|
Re: If someone asks your nationality
Posted 10/8/2010 12:57:29 PM by seaside When people ask that--they typically (IMO) want to know where your ancestors came from--which often indicates a lot about your "culture"--langauages possibly spoken at home--holidays celebrated, foods you eat, more about your family's identity. We've had this discussion on here before. Jews answer Jewish because Jewish people have been persecuted, massacred, and expelled from so many countries (many of which no longer even exist)--had their names changed--lost their possessions and their rights to own property/operate certain businesses, etc. that wherever the family "wound up"--the U.S., Cuba, Canada, etc. was likely not some families' ancestral homeland the way, say, Norway, Wales, or Spain might have been for some other families. Because of the Holocaust, or even the expulsions that resulted in people showing up on Ellis Island or elsewhere, many Jewish families lack the authentic original name, heirlooms, family crest, etc. that families that didn't face that discrimination and thsoe atrocities were able to retain. Thus, when someone wants to know about lineage, heritage, culture--the thing Jewish people often have--the only thing many have--is simply the religion. Think about it--if your family was massacred/expelled out from place to place every couple of hundereds of years, wound up, in let's say, what used to be (but no longer is) Poland in a segregated ghetto for Jews, and then either made it to the U.S. for a better life, or got caught up in the Holocaust en route--had their names changed at Ellis Island--and made it out with the clothes on their backs--they are not likely to have the same cultural attachment to or identify with Poland the way many other families identify with their ancestral homelands, where teh family may have been there forever, integrated into mainstream society, etc. I don't mind explaining this to people, but I get annoyed IRL when people get annoyed with others for answering "Jewish"--like they got the question "wrong" or something. |