Should Martin Heidgen be charged with Murder?
| Forum Opinion Poll | ||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Limo crash trial
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
|
Re: Limo crash trial bottom line is |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:15 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by MrsERod bottom line is he drank, and then proceeded to get behind the wheel. 2 innocent people were killed because of his careless disregard for human life. to me, that IS murder. and if it were my child or family member, God forbid, I'd pushing for nothing LESS than Murder in the first degree. and if the law needed to be changed to make it as clear as day - then I'd spend every waking moment of my life, lobbying for that legislation to be made. but the bottom line is what he did is VEHICLUAR MANSLAUGHTER by law |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial I think you have to look at how the law defines it. I think he should be charged with murder only if they can prove it. I would rather see him get convicted of manslaughter with serious jail time than see the case have a mistrial. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by Redhead so should all the people who are caught via check points for DD they should also be charged with murder? ![]() again....there was NO INTENT on his part to kill somene that night regardless IMO- it doesn't matter whether or not he intended to kill someone. His actions caused the deaths of 2 innocent people. Once someone is dead because of a drunk driver, the driver should be charged with murder. But, no, if no one is hurt, there obviously wouldn't be a murder charge. But, IMO, there should be a prison sentence. Not jail- PRISON. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by Redhead Posted by MrsERod bottom line is he drank, and then proceeded to get behind the wheel. 2 innocent people were killed because of his careless disregard for human life. to me, that IS murder. and if it were my child or family member, God forbid, I'd pushing for nothing LESS than Murder in the first degree. and if the law needed to be changed to make it as clear as day - then I'd spend every waking moment of my life, lobbying for that legislation to be made. but the bottom line is what he did is VEHICLUAR MANSLAUGHTER by law then the law needs to be changed IMO - he MURDERED those 2 people by driving drunk. I don't see it as anything else but Murder. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by dpli I think you have to look at how the law defines it. I think he should be charged with murder only if they can prove it. I would rather see him get convicted of manslaughter with serious jail time than see the case have a mistrial. very GOOD point!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! because despite the outrage they jury will be told they have to decide based on the actual DEF of murder NOT what they think in their hearts it should be |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by MrsERod Posted by Redhead Posted by MrsERod bottom line is he drank, and then proceeded to get behind the wheel. 2 innocent people were killed because of his careless disregard for human life. to me, that IS murder. and if it were my child or family member, God forbid, I'd pushing for nothing LESS than Murder in the first degree. and if the law needed to be changed to make it as clear as day - then I'd spend every waking moment of my life, lobbying for that legislation to be made. but the bottom line is what he did is VEHICLUAR MANSLAUGHTER by law then the law needs to be changed IMO - he MURDERED those 2 people by driving drunk. I don't see it as anything else but Murder. maybe but i guess i just wouldn't care what the hell it is called as long as the end result is that he is in jail for a long time isn't that the real goal here? or is it just semantics? |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by Redhead as long as the end result is that he is in jail for a long time agreed. but unfortunately, the sentence for VMS isn't long enough especially since 1. he's a repeat offender 2. he's still young enough to serve the entire sentence and STILL live a long life. can't say the same for the limo driver, and certainly not for the little girl!
|
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial 15 years is kinda long Message edited 2006-09-12 18:27:13.590000. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by MrsERod bottom line is he drank, and then proceeded to get behind the wheel. 2 innocent people were killed because of his careless disregard for human life. to me, that IS murder. and if it were my child or family member, God forbid, I'd pushing for nothing LESS than Murder in the first degree. and if the law needed to be changed to make it as clear as day - then I'd spend every waking moment of my life, lobbying for that legislation to be made. He'd never be convicted of first degree murder. There's no premeditation and no special circumstances. One of the defendant's strongest defenses to a charge of second degree murder is that he was so drunk, he had diminished capacity and couldn't form the "malice aforethought" or intent required of murder. Based on the recent appellate decisions, merely showing that the defendant had a BAC equal to three times the allowable limit and drove the wrong way down the street is not enough to prove second degree murder. The prosecutors must show that he had a depraved state of mind. His actions are not enough-he must have a "guilty mind." |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by suvenR Posted by Redhead so should all the people who are caught via check points for DD they should also be charged with murder? ![]() again....there was NO INTENT on his part to kill somene that night regardless IMO- it doesn't matter whether or not he intended to kill someone. His actions caused the deaths of 2 innocent people. . But sue... it does matter by LAW... THAT IS THE DIFFERENCE |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by Redhead Posted by dpli I think you have to look at how the law defines it. I think he should be charged with murder only if they can prove it. I would rather see him get convicted of manslaughter with serious jail time than see the case have a mistrial. very GOOD point!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! because despite the outrage they jury will be told they have to decide based on the actual DEF of murder NOT what they think in their hearts it should be this was my point- but you said it so much better! I just hope they include the lesser charge- they might be leaving the jury in a bad situation he should go to jail for a long time - regardless of the actual charge- but the charge needs to fit the crime- or he might not get convicted |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by MrsS2005 Posted by MrsERod bottom line is he drank, and then proceeded to get behind the wheel. 2 innocent people were killed because of his careless disregard for human life. to me, that IS murder. and if it were my child or family member, God forbid, I'd pushing for nothing LESS than Murder in the first degree. and if the law needed to be changed to make it as clear as day - then I'd spend every waking moment of my life, lobbying for that legislation to be made. He'd never be convicted of first degree murder. There's no premeditation and no special circumstances. One of the defendant's strongest defenses to a charge of second degree murder is that he was so drunk, he had diminished capacity and couldn't form the "malice aforethought" or intent required of murder. Based on the recent appellate decisions, merely showing that the defendant had a BAC equal to three times the allowable limit and drove the wrong way down the street is not enough to prove second degree murder. The prosecutors must show that he had a depraved state of mind. His actions are not enough-he must have a "guilty mind." this is exactly why i feel the law should be changed. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:30 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Limo crash trial have any of you ever read Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment. Message edited 2006-09-12 18:32:54.990000. |
Posted 9/12/06 6:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by Redhead But sue... it does matter by LAW... THAT IS THE DIFFERENCE Laws change. So should this one. See, this is why I like corporate law. It doesn't matter if you INTEND to harass someone- it's the OUTCOME that determines how bad the action was. Too bad we can't apply the same theory when someone ends up dead. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial if people want to really make a difference |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by Redhead trying to turn it into something it clearly isn't...is not only fruitless, it is a waste of tax payers money and it will be at the expense of the FAMILY... the outcome of a lawsuit can impact the law... are you saying that you're worried that this isn't the lawsuit that should be used to impact the law, or just that verdicts of lawsuits won't change the law? |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial this law did change recently - drunk drivers used to get off with 1 year in jail max |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by suvenR Posted by Redhead But sue... it does matter by LAW... THAT IS THE DIFFERENCE Laws change. So should this one. See, this is why I like corporate law. It doesn't matter if you INTEND to harass someone- it's the OUTCOME that determines how bad the action was. Too bad we can't apply the same theory when someone ends up dead. sue... sorry i just am not getting your comparisons at all maybe the laws should change.. but it hasn't.. we have VMS....that is what he did, that is what the law states there is a distiction in the eyes of the law between manslaughter and murder and when the law does change...then so be it but for now...it hasn't |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by suvenR Posted by Redhead trying to turn it into something it clearly isn't...is not only fruitless, it is a waste of tax payers money and it will be at the expense of the FAMILY... the outcome of a lawsuit can impact the law... are you saying that you're worried that this isn't the lawsuit that should be used to impact the law, or just that verdicts of lawsuits won't change the law? no i am worried that because there is a VMS charge the jury will have to say it isn't MURDER because what he did THUS FAR...is NOT MURDER in the eyes of the law |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by Beth1210 Posted by Redhead Posted by dpli I think you have to look at how the law defines it. I think he should be charged with murder only if they can prove it. I would rather see him get convicted of manslaughter with serious jail time than see the case have a mistrial. very GOOD point!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! because despite the outrage they jury will be told they have to decide based on the actual DEF of murder NOT what they think in their hearts it should be this was my point- but you said it so much better! I just hope they include the lesser charge- they might be leaving the jury in a bad situation he should go to jail for a long time - regardless of the actual charge- but the charge needs to fit the crime- or he might not get convicted I found this in an article: If convicted of murder, Heidgen could be sentenced to 25 years to life in prison. Jurors also can opt to convict on second-degree manslaughter or criminally negligent homicide, which carry lesser sentences. It would be irresponsible not to include the lesser charges. I'm pretty sure he'll be convicted of something, but probably not murder. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by jf1975 have any of you ever read Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment. it's a fascinating look at crime, intent, and punishment (external as well as internal) to kill someone...to take a life, it's haunting. whether he spends 15 years or 25 years in jail or life in jail, the memory and the realization of what he's done will never leave him. not saying that we as a society should be fine with his self-flagellation, but it's just something to think about. He will pay for this crime for the rest of his life, regardless of where he spends it. this is by no means intended to be directed AT you, or to offend you at all... but.... F*** that - so he's "haunted" for the rest of his life. boo hoo hoo. he should have thought about that before he murdered 2 innocent people. at least he'll have a LIFE to live. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by Redhead sorry i just am not getting your comparisons at all In one arena, people are judged by the OUTCOME of their actions. In this arena (drunk drivers killing people), they are judged on what their INTENT was. |
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by MrsS2005 If convicted of murder, Heidgen could be sentenced to 25 years to life in prison. Jurors also can opt to convict on second-degree manslaughter or criminally negligent homicide, which carry lesser sentences. It would be irresponsible not to include the lesser charges. I'm pretty sure he'll be convicted of something, but probably not murder. thank God
|
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Limo crash trial Posted by MrsS2005 I found this in an article: If convicted of murder, Heidgen could be sentenced to 25 years to life in prison. Jurors also can opt to convict on second-degree manslaughter or criminally negligent homicide, which carry lesser sentences. It would be irresponsible not to include the lesser charges. I'm pretty sure he'll be convicted of something, but probably not murder. Excellent!!! let's hope the jury convicts him of murder!!!
|
|
Posted 9/12/06 6:38 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |


















