I really need some name help - UPDATED

Posted By Message

carissa1643
I LOVE my sons! :)

Member since 5/09

5283 total posts

Name:
Carissa

I really need some name help - UPDATED

UPDATE:
I just want to sincerely thank everyone for their help. I really dont know what I would do without this board everyday! Chat Icon

We decided to name our Chat Icon Constantine William. This is after DH's father and my father. If I have another boy I'll use Joseph. Since I really want Joseph as a first name I would hate to pass up my dad's name as a middle name and then name my second Joseph on top of that. I thought this was fair and I'm finally comfortable with it. If he needs a nickname when he gets older it will be Dean, otherwise I finally like the name the way it is.

Thank you again for all your help!! Chat Icon

*******************************
I hope you ladies aren't sick of me asking for help, but everyone that I can ask is biased so I hope you don't mind. I thought I could make a decision but I'm totally completely torn. I really have no idea what to do.

Let me start off by saying honestly the most important thing I'm praying for is a healthy baby.

Heres the situation. My DH is greek and I'm not. Greek tradition says the first child is named after the paternal grandparents, boy or girl, then the second child is named after the maternal grandparents. I always knew this would be an issue from when we dating at one month. His parents names are Aspasia and Constantine. I agreed on his mother's name. His father's name I'm having difficulty with bc I always wanted to name my son Joseph after my grandfather who passed away 3 years ago. We both agreed a few months ago the baby's name would be Aspasia or Joseph. Now that I find out I'm having a boy, things are changing.

We're baptizing the baby in Greece with an orthodox ceremony, same as the wedding was. This is my idea to include his family in such an important event. His sister who lives there is going to be the godmother. My parents and siblings are also able to come. Most of his family is in Greece, including his parents. So now the issue is bring over a Joseph to the very old school greek community is coming off as disrespectful and insulting, epecially since DH is the only boy and this is our 1st boy it "should" be Constantine. When in reality, its the last thing I ever wanted to do. I thought we would be compromising by using the name I want with the people that matter most to DH.

It's not that I have a problem with the name at all, its more my family and my grandfather. He never had anyone named after him. And I miss him like crazy and I know his side of the family does. My extended family would be absolutely thrilled if I named him Joseph after him, espcially since his wife, my grandmother, has a boyfriend for the past 2 years. I want to do it as a reminder that I still miss him and think about him. I've thought about every way to arrange the names. I'm just so worried if I do Constantine I won't have another son. My options are:
1. Constantine Joseph (call him Joseph with our friends and family)
2. Constantine (call him Constantine, hope for another boy)
3. Joseph Constantine (hope his parents forgive us, next baby if its a girl would have to be Aspasia which I dont love. Aspasia would totally be ruled out if I decided on Constantine)

Please keep in mind for DH and his family I have decided to:
- get baptized greek before the wedding, which means my family can never be godparents to my kids or vice versa
- have a completely greek orthodox wedding ceremony
- still agreed to do these things without my family's support

I'm not and would never use these things against my DH or his family, they are definately my decision but I just don't see the compromise here.

Anyone that has gotten this far about something so silly I seriously appreciate it, I'm just about to cry here I'm so emotional and I hate not feeling the way I should about such a happy time. Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-09-14 10:22:25.200000.

Posted 9/10/09 12:34 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Michelle1123
Baby #5 on the way!

Member since 9/05

7919 total posts

Name:

Re: I really need some name help

I would switch it. Use YOUR family's name (with his fathers as a middle) and use the mothers next (if you have a girl)

Posted 9/10/09 12:38 PM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: I really need some name help

If you use Constantine Joseph, are you sayinig that your friends and family would call him Joseph and DH's family would call him Constantine??

Posted 9/10/09 12:39 PM
 

carissa1643
I LOVE my sons! :)

Member since 5/09

5283 total posts

Name:
Carissa

Re: I really need some name help

Posted by maybeamommy

If you use Constantine Joseph, are you sayinig that your friends and family would call him Joseph and DH's family would call him Constantine??



I dont know, you think thats silly right?

Posted 9/10/09 12:42 PM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: I really need some name help

Posted by carissa1643

Posted by maybeamommy

If you use Constantine Joseph, are you sayinig that your friends and family would call him Joseph and DH's family would call him Constantine??



I dont know, you think thats silly right?



Yeah, I think it will be confusing for Chat Icon

What about calling him CJ?

Posted 9/10/09 12:48 PM
 

carolyns4cupcakes
C ♥'s F

Member since 2/07

6456 total posts

Name:

Re: I really need some name help

There is no right or wrong (I think) but what may be "best" is if chose Constantine and call it a day! Chat Icon

TOUGH situation.

Constantine Joseph works but I doubt calling him Joseph will fly KWIM?

Again, tough situation. I wish you luck. Since you aren't teamChat Icon anymore, please don't stress this for the entire pregnancy, it's not worth it. Enjoy the remainder of your pg!

Good luck!

Posted 9/10/09 12:49 PM
 

carissa1643
I LOVE my sons! :)

Member since 5/09

5283 total posts

Name:
Carissa

Re: I really need some name help

Posted by maybeamommy

Posted by carissa1643

Posted by maybeamommy

If you use Constantine Joseph, are you sayinig that your friends and family would call him Joseph and DH's family would call him Constantine??



I dont know, you think thats silly right?



Yeah, I think it will be confusing for Chat Icon

What about calling him CJ?



CJ is actually my cousins name, the J is for Joseph too lol. If we werent so close that would defiantely be an option.

Posted 9/10/09 12:50 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: I really need some name help

Joseph.

boy #2 can be after his family

girl can be after his family.

you are being very understanding already with the godparent situation.

did you meet your DH in Greece or America? time for his fam to start melting in this pot.

Posted 9/10/09 12:50 PM
 

MrsNicolaxoxo
<3

Member since 6/09

3403 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: I really need some name help

I would do Joseph Constantine. They will forgive you, it's your baby and Joseph means a lot to you. Don't even worry about the old school family in Greece...they will get over it and will just be happy for you to go visit with the baby. Who cares what they say behind your back!!! I have the old school italians to deal with so I know how it is!

Posted 9/10/09 12:50 PM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: I really need some name help

I think you have to determine for youself, not thinking (at first) about DH's family, what you would like his name to be and how important it is for you. If it is very important that he is named or called Joseph, I would make sure that happens. You have been so understanding with DH's family and traditions, but you matter too, and they need to accept you and your desires. Not all of you decisions can be based on DH's heritage and family. However, if it's not really important to you, either give him COnstantine alone, and if you have another boy, it will be Joseph, and if you have a girl, it will be whatever you wish. Or, name him Constantine Joseph, and call him whatever you wish (CJ, Joseph) and let DH's family call him whatever they wish (your little man will eventually decide what he wants to be called and everyone will have to respect that) and you get to pick any names for your future son and/or daughter.

Posted 9/10/09 1:04 PM
 

bluekat16
My boys :-)

Member since 3/09

6659 total posts

Name:
Kathy

Re: I really need some name help

I think you should go with Joseph.

It seems that you've compromised on everyhting up to know to accomodate their Greek traditions. this is great on your part but your children should be named whatever you want.

I think they'll forgive you once they see the baby.

Posted 9/10/09 1:12 PM
 

katiebug
I'll love you for always

Member since 2/08

4624 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: I really need some name help

Personally I would do Constantine Joseph OR Constantine and if I had another boy name him Joseph. It might be that I am part Greek and understand how important it is to them that makes me think this way. I was adamant about our first sons middle name being Michael after my Grandfather (from Greece) and my husband is adamant about our first daughter having the middle name Love after his grandmother, so I totally understand how important names can be.

Neither choice is going to be easy, but whatever you and your DH decide to do, once the baby is here the name you choose will fit him.

P.S. I also really love the name Constantine Joseph. Chat Icon

Posted 9/10/09 1:15 PM
 

Marbo
LOVE

Member since 7/08

2374 total posts

Name:

Re: I really need some name help

I don't know if you have read about my baby naming issues-similar to yours only my dh is italian(if you want the whole story I can fm you)...if you agreed to aspasia and joseph from the beginning that's what it should be, although I know people's minds change(especially now that you know the sex)...is naming this boy after your dh an option? Then he's done and you name the next one? I am really sorry for you I totally understand how you are feeling-the naming thing gave me stress before I was even pregnant-instead of it being nice and fun.

Posted 9/10/09 1:19 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: I really need some name help

Here is my .02

I have a III. There is no way that my first son would not be named after my husband and his father (deceased). I, too, wanted to name my child Joseph after my deceased grandfather.

But, maybe I am old school, and maybe I will get flamed for this, but I would follow the tradition. Name him Constantine Joseph.

Posted 9/10/09 1:25 PM
 

BriBri2u
L'amore vince sempre

Member since 5/05

9320 total posts

Name:
Mrs. B

Re: I really need some name help

I would go with Joseph. You have done everything else to respect the tradition.

They have to understand that YOUR family has traditions as well. Sorry, it just seems so one sided. You've obliged to all their traditions/requests thus far. When is it time for them to do the same?

A friend of mine married a Greek man. They had the typical Greek wedding etc...

When she got pregnant, the whole "this person isn't Greek, so they can't be a godparent".

She put her foot down. She only has one sibiling - whom she is very close with. She didn't care what tradition said, her sibiling was going to be a godparent. His mother went balistic & it came down to my friend basically telling her mil - either live with it or don't see your grandchildren (her MIL said she wouldn't have anything to do with their children if they went along with this).

She got over it.

I commend you for honoring their traditions, I just don't think I could give in to all the traditions of one persons family and pretend like I'm not hurt by it. JMO

Posted 9/10/09 1:28 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: I really need some name help

We have this issue in our family, almost everyone has 2 names and grew up with 2 names. Sometimes similar like Sara=Sally sometimes completely unrelated like Abraham=Nicholas. Legally our Hebrew names taken from our parents and grandparents, at home and friends its 2nd name. This is just how they always did it. Its backwards of what most American Jews do.

My aunt, who married into the family, was so offended by this practice, she didn't name her baby girl until 3 years old, because she didn't want to deal with it. We just called her baby forever and at the age of 22, I slip up and call her baby sometimes!


It was never traumatic, but definitely confusing and annoying growing up. But I respect old traditions, and probably would do Constantine Joseph. But myself would call the baby Joey.








Posted 9/10/09 3:09 PM
 

kahlua716
3 Girls for Me!

Member since 8/07

12475 total posts

Name:
Keri

Re: I really need some name help

Posted by bluekat16

I think you should go with Joseph.

It seems that you've compromised on everyhting up to know to accomodate their Greek traditions. this is great on your part but your children should be named whatever you want.

I think they'll forgive you once they see the baby.



ITA!! Why should you be the one to make all the sacrifices. Use Constantine as a middle name

Posted 9/10/09 3:13 PM
 

shiv
Twinsanity!!

Member since 5/07

4747 total posts

Name:
Shiv

Re: I really need some name help

1. Constantine Joseph (call him Joseph with our friends and family)

I was going to say this before I read it as an option. I think it solves everything, and alot of people go by there middle names. My brother is named after my father and goes by his middle name, I forget that it's not his real name because that's all he's know as.

And when your son goes to Greece, they'll call him whatever but when he's living his everyday life, he'll be Joseph!

Posted 9/10/09 3:14 PM
 

Sweets13
Bella Bambini

Member since 5/05

9300 total posts

Name:

Re: I really need some name help

I come from a very traditional old school Italian family and like the Greek's, the first boy and girl are named after the father's parents. My son was named after my FIL which also happens to be my DH's name. My second was a girl and we didn't name her after my MIL. My parents had more of an issue with it than my inlaws. They were afraid my MIL would be offended, which was not the case at all.

The ONLY thing that is making me tell you that you should name him Constantine is that you are baptizing him in GREECE and it would look disrespectful and insulting since it is taking place in their country, kwim?

Ugh, I feel so bad for you that you have to go through this. What does your DH say about it?

Posted 9/10/09 3:32 PM
 

carissa1643
I LOVE my sons! :)

Member since 5/09

5283 total posts

Name:
Carissa

Re: I really need some name help

My DH is just concerned about how his father and his father's family will feel about. He knows how sensitive this is to me but since we agreed on Aspasia and Joseph from the beginning he said he won't go back on it. I don't him to stress about this either and I know he would do it for me, but I just don't know if it's worth it to name him Joseph with all the "looks" and greek talking I would be getting. I'm sure once the baby is here they will defiantely accept him and call him whatever we say I just hate to be the cause of any unnecessary BS, kwim? Obviously, going by track record of appeasing his family I would rather just keep the peace. Chat Icon

Posted 9/10/09 3:39 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: I really need some name help

I would do Constantine Joseph, this way BOTH men and the tradition is honored. it just seems to me that they are really still steeped in their traditions, and that would mean a lot to me for my son to follow in his father's traditions.

when you are baptising someone with a name in memory or honor of another, to me it doesn't matter whether it's first or second name.

I think it would be lovely...and yeah, people can call him whichever they chose.

and FYI, in Central America, people use the middle name when addressing someone. don't know what your background is, but it would not be strange to do that at all...to use Joseph as his common name. Chat Icon

ETA: when your son gets older, you will be able to tell him how he was named after two wonderful men. it doesn't get much better than that.

Message edited 2009-09-10 15:41:40.963000.

Posted 9/10/09 3:39 PM
 

carissa1643
I LOVE my sons! :)

Member since 5/09

5283 total posts

Name:
Carissa

Re: I really need some name help - UPDATED

bump for update

Posted 9/14/09 10:22 AM
 

Sweets13
Bella Bambini

Member since 5/05

9300 total posts

Name:

Re: I really need some name help - UPDATED

Great update and I think you made the right decision! Nice way to honor BOTH your father and fil.

Chat Icon

Posted 9/14/09 11:09 AM