how do you judge a school district?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
how do you judge a school district? I have been looking on longislandschools.com but i am not quite sure what i am looking for. I mean...the big things i am noticing are the %age of students passing the regents, %age of student receiving advanced diplomas, if the school budget passed...etc... |
|
Posted 9/21/08 10:35 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate
| |
|
Re: how do you judge a school district? Good test scores is a plus. I want schools with lots of clubs, sports, electives in the high school. I personally would prefer a larger district, but DH wants a small one so we'll have to compromise there. |
|
Posted 9/21/08 10:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: how do you judge a school district? Posted by greeneyes361708 Good test scores is a plus. I want schools with lots of clubs, sports, electives in the high school. I personally would prefer a larger district, but DH wants a small one so we'll have to compromise there. do you know where i can find info on test scores? all that i found was percentage of students that passed the regents and received advanced diplomas. TIA |
|
Posted 9/21/08 10:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: how do you judge a school district? I'm looking at test scores (Regents), number of AP courses offered, clubs/sports/extra activities, the teacher to student ratio, the percent of children going to 4-year schools, percent graduating, safety of the district and surrounding areas. I'm also looking at the number of AP scholars/Intel scholars, etc. Message edited 2008-09-21 11:50:44.003000. |
|
Posted 9/21/08 11:46 AM
|
|
|
Re: how do you judge a school district? Test scores, teacher to student ratio, violence. (we were in Riverhead school district... we moved |
|
Posted 9/21/08 11:47 AM
|
|
|
Re: how do you judge a school district? yes, definitely test scores, reviews, ratios, etc. All of the AP comments. |
|
Posted 9/21/08 12:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: how do you judge a school district? i agree most with nov04libride's post. |
|
Posted 9/21/08 12:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: how do you judge a school district? I also agree with a lot of what nov04 said. for me it's % graduating, % going onto 4 year schools, % getting 85 or higher on regents (passing a regents isn't hard to do these days). I love the comment about living in a community where people share the same attitudes as you in education. Message edited 2008-09-21 14:06:16.407000. |
|
Posted 9/21/08 2:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: how do you judge a school district? there are only about 10 that i would absolutely NOT buy into. What advice would you offer for parents looking to identify these schools? I agree with the OP when I ask...how do you spot a good school district from one that you shouldn't buy into? And, what resources are out there for finding the answers? |
|
Posted 9/21/08 2:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: how do you judge a school district? Posted by MrsGT there are only about 10 that i would absolutely NOT buy into. What advice would you offer for parents looking to identify these schools? I agree with the OP when I ask...how do you spot a good school district from one that you shouldn't buy into? And, what resources are out there for finding the answers? My number would be higher than Karen's, but I would look at the school report cards (the link I posted above). I think graduate rate is a huge factor. We crossed a SD off that was 93%. Seems high, but if you think about it that is 7 out of 100 kids not graduating and I think that's pretty high. So when you see SDs in the 80's and lower, that would be a big clue. another thing you may want to look at is the % of free school lunches |
|
Posted 9/21/08 2:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: how do you judge a school district? This is so interesting. I've started looking at the graduation rates, drop out rates, and regents w/ & w/o advanced placement. I graduated from a top high school on LI, with 1% drop out rate and 98% graduating with regents. But I can tell you from experience....plenty of drugs were done, on and off school time and a lot of violence was exchanged (not with weapons...but that may be more of a function of time). I suppose giving your family the most nourished environment you can afford is the best supplement to whatever is done inside the home. It's tough though. How does everyone afford to buy in a good area? |
|
Posted 9/21/08 2:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: how do you judge a school district? Posted by MrsGT This is so interesting. I've started looking at the graduation rates, drop out rates, and regents w/ & w/o advanced placement. I graduated from a top high school on LI, with 1% drop out rate and 98% graduating with regents. But I can tell you from experience....plenty of drugs were done, on and off school time and a lot of violence was exchanged (not with weapons...but that may be more of a function of time). I suppose giving your family the most nourished environment you can afford is the best supplement to whatever is done inside the home. It's tough though. How does everyone afford to buy in a good area? Well, sadly, the percent graduation rate and % going to 4-year schools are somewhat tied into the affluence of the district...and in some cases, where there is $$$$, there are more drugs. It happens everywhere. I think the best that you can hope is that you raise your children to reflect your morals and ethical standards, and that when faced with these choices, they will make the right ones. As for how does everyone afford to buy , my boss went to a financial advisor who gave him this great advice..."Make more money." Seriously though, our choice is a small house in an excellent district, or a very large house in a so-so district. I'm opting for the smaller house. We also both work in Suffolk, and I know that some of the best SDs in Suffolk are more affordable than those in Nassau. Miller Place was ranked #1 in a Suffolk ranking last year (don't ask me which ranking, because I don't remember, but I know it was MP), and there are many reasonably priced homes in that area. It's too far East for us, but if it wasn't, I'd live there in a heartbeat. Message edited 2008-09-21 15:13:03.130000. |
|
Posted 9/21/08 3:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: how do you judge a school district? Seriously though, our choice is a small house in an excellent district, or a very large house in a so-so district. I'm opting for the smaller house. This question is ruling my life right now....I'm so torn. I don't have children and won't need a middle or high school for presumably 10 years or so....Today I'm swaying towards smaller house, good district. Tomorrow, I'll be thinking bigger house, 10 years, let inflation and time work for me and then move. I want to host a family holiday...I know it's silly, but I love having guests over...which I can't do in a small house...who knows...I am plagued by this uncertainty. |
|
Posted 9/21/08 3:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: how do you judge a school district? Posted by MrsGT Seriously though, our choice is a small house in an excellent district, or a very large house in a so-so district. I'm opting for the smaller house. This question is ruling my life right now....I'm so torn. I don't have children and won't need a middle or high school for presumably 10 years or so....Today I'm swaying towards smaller house, good district. Tomorrow, I'll be thinking bigger house, 10 years, let inflation and time work for me and then move. I want to host a family holiday...I know it's silly, but I love having guests over...which I can't do in a small house...who knows...I am plagued by this uncertainty. Well, it's not impossible to find a large dining room in a small house. You just may have to sacrifice some of your wants, whether it is more bedrooms, bathrooms, a garage, a basement, etc. We are considering buying 1 bathroom so long as there is room to add another. You can always add on to a small house, and good SDs often retain value more than other areas. In the district we are looking, homes are on the market an average of 28 days. That is incredibly low in this market, because it is still v. popular because of the area. But if you look at the number of McMansions in so-so districts, obviously many people opt for the larger house! |
|
Posted 9/21/08 3:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: how do you judge a school district? Posted by donegal419 i agree most with nov04libride's post. however, as a teacher, i will tell you NOW that the test scores are not all what they're cracked up to be. i think the 85% passing rate and above is fine. more important is the number of students earning regents diploma or going on to 4 year colleges than the 4th grader passing his science test. Also, i will tell you that those scores include students with special needs taking the test and it messes up the data, so often a school with lower scores is actually a good school with a lot of special education students taking the test. even though as teachers we KNOW these students are below grade level, they still must take the test. and also these tests prove nothing about their actual functioning in class. i had a completely dyslexic child score a 100 on the reading test in 5th grade because she sat there for four hours (this kid was a fighter!) matching up words from the question to the passage. she couldn't READ and she got a perfect score. they are often poorly constructed tests that do not measure much else than echoing back an answer. as a grader for these tests, it would blow your mind what the state considers an acceptable answer. also as an educator, out of the almost 200 districts on long island, there are only about 10 that i would absolutely NOT buy into. Long Island has the BEST public schools in the country...period. as long as you are involved in your child's education and create an environment at home where education is valued, your child for the most part, should do well in most any district. sure people have preferences of district size, elective offerings, etc., but again, on Long Island, with the taxes we pay, most districts are very good. well said. as a fellow educator, I completely agree! we looked briefly at test scores and graduation rates, but also checked out the average class size and student-to-teacher ratio. as a guidance counselor, i also wanted to know the college attendance rates. check out greatschools.com for additional info. |
|
Posted 9/21/08 6:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: how do you judge a school district? As the parent of a learning disabled child & a gifted child the "scores" don't mean squat to me. |
|
Posted 9/21/08 7:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: how do you judge a school district? Posted by KellyFG As the parent of a learning disabled child & a gifted child the "scores" don't mean squat to me. Particularly the 'students attending 4 year college' Here's a scenario-Jenny goes to Jericho & has private tutors her whole life and her parents pay for her to have her college applications professionally done. She has also played tennis with a pro for years & has done all sorts of community service that her stay at home Mom signed her up for. They also can afford to shell out the $$$ tuition for any private school so she doesn't need to stress about that. she's excepted into a few & off she goes along with most of her friends from that demographic in her high school . Julie on the other hand attends Longwood and struggles on her own to study for her honors classes because both of her parents work full time & there is no money for tutors. By the time she's in 11th grade she's working at a fast food place to save up money she'll need when she gets to college. She's applying for financial aid & hoping to get scholarships & knows she'll only be able to afford a state school along with every other kid in her demographic in the state. She busts her arse & gets accepted, the first person in her family to attend a four year college...how many kids from her high school do you think will get in & actually be able to afford to go? Coupled with my first hand experience, six of my son's closest friends went away to school three years ago when they graduated from Connetquot-good school district, good scores, good reputation. Out of those six only 2 are on track to complete the 4 years of college. So in a nutshell what does that number REALLY tell us? I'm a FIRM believer that PARENTS not the school district produce well educated, successful children. I agree with the poster that said there are only a few districts on LI that are truly worth avoiding. well said! great examples of how numbers don't tell the true story of how good or bad a district is.as an educator, i pay NO attention to test scores. they mean nothing to me. they don't take into account special circumstances such as special education programs (where students STILL have to take a test that is years above their level) and i've personally taught in a district that has fabulous test scores...but if you go into one of the classes you will wonder how half of them even passed the test let alone got a 4. well...i know the answer to that but i'm not going there. scores mean zippo to me. |
|
Posted 9/21/08 10:47 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sachem School District | justme1 | 3/11/06 | 12 | Home |
| I a so po-ed- the school district I work for | Bri | 12/6/05 | 9 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| School District Website | FireIslandLove | 12/4/05 | 3 | Home |
| Need Apartment in Sachem East school district | Jennifer | 7/13/05 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| School district boundaries | capricorn75 | 6/9/05 | 2 | Home |
| What school district is ... | emc | 6/6/05 | 7 | Home |






I wouldn't feel comfortable since I read in the paper about students with weapons and drugs in school a few times a year)

, my boss went to a financial advisor who gave him this great advice..."Make more money." 
