Milk- is this bad to do?

Posted By Message

Bri
I Love You to Pieces!

Member since 5/05

9919 total posts

Name:
Brianne

Milk- is this bad to do?

My ped. insists that whole milk is what DD needs for the first year even though she is of average weight. She said the max she should be getting is 24 ounces a day. DD loves her milk and I am struggling to keep her down to just 24 ounces. If I cut her whole milk with water (she takes it cut with water no problem) so that she is still getting 24 ounces max of milk a day, just stretched out by the water addition, am I doing something wrong? I feel like I am just making my own 2% milk which I was told is not ok, but if DD is drinking more than her allowance of whole milk, shouldn't it be ok to do this?

Posted 8/11/10 11:47 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Angel321
...

Member since 4/08

15553 total posts

Name:

Re: Milk- is this bad to do?

i'm really not sure if you are doing anything BAD persay....

can you run it by your doc - or do you not want to do that??

i know when em was having her last 'puking' episode, the doctor told us to cut her milk with water - so the amount of dairy was limited....

Posted 8/11/10 11:51 PM
 

Bri
I Love You to Pieces!

Member since 5/05

9919 total posts

Name:
Brianne

Re: Milk- is this bad to do?

I understand if she was not getting in the milk she should be getting a day. But in essence what is the difference between me giving her 24 ounces of milk and 8 ounces of water separate or me gving her 24 ounces of milk and watering it down to stretch it further?

I don'tt think there is a difference- it is all ending up in the same place.

Posted 8/11/10 11:59 PM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Milk- is this bad to do?

What if you gave her milk sometimes and water other times? So that she's not getting more milk than she's supposed to...but she's also able to drink throughout the day.

Posted 8/11/10 11:59 PM
 

Bri
I Love You to Pieces!

Member since 5/05

9919 total posts

Name:
Brianne

Re: Milk- is this bad to do?

I try separating the 2 and she will sip water but won't really "drink" it. She won't take in much fluid at all unless it is milk from the bottle (which I am trying so hard to kick, but otherwise she flat out refuses milk and is not a big eater- whether she is getting a lot of fluids or not.)

Message edited 2010-08-12 00:06:44.610000.

Posted 8/12/10 12:05 AM
 

Angel321
...

Member since 4/08

15553 total posts

Name:

Re: Milk- is this bad to do?

Posted by Bri

I try separating the 2 and she will sip water but won't really "drink" it. She won't take in much fluid at all unless it is milk from the bottle (which I am trying so hard to kick, but otherwise she flat out refuses milk and is not a big eater- whether she is getting a lot of fluids or not.)



wow - she sounds like Em...who would drink an entire cow's worth of milk from a bottle, but in a sippy - won't touch it.... she does like her water in a sippy - but i've tried every single type of sippy for milk and she just won't go to bed without her bottle... :(

what we do is during the day - she gets sippy's with water - and if she's thirsty - she'll drink it! we only give milk in bottles at bedtime, in the AM/Overnight or at nap time. So this way - we are controlling how much milk she is drinking and limiting her bottles too.. (em is also not a big eater - it's like stopping to eat is an inconvenience to her).

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/12/10 12:10 AM
 

Bri
I Love You to Pieces!

Member since 5/05

9919 total posts

Name:
Brianne

Re: Milk- is this bad to do?

Posted by davenjess

Posted by Bri

I try separating the 2 and she will sip water but won't really "drink" it. She won't take in much fluid at all unless it is milk from the bottle (which I am trying so hard to kick, but otherwise she flat out refuses milk and is not a big eater- whether she is getting a lot of fluids or not.)



wow - she sounds like Em...who would drink an entire cow's worth of milk from a bottle, but in a sippy - won't touch it.... she does like her water in a sippy - but i've tried every single type of sippy for milk and she just won't go to bed without her bottle... :(

what we do is during the day - she gets sippy's with water - and if she's thirsty - she'll drink it! we only give milk in bottles at bedtime, in the AM/Overnight or at nap time. So this way - we are controlling how much milk she is drinking and limiting her bottles too.. (em is also not a big eater - it's like stopping to eat is an inconvenience to her).

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



I guess maybe I am getting worried about her lack of eating and trying to replace it with milk. I am going to try just offering the water in the sippy and schedule her milk and see how that goes- thanksChat Icon

Posted 8/12/10 12:17 AM
 

mathteach
Roll Tide!

Member since 8/08

3169 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Milk- is this bad to do?

The reason they get whole milk is the amount of fat in the milk. It helps brain development. By adding water you're not reducing the amount of fat in the milk itself, KWIM?

Keep cutting it with water, it's def not 2% milk now.

Posted 8/12/10 12:35 AM
 

Angel321
...

Member since 4/08

15553 total posts

Name:

Re: Milk- is this bad to do?

Posted by Bri

Posted by davenjess

Posted by Bri

I try separating the 2 and she will sip water but won't really "drink" it. She won't take in much fluid at all unless it is milk from the bottle (which I am trying so hard to kick, but otherwise she flat out refuses milk and is not a big eater- whether she is getting a lot of fluids or not.)



wow - she sounds like Em...who would drink an entire cow's worth of milk from a bottle, but in a sippy - won't touch it.... she does like her water in a sippy - but i've tried every single type of sippy for milk and she just won't go to bed without her bottle... :(

what we do is during the day - she gets sippy's with water - and if she's thirsty - she'll drink it! we only give milk in bottles at bedtime, in the AM/Overnight or at nap time. So this way - we are controlling how much milk she is drinking and limiting her bottles too.. (em is also not a big eater - it's like stopping to eat is an inconvenience to her).

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



I guess maybe I am getting worried about her lack of eating and trying to replace it with milk. I am going to try just offering the water in the sippy and schedule her milk and see how that goes- thanksChat Icon



what the ped told us to do was just that - NOT offer her milk in bottles other than at bedtimes...because if she drinks LESS milk - she'll eat more food. Has it been overwhelming since we did it? NO - but she has been eating a touch better....and i do think it has something to do with the fact that the milk isn't filling her as often...

Posted 8/12/10 1:04 AM
 

Bri
I Love You to Pieces!

Member since 5/05

9919 total posts

Name:
Brianne

Re: Milk- is this bad to do?

Posted by mathteach

The reason they get whole milk is the amount of fat in the milk. It helps brain development. By adding water you're not reducing the amount of fat in the milk itself, KWIM?

Keep cutting it with water, it's def not 2% milk now.



This is what I thought. TY

Posted 8/12/10 10:15 AM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Milk- is this bad to do?

On days when DS doesn't eat much, I give him as much milk as he wants (up to 35 oz). I'd rather he have more milk than go to bed hungry, and he eats less when he is teething.

Posted 8/12/10 10:18 AM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Milk- is this bad to do?

My ped actually told me to cut DS's milk with water because milk was the ONLY thing he would drink. We were up to about 32 oz a day and she didn't want him getting more than that. She said if he will drink the milk watered down, to keep giving it to him that way.

Posted 8/12/10 10:21 AM
 

LoveMySMT09
<3mySMT.AJT

Member since 1/09

2623 total posts

Name:
VT

Re: Milk- is this bad to do?

my Ped said no more than 12oz of milk/day Chat Icon

he said more than that can cause anemia? has anyone heard of this?

now im starting to second guess that because obviously other Peds have different ideas if you ladies are giving 24+oz/day Chat Icon

Posted 8/12/10 10:25 AM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Milk- is this bad to do?

Posted by sweetsurprise09

my Ped said no more than 12oz of milk/day Chat Icon

he said more than that can cause anemia? has anyone heard of this?

now im starting to second guess that because obviously other Peds have different ideas if you ladies are giving 24+oz/day Chat Icon



My DS is a big boy and always was, so I think the ped said it was OK for us to be on the higher end of the range. Now that I am thinking about it, I think 32 oz max was for the formula, but when we switched to milk, I think she encouraged me to limit it to 28 oz. We also had a non-eater once we were phasing out baby food, so I sometimes let him have a bit more milk, since he was at least taking in something nutritious.

I don't know how old or how big your daughter is, but 12 oz as a max seems low.

Posted 8/12/10 1:02 PM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: Milk- is this bad to do?

Posted by sweetsurprise09

my Ped said no more than 12oz of milk/day Chat Icon

he said more than that can cause anemia? has anyone heard of this?

now im starting to second guess that because obviously other Peds have different ideas if you ladies are giving 24+oz/day Chat Icon




you are absolutely right! and DS did become anemic! (although my ped had us limit to 20 oz)

I would give water alone - it's a good thing for her to get used to drinking water.

and regarding whole milk - it's really 3.7% milk. the AAP recently OK'd 2% milk after year 1 for some cases for cases of overweight babies.

Posted 8/12/10 1:27 PM
 

MikesWife
Wanting...........

Member since 1/06

6887 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Milk- is this bad to do?

When DD is having a less than good eating day, I give her a tablespoon or two of the cereal. It fills her up and gives her nutrients.

Is that an option rather than increasing milk oz or watering it down?

Posted 8/12/10 1:29 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
milk and a bad cough? jburke322 2/8/10 3 Parenting
Is milk really bad for cat? missgwife 12/11/07 5 Pets
Ewwww...bad milk! KaRiSsA 6/2/06 8 Families Helping Families ™
is bad gas, cramping and poor sleep a sign of milk allergy? groovypeg 7/20/10 5 Parenting
Do I reduce the amount of milk she's having if she has a bad phlegmy cough? pickles16 2/14/10 2 Parenting
Trouble switching from Alimentum to whole milk...bad gas issues...any advice? FrankiesGirl107 11/19/08 9 Parenting