Re: i don't understand
Posted 7/13/2009 9:08:23 AM by Ihaveasecret


Posted by hbugal

Im not condoning what she did by any means...

But here is the thing...

What age is acceptable? What are the guidelines? At what age is a child mature enough to be left unattended? Would this have been OK if the eldest child was 13?

I would not have left my girls unattended in a car with their brother..especially not with another child in my care. But I have left them in the car while Ive run into the dry cleaners...but that is only b/c I park exactly in front of the store and I can see them AND the door is open of the dry cleaner..etc...etc...




I am going to take a shot at this only because I did this for a living. The issue here is not the ages as much as the fact that they were left for 30 minutes unattended with an infant at night in a vehicle. Courts will look at the situation surrounding the event. Now if they were left at home or even in the car for 10 minutes max with ventilation when it was light out, it would probably not be the same situation, because many kids, especially mature children, start babysitting in small spurts around the age of 10. But the factors that make this so problematic is the fact that they were left for 30 minutes in the car without an adult, and we are talking about a big mall parking lot in the dark. That is definitely not a safe situation. My bet is that the woman gets her children back and no jail time at all. She will probably get parenting classes and that's about it.

IMO-It is one thing if those kids were in a house alone during the daytime with phone instructions and such, or even if it were a few minutes in the early evening, depending on the maturity of the 10 year old. However, I really feel that the circumstances here make the woman neglectful-KWIM? Sorry for the long legal analysis lol!
Print Post      Close Window