If someone asks your nationality

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: If someone asks your nationality

I am not a smart@ss so I say Italian. They know what they mean. I know what they mean. No reason to make anyone feel uncomfortable.

Posted 10/7/10 6:23 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: If someone asks your nationality

Posted by Tilde
I know what they mean. No reason to make anyone feel uncomfortable.




ITA - I'll answer with ethnicity.

Posted 10/7/10 6:27 PM
 

Juliet
Family is Complete!

Member since 5/05

5913 total posts

Name:
Juliet

Re: If someone asks your nationality

Prior to meeting DH, I used to reply like the rest of us and say my grandparents' nationality, ItalianChat Icon
Since DH was born and raised in Poland and came here as a teen, he called me out on it once when I replied "Italian". From then on, I replied "Italian-American"

Interesting thing, though, a lot of people from outside of NY (and some other big cities) say that responding with your great-grandparents nationality is not very common.

Posted 10/7/10 6:29 PM
 

CAMCaps
Live Laugh Love Run

Member since 6/07

4922 total posts

Name:

Re: If someone asks your nationality

Posted by EnV-McC

Posted by nrthshgrl

If they ask me & I'm in the US, I refer to my ethnicity.

If they ask me & I'm outside of the US, I say I'm American.



Lol, this is me too!


Same here

Posted 10/7/10 6:32 PM
 

springchick
make a wish

Member since 5/08

3566 total posts

Name:
justask

Re: If someone asks your nationality

I am Dominican. I was born and raised there. When I have kids I am going to make sure they understand that they are American and that is their nation but (s)he's parents/grandparents are dominican.

Posted 10/7/10 7:06 PM
 

LondonMarie
LIF Infant

Member since 12/09

211 total posts

Name:
S.

Re: If someone asks your nationality

Posted by Erica

Posted by Tilde
I know what they mean. No reason to make anyone feel uncomfortable.




ITA - I'll answer with ethnicity.




same here

Posted 10/7/10 7:29 PM
 

Mushesgirl
Too blessed to be stressed

Member since 4/09

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: If someone asks your nationality

Posted by Mici C

What do you say?

ETS: I say American. I was born here. I am a citizen here. This is my nation and I'm proud to be an American.



I say EXACTLY the same thingChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/7/10 8:04 PM
 

queensgal
Smile

Member since 4/09

3287 total posts

Name:

Re: If someone asks your nationality

I usually say american and then I get looks - but I am - we traced my mom's family back to the civil war, sure along the way they married some people from europe, but at this point it is so mixed up I don't even know! I don't celebrate any of the traditions, speak other languages, etc. so I think I was raised very american.

I used to get a lot of looks before I changed to my married name. My dad is technically 100% polish - but ALL of my grandparents were born here. I can't cook polish foods and wasn't raised wtih any polish traditions. My mother in law asked me how to make kielbasa - I told her I buy hilshire farms when it goes on sale!

Posted 10/7/10 8:23 PM
 

PrincessVonTrockel
Trophy Wife in Training

Member since 11/09

2953 total posts

Name:
Natalie

Re: If someone asks your nationality

Posted by SingingBowlr

Maltese (Isle of Malta)






This is random, but we went there on our Honeymoon....it was sooooo beautiful there! I want to go again. Chat Icon

Posted 10/8/10 12:46 AM
 

PrincessVonTrockel
Trophy Wife in Training

Member since 11/09

2953 total posts

Name:
Natalie

Re: If someone asks your nationality

I always answer American.

Posted 10/8/10 12:48 AM
 

Tine73

Member since 3/06

22093 total posts

Name:
*********

Re: If someone asks your nationality

I say Italian bc I am 50% Italian and the other 50% is a total combo, so it's easier that way.

Posted 10/8/10 2:53 AM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: If someone asks your nationality

italian-american
proud of my heritage
proud to be an american

Message edited 2010-10-08 06:42:18.967000.

Posted 10/8/10 6:42 AM
 

JDubs
different, not less

Member since 7/09

13160 total posts

Name:

Re: If someone asks your nationality

i am a first generation italian american

Posted 10/8/10 9:26 AM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: If someone asks your nationality

American.

my last relative came over in 1923... so.. we're American

Posted 10/8/10 12:02 PM
 

Mushesgirl
Too blessed to be stressed

Member since 4/09

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: If someone asks your nationality

Posted by queensgal

I usually say american and then I get looks - but I am - we traced my mom's family back to the civil war, sure along the way they married some people from europe, but at this point it is so mixed up I don't even know! I don't celebrate any of the traditions, speak other languages, etc. so I think I was raised very american.

I used to get a lot of looks before I changed to my married name. My dad is technically 100% polish - but ALL of my grandparents were born here. I can't cook polish foods and wasn't raised wtih any polish traditions. My mother in law asked me how to make kielbasa - I told her I buy hilshire farms when it goes on sale!



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/8/10 12:36 PM
 

MrsSchwags
Soccer Baseball Lax Mom

Member since 10/05

11240 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: If someone asks your nationality

I say American - but I feel that whenever I ask that question many aren't looking for that answer. So then I say 1/2 Italian 1/2 German.

Posted 10/8/10 12:51 PM
 

seaside
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

3101 total posts

Name:

Re: If someone asks your nationality

When people ask that--they typically (IMO) want to know where your ancestors came from--which often indicates a lot about your "culture"--langauages possibly spoken at home--holidays celebrated, foods you eat, more about your family's identity.

We've had this discussion on here before. Jews answer Jewish because Jewish people have been persecuted, massacred, and expelled from so many countries (many of which no longer even exist)--had their names changed--lost their possessions and their rights to own property/operate certain businesses, etc. that wherever the family "wound up"--the U.S., Cuba, Canada, etc. was likely not some families' ancestral homeland the way, say, Norway, Wales, or Spain might have been for some other families.

Because of the Holocaust, or even the expulsions that resulted in people showing up on Ellis Island or elsewhere, many Jewish families lack the authentic original name, heirlooms, family crest, etc. that families that didn't face that discrimination and thsoe atrocities were able to retain. Thus, when someone wants to know about lineage, heritage, culture--the thing Jewish people often have--the only thing many have--is simply the religion.

Think about it--if your family was massacred/expelled out from place to place every couple of hundereds of years, wound up, in let's say, what used to be (but no longer is) Poland in a segregated ghetto for Jews, and then either made it to the U.S. for a better life, or got caught up in the Holocaust en route--had their names changed at Ellis Island--and made it out with the clothes on their backs--they are not likely to have the same cultural attachment to or identify with Poland the way many other families identify with their ancestral homelands, where teh family may have been there forever, integrated into mainstream society, etc.



I don't mind explaining this to people, but I get annoyed IRL when people get annoyed with others for answering "Jewish"--like they got the question "wrong" or something.

Posted 10/8/10 12:57 PM
 

SingingBowlr
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/07

571 total posts

Name:
John

Re: If someone asks your nationality

Posted by PrincessVonTrockel

Posted by SingingBowlr

Maltese (Isle of Malta)






This is random, but we went there on our Honeymoon....it was sooooo beautiful there! I want to go again. Chat Icon



I've been to Scotland, but not Malta. It's definitely on our want-to-go list. Thanks for the good review! Chat Icon

Posted 10/8/10 1:04 PM
 

PrincessVonTrockel
Trophy Wife in Training

Member since 11/09

2953 total posts

Name:
Natalie

Re: If someone asks your nationality

Posted by Mushesgirl

Posted by queensgal

My mother in law asked me how to make kielbasa - I told her I buy hilshire farms when it goes on sale!



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon





Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/8/10 2:33 PM
 

Jennifer
Happy

Member since 5/05

4230 total posts

Name:
.

Re: If someone asks your nationality

Posted by Mici C

What do you say?

ETS: I say American. I was born here. I am a citizen here. This is my nation and I'm proud to be an American.



I start off by that as well!!! Followed by my heritage is....

I knew someone who was visiting from Ireland who said, why do Americans always say they're from another country when they are born in America??

Posted 10/8/10 2:47 PM
 

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: If someone asks your nationality

Posted by yankinmanc

American. I got asked that already twice today. Once by a lady who was handcuffed to two other ladies, and another by a lady at school. The first one was much scarier then the second.

I get asked this question every.single.day.of.my.life.



Chat Icon Where were you that you were around 3 women handcuffed to each other? Your day was way more interesting than mine!

Posted 10/8/10 3:29 PM
 

Kahuna
LIF Toddler

Member since 4/10

497 total posts

Name:

Re: If someone asks your nationality

Nobody has ever asked me.

Posted 10/8/10 3:32 PM
 

Buttafli1277
LIF Adult

Member since 8/05

2638 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: If someone asks your nationality

Posted by Andrewz00

Posted by PreshusSmurf

Jewish or American, depending on the context of the conversation.




hmmm.. i never quite figured that one out... like Jewish from Judea?

why is it that Jewish people always say Jewish? should i have been saying all along "Im Catholic" ?


Nationality: American
Ethnicity: Italian and German





I always wondered the same thing. Isn't Jewish a religion??

Posted 10/10/10 11:08 PM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: If someone asks your nationality

Posted by Erica

Posted by Tilde
I know what they mean. No reason to make anyone feel uncomfortable.




ITA - I'll answer with ethnicity.




Me too.

Posted 10/11/10 4:10 AM
 

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Re: If someone asks your nationality

Since I live outside of the US, I say American. My surname is very Polish so I get asked why I have a Polish name. I then explain that my father's family came from Poland. They ask when, I tell them. Then they have a puzzled look as to why I still have my last name. It's annoying, I mean what am I supposed to do change my last name? I then get asked why my accent doesn't sound American when I speak German. It's a vicious cycle. I'm not sure myself what I am these days Chat Icon .

When I visit the US I say Polish and Italian. Interestingly, in Australia, which is also a melting pot, they always say Australian.

Posted 10/11/10 4:35 AM
 
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
if youa re more than one nationality do you.. 04bride 1/3/08 75 Families Helping Families ™
If a security guard asks you to not talk on a cell phone in a particular building Juliet 10/20/06 15 Families Helping Families ™
If Leo asks me one more time if I am still greasing up my stomach.. Janice 10/4/06 4 Pregnancy