Maybe a dumb question? BF related
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Maybe a dumb question? BF related If it's so much easier for babies to drink from a bottle than your breast, why don't more moms exclusively pump? It also seems like it would help with time management as well... being that DH or someone else could give the baby his/her bottle rather than you always needing to do it. In other words, it's not always you that has to get up in the middle of the night to feed, but the baby is still getting the benefits of breast milk. |
|
Posted 6/17/10 10:52 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related If I had a dh willing to do that, I would definitely pump more! |
|
Posted 6/17/10 10:56 AM
|
|
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related I don't necessarily agree that it is easier for a baby to drink from a bottle compared to the breast. Both my kids were EBF in the beginning and didn't start taking a bottle of BM until around 3 months or later. They did not have a preferance... did great on the boob, did great with a bottle. Didn't care how the milk came, as long as they got it. Message edited 2010-06-17 10:58:17.403000. |
|
Posted 6/17/10 10:56 AM
|
|
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related Posted by jerseypanda I don't necessarily agree that it is easier for a baby to drink from a bottle compared to the breast. Both my kids were EBF in the beginning and didn't start taking a bottle of BM until around 3 months or later. They did not have a preferance... did great on the boob, did great with a bottle. Didn't care how the milk came, as long as they got it. I peraonally find it easier to just BF. No need to make a bottle and have a screaming child waiting for it to be ready. I didn't mind being the one to get up at night and feed DC. DH and I had a routine. He would get up and change the diaper, I would get up and nurse. But I also understand that every baby is different and every parent is different. There may be babies that prefer the bottle. There may be some moms that don't want to shoulder the full responsibility of getting up to feed the baby every 2 hours. To each his own! ETA: From the perspective of time management, I don't find it is more convenient to pump. While someone is giving the baby a bottle, you still have to find time to pump. It seems to me it is more convenient to just BF. Plus, I never got as much milk pumping as DC did nursing. ITA! I personally hate making and giving bottles....and pumping for that matter!!! I would so much rather just whip out my boob! So convenient...easy and fast! I love the time we spend nursing...I actually get jealous when DH feeds DD a bottle! |
|
Posted 6/17/10 11:09 AM
|
|
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related Pumping is ANNOYING. Cleaning all those parts every day, plus you have to get up and pump every few hours anyway just to keep up with the baby's needs and keep your supply up. I found BFing easier than pumping while DH gave the baby a bottle. |
|
Posted 6/17/10 11:12 AM
|
|
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related Posted by jerseypanda I don't necessarily agree that it is easier for a baby to drink from a bottle compared to the breast. Both my kids were EBF in the beginning and didn't start taking a bottle of BM until around 3 months or later. They did not have a preferance... did great on the boob, did great with a bottle. Didn't care how the milk came, as long as they got it. I peraonally find it easier to just BF. No need to make a bottle and have a screaming child waiting for it to be ready. I didn't mind being the one to get up at night and feed DC. DH and I had a routine. He would get up and change the diaper, I would get up and nurse. But I also understand that every baby is different and every parent is different. There may be babies that prefer the bottle. There may be some moms that don't want to shoulder the full responsibility of getting up to feed the baby every 2 hours. To each his own! ETA: From the perspective of time management, I don't find it is more convenient to pump. While someone is giving the baby a bottle, you still have to find time to pump. It seems to me it is more convenient to just BF. Plus, I never got as much milk pumping as DC did nursing. ITA as well. It was def much easier to whip out the boob then have to get up and make a bottle |
|
Posted 6/17/10 11:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related I totally hate pumping. I love BFing, and love that in the beginning, feeding is exclusively between me and my baby. It's a special bonding moment just for us. I didn't find BFing hard with either DD. Maybe the first few days until we got into our groove, found the right positions, and my nipples adjusted. But after those first few days, it was very very easy and convenient. |
|
Posted 6/17/10 11:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related Posted by Dee0522 If it's so much easier for babies to drink from a bottle than your breast, why don't more moms exclusively pump? It also seems like it would help with time management as well... being that DH or someone else could give the baby his/her bottle rather than you always needing to do it. In other words, it's not always you that has to get up in the middle of the night to feed, but the baby is still getting the benefits of breast milk. Thoughts?? I have thought this for a long time. For me, BF was very painful and uncomfortable. DS seemed to struggle with "working" so hard ... it broke my heart I love the idea of EP.
|
|
Posted 6/17/10 11:29 AM
|
|
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related I hate pumping too, but I do it so that DH can join in on the feedings. He loves feeding DS, also since i do exclusively pump my supply is low since a pump doesnt do as good as the baby sucking. In result my supply is really low now and its just a matter of time before I have nothing left. Once i get down to only one bottle a day of BM i am going to stop. By then DS will be 3 months and I will be happy he got that much BM! |
|
Posted 6/17/10 11:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related Posted by Dee0522 If it's so much easier for babies to drink from a bottle than your breast, why don't more moms exclusively pump? It also seems like it would help with time management as well... being that DH or someone else could give the baby his/her bottle rather than you always needing to do it. In other words, it's not always you that has to get up in the middle of the night to feed, but the baby is still getting the benefits of breast milk. Thoughts?? Right, but to maintain your supply you have to pump when a bottle is being given to the baby. So, if DH is up in the middle of the night giving a bottle of BM, you ideally would be pumping. Plus, the pump is the devil I pump at work - that is the only time DS gets a bottle of BM (or if we are in a public place for the day - he is way too curious to nurse without flashing the world) |
|
Posted 6/17/10 11:32 AM
|
|
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related I exclusively pumped for 8 weeks because DS wouldn't latch. I would try putting him on the breast for a few minutes everyday and he would just scream and pull his face away but one day he latched and I've been EBF ever since. |
|
Posted 6/17/10 11:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related I exclusively pump and think it is much easier and quicker than breastfeeding!!! I pump three times a day and get enough for the entire day. I also have a ton of frozen breast milk. I think more people should do it. I was discouraged by a bunch of people including lactation consultants but it works really well. The idea is that one session should be able to provide for 2-4 feeding sessions. If you are going to do this, I would recommend a few things: Message edited 2010-06-17 12:31:10.750000. |
|
Posted 6/17/10 12:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related I hated pumping I felt like a cow. |
|
Posted 6/17/10 12:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related I didn't read all the responses but i'm sure most said the same thing... |
|
Posted 6/17/10 12:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related Posted by CaMacho I didn't read all the responses but i'm sure most said the same thing... Because pumping SUCKS! I loved BFing!!! ITA (as I'm pumping now at work)
|
|
Posted 6/17/10 12:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related Posted by SecretTTCer I exclusively pump and think it is much easier and quicker than breastfeeding!!! I pump three times a day and get enough for the entire day. I also have a ton of frozen breast milk. I think more people should do it. I was discouraged by a bunch of people including lactation consultants but it works really well. The idea is that one session should be able to provide for 2-4 feeding sessions. If you are going to do this, I would recommend a few things: 1. rent a hospital grade pump (I actually rented two, one for me and one for my parents' house) 2. buy an extra set of breast supplies for each pumping session so you don't have to wash them in between sessions. 3. wash each day's worth of accessories and bottles in the dishwasher over night Most people are not this lucky with milk supply. They HAVE to pump every single time the baby eats in order to maintain their supply. If I tried, with any pump, to only pump 3 times a day, I would never be able to 1) keep up with the amount my son eats and 2) maintain supply. All that aside, I despise pumping. For me it is so much easier to just put my DS to the boob, have him eat, and go on with my day. I am the primary care giver since I am a stay at home mom, and the only time it might be more convenient is at night, and when my son woke up 4 times a night my husband did help me out and give him a bottle once a night. Now that he is only up once, I don't need the help. I also LOVE breast feeding. I find it incredibly bonding. And there are no parts to clean! |
|
Posted 6/17/10 12:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related Thanks for all your thoughts ladies! I guess I've just read about a lot of people having issues with BF and the baby preferring the bottle nipple... I wondered why more people don't just pump. I do understand the connection it creates with your baby and that you don't have to mess with bottles and pumps and all that. As a soon-to-be mommy I'm just making sure I research all my options! |
|
Posted 6/17/10 12:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: Maybe a dumb question? BF related Pumping is a pain in the a**. Having to sit there for 15 minutes while you are being milked, cleaning all the parts. Then preparing and cleaning bottles all day long. Its much easier IMO just to put the baby on the boob and be done with it. No matter where you are with the baby, there is always going to be warm milk available! Message edited 2010-06-17 13:03:40.123000. |
|
Posted 6/17/10 1:00 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| This might be a dumb question, but...(hospital attire related) | nicopico13 | 6/1/10 | 20 | Pregnancy |
| Probably a really dumb question (computer related) | Justme777 | 5/25/10 | 4 | Parenting |
| This may be a dumb question. (oil related) | babymakes3 | 9/10/09 | 1 | Home |
| sorry if this is a dumb question (sort of politics related) | TiggerBounce | 6/27/08 | 3 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Dumb question,, not parenting related | pooh12 | 5/2/06 | 3 | Parenting |
| i have a question tmi warning(maybe thyroid related) | luvsbob4603 | 10/9/05 | 9 | Families Helping Families ™ |









I love the idea of EP.







