I'm so torn

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

ns1011
I'm wide awake

Member since 4/09

2697 total posts

Name:
Nic

I'm so torn

I know they say you can't spoil a newborn, but I beg to differ. DD is 6 weeks old today and lately DH and I have been having some trouble getting her to sleep and stay asleep unless she is being held. I absolutley LOVE holding her and watching her sleep, but realistically I cannot get myself or anything else done if I am always holding her. When we first brought her home, she would sleep pretty much anywhere and everywhere, but given that we have such a large family and always had people visiting and holding her, it seems she is very used to that now. It's even starting to become a problem at night. She had started sleeping for 5-6 hour stretches, but now she is back to waking every 2-3 hours and its hard to get her back to sleep. No matter how fast asleep I think she is, the minute we put her down she is wide awake and then she gets fussy until we pick her up and soothe her.

I've been reading that it's important to put them down when they are drowsy but not fully asleep so that they learn to fall asleep on their own. I wanted to try this but I feel so awful listening to her cry for me or DH and just ignoring it. It's not so bad when she is just fussing but when it turns to full blown crying I totally cave.

Sometimes I try to nurse her just to get her to fall asleep but then once I put her down, she wakes up. Plus, I don't like putting her down without burping her bc she tends to get gassy and has a bit of reflux so she needs to be upright for about 10 minutes after eating.


Any thoughts? I'm so worried that this is going to set precedent for the next few months.

Thanks for reading - sorry so long.

Posted 8/2/11 11:07 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: I'm so torn

You CANT spoil a newnorn. She maybe having a growth spurt. Get a sling or something, but at this age it is a waste of time to try and train her to do anything. Jmo

Posted 8/2/11 11:10 AM
 

jprimrose
I love my little munchkins!

Member since 10/05

3939 total posts

Name:

Re: I'm so torn

Posted by JennZ

You CANT spoil a newnorn. She maybe having a growth spurt. Get a sling or something, but at this age it is a waste of time to try and train her to do anything. Jmo



ITA She is way to young to spoil and I would definitely not let her cry it out at this age. I like the idea of a sling.

Posted 8/2/11 11:14 AM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: I'm so torn

6 weeks is still too young to train...it does get easier..i found
:healthy sleep habits happy baby" a good book to read.. it explained what is going on in their tiny little brains and bodies!!

You can leave her to fuss but please dont leave her to cry yet!

It gets better!Chat Icon

Posted 8/2/11 11:14 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: I'm so torn

I do believe you can spoil a newborn. I think you should start putting her down awake. Don't let her full out cry but give her 5-10 minutes to fall asleep before picking her up and trying again.

Good luck! Chat Icon

Posted 8/2/11 11:17 AM
 

MayBbaby21
Baby no. 3 coming soon!

Member since 6/09

5738 total posts

Name:

Re: I'm so torn

I agree that she's too young to CIO.

Have you tried putting her down while you're still holding her? Sounds odd, I know. DD always needed to be rocked or nursed to sleep and would sometimes cry when I put her down (we're finally breaking the pattern now that she's older and can handle crying it out a little). I would sometimes lay her down but with my arms still around her and continue to shush or sing to her and then very gently and very slowly pull my arms away.

Posted 8/2/11 11:37 AM
 

KrisT
Two Boys for Me!!

Member since 1/07

5213 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: I'm so torn

I know many disagree with me and it's not so much that I think you can "spoil" a newborn, but I do think that you can start certain habits early on that can be more difficult to break later on. Similarly, I think you can start good habits early that hopefully will help you later on.

For me, I wanted my children to learn early on that they are supposed to sleep in their cribs and to learn how to put themselves to sleep. I had no issues with my first child because he would start to get sleepy, I would put him down and he would sleep.

My second son is another story! For the first 8 weeks I swear unless he was being held, he was crying. I kept trying and didn't have a lot of luck. He was much better at night and I think it is in part because of the routine.

I started very early on with a nighttime routine (which I did the same for my older son). Between 7:00 and 8:00 (right when he was starting to get sleepy and ready to eat), he would get a bath, changed into pjs, and I would feed him in the rocking chair in his room. I would keep the lights dim and put a noise machine on. He caught on pretty quickly that it was time to sleep.

Early on, he usually would be asleep when I put him down, but as he is getting older (he's 4 months now), he definitely is more drowsy when I put him down.

I also have started more of a "nap routine" at this point - when he starts to get fussy, I put him in his crib with the noise machine on.

So I would start a nighttime routine. I really felt like once I got that going, the daytime routine kind of fell into place. I also wouldn't worry so much if the baby is asleep sometimes when you put her down. I think as she starts to get older, its easier to put them down when they are drowsy.

ETA: My first son had reflux and my second son was extremely gassy - both got a lot better around 12 weeks which also helped with their sleeping.

Message edited 2011-08-02 11:40:30.273000.

Posted 8/2/11 11:38 AM
 

JenMarie
One day at a time

Member since 11/07

7397 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: I'm so torn

Do you swaddle her? DD will be 4 weeks this week and I'm able to put her down drowsy only if she's swaddled. If she's not swaddled she'll cry and we have to hold her until she falls asleep. I will let her fuss, but once she starts crying I pick her up.I also only swaddle at night so she will hopefully learn the difference between night time sleep and naps.

Posted 8/2/11 11:38 AM
 

lvdolphins
My Loves!

Member since 5/05

46292 total posts

Name:

Re: I'm so torn

My nephew is 3 months old. As soon as they put him down, he cries.
Been happening since the day he came home. I feel bad, my SIL gets hardly anything done!

I don't think you can spoil a newborn, but, maybe little by little put baby down and let them get used to it.
Your baby is way to young for CIO, but, if you need to go to the bathroom or throw laundry in, little things, let DD fuss and let her know she's OK.

Posted 8/2/11 11:49 AM
 

Mags1227
Just a mommy ...

Member since 10/10

2665 total posts

Name:
M

Re: I'm so torn

Posted by KrisT

I know many disagree with me and it's not so much that I think you can "spoil" a newborn, but I do think that you can start certain habits early on that can be more difficult to break later on. Similarly, I think you can start good habits early that hopefully will help you later on.

For me, I wanted my children to learn early on that they are supposed to sleep in their cribs and to learn how to put themselves to sleep. I had no issues with my first child because he would start to get sleepy, I would put him down and he would sleep.

My second son is another story! For the first 8 weeks I swear unless he was being held, he was crying. I kept trying and didn't have a lot of luck. He was much better at night and I think it is in part because of the routine.

I started very early on with a nighttime routine (which I did the same for my older son). Between 7:00 and 8:00 (right when he was starting to get sleepy and ready to eat), he would get a bath, changed into pjs, and I would feed him in the rocking chair in his room. I would keep the lights dim and put a noise machine on. He caught on pretty quickly that it was time to sleep.

Early on, he usually would be asleep when I put him down, but as he is getting older (he's 4 months now), he definitely is more drowsy when I put him down.

I also have started more of a "nap routine" at this point - when he starts to get fussy, I put him in his crib with the noise machine on.

So I would start a nighttime routine. I really felt like once I got that going, the daytime routine kind of fell into place. I also wouldn't worry so much if the baby is asleep sometimes when you put her down. I think as she starts to get older, its easier to put them down when they are drowsy.

ETA: My first son had reflux and my second son was extremely gassy - both got a lot better around 12 weeks which also helped with their sleeping.



i would agree with this. The # 1 piece of advice my mom (and her generation) gave me was NOT to carry DS around. I am so glad I took it! He was in his crib, in his playard, in the rocker, anything but in my arms. He learned how to sleep and he never got used to being held.

i don't think it's a matter of spoiling, it's a matter of habits. If you get a baby (even one so young) used to being carried, you will have problems putting them down.

just try putting her down when she's not sleepy. interact with her while she's lying down or sitting in a swing or rocker. do tummy time. The more she gets used to different positions, the easier on you.

Posted 8/2/11 11:54 AM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: I'm so torn

She is definitely too young to cry it out. Try swaddling, swing, rocker, bouncer etc

Posted 8/2/11 11:57 AM
 

MrsPornStar
Partners in crime

Member since 10/05

14656 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: I'm so torn

This was DS #1 to a tee. I slept in a chair the first 8 weeks because he only wanted to be held. It was tough but he outgrew it. This also started to happen with DS #2. We started to swaddle him at this point and he slept much better. I did start routines early so that my kids could get used to it. Now, both boys sleep wonderfully and I fully believe it's because I got them used to a routine early on.

Hang in there! Chat Icon

Posted 8/2/11 12:00 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: I'm so torn

Posted by Mags1227

Posted by KrisT

I know many disagree with me and it's not so much that I think you can "spoil" a newborn, but I do think that you can start certain habits early on that can be more difficult to break later on. Similarly, I think you can start good habits early that hopefully will help you later on.

For me, I wanted my children to learn early on that they are supposed to sleep in their cribs and to learn how to put themselves to sleep. I had no issues with my first child because he would start to get sleepy, I would put him down and he would sleep.

My second son is another story! For the first 8 weeks I swear unless he was being held, he was crying. I kept trying and didn't have a lot of luck. He was much better at night and I think it is in part because of the routine.

I started very early on with a nighttime routine (which I did the same for my older son). Between 7:00 and 8:00 (right when he was starting to get sleepy and ready to eat), he would get a bath, changed into pjs, and I would feed him in the rocking chair in his room. I would keep the lights dim and put a noise machine on. He caught on pretty quickly that it was time to sleep.

Early on, he usually would be asleep when I put him down, but as he is getting older (he's 4 months now), he definitely is more drowsy when I put him down.

I also have started more of a "nap routine" at this point - when he starts to get fussy, I put him in his crib with the noise machine on.

So I would start a nighttime routine. I really felt like once I got that going, the daytime routine kind of fell into place. I also wouldn't worry so much if the baby is asleep sometimes when you put her down. I think as she starts to get older, its easier to put them down when they are drowsy.

ETA: My first son had reflux and my second son was extremely gassy - both got a lot better around 12 weeks which also helped with their sleeping.



i would agree with this. The # 1 piece of advice my mom (and her generation) gave me was NOT to carry DS around. I am so glad I took it! He was in his crib, in his playard, in the rocker, anything but in my arms. He learned how to sleep and he never got used to being held.

i don't think it's a matter of spoiling, it's a matter of habits. If you get a baby (even one so young) used to being carried, you will have problems putting them down.

just try putting her down when she's not sleepy. interact with her while she's lying down or sitting in a swing or rocker. do tummy time. The more she gets used to different positions, the easier on you.




ITA!

I hear about moms bringing their babies in the bathroom, wearing them - and that is 100% fine but *I* would lose my mind. I put DD down by herself all the time. Now, at a year old I can put her somewhere safe and she will entertain herself while I shower, cook or make a phone call. She also STTN and will entertain herself for up to an hour in the crib when she wakes up!

She usually falls asleep on her last bottle, I am not going to lie so I don't have to put her in the crib awake but I hope when we stop bottles that she will get used to that too!

Posted 8/2/11 12:04 PM
 

cheryl28
LIF Adult

Member since 2/10

4657 total posts

Name:

Re: I'm so torn

I also think you can "spoil" or start bad habits at an early age. For early on I would let dd hang out in the swing by herself, or in the bouncy seat, or on the floor on a blanket by herself. I would not pick her up unless she was really crying not fussing. I do not believe in holding her all day all the time. I needed to get stuff done and I did not like the slings. Of course I did tummy time with her mommy and me stuff, I sang, talked to her all day. From day 1, we laid her on the floor on a blanket with a stuffed animal and let her be.

I think you should try during the day. Put her in the bouncy seat or swing and it on the floor in the bedroom and fold laundry and talk to her. Or whatever needs to be done. When she's really fussy pick her up and move her. Get her used to not being help all the time but let her know you are right there. Start off, 5 mins even if crying, then get her for a few days then make it longer. I would not let her CIO until she falls asleep yet but she needs to get used to not being held.

Posted 8/2/11 12:13 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: I'm so torn

Posted by Tilde

I do believe you can spoil a newborn. I think you should start putting her down awake. Don't let her full out cry but give her 5-10 minutes to fall asleep before picking her up and trying again.

Good luck! Chat Icon




ITA!

Give her a few minutes to figure out things herself. But only go as far as your comfortable with. I really believe mommy instinct will let you know what is too young and what isn't for your baby.

Posted 8/2/11 12:24 PM
 

ns1011
I'm wide awake

Member since 4/09

2697 total posts

Name:
Nic

Re: I'm so torn

Posted by jprimrose

Posted by JennZ

You CANT spoil a newnorn. She maybe having a growth spurt. Get a sling or something, but at this age it is a waste of time to try and train her to do anything. Jmo



ITA She is way to young to spoil and I would definitely not let her cry it out at this age. I like the idea of a sling.



Thank you. I definitely am NOT planning on letting her cry it out. I know that a nightime routine is going to just take some time. It's more or less the day time that I am concerned about. She seems to want to be held a lot. I had the Peanut Shell sling but I don't really care for the way she fits into it at this point. My sister in law lent me her Maya Wrap and that seems to be better so I'm going to give that a try.

Posted 8/3/11 7:16 AM
 

ns1011
I'm wide awake

Member since 4/09

2697 total posts

Name:
Nic

Re: I'm so torn

Posted by Linda1003

6 weeks is still too young to train...it does get easier..i found
:healthy sleep habits happy baby" a good book to read.. it explained what is going on in their tiny little brains and bodies!!

You can leave her to fuss but please dont leave her to cry yet!

It gets better!Chat Icon



Thank you for the book recommendation. I will check it out. I think I may have not been clear in my OP. I am not letting her cry it out. I barely can let her fuss without running over to soothe her Chat Icon . I'm just worried that maybe I am being too overbearing but I guess with a NB it's never too much. Chat Icon

Posted 8/3/11 7:18 AM
 

ns1011
I'm wide awake

Member since 4/09

2697 total posts

Name:
Nic

Re: I'm so torn

Posted by Tilde

I do believe you can spoil a newborn. I think you should start putting her down awake. Don't let her full out cry but give her 5-10 minutes to fall asleep before picking her up and trying again.

Good luck! Chat Icon




I've been trying this. It seems to be hit or miss. Thanks Chat Icon

Posted 8/3/11 7:19 AM
 

ns1011
I'm wide awake

Member since 4/09

2697 total posts

Name:
Nic

Re: I'm so torn

Posted by MayBbaby21

Have you tried putting her down while you're still holding her? Sounds odd, I know. DD always needed to be rocked or nursed to sleep and would sometimes cry when I put her down (we're finally breaking the pattern now that she's older and can handle crying it out a little). I would sometimes lay her down but with my arms still around her and continue to shush or sing to her and then very gently and very slowly pull my arms away.



This I have been doing at night and it seems to work when I initially put her down for the night. Even in the middle of the night I have done this, but most of the time she will stir and wake up 5 minutes later. I usually have to lay in my bed and rock her rock-n-play sleeper for a good 5-10 minutes.

Posted 8/3/11 7:21 AM
 

ns1011
I'm wide awake

Member since 4/09

2697 total posts

Name:
Nic

Re: I'm so torn

Posted by JenMarie

Do you swaddle her? DD will be 4 weeks this week and I'm able to put her down drowsy only if she's swaddled. If she's not swaddled she'll cry and we have to hold her until she falls asleep. I will let her fuss, but once she starts crying I pick her up.I also only swaddle at night so she will hopefully learn the difference between night time sleep and naps.



Swaddling is a whole other issue for me.Chat Icon I can't decide if DD likes it or not. I had tried swaddling her for the first week or so when we brought her home. I don't know if we just didn't do it right or if she just didn't like it but she always managed to kick herself out of the blanket. Then I started using the swaddle-me blankets but she seemed to not like having her arms confined. She LOVES to keep her little hands up by her cheeks or ears while she sleeps (she even did that in all of her sono pics) so I started swaddling her with her arms out. But of course now she has the startle reflex and that sometimes wakes her up - but not always. I recently tried to swaddle her tight again and the first night I noticed that she fell off to sleep very easily. Maybe it was a coincidence though bc the next time I did it she turned beat red with frustration until I let her arms loose. I'm just not sure what makes her more comfortable. She gets gassy and kicks her legs around a lot so maybe the tight swaddle is too much on her stomach Chat Icon . I wish babies had a little message board across their foreheads that told you what they wanted/were feeling Chat Icon

Posted 8/3/11 7:27 AM
 

ns1011
I'm wide awake

Member since 4/09

2697 total posts

Name:
Nic

Re: I'm so torn

Posted by cheryl28

I think you should try during the day. Put her in the bouncy seat or swing and it on the floor in the bedroom and fold laundry and talk to her. Or whatever needs to be done. When she's really fussy pick her up and move her. Get her used to not being help all the time but let her know you are right there. Start off, 5 mins even if crying, then get her for a few days then make it longer. I would not let her CIO until she falls asleep yet but she needs to get used to not being held.



Thank you. I started doing this. It seems to buy me about 10 minutes or so before she gets too fussy. Hopefully it will start to stretch longer.

Posted 8/3/11 7:28 AM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: I'm so torn

my kids were spoiled.
I had nothing better to do then hold them...we were equally addicted to it.

I really don't believe in letting kids cry at allChat Icon I did not care about anything else though...I knew holding my infant was a limited time in my life, so I held them...they did not sleep and I would be up at all hours cleaning my house. My dh was neglected...

not sure where this post is going

Chat Icon I loved holding my babies but all else around me went to hell.

Posted 8/3/11 7:31 AM
 

ns1011
I'm wide awake

Member since 4/09

2697 total posts

Name:
Nic

Re: I'm so torn

Posted by KrisT

I know many disagree with me and it's not so much that I think you can "spoil" a newborn, but I do think that you can start certain habits early on that can be more difficult to break later on. Similarly, I think you can start good habits early that hopefully will help you later on.

For me, I wanted my children to learn early on that they are supposed to sleep in their cribs and to learn how to put themselves to sleep. I had no issues with my first child because he would start to get sleepy, I would put him down and he would sleep.

My second son is another story! For the first 8 weeks I swear unless he was being held, he was crying. I kept trying and didn't have a lot of luck. He was much better at night and I think it is in part because of the routine.

I started very early on with a nighttime routine (which I did the same for my older son). Between 7:00 and 8:00 (right when he was starting to get sleepy and ready to eat), he would get a bath, changed into pjs, and I would feed him in the rocking chair in his room. I would keep the lights dim and put a noise machine on. He caught on pretty quickly that it was time to sleep.

Early on, he usually would be asleep when I put him down, but as he is getting older (he's 4 months now), he definitely is more drowsy when I put him down.

I also have started more of a "nap routine" at this point - when he starts to get fussy, I put him in his crib with the noise machine on.

So I would start a nighttime routine. I really felt like once I got that going, the daytime routine kind of fell into place. I also wouldn't worry so much if the baby is asleep sometimes when you put her down. I think as she starts to get older, its easier to put them down when they are drowsy.

ETA: My first son had reflux and my second son was extremely gassy - both got a lot better around 12 weeks which also helped with their sleeping.



We've started a bedtime routine with her too. She gets a sponge bath and nightitme lotion before I put on her pj's. Then I nurse her for a little while and she usually falls asleep. However, bc she gets gassy I have to make sure she burps so that usually wakes her up a little bit. Then I rock her and read her a book until she falls asleep. She has a bit of reflux too so unfortunately I cannot just put her down as soon as she falls asleep when eating. I lay her down with the white noise machine as well. I haven't been doing it during the day with naps bc I wanted her to be able to start to distinguish between nap time and night time. During the day, if she naps in her bassinet, I play some classical music (on the same white noise machine). Otherwise, it's whatever noises are going on wherever she fell asleep, (i.e., the swing, bouncer, etc, car radio, etc). She is definitely used to sleeping with noise so that's a plus. Even the dog barking or vaccuum running doesn't seem to bother her.

Posted 8/3/11 7:33 AM
 

ns1011
I'm wide awake

Member since 4/09

2697 total posts

Name:
Nic

Re: I'm so torn

Posted by Janice

my kids were spoiled.
I had nothing better to do then hold them...we were equally addicted to it.

I really don't believe in letting kids cry at allChat Icon I did not care about anything else though...I knew holding my infant was a limited time in my life, so I held them...they did not sleep and I would be up at all hours cleaning my house. My dh was neglected...

not sure where this post is going

Chat Icon I loved holding my babies but all else around me went to hell.



I hear you. Thats the part that has me torn. She is getting so big right before my eyes and I know this time I have to hold and cuddle her is so limited. I'm just trying to find a balance. Everyone told me to sleep when she sleeps but that was when I would get things done, bc whenever she was up, even if she was content without being held, I just wanted to play with her.

Posted 8/3/11 7:35 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaƮt

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: I'm so torn

Posted by KrisT

I know many disagree with me and it's not so much that I think you can "spoil" a newborn, but I do think that you can start certain habits early on that can be more difficult to break later on. Similarly, I think you can start good habits early that hopefully will help you later on.

For me, I wanted my children to learn early on that they are supposed to sleep in their cribs and to learn how to put themselves to sleep. I had no issues with my first child because he would start to get sleepy, I would put him down and he would sleep.

My second son is another story! For the first 8 weeks I swear unless he was being held, he was crying. I kept trying and didn't have a lot of luck. He was much better at night and I think it is in part because of the routine.

I started very early on with a nighttime routine (which I did the same for my older son). Between 7:00 and 8:00 (right when he was starting to get sleepy and ready to eat), he would get a bath, changed into pjs, and I would feed him in the rocking chair in his room. I would keep the lights dim and put a noise machine on. He caught on pretty quickly that it was time to sleep.

Early on, he usually would be asleep when I put him down, but as he is getting older (he's 4 months now), he definitely is more drowsy when I put him down.

I also have started more of a "nap routine" at this point - when he starts to get fussy, I put him in his crib with the noise machine on.

So I would start a nighttime routine. I really felt like once I got that going, the daytime routine kind of fell into place. I also wouldn't worry so much if the baby is asleep sometimes when you put her down. I think as she starts to get older, its easier to put them down when they are drowsy.

ETA: My first son had reflux and my second son was extremely gassy - both got a lot better around 12 weeks which also helped with their sleeping.



I think this is all great advice Chat Icon It really depends on your tolerance for holding your newborn. I never minded spoiling my kids by holding them all the time because in reality, they are only little for so long, but that's what worked for ME (and it didn't always work Chat Icon). I like the idea of starting a routine early, babies are very very smart and there is really no downside to getting your baby used to what happens every night.

My best tricks were swaddling very tightly and using a LOUD sound machine, it really helped my DD sleep much better.

Posted 8/3/11 7:40 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I came home from the mall to find my tiny apartment torn apart... Janice 11/17/07 46 Parenting
Does anyone have a kid's piano? We are torn... Janice 11/16/07 6 Parenting
I am so torn, should I buy a winter jacket? peabody 11/11/07 9 Pregnancy
Help! torn between 2 strollers...need your expertise!!! MrsBlueSash 3/5/07 15 Pregnancy
so torn what shouls i get.. stroller related..LONG 04bride 7/16/06 11 Parenting
I am torn...did anybody tell work about being pg before 12 weeks? GenLCSW 5/8/06 19 Pregnancy