How do you handle...

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

LoveMyFamily
LIF Toddler

Member since 1/11

418 total posts

Name:
Alyson

How do you handle...

Other parents, family, or friends who, while you are holding your baby/toddler, will just put their arms out & take your child from you, without asking permission?

Some added info: I'm talking about constantly, and never asking, and this being done by a relative who sees my toddler two days a year. It bothers me, but I feel like it's not worth the fight, except when my daughter is tired & the relative doesn't take one or two no's... it takes me saying 'no' three times to get her to stop! And then, I get an attitude. Anyone else deal with this & still have a relationship with that relative?

Message edited 2012-07-29 09:11:41.497000.

Posted 7/29/12 8:03 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: How do you handle...

I hand the child off and thank God for the break. Chat Icon

Posted 7/29/12 8:07 AM
 

babylove26
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

987 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you handle...

Posted by sfp0701

I hand the child off and thank God for the break. Chat Icon



Chat Icon yes i do the same.

Posted 7/29/12 8:09 AM
 

JenandMikey
life is good =)

Member since 5/07

4216 total posts

Name:
We're so blessed!

Re: How do you handle...

not a big deal....i had more of a problem if someone wanted to feed my dd's only because they had reflux and needed lots of breaks to slow them down and burp....so most of the time i said no to feeding them....but just to hold them didn't bother me at all if they took them out of my arms

Posted 7/29/12 8:09 AM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: How do you handle...

Posted by babylove26

Posted by sfp0701

I hand the child off and thank God for the break. Chat Icon



Chat Icon yes i do the same.



Me too!!!

Posted 7/29/12 8:44 AM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: How do you handle...

Make a quick turn, walk away and pretend you don't see them Chat Icon seriously, that drove me crazy and people got the hint when I walked away. I find it really obnoxious to just 'take' the baby from a new mother.

Posted 7/29/12 8:48 AM
 

EricaAlt
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

22665 total posts

Name:
Erica

Re: How do you handle...

DS 1 I was more annoyed. Worked full time so the little time I did spend with DS I wanted him to myself. With ds2 I got much more laid back and like the PP said... Hand him off no problems and enjoy a break. I'm also a SAHM. Now I look forward to a break.

Posted 7/29/12 9:10 AM
 

LoveMyFamily
LIF Toddler

Member since 1/11

418 total posts

Name:
Alyson

Re: How do you handle...

Posted by OrganicMama

Make a quick turn, walk away and pretend you don't see them Chat Icon seriously, that drove me crazy and people got the hint when I walked away. I find it really obnoxious to just 'take' the baby from a new mother.



OrganicMama, that's how I feel, whether or not I'm a new mom. My daughter is 15 mos old and I'm a pretty laid back mom. But, even my own mother, who is one of the few who I trust fully with my daughter, always asks if she can hold her when I have her in my arms, always asks if she can give her food and if so, how much, etc... she just respects my parental rights, which I appreciate.

Posted 7/29/12 9:13 AM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: How do you handle...

Posted by AlyJD

Posted by OrganicMama

Make a quick turn, walk away and pretend you don't see them Chat Icon seriously, that drove me crazy and people got the hint when I walked away. I find it really obnoxious to just 'take' the baby from a new mother.



OrganicMama, that's how I feel, whether or not I'm a new mom. My daughter is 15 mos old and I'm a pretty laid back mom. But, even my own mother, who is one of the few who I trust fully with my daughter, always asks if she can hold her when I have her in my arms, always asks if she can give her food and if so, how much, etc... she just respects my parental rights, which I appreciate.



ITA, I just assumed you were a new mom because that mostly happens with newborns. My family is the same, they always ask first. DH's family had no respect for my parental rights, and unfortunately they missed out on a lot of time with of DS because of it. After a period of not speaking or seeing them, we had a long discussion and they now understand they have to respect my role as the mother to my son.

Posted 7/29/12 10:20 AM
 

LoveMyFamily
LIF Toddler

Member since 1/11

418 total posts

Name:
Alyson

Re: How do you handle...

Posted by OrganicMama

Posted by AlyJD

Posted by OrganicMama

Make a quick turn, walk away and pretend you don't see them Chat Icon seriously, that drove me crazy and people got the hint when I walked away. I find it really obnoxious to just 'take' the baby from a new mother.



OrganicMama, that's how I feel, whether or not I'm a new mom. My daughter is 15 mos old and I'm a pretty laid back mom. But, even my own mother, who is one of the few who I trust fully with my daughter, always asks if she can hold her when I have her in my arms, always asks if she can give her food and if so, how much, etc... she just respects my parental rights, which I appreciate.



ITA, I just assumed you were a new mom because that mostly happens with newborns. My family is the same, they always ask first. DH's family had no respect for my parental rights, and unfortunately they missed out on a lot of time with of DS because of it. After a period of not speaking or seeing them, we had a long discussion and they now understand they have to respect my role as the mother to my son.



I'm with ya... it def is mostly w/ new moms. This one has been doing this for a while (luckily, we don't live nearby, so it's only a couple times a year), but still. Glad your thing worked out... maybe I'll try that next time. Thanks for your help!

Posted 7/29/12 10:59 AM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you handle...

What is really the problem though? If it is just that you feel disrespected then u should try and remember that the break is nice, even if it comes with this annoying caveat. If it's that they are taking the baby at a bad time (like eating or something) then voice that in a nice way. If you just never want to let your kid go with others- maybe that's a habit you should try and break anyway. I let everyone take my kids bc let's face it- they eventually get handed back and it's usually pretty quickly if it's not someone my kids enjoy. If my kids ARE enjoying, why would I take that from them? I am a SAHM so maybe I welcome breaks more than a FTWM but I used to be a FTWM and even though I worked 70 hours a week it didn't mean I wasn't happy to pass ds off to someone so I could eat or drink in peace at a party for twenty minutes.

Posted 7/29/12 12:41 PM
 

cj7305
=)

Member since 8/05

12296 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you handle...

Posted by alli3131

Posted by babylove26

Posted by sfp0701

I hand the child off and thank God for the break. Chat Icon



Chat Icon yes i do the same.



Me too!!!



SameChat Icon

Posted 7/29/12 12:58 PM
 

wingsofsong
My 3 little loves <3<3<3

Member since 1/09

7395 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: How do you handle...

I haven't really experienced it a whole lot, but it has happened a few times. I usually take the passive aggressive route Chat Icon After they take him, I'll say something like, "That's ok, I didn't want to hold him anyway." with a smile, so it comes off like a joke but also makes them aware of what they dis, and maybe remember next time. I hear ya, that really bugs me!

Posted 7/29/12 1:55 PM
 

HoneymoonBaby
LIF Adolescent

Member since 11/11

635 total posts

Name:
CJ

How do you handle...

I used the " she's cranky" or " she's tired" to fend off would be holders at my DD's baptism party. But, some people are very persistent!

Posted 7/29/12 2:35 PM
 

Mags1227
Just a mommy ...

Member since 10/10

2665 total posts

Name:
M

Re: How do you handle...

my MIL did that to me when DS was around 2 months in her own house during her birthday party.

I calmly walked out of the room (with her holding my child) and told DH we needed to go home now. She came running out trying to explain how she knows I'm tired and wanted to give me a break (one i didn't ask for) and I again calmly said we are leaving.
she then went on and one how he's her precious little one and how much she loves him and how i'm her daughter too. at that point i said four things. 1- don't pretend you don't speak english. if you want to say something say it. 2. i am not yours. i have my own mother and you are not it. 3. he is not yours. he is my son and DH's son. 4. i will not allow you to take my child away form me. my child my rules, you don't like it you don't have to see him.

It was mean, she was shocked (no one ever talks back to her) and she was upset. but let me assure you she checks with me with everything now. and we have a much better relationship.

Posted 7/30/12 1:01 AM
 

SweetPeaMomma
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/07

806 total posts

Name:
jen

Re: How do you handle...

Posted by Mags1227

my MIL did that to me when DS was around 2 months in her own house during her birthday party.

I calmly walked out of the room (with her holding my child) and told DH we needed to go home now. She came running out trying to explain how she knows I'm tired and wanted to give me a break (one i didn't ask for) and I again calmly said we are leaving.
she then went on and one how he's her precious little one and how much she loves him and how i'm her daughter too. at that point i said four things. 1- don't pretend you don't speak english. if you want to say something say it. 2. i am not yours. i have my own mother and you are not it. 3. he is not yours. he is my son and DH's son. 4. i will not allow you to take my child away form me. my child my rules, you don't like it you don't have to see him.

It was mean, she was shocked (no one ever talks back to her) and she was upset. but let me assure you she checks with me with everything now. and we have a much better relationship.



this honestly is not judgement, i'm just trying to understand...why was it so upsetting that you wanted to leave your MIL's house? i remember slightly feeling this way when someone would just take DS from my arms w/o asking in the first 2 or 3 months, but not to the point where i would storm out of the person's birthday party. again, i don't mean to sound nasty here, everyone is different in their feelings. just a little surprised at such a strong reaction.

Posted 7/30/12 7:57 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you handle...

I found after having my DD that some people are just weird when it comes to their behaviors around babies. People just don't think first before they act.

It actually drove me insane when someone would grab her out of my arms or try to take over when I was doing something with her. I would just say, "No, I got her right now. Thank you". Sometimes I had to say it more than once and if someone got an attitude, too bad. The way I looked at it was she is MY child and what I want comes first, if that pi$$ed someone off that's there issue to deal with.

*Most* people were fine, it was just that weird 1 or 2 who pulled that cr@p.

Posted 7/30/12 8:05 AM
 

LoveMyFamily
LIF Toddler

Member since 1/11

418 total posts

Name:
Alyson

Re: How do you handle...

Posted by SweetPeaMomma

Posted by Mags1227

my MIL did that to me when DS was around 2 months in her own house during her birthday party.

I calmly walked out of the room (with her holding my child) and told DH we needed to go home now. She came running out trying to explain how she knows I'm tired and wanted to give me a break (one i didn't ask for) and I again calmly said we are leaving.
she then went on and one how he's her precious little one and how much she loves him and how i'm her daughter too. at that point i said four things. 1- don't pretend you don't speak english. if you want to say something say it. 2. i am not yours. i have my own mother and you are not it. 3. he is not yours. he is my son and DH's son. 4. i will not allow you to take my child away form me. my child my rules, you don't like it you don't have to see him.

It was mean, she was shocked (no one ever talks back to her) and she was upset. but let me assure you she checks with me with everything now. and we have a much better relationship.



this honestly is not judgement, i'm just trying to understand...why was it so upsetting that you wanted to leave your MIL's house? i remember slightly feeling this way when someone would just take DS from my arms w/o asking in the first 2 or 3 months, but not to the point where i would storm out of the person's birthday party. again, i don't mean to sound nasty here, everyone is different in their feelings. just a little surprised at such a strong reaction.



Thanks for the story... I kinda wish I made that big of a stink abotu it in the beginning. And I understand the follow-up question as well. Maybe it seemed to be overreaction to walk out of a birthday party, but it certainly seems to have made the point. I, myself, didn't say a thing for a year & had to recently (to one person on my husband's side of the family) b/c she tried to take my DD out of my arms after I, clearly upset, tried for 2 hours to get her to sleep & finally said 'f' it. All I had to do, though, is say "no,"... and it took THREE 'NO'S' to get her to give up, and even then, SHE gave ME the attitude, instead of just saying sorry.

I feel that often, people do this w/o trying to be mean, but we (including myself) take it offensively. I feel that it puts me in an awkward spot; I can just give up my child to someone who she may not be comfortable with yet, or make an affirmative statement about not doing so which often puts the other person in an awkward situation. Instead, people should ask "can I hold her?" and wait for my affirmative "sure!" My own mother would never take my child out of my or DH's hands... why should someone else have that right?

Ok, so in short... maybe walking out of a bday party was a bit much (IMO), but if it made the point & made the relationship stronger, I say all the more power to her :)

Posted 7/30/12 8:07 AM
 

LoveMyFamily
LIF Toddler

Member since 1/11

418 total posts

Name:
Alyson

Re: How do you handle...

Posted by Hofstra26

I found after having my DD that some people are just weird when it comes to their behaviors around babies. People just don't think first before they act.

It actually drove me insane when someone would grab her out of my arms or try to take over when I was doing something with her. I would just say, "No, I got her right now. Thank you". Sometimes I had to say it more than once and if someone got an attitude, too bad. The way I looked at it was she is MY child and what I want comes first, if that pi$$ed someone off that's there issue to deal with.

*Most* people were fine, it was just that weird 1 or 2 who pulled that cr@p.



Hofstra, I couldn't agree w/ everything you said more! Why people feel that it is appropriate to jump in on my parenting of my own child is beyond me. A simple "can I hold her?" would likely prompt a "sure!" And then, as some ppl said above, I can "enjoy the break."

Posted 7/30/12 8:09 AM
 

JenMarie
One day at a time

Member since 11/07

7397 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: How do you handle...

Posted by sfp0701

I hand the child off and thank God for the break. Chat Icon



Ditto!

Posted 7/30/12 8:15 AM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: How do you handle...

I used to get annoyed when I had my first DS and would quietly stew, by the time. Had second DS I was over it and welcomed the break.

Posted 7/30/12 8:21 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you handle...

Posted by AlyJD

Posted by Hofstra26

I found after having my DD that some people are just weird when it comes to their behaviors around babies. People just don't think first before they act.

It actually drove me insane when someone would grab her out of my arms or try to take over when I was doing something with her. I would just say, "No, I got her right now. Thank you". Sometimes I had to say it more than once and if someone got an attitude, too bad. The way I looked at it was she is MY child and what I want comes first, if that pi$$ed someone off that's there issue to deal with.

*Most* people were fine, it was just that weird 1 or 2 who pulled that cr@p.



Hofstra, I couldn't agree w/ everything you said more! Why people feel that it is appropriate to jump in on my parenting of my own child is beyond me. A simple "can I hold her?" would likely prompt a "sure!" And then, as some ppl said above, I can "enjoy the break."



ITA with you too. It's not that I had a problem with people holding her, quite the contrary. But I just HATED when someone would walk over and GRAB her. I also hated when someone was holding her and I went to take her back and they would fight me and turn away. I just never understood that behavior.

Like I said, most people were fine, it was just that rare one or two who drove me nuts.

Posted 7/30/12 8:35 AM
 

3under3
LIF Infant

Member since 7/12

192 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you handle...

Posted by babylove26

Posted by sfp0701

I hand the child off and thank God for the break. Chat Icon



Chat Icon yes i do the same.



This for the most part! I don't think people need to ask me to hold my toddler however if they put their arms out and my toddler is cranky and pulls back and doesn't want to go to them I think they should stop.

I HATE when my kids are tired or cranky only want to be with me or DH and someone insists on "helping" me by taking them. It always makes things worse!

Posted 7/30/12 11:13 AM
 

Mags1227
Just a mommy ...

Member since 10/10

2665 total posts

Name:
M

Re: How do you handle...

Posted by AlyJD

Posted by SweetPeaMomma

Posted by Mags1227

my MIL did that to me when DS was around 2 months in her own house during her birthday party.

I calmly walked out of the room (with her holding my child) and told DH we needed to go home now. She came running out trying to explain how she knows I'm tired and wanted to give me a break (one i didn't ask for) and I again calmly said we are leaving.
she then went on and one how he's her precious little one and how much she loves him and how i'm her daughter too. at that point i said four things. 1- don't pretend you don't speak english. if you want to say something say it. 2. i am not yours. i have my own mother and you are not it. 3. he is not yours. he is my son and DH's son. 4. i will not allow you to take my child away form me. my child my rules, you don't like it you don't have to see him.

It was mean, she was shocked (no one ever talks back to her) and she was upset. but let me assure you she checks with me with everything now. and we have a much better relationship.



this honestly is not judgement, i'm just trying to understand...why was it so upsetting that you wanted to leave your MIL's house? i remember slightly feeling this way when someone would just take DS from my arms w/o asking in the first 2 or 3 months, but not to the point where i would storm out of the person's birthday party. again, i don't mean to sound nasty here, everyone is different in their feelings. just a little surprised at such a strong reaction.



Thanks for the story... I kinda wish I made that big of a stink abotu it in the beginning. And I understand the follow-up question as well. Maybe it seemed to be overreaction to walk out of a birthday party, but it certainly seems to have made the point. I, myself, didn't say a thing for a year & had to recently (to one person on my husband's side of the family) b/c she tried to take my DD out of my arms after I, clearly upset, tried for 2 hours to get her to sleep & finally said 'f' it. All I had to do, though, is say "no,"... and it took THREE 'NO'S' to get her to give up, and even then, SHE gave ME the attitude, instead of just saying sorry.

I feel that often, people do this w/o trying to be mean, but we (including myself) take it offensively. I feel that it puts me in an awkward spot; I can just give up my child to someone who she may not be comfortable with yet, or make an affirmative statement about not doing so which often puts the other person in an awkward situation. Instead, people should ask "can I hold her?" and wait for my affirmative "sure!" My own mother would never take my child out of my or DH's hands... why should someone else have that right?

Ok, so in short... maybe walking out of a bday party was a bit much (IMO), but if it made the point & made the relationship stronger, I say all the more power to her :)




there was much more to the story. MIL was overbearing since the day DS was born. Telling me what he needed and when and basically calling me a bad mother for not BF or doing things not her way. she didn't know how to bottle feed but insisted she did and DS almost choked because of her. she argued over everything even though she had her babies in the early 80's in communist Ukraine. things have changed and she really did not know what she was talking about.
also, she didn't just take the baby out of my hands. I was in a different room trying to rock him to sleep. she came in and said to go eat. i told her i'm fine and not hungry and to go entertain her guests (all her family who expect her to wait on them hand and foot) she insisted i said no about three more times. Finally she just grabbed him by the sides and pulled him out of my arms. I tried not to overreact. I went into the bathroom to calm down. Once i did I tried to look at the situation logically, and 20 minutes later still felt it was wrong and dangerous to my child. She also knew what she did was wrong since she started running after me and apologizing (the woman never apologizes)

i think if i didn't let her get away with so much early on to keep the peace, that never would have happened. but it did, and now she gets that I am his mother and I will decide what's best for my child. we still have issues (like she forces him to eat her way when he doesn't want to, she dresses him to warm cause he's cold and he comes home sweating) but they are smaller and i make sure to not be there to see it. i know eventually DS will just walk away form her or flat our refuse her when she forces her way upon him.

sorry the explanation was so long!

Posted 7/30/12 12:44 PM
 

08BabySurprise
My Life. My Everything.

Member since 10/07

9151 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you handle...

Posted by JenMarie

Posted by sfp0701

I hand the child off and thank God for the break. Chat Icon



Ditto!



This. Chat Icon

Posted 7/30/12 1:58 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
"Road Rage" type situations - how do you handle them? greenfreak 11/3/06 42 Families Helping Families ™
We are trying to find a specific kind of door "handle" for a sliding bathroom door...(PIC) AndreaLMT 8/18/06 4 Home
Can anyone offer advice on how to handle MIL smoking in her house? btrflygrl 7/6/06 16 Parenting
For moms that dont have family by them, how did you handle it when your baby was born JerseyMamaOf3 3/7/06 1 Parenting
How do you handle it when your friends disagree? baghag 3/1/06 5 Families Helping Families ™