I have a question about morals

Posted By Message

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

I have a question about morals

The post about handicapped parking spaces reminded me - but this is more of a personal issue.

I have severasl extended family members that I love dearly but their idea of morals is very dissimmilar to mine.

Small example: In doing taxes for the past three years, they used an accountant who INTENTIONALLY omitted information regarding their employer-run retirement plan so they could get more money back on their tax return.

Of course the IRS caught on and they owe money now for the past several years.

I say that this is black-and-white wrong, I don't see any other way to look at it, I physically cannot make myself see that this is right or okay in any way.

This particular family member insists there is nothing wrong, that it wasn't a lie, it was an omission, and not morally wrong at all.

I have other extended family members who see nothing wrong with purchasing items from someone who comes into their place of business selling obviously stolen items. It bothers me SO much but they truly feel that there is nothing wrong with what they are doing.

My biggest problem? I have a hard time wrapping my brain around the fact that this is a moral issue and not a black-and-white, right-or-wrong issue. It's not an opinion thing, and I don't see how they can think behavior like this is right at all.

So my question: can morality really be a gray area, or is it more black-and-white?

Posted 5/19/11 9:45 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: I have a question about morals

While I don't agree that it's okay to receive stolen goods (though I've probably fudged a little on my taxes), I think morals are definitely a gray area.

Posted 5/19/11 9:50 AM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: I have a question about morals

Im usually a "back-white right-wrong " person.. I have always been. However.. the ex you give...Im questioning a bit.. I take the second example as bootleg DVD purchases...I don't have a moral problem with that. I know my acct probably exaggerated how much we contributed to charity on my taxes...do i feel morally wrong.. nah....

so I guess to answer the question...not everything is black or white. SOME things definitely are to ME... though...
everyone has their own moral compass...so to you it may be black or white..to me..gray...

Message edited 2011-05-19 09:52:06.160000.

Posted 5/19/11 9:50 AM
 

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: I have a question about morals

I think it can be gray, but some actions are black and white. Like in your example, they knowingly omitted the information because it directly benefited them, that's the same as lying to me. Having mistakenly omitted it for years being unaware of the benefit, totally different to me.

Hopefully that makes sense.....

Message edited 2011-05-19 10:03:00.950000.

Posted 5/19/11 9:51 AM
 

BethanyLynn
Love these munchkins

Member since 10/09

6295 total posts

Name:
Bethany

Re: I have a question about morals

Posted by jilliibabii

While I don't agree that it's okay to receive stolen goods (though I've probably fudged a little on my taxes), I think morals are definitely a gray area.



ITA

Posted 5/19/11 9:51 AM
 

AngnShaun
Sisters

Member since 1/10

21015 total posts

Name:
Ang

Re: I have a question about morals

My first thought was yes there are lots of gray areas... because everyone is different... just because the state or us govt says its illegal doesnt mean its morally wrong to some people...

Posted 5/19/11 9:53 AM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: I have a question about morals

Buying stolen goods is illegal
Purposely omitting info on your taxes is probably illegal as well.


What was the point in omitting tax info when they knew they would get caught and have to not only pay what they owed but now also have to pay a fee and interest?


Posted 5/19/11 10:01 AM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: I have a question about morals

Lying by omission is still lying. They knew what they were doing, that is black and white to me.

Posted 5/19/11 10:06 AM
 

memi7206
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2355 total posts

Name:
Due Dec 29th!!!!!

Re: I have a question about morals

while there are things that are black and white, I think even parts of those things can have a grey area to some people whereas they can overlook an offense based on how they view the severity of it, even if its technically "wrong". They may see it as less wrong for one reason, while you see it as more wrong for another.

Not to beat a dead horse, and Im not calling anyone out, just using this as a recent example. There are some people who felt VERY strongly about not parking in the handicapped spot, while they felt that speeding, while breaking the law was a much lesser offense.

In that case, its a personal issue. While both parties are wrong, one feels one instance is more wrong than the other. I think the people who were most offended by the handicap space issue, had people close to them who were handicapped but have never lost someone in a crash caused by excessive speed. Yet if you asked someone who lost a family member due to a reckless driver traveling at a high rate of speed, they would feel that was the bigger offense. Point is, I think its all relative to a person experiences, KWIM?

Message edited 2011-05-19 10:10:02.557000.

Posted 5/19/11 10:08 AM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: I have a question about morals

I think everyone's personal opinion as to whether something is right or wrong is very black and white. But the collective opinions of everyone makes it much more a gray issue.

I feel very strongly one way and you feel very strongly the other way. I'm black, you're white... together we are gray!

Posted 5/19/11 10:13 AM
 

bird382
.

Member since 7/07

1712 total posts

Name:

Re: I have a question about morals

Few things to me are as easy as black or white. I'm comfortable in the gray area but understand that some people NEED to see things as black or white to feel comfortable. It's just easier to compartmentalize something as right or wrong -- even though, IMO, many issues are not that simple.

Also, I don't necessarily think that something is amoral just because it's illegal. Sure, many illegal things are CLEARLY amoral...but not all.

Posted 5/19/11 10:32 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: I have a question about morals

Posted by memi7206

while there are things that are black and white, I think even parts of those things can have a grey area to some people whereas they can overlook an offense based on how they view the severity of it, even if its technically "wrong". They may see it as less wrong for one reason, while you see it as more wrong for another.

Not to beat a dead horse, and Im not calling anyone out, just using this as a recent example. There are some people who felt VERY strongly about not parking in the handicapped spot, while they felt that speeding, while breaking the law was a much lesser offense.

In that case, its a personal issue. While both parties are wrong, one feels one instance is more wrong than the other. I think the people who were most offended by the handicap space issue, had people close to them who were handicapped but have never lost someone in a crash caused by excessive speed. Yet if you asked someone who lost a family member due to a reckless driver traveling at a high rate of speed, they would feel that was the bigger offense. Point is, I think its all relative to a person experiences, KWIM?



I agree with this. It can be both B&W and gray.

Although I don't know anyone close to me that qualifies to park in a handicap spot, I do feel very strongly against it. But yes I think that personal experiences make for stronger stances.

Posted 5/19/11 10:50 AM
 

emilylives
biking

Member since 12/09

2163 total posts

Name:
Emily

Re: I have a question about morals

There are certain situations that are more black and white (murder, for example), but generally, I think that there is so much gray in morality.

ETA I, personally, see those as morally wrong. However, I don't see it as there's no question, or wonder how anyone could disagree with me.

Message edited 2011-05-19 13:28:39.757000.

Posted 5/19/11 1:27 PM
 

DumpsterBaby
My compass when I'm lost

Member since 5/11

2210 total posts

Name:
My anchor when I get tossed

Re: I have a question about morals

Like PP have said, I think there are gray areas and black and white areas. Everyone (hopefully) has a sense of morality and uses their (hopefully) best judgment.

Posted 5/19/11 1:29 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: I have a question about morals

Morals is really grey.

Your example is black and white. Omissions were INTENTIONAL. How is that NOT a lie??

Posted 5/19/11 3:05 PM
 

emilylives
biking

Member since 12/09

2163 total posts

Name:
Emily

Re: I have a question about morals

Every time someone says "How can that not be wrong," I just think about abortion, or the death penalty, or stem cells, or gun control, or handicapped parking spaces, and realize that there are always going to be the people who say "This is wrong without a shadow of a doubt" and those that completely disagree. Nothing is wrong without a shadow of a doubt to everyone on the planet.

Posted 5/19/11 3:44 PM
 

PeasandCarrots
♥

Member since 5/07

9579 total posts

Name:
L

Re: I have a question about morals

Posted by memi7206


Not to beat a dead horse, and Im not calling anyone out, just using this as a recent example. There are some people who felt VERY strongly about not parking in the handicapped spot, while they felt that speeding, while breaking the law was a much lesser offense.




I 200% agree! I think that for some people it's very black and white. You know the right thing to do and you do it no matter what. You come to complete stops at a stop sign, you don't park in a handicap spot, you don't lie on your taxes, and you don't buy things you know are stolen. However, some people feel like it's ok to justify things thus making it a gray area. I didn't see anybody coming so no I didn't stop, I didn't lie about the taxes I just "forgot", I didn't have proof that was stolen, and I didn't see the sign. Does it make them wrong....to a black and white person Yes, but to somebody else they had no intention of hurting anybody so No they just did what was easier/best for them.

I think that having high morals is doing what is right even when nobody is looking and when nobody expects it. Like Stopping at a stop sign is easy......calling 911 when you see someone laying on the sidewalk seems to be a hard thing to do these dayChat Icon Does that make sense?

Posted 5/19/11 5:49 PM
 

DGoldfarb0776
LIF Adolescent

Member since 4/08

767 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: I have a question about morals

My first thorught goes back to when I was buying clothing last night in Sears.

DH had given me the cash to make a payment on his Discover card, and I also had to buy some shorts for the summer.

The cashier took the payment, and processed it without any problems. Then he just bagged up my clothes and took off the sensors and such as he did that... I didn't pay anything for the clothing and he didn't scan any items. I could have probably easily walked out of the store and into our car without paying...that would have been about $200.00 of free clothing.

Me being the person that I am, I say something and he was ever so grateful that I did! He thanked me for being honest about it as I'm sure it could have been his job on the line if I had gotten all those free clothes.

To me it's black/white right/wrong kind of thing. The one time I know I'm doing something wrong is probably the time that I'm going to get caught.

Posted 5/19/11 7:41 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: I have a question about morals

Morals for sure have grey areas, its very subjective. The examples you gave are more black and white but theres always much more to every story , and some things are just clearer then others.

Posted 5/19/11 9:23 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
closing question and walk through question? nancygrace 1/6/07 3 Home
Not a TTC question, but a personal question Ambersmom 12/26/06 5 TTC
First question....now 2nd question... dree 10/27/06 10 Parenting
Paint Question (2nd question in org. post) MrsSchwags 10/5/06 12 Home
I have a question and Forgive me post( another question on bottom) luvsbob4603 6/16/06 14 Families Helping Families ™
Another question before I become a mom- Hospital question Shelly 4/10/06 11 Parenting