Melting Pot for men?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
Melting Pot for men? My hubby is turning 30 and i'm planning a dinner for him. I wanted to do something different than just a regular restaurant. I tried hibachi but the tables are too small to accommodate the number of people we're having.. I've never been to the Melting Pot but i've heard it's fun.... This may be a stupid question, but do guys tend to like the melting pot experience or is it more of a girls night out? DH likes to eat good food in good portions. He's not into fancy trendy meals with tiny beautifully decorated portions or tapas or anything like that... .is this place for him or should I keep looking... any other suggestions for something a little different? Message edited 2011-09-27 12:26:27.300000. |
|
Posted 9/26/11 9:17 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? DH & I have gone he enjoyed himself. |
|
Posted 9/26/11 9:19 AM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? I went there with a bunch of gf's and when I explained it to DH he was like no thanks Id rather not cook bite size food for myself. I am going out to dinner to have it done for me LOL My DH is a steak and potatoes kinda guy though so he'd hate it. |
|
Posted 9/26/11 9:22 AM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? We go with another couple and DH and the other DH love it. |
|
Posted 9/26/11 9:42 AM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Melting Pot for men? Posted by OneOfEach I went there with a bunch of gf's and when I explained it to DH he was like no thanks Id rather not cook bite size food for myself. I am going out to dinner to have it done for me LOL My DH is a steak and potatoes kinda guy though so he'd hate it. So funny- my DH said the same exact thing!
|
Posted 9/26/11 9:45 AM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? Posted by OneOfEach I went there with a bunch of gf's and when I explained it to DH he was like no thanks Id rather not cook bite size food for myself. I am going out to dinner to have it done for me LOL . DH said the same thing !
|
|
Posted 9/26/11 9:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? Posted by NervousNell Posted by OneOfEach I went there with a bunch of gf's and when I explained it to DH he was like no thanks Id rather not cook bite size food for myself. I am going out to dinner to have it done for me LOL My DH is a steak and potatoes kinda guy though so he'd hate it. So funny- my DH said the same exact thing! I often complain about restaurants that don't cook my food. That's why I don't eat sushi (cook my d@mn food! You're a cook, so cook! ), and I don't order fajitas at a Mexican restaurant, since I have to assemble my own food.... I'd much rather go to a steakhouse or BBQ place and get a big plate of cooked meat.
|
|
Posted 9/26/11 9:51 AM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? The place is fun and the cheese and chocoloate fondue is DELISH! But the food is gross (I thought). And I had to cook my own little cubes of chicken myself. It was nasty. |
|
Posted 9/26/11 9:54 AM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? LOVE the melting pot!! my DH likes it.... but more to take me there for a nice date night. the meal takes a long time, which i don't know would be good for a birthday party. it would be hard for people to get up and talk bc they need to keep an eye on their food |
|
Posted 9/26/11 10:00 AM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? Posted by ml110 LOVE the melting pot!! my DH likes it.... but more to take me there for a nice date night. the meal takes a long time, which i don't know would be good for a birthday party. it would be hard for people to get up and talk bc they need to keep an eye on their food also- you share the pots... which is fine for 2 or 4 people. but to have a bunch of people sharing the pots of cheese or broth might not work out too well.i would look for a steak house or something. i live in NJ.... and for DHs 30th we went for Rodizio. basically, they come around with different kinds of meats on skewers and keep coming until you tell them you're done!!! haha it also comes with rice, spinach, fries, all that kind of stuff. it was very cool- and something different than a normal steak house. not sure if theres anything like that on LI though... that sounds great...where is New Jersey is that? |
|
Posted 9/26/11 10:02 AM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? My DH refuses to go too LOL |
|
Posted 9/26/11 10:11 AM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? Posted by DramaQueen10 Posted by ml110 LOVE the melting pot!! my DH likes it.... but more to take me there for a nice date night. the meal takes a long time, which i don't know would be good for a birthday party. it would be hard for people to get up and talk bc they need to keep an eye on their food also- you share the pots... which is fine for 2 or 4 people. but to have a bunch of people sharing the pots of cheese or broth might not work out too well.i would look for a steak house or something. i live in NJ.... and for DHs 30th we went for Rodizio. basically, they come around with different kinds of meats on skewers and keep coming until you tell them you're done!!! haha it also comes with rice, spinach, fries, all that kind of stuff. it was very cool- and something different than a normal steak house. not sure if theres anything like that on LI though... that sounds great...where is New Jersey is that? it was in Newark- the restaurant is called Iberia Peninsula. but theres a few rodizio restaurants in that area. we had i think almost 20 people, and they had no problem accomodating us. its definitely a great "guy" meal... and something different. i just went and googled "rodizio long island" and a couple places came up... so you can check that out, too! |
|
Posted 9/26/11 10:14 AM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? My DH LOVES the Melting Pot. We even took FIL there for his birthday last year and he LOVED it even more. FIL even came up with a "strategy" to cook as much as possible at one time and not have to wait as long, lol. I think some guys have even more fun there than women. |
|
Posted 9/26/11 10:37 AM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? We both love it... me more than DH tho. But he does enjoy it every much. We often go with my friend and her DH (who first introduced it to me on Philly years ago). They both LOVE it too! |
|
Posted 9/26/11 11:19 AM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? Posted by ml110 Posted by DramaQueen10 Posted by ml110 LOVE the melting pot!! my DH likes it.... but more to take me there for a nice date night. the meal takes a long time, which i don't know would be good for a birthday party. it would be hard for people to get up and talk bc they need to keep an eye on their food also- you share the pots... which is fine for 2 or 4 people. but to have a bunch of people sharing the pots of cheese or broth might not work out too well.i would look for a steak house or something. i live in NJ.... and for DHs 30th we went for Rodizio. basically, they come around with different kinds of meats on skewers and keep coming until you tell them you're done!!! haha it also comes with rice, spinach, fries, all that kind of stuff. it was very cool- and something different than a normal steak house. not sure if theres anything like that on LI though... that sounds great...where is New Jersey is that? it was in Newark- the restaurant is called Iberia Peninsula. but theres a few rodizio restaurants in that area. we had i think almost 20 people, and they had no problem accomodating us. its definitely a great "guy" meal... and something different. i just went and googled "rodizio long island" and a couple places came up... so you can check that out, too! This place is in Mineola Rodizio |
|
Posted 9/26/11 11:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? ive always wanted to try the Melting Pot... sounds interesting... but i can see how a lot of guys wouldn't be interested. |
|
Posted 9/26/11 11:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? My good friend works at the Melting Pot in Farmingdale. I love it and many of my friends love it as well. But many men don't really like the idea of cooking their own food and if your going with a large group you may get a mixed crowd. I would definitely consider a steakhouse or BBQ or maybe even a dinner cruise. |
|
Posted 9/26/11 12:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? it is def not enough food for my DH. |
|
Posted 9/26/11 1:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? Posted by BellaBoo Posted by ml110 Posted by DramaQueen10 Posted by ml110 LOVE the melting pot!! my DH likes it.... but more to take me there for a nice date night. the meal takes a long time, which i don't know would be good for a birthday party. it would be hard for people to get up and talk bc they need to keep an eye on their food also- you share the pots... which is fine for 2 or 4 people. but to have a bunch of people sharing the pots of cheese or broth might not work out too well.i would look for a steak house or something. i live in NJ.... and for DHs 30th we went for Rodizio. basically, they come around with different kinds of meats on skewers and keep coming until you tell them you're done!!! haha it also comes with rice, spinach, fries, all that kind of stuff. it was very cool- and something different than a normal steak house. not sure if theres anything like that on LI though... that sounds great...where is New Jersey is that? it was in Newark- the restaurant is called Iberia Peninsula. but theres a few rodizio restaurants in that area. we had i think almost 20 people, and they had no problem accomodating us. its definitely a great "guy" meal... and something different. i just went and googled "rodizio long island" and a couple places came up... so you can check that out, too! This place is in Mineola Rodizio I've gone to a place like that on Northern Blvd http://www.greenfieldchurrascaria.com/ |
|
Posted 9/26/11 1:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? Ironically there was one of these where the Melting pot in Farmingdale is....Definitely a Man's meal. |
|
Posted 9/26/11 1:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? DH and I went to the Melting Pot a year ago for my birthday and we both enjoyed the food although DH wasn't thrilled about eating small portions and cooking the food. |
|
Posted 9/26/11 1:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? I would try a Brazilian place like Plataforma Churrascaria |
|
Posted 9/26/11 1:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? Posted by maybeamommy I would try a Brazilian place like Plataforma Churrascaria VERY manly! My DH and his friends went there as part of his bachelor partyITA! Churrascarias are great! |
|
Posted 9/26/11 1:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? Posted by ml110 Posted by DramaQueen10 Posted by ml110 LOVE the melting pot!! my DH likes it.... but more to take me there for a nice date night. the meal takes a long time, which i don't know would be good for a birthday party. it would be hard for people to get up and talk bc they need to keep an eye on their food also- you share the pots... which is fine for 2 or 4 people. but to have a bunch of people sharing the pots of cheese or broth might not work out too well.i would look for a steak house or something. i live in NJ.... and for DHs 30th we went for Rodizio. basically, they come around with different kinds of meats on skewers and keep coming until you tell them you're done!!! haha it also comes with rice, spinach, fries, all that kind of stuff. it was very cool- and something different than a normal steak house. not sure if theres anything like that on LI though... that sounds great...where is New Jersey is that? it was in Newark- the restaurant is called Iberia Peninsula. but theres a few rodizio restaurants in that area. we had i think almost 20 people, and they had no problem accomodating us. its definitely a great "guy" meal... and something different. i just went and googled "rodizio long island" and a couple places came up... so you can check that out, too! Sounds like a Brazilian Steakhouse LOVE LOVE LOVE these places! Hubby does too. I definitely would think that as an awesome, different kind of bday party meal. |
|
Posted 9/26/11 2:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Melting Pot for men? I'm a girl and I really don't like that place too much. #1 I feel like it's unsanitary with people all sticking their eating utensils in the same pot. #2 The cheese part and chocolate part was not bad but the meats/seafood you cook yourself was not very good. It irritated me that I was paying over $40 to cook my own dinner. I don't even cook dinner at home, I'm sure as he!! not paying to cook it! |
|
Posted 9/26/11 3:48 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Does anyone need a $10.00 off Melting Pot coupon? | Ambersmom | 3/22/09 | 0 | Dining In or Out |
| If you've been to the new Melting Pot in Farmingdale... | 4ForMe | 1/14/08 | 16 | Dining In or Out |
| Anyone know where I can get a coupon for Melting Pot in Farmingdale? | cloddy | 1/5/08 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| yum! going to melting pot tonight! | ml110 | 3/21/07 | 8 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Going to The Melting Pot for dinner on Sunday! | Anniegrl | 2/17/06 | 18 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Going to the Melting Pot tonight!! Review added | dandj | 1/19/07 | 21 | Families Helping Families ™ |







So funny- my DH said the same exact thing!



also- you share the pots... which is fine for 2 or 4 people. but to have a bunch of people sharing the pots of cheese or broth might not work out too well.






VERY manly! My DH and his friends went there as part of his bachelor party
