Should Martin Heidgen be charged with Murder?
| Forum Opinion Poll | ||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Limo crash trial
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] | |
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Limo crash trial the outcome of a lawsuit can impact a law civily, but criminally.... |
Posted 9/12/06 6:39 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by suvenR Posted by Redhead sorry i just am not getting your comparisons at all In one arena, people are judged by the OUTCOME of their actions. In this arena (drunk drivers killing people), they are judged on what their INTENT was. sue...i guess i am looking at the laws i am looking at the definiton of manslaughter Vehicular manslaughter...and that is what he did...TO A TEE. WORD FOR WORD why is it necessary to call it murder because it has a 25 year sentence..? well then lets LOBBY for the sentencing of VMA to change there is NO NEED for the WORDING TO CHANGE i mean come on..... |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial
|
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by Redhead there is NO NEED for the WORDING TO CHANGE i mean come on..... IMO, this is about MUCH MORE than words. INTENT and OUTCOME. Right now, it's okay to kill people as long as you were just irresponsible and stupid. I think we should be held responsible for the damage that we cause as a result of our irresponsible actions. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:42 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by MrsERod Posted by jf1975 have any of you ever read Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment. it's a fascinating look at crime, intent, and punishment (external as well as internal) to kill someone...to take a life, it's haunting. whether he spends 15 years or 25 years in jail or life in jail, the memory and the realization of what he's done will never leave him. not saying that we as a society should be fine with his self-flagellation, but it's just something to think about. He will pay for this crime for the rest of his life, regardless of where he spends it. this is by no means intended to be directed AT you, or to offend you at all... but.... F*** that - so he's "haunted" for the rest of his life. boo hoo hoo. he should have thought about that before he murdered 2 innocent people. at least he'll have a LIFE to live. no worries, I understand what you are saying...but my point is really this people want him to get the max b/c they want him to PAY for what he did. regardless he is going to have his life (whether he spends most of it in jail or not) unless he is given the death penalty...which is NOT going to happen. we want to see him suffer b/c we hurt for what he did...I am just putting it out there...there are worse things than jail. MUCH worse. |
Posted 9/12/06 6:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by Beth1210 ok- I feel better now - he will most likely be convicted of the lesser charge- I wasn't sure that they included it- but I am glad they did you feel better because he'll most likely be convicted of the lesser charge?
|
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by suvenR Posted by Redhead there is NO NEED for the WORDING TO CHANGE i mean come on..... IMO, this is about MUCH MORE than words. INTENT and OUTCOME. Right now, it's okay to kill people as long as you were just irresponsible and stupid. I think we should be held responsible for the damage that we cause as a result of our irresponsible actions. It's not ok to kill someone. It's not like this guy will just walk away free. He'll probably just be convicted of a lesser crime. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by MrsS2005 It's not ok to kill someone. It's not like this guy will just walk away free. He'll probably just be convicted of a lesser crime. this is true. At least there will be some punishment. IMO, not enough, but at least some |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by suvenR Posted by Redhead there is NO NEED for the WORDING TO CHANGE i mean come on..... IMO, this is about MUCH MORE than words. INTENT and OUTCOME. Right now, it's okay to kill people as long as you were just irresponsible and stupid. I think we should be held responsible for the damage that we cause as a result of our irresponsible actions. why do you care what it is called sue? and right now...it isn't ok to kill anyone...regardless... you are arguing over having the name murder...and i think that is silly as long as the end result is JAIL and if it was comparable to a murder punishment.. who cares... then you are fighting for the word you are arguing from your heart...not your head and although i understand and i think that is fruitless and an utter waste of time and energy Message edited 2006-09-12 18:47:59.437000. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:45 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by suvenR Posted by Redhead there is NO NEED for the WORDING TO CHANGE i mean come on..... IMO, this is about MUCH MORE than words. INTENT and OUTCOME. Right now, it's okay to kill people as long as you were just irresponsible and stupid. I think we should be held responsible for the damage that we cause as a result of our irresponsible actions. the law doesn't say it's ok to kill someone. the law says "you did something that was reckless and cause the death of an innocent party. while you did not INTEND to cause their death, your actions are so irresponsible and are NOT excusable...therefore, you will be imprisoned for X amount of time." there is a punishment...he will get one. perhaps the lobby should be for DRUNK drivers convicted of vehicular manslaughter to have STIFFER sentences...have the drunken state be a mitigating factor to STIFFEN, not LESSEN the crime. |
Posted 9/12/06 6:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Intent is extremely important. People die at the hands of others all the time. If we only looked at the outcome, someone who accidentally killed someone would be treated the same as someone who planned out a cold blooded killing. Although people died in both situations, they're not the same and shouldn't be compared in terms of punishment. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by suvenR Posted by Beth1210 ok- I feel better now - he will most likely be convicted of the lesser charge- I wasn't sure that they included it- but I am glad they did you feel better because he'll most likely be convicted of the lesser charge? you are twisting my words- and part of the posting was that me and few other people were concerned about him GETTING OFF- b/c the lesser charge was not included- if the jury did not feel the DA meet the requirments for murder and the manslaughter was not an option- then he would be found not guilty Message edited 2006-09-12 18:48:28.200000. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by Beth1210 Posted by suvenR Posted by Beth1210 ok- I feel better now - he will most likely be convicted of the lesser charge- I wasn't sure that they included it- but I am glad they did you feel better because he'll most likely be convicted of the lesser charge? you are twisting my words- and part of the posting was that me and few other people were concerned about him GETTING OFF- b/c the lesser charge was not included- if the jury did not feel the DA meet the requirments for murder and the manslaughter was not an option- then he would be found not guilty exactly... and yes i do think he should be convicted of the crime he committed and that is VMS |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by jf1975 Posted by suvenR Posted by Redhead there is NO NEED for the WORDING TO CHANGE i mean come on..... IMO, this is about MUCH MORE than words. INTENT and OUTCOME. Right now, it's okay to kill people as long as you were just irresponsible and stupid. I think we should be held responsible for the damage that we cause as a result of our irresponsible actions. the law doesn't say it's ok to kill someone. the law says "you did something that was reckless and cause the death of an innocent party. while you did not INTEND to cause their death, your actions are so irresponsible and are NOT excusable...therefore, you will be imprisoned for X amount of time." there is a punishment...he will get one. perhaps the lobby should be for DRUNK drivers convicted of vehicular manslaughter to have STIFFER sentences...have the drunken state be a mitigating factor to STIFFEN, not LESSEN the crime. I completely agree. We should have harsher penalties for drunk drivers who kill people, but it shouldn't be called murder. I also think there should be some type of sentencing enhancement system for drunk drivers that give even harsher penalties to those who have previously been arrested for drunk driving. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:50 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by MrsS2005 Posted by jf1975 Posted by suvenR Posted by Redhead there is NO NEED for the WORDING TO CHANGE i mean come on..... IMO, this is about MUCH MORE than words. INTENT and OUTCOME. Right now, it's okay to kill people as long as you were just irresponsible and stupid. I think we should be held responsible for the damage that we cause as a result of our irresponsible actions. the law doesn't say it's ok to kill someone. the law says "you did something that was reckless and cause the death of an innocent party. while you did not INTEND to cause their death, your actions are so irresponsible and are NOT excusable...therefore, you will be imprisoned for X amount of time." there is a punishment...he will get one. perhaps the lobby should be for DRUNK drivers convicted of vehicular manslaughter to have STIFFER sentences...have the drunken state be a mitigating factor to STIFFEN, not LESSEN the crime. I completely agree. We should have harsher penalties for drunk drivers who kill people, but it shouldn't be called murder. I also think there should be some type of sentencing enhancement system for drunk drivers that give even harsher penalties to those who have previously been arrested for drunk driving. this is the crux of it...and what we should be fighting for/care about. the rest is what Red said...semantics. |
Posted 9/12/06 6:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial i agree Message edited 2006-09-12 18:59:53.650000. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial the one tidbit that might be a biggie in swaying the conviction to murder as certain statements he "supposively" made after the accident |
|
Posted 9/12/06 7:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by Redhead Posted by MrsERod bottom line is he drank, and then proceeded to get behind the wheel. 2 innocent people were killed because of his careless disregard for human life. to me, that IS murder. and if it were my child or family member, God forbid, I'd pushing for nothing LESS than Murder in the first degree. and if the law needed to be changed to make it as clear as day - then I'd spend every waking moment of my life, lobbying for that legislation to be made. but the bottom line is what he did is VEHICLUAR MANSLAUGHTER by law Unfortunate in this case since it doesn't seem to fit the crime, but it is the case. Theresa- many hugs for having to relive your mom's death again today
|
|
Posted 9/12/06 7:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by Beth1210 Posted by suvenR Posted by Beth1210 ok- I feel better now - he will most likely be convicted of the lesser charge- I wasn't sure that they included it- but I am glad they did you feel better because he'll most likely be convicted of the lesser charge? you are twisting my words- and part of the posting was that me and few other people were concerned about him GETTING OFF- b/c the lesser charge was not included- if the jury did not feel the DA meet the requirments for murder and the manslaughter was not an option- then he would be found not guilty I did not twists your words. I questioned why you said what you said. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 7:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by suvenR Posted by Beth1210 Posted by suvenR Posted by Beth1210 ok- I feel better now - he will most likely be convicted of the lesser charge- I wasn't sure that they included it- but I am glad they did you feel better because he'll most likely be convicted of the lesser charge? you are twisting my words- and part of the posting was that me and few other people were concerned about him GETTING OFF- b/c the lesser charge was not included- if the jury did not feel the DA meet the requirments for murder and the manslaughter was not an option- then he would be found not guilty I did not twists your words. I questioned why you said what you said. I am saying I feel better that the lesser charge is included- with out the posting about the lesser charge my post is taken out of context |
|
Posted 9/12/06 7:40 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] | |
















