Re: How do you handle...
Posted 7/30/2012 12:44:25 PM by Mags1227


Posted by AlyJD


Posted by SweetPeaMomma


Posted by Mags1227

my MIL did that to me when DS was around 2 months in her own house during her birthday party.

I calmly walked out of the room (with her holding my child) and told DH we needed to go home now. She came running out trying to explain how she knows I'm tired and wanted to give me a break (one i didn't ask for) and I again calmly said we are leaving.
she then went on and one how he's her precious little one and how much she loves him and how i'm her daughter too. at that point i said four things. 1- don't pretend you don't speak english. if you want to say something say it. 2. i am not yours. i have my own mother and you are not it. 3. he is not yours. he is my son and DH's son. 4. i will not allow you to take my child away form me. my child my rules, you don't like it you don't have to see him.

It was mean, she was shocked (no one ever talks back to her) and she was upset. but let me assure you she checks with me with everything now. and we have a much better relationship.



this honestly is not judgement, i'm just trying to understand...why was it so upsetting that you wanted to leave your MIL's house? i remember slightly feeling this way when someone would just take DS from my arms w/o asking in the first 2 or 3 months, but not to the point where i would storm out of the person's birthday party. again, i don't mean to sound nasty here, everyone is different in their feelings. just a little surprised at such a strong reaction.



Thanks for the story... I kinda wish I made that big of a stink abotu it in the beginning. And I understand the follow-up question as well. Maybe it seemed to be overreaction to walk out of a birthday party, but it certainly seems to have made the point. I, myself, didn't say a thing for a year & had to recently (to one person on my husband's side of the family) b/c she tried to take my DD out of my arms after I, clearly upset, tried for 2 hours to get her to sleep & finally said 'f' it. All I had to do, though, is say "no,"... and it took THREE 'NO'S' to get her to give up, and even then, SHE gave ME the attitude, instead of just saying sorry.

I feel that often, people do this w/o trying to be mean, but we (including myself) take it offensively. I feel that it puts me in an awkward spot; I can just give up my child to someone who she may not be comfortable with yet, or make an affirmative statement about not doing so which often puts the other person in an awkward situation. Instead, people should ask "can I hold her?" and wait for my affirmative "sure!" My own mother would never take my child out of my or DH's hands... why should someone else have that right?

Ok, so in short... maybe walking out of a bday party was a bit much (IMO), but if it made the point & made the relationship stronger, I say all the more power to her :)




there was much more to the story. MIL was overbearing since the day DS was born. Telling me what he needed and when and basically calling me a bad mother for not BF or doing things not her way. she didn't know how to bottle feed but insisted she did and DS almost choked because of her. she argued over everything even though she had her babies in the early 80's in communist Ukraine. things have changed and she really did not know what she was talking about.
also, she didn't just take the baby out of my hands. I was in a different room trying to rock him to sleep. she came in and said to go eat. i told her i'm fine and not hungry and to go entertain her guests (all her family who expect her to wait on them hand and foot) she insisted i said no about three more times. Finally she just grabbed him by the sides and pulled him out of my arms. I tried not to overreact. I went into the bathroom to calm down. Once i did I tried to look at the situation logically, and 20 minutes later still felt it was wrong and dangerous to my child. She also knew what she did was wrong since she started running after me and apologizing (the woman never apologizes)

i think if i didn't let her get away with so much early on to keep the peace, that never would have happened. but it did, and now she gets that I am his mother and I will decide what's best for my child. we still have issues (like she forces him to eat her way when he doesn't want to, she dresses him to warm cause he's cold and he comes home sweating) but they are smaller and i make sure to not be there to see it. i know eventually DS will just walk away form her or flat our refuse her when she forces her way upon him.

sorry the explanation was so long!
Print Post      Close Window