I'm frustrated...(updated at bottom)
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
I'm frustrated...(updated at bottom) I know this is MY fault, because I've put on "shows" in the past to get her to eat... Message edited 2008-08-19 21:57:49.260000. |
|
Posted 8/19/08 7:36 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: I'm frustrated... That is so frustrating. |
|
Posted 8/19/08 7:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated... i'm a recent convert of "if the child is hungry, he/she will eat". when DD was little i was overly concerned with what she ate, probably to a fault. we just went away last week, and she hardly ate anything...for a week! once she got home, everything went back to normal. she still has her days where she'll take a bite or two and then take off, but i now just let her go to bed "hungry" as she may be just fine and not want anything. |
|
Posted 8/19/08 7:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated... DS is the worst eater. I have tried it all, and have come to the conclusion, if he is hungry, he will eat. I can't make him eat if he doesn't want to, but he knows, that if he doesn't eat what is on his plate, thats it. No snack or dessert. No other choices. I never budge on this. He seems to be better, although he eats an alternating menu every other night since he is so picky, he will finish what is on his plate and looks forward to a small snack after bathtime and a little TV. |
|
Posted 8/19/08 7:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated... homestly, I think you are fighting a losing battle.....she will eat when she is hungry |
|
Posted 8/19/08 7:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated... I know it's so frustrating, but I really believe in picking your battles. Also, she has way too much control in the situation, as far as I'm concerned. If she doesn't want to eat, honestly, then she doesn't eat. She's not going to starve. Eventually she'll get hungry and you can offer her dinner again or breakfast or lunch or whatever meal she refused. There are just some things that I think aren't worth battling over, and eating is one of them. Will I make whatever she wants to please her? Hell no, but I also won't pull my hair out trying to get her to eat. However, when she doesn't eat, the tv is off and she can play with puzzles or books, that's it. And no snacks or anything of the sort. |
|
Posted 8/19/08 7:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated... Food fights are just not worth it! I used to babysit for a family who would shove food into their toddlers mouth and cover his mouth and make sure he swallowed it. It drove me nuts! |
|
Posted 8/19/08 7:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated... My DD is like this (except she is 20 months). Sometimes she is hungry and she'll eat most times she is not. The last time she ate a full meal was lunch yesterday. Mostly she picks and grazes. She is in the 25% percentile for weight. |
|
Posted 8/19/08 8:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated... Posted by Diana1215 That is so frustrating. I would honestly let her go to bed without eating. I try not to force DS to eat anymore. It was making me crazy - and getting us nowhere. When he doesn't want to eat what I make him - then tough on him - he can go to bed hungry and have a nice big breakfast the next day! This is exactly what I do. It isn't going to kill them, and maybe next time they'll sit and eat when dinner is ready. Or maybe not, and that's OK too - I don't force the issue with him as long as he is eating in general throughout the day. |
|
Posted 8/19/08 8:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated... Posted by stephanief homestly, I think you are fighting a losing battle.....she will eat when she is hungry I agree!
|
|
Posted 8/19/08 8:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated... I just stoped pushing her to eat when she got that way (which wasnt too far off from the way you decribed your daughter got). I couldnt fight with her anymore.. so now when she wont eat I tell her thats ok but she isnt getting anything else after dinner. She does ask for a snack but I tell her no and she goes to bed without it. She will eat when she's hungry.. and she'll eat what I give her |
|
Posted 8/19/08 9:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated... Posted by MelToddJulia Posted by stephanief homestly, I think you are fighting a losing battle.....she will eat when she is hungry I agree! I agree too. Sometimes DD's dinner will stay on the table until she goes to bed. I figure she'll eat when she's hungry. My only rule about not eating breakfast, lunch, dinner is no snacks. |
|
Posted 8/19/08 9:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated... Thank you everyone. |
|
Posted 8/19/08 9:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated... I wish I had advice Message edited 2008-08-19 21:54:49.643000. |
|
Posted 8/19/08 9:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated... Honestly Melissa she's not going to starve. If she doesn't want to eat, don't make her. If she's hungry before bed send her to bed hungry once and she'll learn. |
|
Posted 8/19/08 9:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated...(updated at bottom)
|
|
Posted 8/19/08 10:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated...(updated at bottom) Posted by pmpkn087 But, if you didn't, then she would be playing and getting the upper hand. You can't have that either. Situations like this are really tricky and these little bugs try to play us every minute of the day. See, that is totally it. I guess Em and I both have some deep rooted control issues because it was more about the control of the situation then her eating. I wanted her to understand that she can't just play EVERY second of the day. Sometimes we need to do things like stop, eat, use the potty, take naps, etc. We need our routines and our structures and if left up to her she wouldn't do any of this and would just play endlessly!!! She seriously asked me if I could give her bites in the living room while she played. She wanted me to follow her around with the fork which was NOT HAPPENING! We were eating at the table, and that was it! So yea, tomorrow is a new day. I know we have to be more strict about enforcing the table rule for all meals (we are more lax at breakfast because we are running out the door to bring DH to work) so that she understands that it is what we expect. We'll see how tomorrow goes. |
|
Posted 8/19/08 10:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated...(updated at bottom) if she continues wanting to act this way tell her she is punished and no toys. i know thats hard but if you tell her to go to he room with out toys it will hit her that she cannot play. or start taking away things she enjoys- tv, going to the beach, playing with friends. have the upperhand now becuase even though they are young its easy for them to manupulate. i have one of those at home. i let her eat breakfast and lunch in the tv room sometimes if im in a rush but dinner we eat together and if she doesnt eat- no tv an she goes right to bed. this child eats dinner every night - not everything but something and if he dosnt want to eat then she sits there until we are done and will eat her next meal. i feel for you and hope things get better. |
|
Posted 8/19/08 10:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated...(updated at bottom) Posted by pmpkn087 I think once you calmed down and talked with her, you hadled it beautifully.It's easy for us to say 'she won't starve, don't make her eat.' But, if you didn't, then she would be playing and getting the upper hand. You can't have that either. Situations like this are really tricky and these little bugs try to play us every minute of the day. As they get older, they understand lots more. It's not as easy as having a one year old and saying 'well, you don't want to eat, then fine,' because she is old and smart enought to talk back, manipulate, try to bargain, etc. I'm glad you stayed firm and all ended well (today ) I should have elaborated. I wouldn't have let her play. We make DD sit at the table with us until we're done but I just don't argue with her about eating anymore. I have food/weight issues and do not want to pass those issues onto DD by forcing her to eat or give her a complex about being thin or whatever. |
|
Posted 8/19/08 10:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated...(updated at bottom) Posted by Corinne do you have the tv on during dinner? The TV is always off during dinner. The thing that is hard about taking toys away is that there is NOWHERE to put them. We live in 4 rooms. 2 bedrooms, livingroom and the kitchen. There are toys in her bedroom, toys in the living room. I'd have to put her in our bedroom to gt rid of the toys and she'd probably just jump on our bed We also have barely any closets. Seriously, I was so ticked off tonight that I considered throwing the toys in a bag and just putting it outside! Thankfully I calmed down and we didn't go that far!
|
|
Posted 8/19/08 11:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: I'm frustrated...(updated at bottom) Honestly it does sound like a control thing...I'm not an expert and i don't know your DD personally but it just sounds like it. She is probably old enough to get the concept of "it is dinner time, we are eating together now" and if she doesn't want to eat, then she doesn't eat. But she should remain at the table for a period of time (10 min? 15 min? whatever you think is fair but it should be a set time frame in your head) and then if she doesn't want to eat while the family is eating, she can go. Later if she asks for food, the dinner is retrieved from the counter or fridge and given to her. But for the entire family to sit down again and entertain her while she eats is not right IMO. It's basically giving her the control and attention - exactly what will continue the behavior. Obviously you aren't going to leave her alone in the room to eat since she is small but to recreate the dining scene is not helpful in the situation. If she doesn't want to eat the meal, no other subsitution. It's not like you are trying to force her to eat foods she hates, you have prepared something she likes, but it's just hit or miss if she'll eat. Good Luck with it... I'm lucky with my kids and food for the most part although they do play their fair share of "games" with it as well. FWIW, I think it's fine that you try to entertain her or whatever, she's a small child and even bigger kids need entertaining at mealtime but you don't want to feel like it's a fight every night about the actual eating. We play a few different thought provoking games questions game with my kids all the time at dinner, the entertainment makes things go smoother. |
|
Posted 8/19/08 11:16 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I'm out... sad... and frustrated | MrsPornStar | 9/13/07 | 31 | TTC |
| UPDATE!!!! LONG VENT: Back from hospital and so frustrated I am ready to cry | Mommy2Boys | 4/1/07 | 26 | Pregnancy |
| soooooo frustrated!UPDATE...Pants found at last!! (see bottom of page ) | Blondie805 | 11/7/06 | 9 | Fashion & Beauty! |
| I forgot to go in for bloodwork!!! - UPDATE SO FRUSTRATED!! | leighla | 6/28/06 | 5 | Infertility |
| Getting Frustrated . . . . Best and quickest way to lose 10-15 pounds | Bri | 5/22/06 | 9 | Diet & Fitness |
| SO Frustrated!!! Does anyone's husband forget to tell you things? | MrsRbk | 2/2/06 | 3 | Families Helping Families ™ |














)