be such a pain. So instead of getting opinions I got you calling me defensive and thinking that I just want to go shopping...I don't care what you think and you keep pushing Chris's number on me won't change my mind. A different seat may just make the difference and I was asking about that in my original post... Kerry, I actually thought Tarabelle's posts gave you a lot of valuable info that was probably more useful than other people's posts only because she pointed out the fact that your current seat is has one of the smallest heights out there and therefore showing that you would probably have the same issue even if you bought a new seat. I'm all for not spending $ if I don't need to, so I thought it was good info for you. Everyone's opinions on here are just that, opinions, but she did offer some more insight that the average LIFer doesn't have. And FWIW, I don't know tarabelle at all, so this is not a case of a "friend having a friend's back" - if anything you and I have met and I know you're just trying to do the best for your DS. I honestly would try adjusting the incline of the seat while rearfacing. I know you said he likes to sleep in the carseat on long drives, but he may be perfectly fine being angled up a few degrees and then you would also get more legroom back in the front passenger seat. Also, you can always go to BBB and they will let you bring out a carseat to your car to try it out. I am hoping to do that soon bc DS seems to be outgrowing his infant seat (to my dismay since I hoped he'd be in it for a while longer!). ETA: Just saw your other post that you already tried the more inclined position. Ok, so do you have the option to put his carseat in the middle? Maybe that would resolve the problem? i agree completely - and I have the same seat as you have. I know the exact issue you're speaking of, i had it in my car as well. I just dealt with it until I turned DS forward facing. Anyone that had a problem with the front passenger leg room could sit in the backseat with the baby. |
|
Posted 2/16/11 2:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: need a new car seat! Shorty--- Hubby can fit in the front seat, barely. But god forbid I get in an accident, the airbag is going to seriously hurt him. And both his legs will get broken. He says it doesn't bother him that his legs her squished but I can see it in his face that he is uncomfortable. For now we are dealing with it and he can sit in the back as long as I am not babysitting my friends kids and they are back there..I am just going to have to find something to do...Thanks |
|
Posted 2/16/11 2:36 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I need help with choosing a new car seat because the one I picked is discontinued | brownie | 4/8/09 | 8 | Pregnancy |
| New Car Seat Ease of Use Ratings | KPtoys | 1/31/08 | 5 | Parenting |
| OK - need a new car seat for Cailen... | lipglossjunky73 | 10/22/07 | 26 | Parenting |
| XP: Brand new car seat for sale | MrsSchwags | 6/8/07 | 5 | Parenting |
| Brand New Car Seat for sale | MrsSchwags | 6/8/07 | 0 | Pregnancy |
| brand new car seat, what to do? | iwed2005 | 3/3/07 | 3 | Parenting |





