Re: how do you judge a school district?
Posted 9/21/2008 12:41:11 PM by donegal419

i agree most with nov04libride's post.

however, as a teacher, i will tell you NOW that the test scores are not all what they're cracked up to be. i think the 85% passing rate and above is fine. more important is the number of students earning regents diploma or going on to 4 year colleges than the 4th grader passing his science test.

Also, i will tell you that those scores include students with special needs taking the test and it messes up the data, so often a school with lower scores is actually a good school with a lot of special education students taking the test. even though as teachers we KNOW these students are below grade level, they still must take the test. and also these tests prove nothing about their actual functioning in class. i had a completely dyslexic child score a 100 on the reading test in 5th grade because she sat there for four hours (this kid was a fighter!) matching up words from the question to the passage. she couldn't READ and she got a perfect score. they are often poorly constructed tests that do not measure much else than echoing back an answer. as a grader for these tests, it would blow your mind what the state considers an acceptable answer.

also as an educator, out of the almost 200 districts on long island, there are only about 10 that i would absolutely NOT buy into. Long Island has the BEST public schools in the country...period. as long as you are involved in your child's education and create an environment at home where education is valued, your child for the most part, should do well in most any district. sure people have preferences of district size, elective offerings, etc., but again, on Long Island, with the taxes we pay, most districts are very good.
Print Post      Close Window