i don't understand
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
i don't understand when will people learn?????? |
|
Posted 7/12/09 4:32 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: i don't understand I would flip out if my "friend" did that with my kid!!! |
|
Posted 7/12/09 4:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand Im not condoning what she did by any means... |
|
Posted 7/12/09 4:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand Posted by hbugal What age is acceptable? What are the guidelines? At what age is a child mature enough to be left unattended? Would this have been OK if the eldest child was 13? i can't answer that, but i know for sure that i would not leave a 10 and a 7 year old in charge of a 9 month old baby at home, let alone in a car parked outside the mall while i went shopping. and even if the eldest was 13 and not 10, no, i don't think it's acceptable. there was an infant in the car. would i change my mind if there was a 13 year old and a 7 year old in the car? maybe... but i doubt it. i have not been in that situation yet. |
|
Posted 7/12/09 5:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand I don't think any child under age 18 should be left alone- period! |
|
Posted 7/12/09 5:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand OMGGGGGGGGG idiots!!!!!! |
|
Posted 7/12/09 5:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand UNREAL!!!! |
|
Posted 7/12/09 5:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand Posted by hbugal Im not condoning what she did by any means... But here is the thing... What age is acceptable? What are the guidelines? At what age is a child mature enough to be left unattended? Would this have been OK if the eldest child was 13? weird....I was thinking the same. is it different if the 10 year old was left at home with kids? |
|
Posted 7/12/09 5:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand terrible....people are stupid, period |
|
Posted 7/12/09 5:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand Posted by Janice Posted by hbugal Im not condoning what she did by any means... But here is the thing... What age is acceptable? What are the guidelines? At what age is a child mature enough to be left unattended? Would this have been OK if the eldest child was 13? weird....I was thinking the same. is it different if the 10 year old was left at home with kids? My girls are 10 and I wouldnt leave them at home watching their little brother...even if he was sound asleep...In general I dont leave them home alone at all (although I have left them while Ive taken a walk around the block or dropped one off at school when the other is sick) Around here we have before and after school care, I believe, through 6th grade...So then is the consensus then that children older than 12/13 can stay alone??? My SILs were just here from Florida and where they live before and after school care is through 4th grade so where they live it is quite common for 10 year olds to come home alone after school... Is there a law or something that says what is appropriate? Or is it left up to ones own judgement? And...if there isnt a law who are we to say then that someones judgement is wrong just b/c it differs from our own? Were the children in eminent danger? We spend our lives, as parents, protecting our children from "maybes" and "could bes"...we're all bound to make a bad decision from time to time. Like I said though..I do agree that, to leave those kids in the car, was totally inappropriate... |
|
Posted 7/12/09 6:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand Posted by Arieschick29 I don't think any child under age 18 should be left alone- period! I would never for fear of heat, kidnapping, carjacking etc. My mother or father never left us alone- in the car, in the house anywhere. I am totally not condoning what this woman did, but I don't understand your statement. You wouldn't leave a 17 year old home alone? Would you get a baby-sitter for your 17 year old? 17 year olds can drive. Would you not let your child drive by themselves? Just curious..... My mom started leaving me home around 14. I wasn't allowed though to watch my brother who was 3 years younger until I was 15. 10 is definitly too young especially with an infant in the car. Some people just don't think. ETA: I was babysitting other people's children at 15 also.... Message edited 2009-07-12 20:25:05.600000. |
|
Posted 7/12/09 8:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand Posted by hbugal Im not condoning what she did by any means... But here is the thing... What age is acceptable? What are the guidelines? At what age is a child mature enough to be left unattended? Would this have been OK if the eldest child was 13? I would not have left my girls unattended in a car with their brother..especially not with another child in my care. But I have left them in the car while Ive run into the dry cleaners...but that is only b/c I park exactly in front of the store and I can see them AND the door is open of the dry cleaner..etc...etc... I don't think they should've been unattended in the car period for that length of time. Running into the dry cleaners or the post office is different from a 20+ minute shopping trip. But that aside. I would allow my child to stay unattended at the same age I would be allowing the child to go to inside the mall alone. For me, I think I was about 12 when I was allowed to go to the mall without my mom. That sounds reasonable. In this situation though, there was also a baby involved. I don't think those kids were old enough to be left in charge of the baby. I would not have a 10 year old babysitting a 9 month old if I wasn't in the same house. That's just not old enough. |
|
Posted 7/12/09 8:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand Posted by Arieschick29 I don't think any child under age 18 should be left alone- period! I would never for fear of heat, kidnapping, carjacking etc. My mother or father never left us alone- in the car, in the house anywhere. i was babysitting, alone, at the age of 14 for other families. at the age of 16-17 i was wandering the neighborhood with my friends--i can't imagine my mom not letting me out alone as a senior in high school! for the mom in the original story--what makes it the worst is that there was a baby in the car, which was not running. who knows if the windows were down. if it were a 13 and 10 year old, it would be different IMO. i stayed home many times alone with my sister at 13. you don't leave a baby alone with a 10 year old in a deserted parking lot though at that time of night for any reason. |
|
Posted 7/12/09 8:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand I remember being 10 and staying at home with my infant sister while my mother ran errands. |
|
Posted 7/12/09 8:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand Honestly, if the infant wasn't in the car, I don't think I'd even think twice about it. I would never leave an infant in the car with a 10 and 7 year old. |
|
Posted 7/12/09 8:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand Posted by nicrae Posted by Arieschick29 I don't think any child under age 18 should be left alone- period! I would never for fear of heat, kidnapping, carjacking etc. My mother or father never left us alone- in the car, in the house anywhere. I am totally not condoning what this woman did, but I don't understand your statement. You wouldn't leave a 17 year old home alone? Would you get a baby-sitter for your 17 year old? 17 year olds can drive. Would you not let your child drive by themselves? Just curious..... My mom started leaving me home around 14. I wasn't allowed though to watch my brother who was 3 years younger until I was 15. 10 is definitly too young especially with an infant in the car. Some people just don't think. ETA: I was babysitting other people's children at 15 also.... I understand your point- my statement was a little out there looking back at it. DD is only 4 months but I don't know how I'll ever leave her alone at home or let her go out with friends. I think of all the crazies out there and start to panic. I know it'll happen one day though so I guess more realistically I wouldnt leave my children with anyone under 16 ( which IMO I think is a good age for babysitters) |
|
Posted 7/12/09 10:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand I babysat infants at 12 years old. So while I think it's fine for a 12 year old, I think for me the issue is that they were in a car and in public. My concern is mainly how hot the car gets but I'm on the fence about this one. I think 10 is too young to be left in charge of 2 kids. I know some 30 year old that can't do it. Message edited 2009-07-13 05:57:01.350000. |
|
Posted 7/13/09 5:56 AM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand I don't think any of those children should have been left in the car because it was 9:30 at night and there are alot of wackos out there. |
|
Posted 7/13/09 8:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand That disgusts me! Unfortunately, in my previous line of work, that was an all too common situation I dealt with on a day to day basis |
|
Posted 7/13/09 9:00 AM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand Posted by hbugal Im not condoning what she did by any means... But here is the thing... What age is acceptable? What are the guidelines? At what age is a child mature enough to be left unattended? Would this have been OK if the eldest child was 13? I would not have left my girls unattended in a car with their brother..especially not with another child in my care. But I have left them in the car while Ive run into the dry cleaners...but that is only b/c I park exactly in front of the store and I can see them AND the door is open of the dry cleaner..etc...etc... I am going to take a shot at this only because I did this for a living. The issue here is not the ages as much as the fact that they were left for 30 minutes unattended with an infant at night in a vehicle. Courts will look at the situation surrounding the event. Now if they were left at home or even in the car for 10 minutes max with ventilation when it was light out, it would probably not be the same situation, because many kids, especially mature children, start babysitting in small spurts around the age of 10. But the factors that make this so problematic is the fact that they were left for 30 minutes in the car without an adult, and we are talking about a big mall parking lot in the dark. That is definitely not a safe situation. My bet is that the woman gets her children back and no jail time at all. She will probably get parenting classes and that's about it. IMO-It is one thing if those kids were in a house alone during the daytime with phone instructions and such, or even if it were a few minutes in the early evening, depending on the maturity of the 10 year old. However, I really feel that the circumstances here make the woman neglectful-KWIM? Sorry for the long legal analysis lol! |
|
Posted 7/13/09 9:08 AM
|
|
|
Re: i don't understand OMG....I work in the NCJail I cant wait to see this idiot. I wish I could give her a piece of my mind! |
|
Posted 7/13/09 9:13 AM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| captain charisma (Don) | luvsbob4603 | 3/18/06 | 11 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| I don't understand it...(long vent) | Stefanie | 3/7/06 | 58 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Where's Don?? | Gertyrae | 3/1/06 | 8 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Don | luvsbob4603 | 3/1/06 | 6 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Comedic Actor Don Knotts Dies at 81 | IrishTracy | 2/25/06 | 9 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Don Knotts passed away | LisaW | 2/25/06 | 14 | Families Helping Families ™ |















