Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by TuttsyLow I am so RELIEVED that so many of the above do not pity this man. Without getting into personal detail- i have witnessed this situation on many occasions. I have had people from other countries come to the US for "vacation" and get "sick" while they are here and need xyz surgery, treatment or whatever then return to their native country after months of rehab free of charge. In the same day i will see an elderly woman whom worked her whole life here and payed insurance get rejected from a nursing home because either she dosent have enough $$ or has "too much" $. I can't take it but this is not remotely the same situation. listen, like it or lump it, the guy was here illegally BUT he was breaking his back here for 23 years for employers who take advantage of his illegal status and desire to do right for his family paying him a PITANCE and who can now walk away and wash his hands of it??? no. that is just not right. and I can totally see why he didn't want to dime out the rest of his family b/c he got sick. think about this, for all of these years, this family lived in the shadows, working, performing for others...they had NO insurance or public assistance. they were not draining the system. they worked and contributed in their own way to society...maybe by washing your clothes, delivering your food, waiting on your table as took your family jaunt to chinatown...they WORKED. so yes, I do feel badly for this man. what a strange position to be in. and yes absolutely he put himself in this position, but not without help of "law abiding" citizens that enabled this man for all of these years. one of his employers COULD HAVE sponsored this man and his family, made him a citizen and paid some damned health insurance and pay roll taxes too. it's not black and white. but the man is a human being. and his situation absolutely gets my compassion. it SUCKS. |
Posted 10/5/11 2:08 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by mrsBLT i may be a biotch for saying this, but i can't believe people actually feel sorry for this man. i have zero remorse for people who come here illegally and stay here illegally for more than 20 years, and then expect to receive free care. zero. not at all.. when we have a 24 year old dead because he couldn't afford both antibiotics and painkillers, i can't believe it either.. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 2:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by buttercup Posted by mrsBLT i may be a biotch for saying this, but i can't believe people actually feel sorry for this man. i have zero remorse for people who come here illegally and stay here illegally for more than 20 years, and then expect to receive free care. zero. not at all.. when we have a 24 year old dead because he couldn't afford both antibiotics and painkillers, i can't believe it either.. Which is just so wrong. NO ONE should be denied health care, rich or poor or in between. IMO it's a basic human right. I do feel very badly that the man had the stroke. I do not feel badly that his family abandoned him because I don't know the back story there, like I said, he could be a rotten person. Maybe his family has good reason to hate him. I do get angry that people here legally won't get the same level of care that Mr. Fok did. I am angry that the businesses who employed him skirted the system and will face no repercussions. I think the author was trying to make us pity Mr Fok but I think he failed. I feel bad Mr Fok has health problems. That is the extent of my empathy. All of his other issues seem to be brought upon himself. He flat out lied to social workers, evaded questions, wouldn't work with them. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 3:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by tarabelle99 I do feel very badly that the man had the stroke. I do not feel badly that his family abandoned him because I don't know the back story there, like I said, he could be a rotten person. Maybe his family has good reason to hate him. I do get angry that people here legally won't get the same level of care that Mr. Fok did. I am angry that the businesses who employed him skirted the system and will face no repercussions. I think the author was trying to make us pity Mr Fok but I think he failed. I feel bad Mr Fok has health problems. That is the extent of my empathy. All of his other issues seem to be brought upon himself. He flat out lied to social workers, evaded questions, wouldn't work with them. ITA. I felt no sympathy at all reading this article. I actually felt angry that this guy received great medical care for a year free of charge, while my 91 year old grandfather (who suffers from dementia to the point that he doesn't even recognize me) had surgery recently and WASN'T EVEN ALLOWED TO STAY OVERNIGHT. Yep, my 88 year old grandmother had to take him home and the anesthesia had barely worn off. Guess there aren't enough beds for the average taxpaying Medicare user when illegal immigrants are filling them. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 4:45 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by computergirl Guess there aren't enough beds for the average taxpaying Medicare user when illegal immigrants are filling them. I just wanted to point out that most likely this was not the case. insurers throw people out of the hospital on a daily basis b/c they don't want to pay the bill either. especially if your grandparents are part of a Medicare HMO and not regular medicare. a total tangent, but the benefits are not the same and can sometimes be very lacking in coverage.
|
Posted 10/5/11 5:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year I didn't read the story - because it would make me sick. Message edited 2011-10-05 20:04:11.693000. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 8:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by tarabelle99 They have really painted the picture to be this poor illegal immigrant stuck in the hospital. Let's consider a few things Maybe he has no family interested in helping him because he is an insufferable bazturd. Maybe he beat his wife and kids growing up. The hospital has spent over a million dollars, unreimbursed, on his care because he is here illegally. This poor unfortunate soul contributed heavily to his own debt to the hospital by not working with the hospital social workers and being evasive with information. Know who is going to pay his bill? And the bills of others like him? We do. Higher insurance premiums. Higher hospital bills. You know what the article DOESN'T mention? The uncompensated care pool. Ever look at an Explanation of Benefits your insurance pays to a hospital after an inpatient stay? Ever notice that little NY State surcharge tucked in there, oh so neatly? Yeah, our insurance companies pay a surcharge to hospitals to assist in funding an uncompensated care pool, which is used to provide care to indigent people, including care provided to illegal immigrants. http://www.health.state.ny.us/facilities/hospital/indigent_care/2008_indigent_care_report.htm Of course, the primary cause for all of this is that the man was not here legally. Had he been a legal resident, his care would have been covered by Medicaid or even Medicare. Yet the man has lived here for 20+ years without ever paying income or payroll taxes, he will get a free ride. His credit won't be destroyed, he won't be sued, his accounts won't be levied, no garnishment of wages or disability.................. It's a sticky situation. Can't throw the man on the street, it is illegal and inhumane, but this is what is driving some hospitals under. So how do we fix it? You are exactly right. Take a peek at how many hospitals have gone under in nyc in recent years: these are only the ones I can remember off the top: St Vincents, Cabrini, St. Johns Queens, Victory Memorial, Parkway, Mary Immaculate. How many beds lost? How many jobs lost? Yes we have to provide care to the ill, but at what cost to those of us here legally? |
|
Posted 10/5/11 8:50 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |







