Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year |
|
Posted 10/4/11 9:51 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year What a sad story. I wouldn't wish that life upon anyone. |
|
Posted 10/4/11 10:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Wow. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 9:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year They have really painted the picture to be this poor illegal immigrant stuck in the hospital. Message edited 2011-10-05 09:49:38.680000. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 9:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by tarabelle99 They have really painted the picture to be this poor illegal immigrant stuck in the hospital. Let's consider a few things Maybe he has no family interested in helping him because he is an insufferable bazturd. Maybe he beat his wife and kids growing up. The hospital has spent over a million dollars, unreimbursed, on his care because he is here illegally. This poor unfortunate soul contributed heavily to his own debt to the hospital by not working with the hospital social workers and being evasive with information. Know who is going to pay his bill? And the bills of others like him? We do. Higher insurance premiums. Higher hospital bills. You know what the article DOESN'T mention? The uncompensated care pool. Ever look at an Explanation of Benefits your insurance pays to a hospital after an inpatient stay? Ever notice that little NY State surcharge tucked in there, oh so neatly? Yeah, our insurance companies pay a surcharge to hospitals to assist in funding an uncompensated care pool, which is used to provide care to indigent people, including care provided to illegal immigrants. http://www.health.state.ny.us/facilities/hospital/indigent_care/2008_indigent_care_report.htm Of course, the primary cause for all of this is that the man was not here legally. Had he been a legal resident, his care would have been covered by Medicaid or even Medicare. Yet the man has lived here for 20+ years without ever paying income or payroll taxes, he will get a free ride. His credit won't be destroyed, he won't be sued, his accounts won't be levied, no garnishment of wages or disability.................. It's a sticky situation. Can't throw the man on the street, it is illegal and inhumane, but this is what is driving some hospitals under. So how do we fix it? thank you for so eloquently putting this into words |
|
Posted 10/5/11 9:52 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by tarabelle99 The hospital has spent over a million dollars, unreimbursed, on his care because he is here illegally. This poor unfortunate soul contributed heavily to his own debt to the hospital by not working with the hospital social workers and being evasive with information. Know who is going to pay his bill? And the bills of others like him? We do. Higher insurance premiums. Higher hospital bills. You know what the article DOESN'T mention? The uncompensated care pool. Ever look at an Explanation of Benefits your insurance pays to a hospital after an inpatient stay? Ever notice that little NY State surcharge tucked in there, oh so neatly? Yeah, our insurance companies pay a surcharge to hospitals to assist in funding an uncompensated care pool, which is used to provide care to indigent people, including care provided to illegal immigrants. http://www.health.state.ny.us/facilities/hospital/indigent_care/2008_indigent_care_report.htm Of course, the primary cause for all of this is that the man was not here legally. Had he been a legal resident, his care would have been covered by Medicaid or even Medicare. Yet the man has lived here for 20+ years without ever paying income or payroll taxes, he will get a free ride. His credit won't be destroyed, he won't be sued, his accounts won't be levied, no garnishment of wages or disability.................. It's a sticky situation. Can't throw the man on the street, it is illegal and inhumane, but this is what is driving some hospitals under. So how do we fix it? These were the FIRST things I thought when I saw the post title "illegal immigant in hospital for a year."
|
|
Posted 10/5/11 9:56 AM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year let's also look at the employers exploiting this man and his family. |
Posted 10/5/11 10:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by Ophelia let's also look at the employers exploiting this man and his family. how many businesses involved here? his jobs at different locations, his wife's job, his son's jobs. none of them paying payroll taxes, workers comp, health insurance...nothing. someone was making more money off of this family than I care to imagine. $5 an hour. the total picture is ugly. FUGLY. I think his employer should be held accountable for his hospital bill. maybe that will teach companies not to hire off the books, especially illegals. maybe it will teach them some kind of responsiblity. maybe JUST maybe, once those jobs dry up some the illegal immigration will slow down. if there are no jobs, no earning potential, they will not come. YES! Time for these corporations and business owners to be responsible for breaking the law too. I saw a special somewhere that showed one of the meat processing companies down south would go to Central America and bring workers here by the busload illegally and then ICE deports some, not penalties to the company, and they just do it over again. Sickening. If there were no jobs to be had for illegal immigrants, the lure to come here wouldn't be so great. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 10:07 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by Ophelia let's also look at the employers exploiting this man and his family. how many businesses involved here? his jobs at different locations, his wife's job, his son's jobs. none of them paying payroll taxes, workers comp, health insurance...nothing. someone was making more money off of this family than I care to imagine. $5 an hour. the total picture is ugly. FUGLY. I think his employer should be held accountable for his hospital bill. maybe that will teach companies not to hire off the books, especially illegals. maybe it will teach them some kind of responsiblity. maybe JUST maybe, once those jobs dry up some the illegal immigration will slow down. if there are no jobs, no earning potential, they will not come. ITA! EVERYONE involved should be held accountable. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 10:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by Ophelia let's also look at the employers exploiting this man and his family. how many businesses involved here? his jobs at different locations, his wife's job, his son's jobs. none of them paying payroll taxes, workers comp, health insurance...nothing. someone was making more money off of this family than I care to imagine. $5 an hour. the total picture is ugly. FUGLY. I think his employer should be held accountable for his hospital bill. maybe that will teach companies not to hire off the books, especially illegals. maybe it will teach them some kind of responsiblity. maybe JUST maybe, once those jobs dry up some the illegal immigration will slow down. if there are no jobs, no earning potential, they will not come. ITA. Very well said. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 10:22 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by tarabelle99 They have really painted the picture to be this poor illegal immigrant stuck in the hospital. Let's consider a few things Maybe he has no family interested in helping him because he is an insufferable bazturd. Maybe he beat his wife and kids growing up. The hospital has spent over a million dollars, unreimbursed, on his care because he is here illegally. This poor unfortunate soul contributed heavily to his own debt to the hospital by not working with the hospital social workers and being evasive with information. Know who is going to pay his bill? And the bills of others like him? We do. Higher insurance premiums. Higher hospital bills. You know what the article DOESN'T mention? The uncompensated care pool. Ever look at an Explanation of Benefits your insurance pays to a hospital after an inpatient stay? Ever notice that little NY State surcharge tucked in there, oh so neatly? Yeah, our insurance companies pay a surcharge to hospitals to assist in funding an uncompensated care pool, which is used to provide care to indigent people, including care provided to illegal immigrants. http://www.health.state.ny.us/facilities/hospital/indigent_care/2008_indigent_care_report.htm Of course, the primary cause for all of this is that the man was not here legally. Had he been a legal resident, his care would have been covered by Medicaid or even Medicare. Yet the man has lived here for 20+ years without ever paying income or payroll taxes, he will get a free ride. His credit won't be destroyed, he won't be sued, his accounts won't be levied, no garnishment of wages or disability.................. It's a sticky situation. Can't throw the man on the street, it is illegal and inhumane, but this is what is driving some hospitals under. So how do we fix it? ETA: Finally finished reading it. he lied.. he implied he lived up a 5story walk up (he was on the ground floor) he wasn't cut off from his family .. he WANTED to be cut off. He knew what he was doing even if the reasons were wrong. My husband's parents escaped Hong Kong for the same reasons. The same way. She's now a US citizen. 23yrs .. ? really? Sorry. But I think he got more than he deserved. Fine, top of the line care that most of us can't afford right now. I know *I* couldn't. I have insurance and it won't cover a year in the hospital. It wouldn't cover much of what he went through or treatments he should have gotten. I would have been banktrupted in trying to pay my copay, deductibles and responsible portions. He got it free. So he was confined to a hospital. Sounds like jail? well it should. There's a reason its called 'illegal'. I think he's lucky. I think he should be grateful. The story sounds like its supposed to be showing how sad the situtation is. I think its probably more common that we think and like PP said "WE" pay the price. I may be a US citizen. I may have a job. I may be of all sound mind and body but I can't afford a hosptial stay and I can barely afford my insurance premiums. The system is being s*cked dry by cases like this. I'm glad he got the care he needed. Lucky him. Maybe next time folks will know who he is... or is there a reason there's no photos? What's to stop him from seeking care like this again? The adult children who hate it here? Pfft. GO HOME then! Why complain about the country your father gave up everything for? You are here illegally.. make it right, go home. How ungrateful! Ironically, i know that's not possible. Hong Kong won't take them back. They won't take my husband either. Most of those kids (like my hubby) came to America under their parents passports, have none of their own. Unless the parents have the paperwork to file for the passport (which it seems these won't) they they are without citizenship. Unless they choose to become US citizens. Which with that attitude I guess isn't the case. ETA#2: HELL I couldnt even stay in the hospital more than 4days after my c/s cause *I* couldn't afford it and I had a higher than normal blood pressure and a torn incision.. I didn't need a year.. I needed a WEEK! Message edited 2011-10-05 10:50:52.887000. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 10:25 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year i may be a biotch for saying this, but i can't believe people actually feel sorry for this man. i have zero remorse for people who come here illegally and stay here illegally for more than 20 years, and then expect to receive free care. zero. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 10:40 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by mrsBLT i may be a biotch for saying this, but i can't believe people actually feel sorry for this man. i have zero remorse for people who come here illegally and stay here illegally for more than 20 years, and then expect to receive free care. zero. I don't feel sorry for him, I just think the businesses that continue to hire illegals should be held accountable too. If they can't get work, they would be less inclined to come here. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 10:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Just a note about employers paying people off the books. I know of several contractors who have LEGAL US citizens - born and bred working for them off the books as these guys do not want to be paid on the books - we are talking about guys getting $20 an hour cash for carpentry / laboring type of work. I know its not legal on the employers part but just wanted to point out that its not all illegal immigrants who insist on working OFF the books. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 10:54 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by Ophelia I think his employer should be held accountable for his hospital bill. maybe that will teach companies not to hire off the books, especially illegals. maybe it will teach them some kind of responsiblity. maybe JUST maybe, once those jobs dry up some the illegal immigration will slow down. if there are no jobs, no earning potential, they will not come. I COMPLETELY AGREE (yes shouting!!) In order to stop illegal immigration, you need to hold employers accountable for employees that are here illegally. Fine the hell out of them. Let them pay for undocumented workers' health care. Someone is hiring them & not paying payroll taxes, disability insurance, etc. We hire staff that are here on visas all of the time. I expect to get my arse handed to me if I were to hire someone without the proper documentation, that was checked personally. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 10:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by Xelindrya ETA#2: HELL I couldnt even stay in the hospital more than 4days after my c/s cause *I* couldn't afford it and I had a higher than normal blood pressure and a torn incision.. I didn't need a year.. I needed a WEEK! Yep - I was moved from an intensive care room at 11:59PM to a 'regular' room because my insurance company called and said "Get her outta there, we are not paying for that anymore." I'm sure my doctor didnt say that I didnt need it anymore - some reference book and pencil pusher made the decision that after almost dying I get X days in intensive care and after that, too bad. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 10:59 AM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by beachgirl Just a note about employers paying people off the books. I know of several contractors who have LEGAL US citizens - born and bred working for them off the books as these guys do not want to be paid on the books - we are talking about guys getting $20 an hour cash for carpentry / laboring type of work. I know its not legal on the employers part but just wanted to point out that its not all illegal immigrants who insist on working OFF the books. This is slightly off topic but just wanted to put it out there. I caveated my statement to say "especially illegal" the difference between being legal and illegal here is really negligible, except that the hospital would have been able to apply for emergency medicaid for a person without health insurance and the person would been transfered to a home for the rest of his treatment rather than have stayed in the hospital. the burden would shift from the hospital to the tax payer at that point. Message edited 2011-10-05 11:10:14.790000. |
Posted 10/5/11 11:09 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Thank Heavens people spoke up about this. I am not as eloquent as PP (especially Ophelia - whose posts I love reading on these issues , I learn SO much |
|
Posted 10/5/11 11:27 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year I have no sympathy for this man at all. I completely agree with both Tarabelle and Ophelia. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 11:35 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by kahlua716 I have no sympathy for this man at all. I completely agree with both Tarabelle and Ophelia. It's a disgusting story- and I literally rolled my eyes at the end of the article because the author seems to want us to feel bad for Fok and his family. How can you have no sympathy for a man who not only suffered a devastating stroke, but also faces a lifetime of dialysis and additional serious health problems? To feel sympathy for a human being who has suffered and endured such pain due to an array of serious health complications speaks to the core of what it means to be an empathic and decent human being. Your opinions about illegal immigration, the uninsured, and your criticisms of the "system" should have no bearing on your ability to feel empathy for another individual. What you wrote above is disgusting, not the story. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 1:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by tarabelle99 They have really painted the picture to be this poor illegal immigrant stuck in the hospital. Let's consider a few things Maybe he has no family interested in helping him because he is an insufferable bazturd. Maybe he beat his wife and kids growing up. The hospital has spent over a million dollars, unreimbursed, on his care because he is here illegally. This poor unfortunate soul contributed heavily to his own debt to the hospital by not working with the hospital social workers and being evasive with information. Know who is going to pay his bill? And the bills of others like him? We do. Higher insurance premiums. Higher hospital bills. You know what the article DOESN'T mention? The uncompensated care pool. Ever look at an Explanation of Benefits your insurance pays to a hospital after an inpatient stay? Ever notice that little NY State surcharge tucked in there, oh so neatly? Yeah, our insurance companies pay a surcharge to hospitals to assist in funding an uncompensated care pool, which is used to provide care to indigent people, including care provided to illegal immigrants. http://www.health.state.ny.us/facilities/hospital/indigent_care/2008_indigent_care_report.htm Of course, the primary cause for all of this is that the man was not here legally. Had he been a legal resident, his care would have been covered by Medicaid or even Medicare. Yet the man has lived here for 20+ years without ever paying income or payroll taxes, he will get a free ride. His credit won't be destroyed, he won't be sued, his accounts won't be levied, no garnishment of wages or disability.................. It's a sticky situation. Can't throw the man on the street, it is illegal and inhumane, but this is what is driving some hospitals under. So how do we fix it? This issue makes me very angry but I want to say THANK YOU for putting into words what I would love to scream from the rooftops... |
|
Posted 10/5/11 1:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by MrsA714 Posted by mrsBLT i may be a biotch for saying this, but i can't believe people actually feel sorry for this man. i have zero remorse for people who come here illegally and stay here illegally for more than 20 years, and then expect to receive free care. zero. I don't feel sorry for him, I just think the businesses that continue to hire illegals should be held accountable too. If they can't get work, they would be less inclined to come here. Yes and yes. But honestly, as much as the onus should fall on business owners for hiring illegal immigrants, whatever happened to OWNING your sh!t and admitting that you are here illegally no matter whether you are working or not?? |
|
Posted 10/5/11 1:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Message edited 2011-10-11 10:56:16.550000. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 1:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by headoverheels Posted by MrsA714 Posted by mrsBLT i may be a biotch for saying this, but i can't believe people actually feel sorry for this man. i have zero remorse for people who come here illegally and stay here illegally for more than 20 years, and then expect to receive free care. zero. I don't feel sorry for him, I just think the businesses that continue to hire illegals should be held accountable too. If they can't get work, they would be less inclined to come here. Yes and yes. But honestly, as much as the onus should fall on business owners for hiring illegal immigrants, whatever happened to OWNING your sh!t and admitting that you are here illegally no matter whether you are working or not?? While I agree there is a personal responsibility, they come for the job opportunities. If you want to stop illegal immigrants from coming, stop the companies & individuals that hire them. The problem is the hiring of these workers. The illegal immigrants are the symptom of the problem. |
|
Posted 10/5/11 2:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal immigrant in hosp for a year Posted by kahlua716 I have no sympathy for this man at all. I completely agree with both Tarabelle and Ophelia. It's a disgusting story- and I literally rolled my eyes at the end of the article because the author seems to want us to feel bad for Fok and his family. I do not see how you can have no compassion very sad that in the world we live in this is still the train of thought... VERY SAD! |
|
Posted 10/5/11 2:06 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |






There is so much wrong with the state that we are living in. I feel so bad for this mad. His family dynamics is just awful now. 





How ungrateful! Ironically, i know that's not possible. Hong Kong won't take them back. They won't take my husband either. Most of those kids (like my hubby) came to America under their parents passports, have none of their own. Unless the parents have the paperwork to file for the passport (which it seems these won't) they they are without citizenship. Unless they choose to become US citizens. Which with that attitude I guess isn't the case.





). When I read this at first and only a few people had responded, I was shocked at the sympathy being shown. I don't feel it at all. Not that I am glad he has a stroke and needed medical care, but he is here ILLEGALLY. WHY in the H-E-L-L does he get top notch care when he paid nothing in to the system. GRRRRR....


