Issues with tenant
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
Issues with tenant I have a tenant that wants to break her lease early, she bounced her check for March's rent and has the intention of living out her security. Does anyone have any experience in suing a tenant, or any suggestions for a lawyer. Thanks |
|
Posted 3/11/14 6:32 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Issues with tenant What does your lease says about breaking a lease? |
|
Posted 3/12/14 6:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant No experience per se but maybe it would just be easy and save you more money in the long run to get another tenant and be done with her. She sounds like a dirtbag and if she has no money she could really damage your place in retaliation KWIM? I say cut your losses. There are good tenants out there especially in this housing market. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 7:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee No experience per se but maybe it would just be easy and save you more money in the long run to get another tenant and be done with her. She sounds like a dirtbag and if she has no money she could really damage your place in retaliation KWIM? I say cut your losses. There are good tenants out there especially in this housing market. I agree with this. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 7:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee No experience per se but maybe it would just be easy and save you more money in the long run to get another tenant and be done with her. She sounds like a dirtbag and if she has no money she could really damage your place in retaliation KWIM? I say cut your losses. There are good tenants out there especially in this housing market. Why does she sound like a dirtbag? Maybe she is down on her luck and realizes she can't afford the place anymore. She could be trying to help the OP by getting out of the lease so she can rent it to a person that can pay rent on time. I am actually shocked you made that comment, since you are a social worker (I know this cause you mention it in 90% of your posts) and should be sympathetic to people. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 7:45 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant Posted by SlurpeeDad Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee No experience per se but maybe it would just be easy and save you more money in the long run to get another tenant and be done with her. She sounds like a dirtbag and if she has no money she could really damage your place in retaliation KWIM? I say cut your losses. There are good tenants out there especially in this housing market. Why does she sound like a dirtbag? Maybe she is down on her luck and realizes she can't afford the place anymore. She could be trying to help the OP by getting out of the lease so she can rent it to a person that can pay rent on time. I am actually shocked you made that comment, since you are a social worker (I know this cause you mention it in 90% of your posts) and should be sympathetic to people. maybe that is a strong word but it sounds like she was just assuming this is okay. And FWIW there are people who are down on their luck that are still dirtbags about things and act entitled. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 8:07 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant PS she said she bounced a check already. Aren't you the same dude who's always going after teachers? I guess it's time to go after social workers. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 8:11 AM
|
|
|
Issues with tenant Just let her go. The money is not worth the potential hassle. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 8:15 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee PS she said she bounced a check already. Aren't you the same dude who's always going after teachers? I guess it's time to go after social workers. I'm not stirring the pot or 'going after social workers', I just don't agree with your assumption. You have never bounced a check, ever in your life? I guess one mistake makes you a dirtbag. Although, I should know not to get into a disagreement with you because you get all uptight when someone doesn't agree with you or calls you out on something. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 8:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant The law is in her favor - if you try to even sue her, she could potentially live there for up to 6 months w/out rent. I agree about cutting your loses and getting her out ASAP. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 9:04 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant Posted by MrsMerlot The law is in her favor - if you try to even sue her, she could potentially live there for up to 6 months w/out rent. I agree about cutting your loses and getting her out ASAP. THIS something similar happened with my sister and the courts said even with an eviction notice they could live there 6 months rent free let her out of her lease, let her live out her security and find someone else |
|
Posted 3/12/14 9:22 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant Posted by SlurpeeDad Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee PS she said she bounced a check already. Aren't you the same dude who's always going after teachers? I guess it's time to go after social workers. I'm not stirring the pot or 'going after social workers', I just don't agree with your assumption. You have never bounced a check, ever in your life? I guess one mistake makes you a dirtbag. Although, I should know not to get into a disagreement with you because you get all uptight when someone doesn't agree with you or calls you out on something. I've never bounced a check in my life & I've made plenty of mistakes. The tenant is someone who doesn't intend to pay their rent & ride out their security deposit. That's not a "mistake". It's an ongoing issue that the tenant is choosing to ignore while taking advantage of the situation. I also equate that with dirtbag - even if they're down on their luck. OP - I'd check the laws in your area & what your lease says. You may wind up spending more time & money in court than you want. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 9:27 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant Posted by MrsMerlot The law is in her favor - if you try to even sue her, she could potentially live there for up to 6 months w/out rent. I agree about cutting your loses and getting her out ASAP. The only thing you could possibly go after her with is in fact she does do any damage to the property and it exceeds the security. ie: let's say there's damage, since she's "using" that last month security as her rent, then you won't be compensated for those damages. Its true, its really not worth it.... Sounds more like shes in a bind than a dirtbag. If she was never a problem before then id just try and find a new tenant. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 9:29 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant Posted by nrthshgrl I've never bounced a check in my life & I've made plenty of mistakes. The tenant is someone who doesn't intend to pay their rent & ride out their security deposit. That's not a "mistake". It's an ongoing issue that the tenant is choosing to ignore while taking advantage of the situation. I also equate that with dirtbag - even if they're down on their luck. OP - I'd check the laws in your area & what your lease says. You may wind up spending more time & money in court than you want. The OP said she bounced a check in March and did not mention it being an ongoing problem. If she bounced her last check and now wants to use the security deposit as her last months rent, she obviously is trying to make it as right as she possibly can. I don't see what situation she is 'taking advantage of.' |
|
Posted 3/12/14 9:52 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant Posted by AngnShaun Posted by MrsMerlot The law is in her favor - if you try to even sue her, she could potentially live there for up to 6 months w/out rent. I agree about cutting your loses and getting her out ASAP. The only thing you could possibly go after her with is in fact she does do any damage to the property and it exceeds the security. ie: let's say there's damage, since she's "using" that last month security as her rent, then you won't be compensated for those damages. Its true, its really not worth it.... Sounds more like shes in a bind than a dirtbag. If she was never a problem before then id just try and find a new tenant. Agreed. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 9:53 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant Posted by MrsMerlot The law is in her favor - if you try to even sue her, she could potentially live there for up to 6 months w/out rent. I agree about cutting your loses and getting her out ASAP. The only thing you could possibly go after her with is in fact she does do any damage to the property and it exceeds the security. ie: let's say there's damage, since she's "using" that last month security as her rent, then you won't be compensated for those damages. I agree with this, unless there is damage, I would let it go and find a new tenant. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 10:08 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant Posted by SlurpeeDad Posted by nrthshgrl I've never bounced a check in my life & I've made plenty of mistakes. The tenant is someone who doesn't intend to pay their rent & ride out their security deposit. That's not a "mistake". It's an ongoing issue that the tenant is choosing to ignore while taking advantage of the situation. I also equate that with dirtbag - even if they're down on their luck. OP - I'd check the laws in your area & what your lease says. You may wind up spending more time & money in court than you want. The OP said she bounced a check in March and did not mention it being an ongoing problem. If she bounced her last check and now wants to use the security deposit as her last months rent, she obviously is trying to make it as right as she possibly can. I don't see what situation she is 'taking advantage of.'
|
|
Posted 3/12/14 10:08 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant Posted by MrsMerlot The law is in her favor - if you try to even sue her, she could potentially live there for up to 6 months w/out rent. I agree about cutting your loses and getting her out ASAP. The only thing you could possibly go after her with is in fact she does do any damage to the property and it exceeds the security. ie: let's say there's damage, since she's "using" that last month security as her rent, then you won't be compensated for those damages. As of right now there is no security deposit. If she decides she wants to use the security as rent then it is what it is. What I would do is go talk to her. Find out what she needs. Find out when she is leaving. I would absolutely have her sign a document saying "I am breaking my lease, the landlord is ok with it and wont penalize me, and this is the date I am leaving, and I give permission to the landlord to show the apartment while I still live here in accordance with my main lease (giving her notice etc)." (or something like that) This way you have a date in writing. She has security that you wont sue her for rent for breaking the lease, and she has SOME motivation to not trash the apartment. If she wants to get out treat her with kindness to protect your asset. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 10:40 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant Posted by Paramount Posted by MrsMerlot The law is in her favor - if you try to even sue her, she could potentially live there for up to 6 months w/out rent. I agree about cutting your loses and getting her out ASAP. The only thing you could possibly go after her with is in fact she does do any damage to the property and it exceeds the security. ie: let's say there's damage, since she's "using" that last month security as her rent, then you won't be compensated for those damages. As of right now there is no security deposit. If she decides she wants to use the security as rent then it is what it is. What I would do is go talk to her. Find out what she needs. Find out when she is leaving. I would absolutely have her sign a document saying "I am breaking my lease, the landlord is ok with it and wont penalize me, and this is the date I am leaving, and I give permission to the landlord to show the apartment while I still live here in accordance with my main lease (giving her notice etc)." (or something like that) This way you have a date in writing. She has security that you wont sue her for rent for breaking the lease, and she has SOME motivation to not trash the apartment. If she wants to get out treat her with kindness to protect your asset. . I agree with this. And I still stand by my initial assessment. If the OP is already coming on here frustrated and talking about getting a lawyer, it doesn't sound like a good situation. The fact of what I do for a living has nothing to do with my opinion so there's no need to get personal on here but again Slurpee Dad I know that's how YOU are in most of your posts with people. I also have never bounced a check either so don't ASSume. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 4:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee Posted by Paramount Posted by MrsMerlot The law is in her favor - if you try to even sue her, she could potentially live there for up to 6 months w/out rent. I agree about cutting your loses and getting her out ASAP. The only thing you could possibly go after her with is in fact she does do any damage to the property and it exceeds the security. ie: let's say there's damage, since she's "using" that last month security as her rent, then you won't be compensated for those damages. As of right now there is no security deposit. If she decides she wants to use the security as rent then it is what it is. What I would do is go talk to her. Find out what she needs. Find out when she is leaving. I would absolutely have her sign a document saying "I am breaking my lease, the landlord is ok with it and wont penalize me, and this is the date I am leaving, and I give permission to the landlord to show the apartment while I still live here in accordance with my main lease (giving her notice etc)." (or something like that) This way you have a date in writing. She has security that you wont sue her for rent for breaking the lease, and she has SOME motivation to not trash the apartment. If she wants to get out treat her with kindness to protect your asset. . I agree with this. And I still stand by my initial assessment. If the OP is already coming on here frustrated and talking about getting a lawyer, it doesn't sound like a good situation. The fact of what I do for a living has nothing to do with my opinion so there's no need to get personal on here but again Slurpee Dad I know that's how YOU are in most of your posts with people. I also have never bounced a check either so don't ASSume. What you do for a living comes up in almost every thread you post in so I'm sure it has something to do with your opinion. The OP is doing the right thing in trying to find out what her options are, and that may mean contacting a lawyer. I still don't think it makes the tenant a dirtbag. And I have bounced a check, I was 18 and felt awful and wanted to make it right to the person receiving the check. I guess I was a dirtbag then. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 8:40 PM
|
|
|
Issues with tenant I def don't think bouncing a check means you're a dirtbag. My dh had his car stolen, with our bank info inside. I forgot that we put a stop on everything and wrote a bad check to our complex. It bounced. I am not a dirtbag. Shit happens in life and you sometimes fall behind and can't catch up. Happened to dh and I when we were first married and I lost my job. We had to break a lease and move in with his mom until we landed back on our feet. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 8:49 PM
|
|
|
Issues with tenant I didn't read all the responses but I have/have had tenants and I would NEVER EVER let them live out the last month with security. It even states this in standard leases. Reason being is what if she's damaged something? Now you have to go after her for money. |
|
Posted 3/12/14 9:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant I agree with the the poster above that under normal circumstances I wouldn't let anyone live out their security however in this case especially since she just bounced a check I would just let her live it out. It will be cheaper in the end then having to pay eviction fees etc. Sounds like she is down and out on her luck and thankfully she already gave you a warning. It's not 100% right but it could be much much worse (i.e. not paying her rent then you having to legally evict her) |
|
Posted 3/12/14 9:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant As a landlord, I can tell you it is not worth your time and aggravation. Just let her go. |
|
Posted 3/13/14 12:00 AM
|
|
|
Re: Issues with tenant Posted by FirstMate As a landlord, I can tell you it is not worth your time and aggravation. Just let her go. This. I am also a landlord and it is not worth the time to go after this. If the tenant is starting to bounce checks and requested to break lease, there is a issue going on and most likely you'd end up bearing the financial brunt of it if you made them stay. |
|
Posted 3/13/14 8:37 AM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tenant Issues - I need some assistance | KPtoys | 10/24/08 | 5 | Home |
| Office Bathroom Issues | LadyMaravilla | 8/16/05 | 29 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Stomach issues with dieting? | nov04libride | 8/4/05 | 9 | Diet & Fitness |
| Mom Issues. | monkeybride | 8/1/05 | 6 | Pregnancy |
| Car Issues | Redhead | 6/10/05 | 11 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Leash Issues | Redhead | 5/11/05 | 14 | Pets |















