Is this a fair statement?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >>

stinger
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

4971 total posts

Name:

Is this a fair statement?

I was chatting with someone today and the topic of excercising came up. She made a statement about how there is no reason a SAHM of school-aged kids should be "fat" (I guess she meant unfit/out of shape/overweight). That they of all people have no excuse to NOT workout. I thought it was a bit generalized, but then based on my own situation (single working full time mom who makes time to workout) I can see what she means. But I still think it's a bit judgemental since you don't know every person's situations.

Posted 2/20/12 9:12 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

ModDot
PUMPKIN ALL THE THINGS

Member since 8/11

2196 total posts

Name:
Trissy

Re: Is this a fair statement?

I think it depends on the person, what their schedule is like and what their priorities are

Posted 2/20/12 9:18 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this a fair statement?

It's hard to see anyone overweight, just as it's hard to see anyone as a smoker, on drugs, etcetera. It's hard to see people live a life that is detrimental to their own health, especially with all that we know now.

It's even more frustrating to hear someone whine about being a diabetic, having swollen ankles, knee problems, etc, when they merely need to lose weight and eat right, but they never put down a donut or deny a slice of cake.

I have people like this in my life and it's infuriating but I think for some food is an addiction and needs to be treated as such. I think it stems a lot deeper than just the desire for food; I think they are feeding something else that is lacking in their life or food is being used as a medication to ease the pain of something.

I can see where she is coming from, but I also see where everyone, SAHM or not, should be working out and eating right.

That said, you don't know if the person that you see as overweight actually is in the process of losing weight and has lost a great deal already. When I go to the gym I see many overweight people, and I commend them. They are there, doing their thing, trying to reach a goal.

Message edited 2012-02-20 21:29:45.113000.

Posted 2/20/12 9:20 PM
 

LoveDayLove
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

1250 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this a fair statement?

I think the issue is when you look at someone you don't know their story. Maybe thy were anorexic but had trouble getting pregnant gained weight and have struggled to get it off or maybe they have lost a bunch of weight but have a
lot more to lose. I commend SAHM and SAHD because there job is just as hard as people who go to an office for 40 hour a week.

Posted 2/20/12 9:30 PM
 

cds58019
The loves of my life :)

Member since 6/08

4276 total posts

Name:
Candice

Re: Is this a fair statement?

I can kind of see her point. The way my life is now, I should be able to exercise at least a few times a week once the kids are of school age. However I dont know have things might change by then either.

But again that's just my life. Everyone is different so it wouldn't apply for every SAHM.

Posted 2/20/12 9:31 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this a fair statement?

I can only speak for myself but I've said to myself that once my DD is in school I honestly don't have a reason to not go to the gym every morning. But that's just me and based on what I know my days will look like without DD. Hopefully when the time comes I drag my lazy butt off the couch and go!! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon .............that's the plan anyway!! Chat Icon

Posted 2/20/12 9:34 PM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: Is this a fair statement?

IMO, no its not a fair statement. As a pp said, just because they are home doesn't mean they can hit the gym every day or every other.

They could be caring for a sick parent, or grandparent. They may just not have the funds for a gym.

Posted 2/20/12 9:36 PM
 

stinger
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

4971 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this a fair statement?

Posted by saraH

IMO, no its not a fair statement. As a pp said, just because they are home doesn't mean they can hit the gym every day or every other.

They could be caring for a sick parent, or grandparent. They may just not have the funds for a gym.



Maybe the caregiving part, but you don't need a gym! I jog for cardio and work out using videos in my living room. I don't have a gym membership.

Posted 2/20/12 9:38 PM
 

stinger
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

4971 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this a fair statement?

Posted by retrochick

I think it depends on the person, what their schedule is like and what their priorities are



Yes very true about priorities. I know SAHMs who cook amazing, elaborate meals, others who spend hours at the school on PTA committees, and others whose homes are spotless!

I didn't think the statement meant that they weren't doing anything, just that they, if anyone, has *some* time to take care of their health.

Posted 2/20/12 9:41 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this a fair statement?

I don't think there is any reason - outside of a specific health issues (i.e. thyroid issues) that anyone should be fat.

For a SAHM, I think it's a fair statement.
While I'm not a SAHM, here I am. Fat.

I can say that I have no time to excercise but I'm on LIF. I watch TV. I sleep until 7am. All times I can be exercising.

I can make every excuse in the book as to why I'm fat but the fact is I eat more than I use.


Posted 2/20/12 10:04 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Is this a fair statement?

If it is a persons priority to be in shape they will be, period. If a person SAHM or not does not make that one of the most important things in their life then they won't be.

By the way I think it is a pretty stupid thing to say Chat Icon I mean maybe the free a time a SAHM has they want to dedicate to a hobby other then working out. I am a SAHM for the last 4 months and I have been working out more than pre baby bc I want to get back to my pregnancy weight, but I always worked out not just now that I am a SAHM.

Message edited 2012-02-20 22:15:56.800000.

Posted 2/20/12 10:13 PM
 

prunepie
LIF Adult

Member since 7/06

4357 total posts

Name:
jennifer

Re: Is this a fair statement?

Posted by cncforever

It's hard to see anyone overweight, just as it's hard to see anyone as a smoker, on drugs, etcetera. It's hard to see people live a life that is detrimental to their own health, especially with all that we know now.

It's even more frustrating to hear someone whine about being a diabetic, having swollen ankles, knee problems, etc, when they merely need to lose weight and eat right, but they never put down a donut or deny a slice of cake.

I have people like this in my life and it's infuriating but I think for some food is an addiction and needs to be treated as such. I think it stems a lot deeper than just the desire for food; I think they are feeding something else that is lacking in their life or food is being used as a medication to ease the pain of something.

I can see where she is coming from, but I also see where everyone, SAHM or not, should be working out and eating right.

That said, you don't know if the person that you see as overweight actually is in the process of losing weight and has lost a great deal already. When I go to the gym I see many overweight people, and I commend them. They are there, doing their thing, trying to reach a goal.





its sooo hard for me to read this post. makes me so sad.

i am preggo now so super sensitive so ..please not trying to start anything :) the sentance you wrote that says..."they merely need to lose weight....etcetcetc"

to me that sentance seems so dismissive or maybe naive i guess.

i have been skinny fat and inbetween. there was a period in my life due to depression that i ate whatever...but i must say..... that in general i am much more conscious of health and wellness than most of my thin counterparts.

i think my defense of being overweight is this. YOU the outsider can see the weight etc.

what YOU/US DONT SEE in so many thin people is that....yes many are health conscious...but ooooh myyy gawwwd i cant tell you how many of my friends drink like fish on the weekend...take over the counter diet aids....will eat fast food non stop for a few days and then starve themselves for the next few...
and dannng they look hot and good...but are they really healthy?


its veryy hard to judge what is really going on with ANYONE.

wether someone is THIN or OVERWEIGHT.

sad thing is i am fat now...but mentally in a much better place about loving myself and not binging/purging/, drinking ...than i ever was when i was thin/hot/etc.

i am constantly in awe of those people who are FIT. THIN to me means nothing...cause like i stated you can be unwell and thin.

i love those bodies who are toned..you can tell they hit the gym.....its awesome..but even then...because i know too much about mental illness and body dysmorphic disorder..that i try not to applaud too loudly because you just never know what goes on behind closed doors


i just want everyone i know to be happy...truly deep down. and if we all know if our hearts we are doing the best we can and if not...that we will try to gain help along the way...that that is ultimately the goal Chat Icon

Posted 2/20/12 10:21 PM
 

PennyCat
Just call me mommy :)

Member since 7/08

19084 total posts

Name:
Jib

Re: Is this a fair statement?

Posted by prunepie

Posted by cncforever

It's hard to see anyone overweight, just as it's hard to see anyone as a smoker, on drugs, etcetera. It's hard to see people live a life that is detrimental to their own health, especially with all that we know now.

It's even more frustrating to hear someone whine about being a diabetic, having swollen ankles, knee problems, etc, when they merely need to lose weight and eat right, but they never put down a donut or deny a slice of cake.

I have people like this in my life and it's infuriating but I think for some food is an addiction and needs to be treated as such. I think it stems a lot deeper than just the desire for food; I think they are feeding something else that is lacking in their life or food is being used as a medication to ease the pain of something.

I can see where she is coming from, but I also see where everyone, SAHM or not, should be working out and eating right.

That said, you don't know if the person that you see as overweight actually is in the process of losing weight and has lost a great deal already. When I go to the gym I see many overweight people, and I commend them. They are there, doing their thing, trying to reach a goal.






i am constantly in awe of those people who are FIT. THIN to me means nothing...cause like i stated you can be unwell and thin.




This.


But I also was taken aback by this post. You never know the true story behind a person's weight whether it be something going on physically.. emotionally.. One of my best friends is VERY overweight because of a health condition, but she eats healthier and is committed to physical exercise that I beyond admire her.


Seeing someone smoke or use drugs is VERY different than seeing someone who is overweight- in my opinion.

Message edited 2012-02-20 23:50:25.480000.

Posted 2/20/12 10:50 PM
 

Adri
Joy!

Member since 5/05

3116 total posts

Name:
A

Re: Is this a fair statement?

It depends on the priorities. I try to workout 3-5 times a week while DS is at school. If I'm sick or hurt (once I bumped my little toes and they were swollen for a month) or busy, I won't work out.

But what works for me, doesn't work for others. If others don't want to work out, it is their business, it is not mine how they prefer to spend their time.

As someone said, some moms are very busy with the PTA, volunteering, etc. I found my balance with working out, volunteering and studying, but if is up to me, I wouldn't work out (I do it because I feel I have to).

It is true about physical conditions. I'm petite but I have fat on certain areas that won't go away... even exercising. Someone asked me if I was pregnant a couple of weeks ago Chat Icon

I don't think it is a fair statement.



Posted 2/20/12 11:03 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this a fair statement?

nrthshrgrl wrote that no one should be fat, barring a medical issue.

I simply wrote that everyone should be trying to work out and eat right.

I am overweight myself at the current moment at the highest weight I have ever been and it's no one's fault but my own, but I am working on it.

Message edited 2012-02-20 23:04:46.123000.

Posted 2/20/12 11:04 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this a fair statement?

Posted by PennyCat



Seeing someone smoke or use drugs is VERY different than seeing someone who is overweight- in my opinion.



In extreme cases, I see it as addiction. When you see someone morbidly obese, unable to walk or breathe on their own or unable to leave their house or work, I see addiction and someone slowly killing themselves. It's sad and just as people turn to drugs to feel better, some people turn to food. I feel for those people and their families.

Do I feel bad for myself when I whine that I can't fit into my size 10 jeans anymore? Nope. It was my own fault due too many nights of excessive eating of fast food and lack of excerising.

Message edited 2012-02-20 23:10:04.460000.

Posted 2/20/12 11:08 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Is this a fair statement?

I don't know why ANYONE cares!

Really! This is beyond ridiculous to judge ANYONE based on what they should or should not do based on their occupation.

Why do people care what others are doing?

Posted 2/20/12 11:13 PM
 

PennyCat
Just call me mommy :)

Member since 7/08

19084 total posts

Name:
Jib

Re: Is this a fair statement?

Posted by cncforever

Posted by PennyCat



Seeing someone smoke or use drugs is VERY different than seeing someone who is overweight- in my opinion.



In extreme cases, I see it as addiction. When you see someone morbidly obese, unable to walk or breathe on their own or unable to leave their house or work, I see addiction and someone slowly killing themselves. It's sad and just as people turn to drugs to feel better, some people turn to food. I feel for those people and their families.

Do I feel bad for myself when I whine that I can't fit into my size 10 jeans anymore? Nope. It was my own fault due too many nights of excessive eating of fast food and lack of excerising.



morbid obsesity is an extreme case... You mentioned people just being overweight and in many cases, it's not the person's fault.

Posted 2/20/12 11:30 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this a fair statement?

Posted by PennyCat

Posted by cncforever

Posted by PennyCat



Seeing someone smoke or use drugs is VERY different than seeing someone who is overweight- in my opinion.



In extreme cases, I see it as addiction. When you see someone morbidly obese, unable to walk or breathe on their own or unable to leave their house or work, I see addiction and someone slowly killing themselves. It's sad and just as people turn to drugs to feel better, some people turn to food. I feel for those people and their families.

Do I feel bad for myself when I whine that I can't fit into my size 10 jeans anymore? Nope. It was my own fault due too many nights of excessive eating of fast food and lack of excerising.



morbid obsesity is an extreme case... You mentioned people just being overweight and in many cases, it's not the person's fault.



Due to medical condition, no. If you're on steroids to help a medical issue, yes, you gain weight. If you have a sluggish thyroid, you can hold onto weight more than someone who isn't. If you have a back issue due to an injury and can't work out, yes, you may be overweight.

But the majority of people I know, it's simply overeating, eating the wrong foods, and not working out. This is why most people these days are on Weight Watchers. It's why diets are so popular. People have out of control eating, out of control portion sizes, and are looking to fix it. I am one of them.

If you saw me, you'd see me as overweight but you wouldn't know I already lost 6lbs and am working out every single day at the gym. That's what I keep in mind when I see someone overweight, that they may be in the process of fixing it.

Everyone else who ******* and moans (without a medical issue), I have no patience for. There is nothing worse to me than someone being pre-diabetic due to no fault of their own and they still don't do a darn thing about it.

I have a family member that is prediabetic. Has had 4 heart attacks. Has had a double knee replacement due to long-term stress on their knees. Was told by their primary care doctor to lose weight ASAP. We pooled together money to get them a gym membership and sessions with a personal trainer. We give them support and healthy recipes. They didn't want the gym membership, said they "didn't have time," and still continues to eat at the diner 4 times a week and eats horribly. They are going to lose their life early, and who suffers? us. I have no patience for that. There's simply no excuse.

If you can't work out, eat less. Eat better. Make time. I crawl out of the bed at 4:30 AM to hit the gym, because that's the only time I can go. I'm exhausted and cranky but I do it. I have no excuse not to, and I try to practice what I preach. I did the bad to myself and I have to now unravel it.

You get one chance at life. One body. You can't trade it in. May as well cherish it and keep it in the best shape you can, not just for aesthetics, but for internal health. People forget that they can get the body and health they want, you just have to put in the work and it will happen. It's attainable for most, you just have to put in the effort, just as you do anything else.

Message edited 2012-02-20 23:50:57.300000.

Posted 2/20/12 11:39 PM
 

DirtyBlonde
*****

Member since 11/07

7344 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this a fair statement?

Not fair at all.

Your metabolism changes as you get older - kids are exhausting, so is maintaining a home...Everyone knows weight loss is a result of exercise and eating less but it's easy to say and far harder to do.

It has so much to do with what's going on with you mentally/emotionally too; weight loss is a very personal thing in that way.

Posted 2/20/12 11:51 PM
 

gina409
TWINS!

Member since 12/09

27635 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Is this a fair statement?

Posted by smdl

I don't know why ANYONE cares!

Really! This is beyond ridiculous to judge ANYONE based on what they should or should not do based on their occupation.

Why do people care what others are doing?




THIS TIMES 7 MILLION BILLION TRILLION!

i cannot believe this thread!!!!!!!!!!!!!Chat Icon

on a side note i will say i know people who think when u r a SAHM or something along the lines u get to sit at home all day with your feet up

i do not have a job per say..i do not have a paying job..

i left my paying job to care for my mother who had a stroke and left her paralyzed on her right side..

i go by my parents house every day..i get no holidays off..

when people here i do not have a "job" they r like oh u must love it u get to relax all day

if by relax u mean,showering someone,cleaning up cooking,food shopping,helping them to bathroom, etc etc etc then yes i relax all day

always easy to think u know what goes on in people's lives from the outside..truth is nobody has a flipping idea unless they have gone through the exact same thing

Posted 2/21/12 12:03 AM
 

MrsC614
My little angel is here <3

Member since 7/09

2851 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: Is this a fair statement?

Posted by gina409

Posted by smdl

I don't know why ANYONE cares!

Really! This is beyond ridiculous to judge ANYONE based on what they should or should not do based on their occupation.

Why do people care what others are doing?




THIS TIMES 7 MILLION BILLION TRILLION!

i cannot believe this thread!!!!!!!!!!!!!Chat Icon

on a side note i will say i know people who think when u r a SAHM or something along the lines u get to sit at home all day with your feet up

i do not have a job per say..i do not have a paying job..

i left my paying job to care for my mother who had a stroke and left her paralyzed on her right side..

i go by my parents house every day..i get no holidays off..

when people here i do not have a "job" they r like oh u must love it u get to relax all day

if by relax u mean,showering someone,cleaning up cooking,food shopping,helping them to bathroom, etc etc etc then yes i relax all day

always easy to think u know what goes on in people's lives from the outside..truth is nobody has a flipping idea unless they have gone through the exact same thing



Xoxo you are a wonderful person Gina. I have so much respect for you because you are kind, and considerate of others feelings, and just a beautiful person inside and out. Are you really shocked at what you are reading on this post? I'm not. I've been posting on here more lately because with my broken rib there is not much to do so here i am posting. But I've been doing lots of lurking. Gina, there is so much bullying going on here. And unfortunately it happens like this in real life tooChat Icon before people start making stupid statements about someone's weight, or life, they should take a day and walk in that persons shoes.

Posted 2/21/12 1:36 AM
 

gina409
TWINS!

Member since 12/09

27635 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Is this a fair statement?

thank you so much!!!!!!

i think it must be a gina thing cause i am gonna say it right back to you!

doing all you do with a broken ribChat Icon ..those r sooo painful! and esp after all you guys went through with your daughter

only strong mommies can do that!(and for the record she has one of the most insanley beautiful children i have ever seen)

keep your chin up and keep healing and resting and getting better..

u r so right i do not know why anyon surprises me anymore but for all the rotten apples the really good ones i meet through these boards make up for it

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/21/12 1:53 AM
 

MrsC614
My little angel is here <3

Member since 7/09

2851 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: Is this a fair statement?

Posted by gina409

thank you so much!!!!!!

i think it must be a gina thing cause i am gonna say it right back to you!

doing all you do with a broken ribChat Icon ..those r sooo painful! and esp after all you guys went through with your daughter

only strong mommies can do that!(and for the record she has one of the most insanley beautiful children i have ever seen)

keep your chin up and keep healing and resting and getting better..

u r so right i do not know why anyon surprises me anymore but for all the rotten apples the really good ones i meet through these boards make up for it

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Thanks mama!!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/21/12 2:13 AM
 

FinanceMonkey
LIF Infant

Member since 1/12

235 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this a fair statement?

I don't think it's a fair Statement

Posted 2/21/12 3:34 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >>
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Do You Think The Statement "Death Comes In Threes" is true? HoneyBadger 3/5/08 13 Families Helping Families ™
Moms of kids over 2...confirm or deny the following statement... Eireann 1/8/08 25 Parenting
How do you pay of your credit card statement? NewlyMrs 9/28/07 28 Families Helping Families ™
Can someone explain the statement "There are so many expenses that go into buying a home!" NewlyMrs 5/1/07 21 Home
Reading Don's post "refreshed" the craziest statement I have ever heard... Eva Luna 12/15/06 22 Families Helping Families ™
Do You Believe in the Statement Once a Cheater...Always a Cheater? Ali1 4/6/06 52 Families Helping Families ™